An observational study of Australian private practice physiotherapy consultations to explore the prescription of self-management strategies

Factors Associated With Compliance With Self-Management Home Therapies for Spine Pain: A Survey of Participants Attending a Chiropractic Teaching Clinic in South Africa

Objective

The purpose of this study was to determine factors that affect compliance with various prescribed home therapies based on reported feedback from participants with spine pain.

Methods

This was a descriptive, quantitative, cross-sectional survey. A purposive sampling method was used to recruit 121 participants with neck and back pain attending the Durban University of Technology Chiropractic Day Clinic located in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. Data were collected using a self-administered questionnaire. Descriptive statistics, including frequencies and percentages, were used to summarize the data, and odds ratios (ORs) were calculated.

Results

Most participants presented with chronic pain, reporting an average severity of 6 out of 10 and little disability from the pain. Home therapy included stretches (92.2%), heat therapy (49.1%), and ice therapy (38.8%). Almost two-thirds (62.1%) of participants reported being fully compliant with the prescribed home therapy, while 32.8% reported partial compliance. The main factors that potentially affected compliance were laziness and forgetfulness. Participants who reported having depression were less compliant (OR, 0.181), while those with chronic pain were more compliant (OR, 3.74). Those who believed that home therapy would alleviate their pain were also more compliant (OR, 3.83).

Conclusion

The study found that a majority of participants with spine pain were compliant with prescribed chiropractic home treatment. Key factors that potentially influenced compliance were identified.

An exploration of physiotherapists' perceived benefits and barriers towards using psychosocial strategies in their practice

BACKGROUND

This study aimed to determine what physiotherapists perceive are the benefits of using psychosocial strategies in their own practice, and whether perceived barriers extend beyond practitioner and contextual barriers.

METHODS

Content analysis of two open-ended questions was conducted. Australian physiotherapists (n = 206) provided written comments.

RESULTS

Three key categories of benefits emerged: patient benefits, shared patient and physiotherapist benefits, and physiotherapist benefits. Patient benefits included improved rehabilitation experience, improved patient wellbeing and improvement of psychosocial responses. Specifically, increased patient enjoyment, improved self-management and improved understanding of the links between their physical and psychological health. Therapeutic alliance appeared as a shared patient and physiotherapist benefit, with specific reference to enhanced partnerships and improved patient-centred practice. Physiotherapist benefits comprised of improved needs assessment and occupational benefits such as reduced load. Three key categories of physiotherapist barriers, contextual barriers, and patient barriers emerged. Time, knowledge, confidence, lack of expertise, and limited formal training, were the main barriers, specifically a lack of practical training, and for more complex strategies. Physiotherapists acknowledged patient barriers such as patient resistance, lack of understanding, and complex mental health needs.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings contribute novel information with regard to the benefits and barriers of psychosocial approaches from a physiotherapist perspective. Physiotherapists may benefit from further support in their use of psychosocial approaches, to emphasize the benefits for their own practice. Furthermore, to potentially reduce patient barriers and improve outcomes, patient education concerning a biopsychosocial model of care could be valuable.

Characteristics associated with high levels of patient-reported adherence to self-management strategies prescribed by physiotherapists

Background/aims

Physiotherapist-prescribed self-management strategies are an important component of physiotherapy practice but they can only be effective if patients adhere. The aim of this study was to explore patient-reported adherence to physiotherapist-prescribed self-management strategies, and the extent to which patient, physiotherapist, consultation and prescription characteristics are associated with high levels of adherence.

Methods

A cross-sectional observational study across four private practices; including 14 physiotherapists and 113 patients was conducted. Data were collected in two stages. The first stage consisted of observing a patient at their physiotherapist consultation to collect data regarding the physiotherapist's prescription of self-management strategies. The second stage consisted of a follow-up telephone interview with each observed patient to record the patient-reported level of adherence to each prescribed self-management strategy.

Results

Prescribed self-management strategies where physiotherapists asked patients to repeat details of the self-management strategy were 6.54 times (95% confidence interval 2.91–14.98) more likely to be highly adhered to than strategies where the physiotherapist did not do this. Prescribed strategies accompanied by printed information were 2.73 times (95% confidence interval 1.24–6.00) more likely to be highly adhered to than strategies that were not. Advice such as to rest from activity (odds ratio=0.18; 95% confidence interval 0.08–0.40) was less likely to be highly adhered to when compared to home-based exercise programmes.

Conclusions

To improve patient-reported adherence to self-management strategies, physiotherapists should be encouraged to provide supplementary printed information and ask their patients to repeat details of the prescribed strategy.

Promoting the Use of Self-management Strategies for People With Persistent Musculoskeletal Disorders: The Role of Physical Therapists

Persistent musculoskeletal pain is a worldwide health problem resulting in negative effects on individuals' wellbeing and substantial costs to society. Recently, there has been discussion about effective treatment approaches to persistent musculoskeletal disorders, including low back pain. In this Viewpoint, the authors argue that self-management strategies are essential to the management of persistent musculoskeletal disorders and outline the physical therapist's role in supporting effective self-management. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 2019;49(4):212-215. doi:10.2519/jospt.2019.0605.

Patient adherence to an exercise program for chronic low back pain measured by patient-report, physiotherapist-perception and observational data

The effectiveness of exercise programs for chronic low back pain (CLBP) is dependent upon patient adherence which is problematic to measure accurately. This cross-sectional observational study aimed to compare patient-reported levels of adherence with physiotherapists' perceptions of patient adherence; and to explore the proportion of patients who could accurately recall and demonstrate the exercises contained within their prescribed exercise program for CLBP. Participating patients (n = 61) included those attending for a follow-up consultation with a physiotherapist (n = 15) at a consenting practice (n = 6) who had been prescribed an exercise program for CLBP. Patients were asked to self-report their level of adherence to the exercise program which was then compared to their physiotherapist's perception of adherence. Patients were also asked to recall and demonstrate the exercise program to an independent researcher, which was compared to the prescribed program. Results indicated that in total, 24 patients (39%; 95% CI: 27-52%) self-reported as being completely adherent compared with 10 patients (16%; 95% CI: 8-28%) who were perceived by their physiotherapists as completely adherent (raw agreement: 0.21). However, only nine patients (15%, 95% CI: 7-26%) were able to accurately recall and demonstrate their prescribed exercise program to the researcher, of which eight of these nine patients self-reported complete adherence to the exercise program. In comparison, only four of these nine patients were perceived by the physiotherapist to be completely adherent. These results suggest that patient adherence to home-based exercise programs for CLBP might be assessed more accurately using multi-faceted measures which include an observational component.