Patterns of Clinical Progression Among Patients With Autosomal Recessive Limb-Girdle Muscular Dystrophy: A Systematic Review

OBJECTIVES

As the clinical course of autosomal recessive limb-girdle muscular dystrophy (LGMDR) is highly variable, this study characterized the frequency of loss of ambulation (LOA) among patients by subtype (LGMDR1, LGMDR2, LGMDR3-6, LGMDR9, LGMDR12) and progression to cardiac and respiratory involvement among those with and without LOA.

METHODS

Systematic literature review.

RESULTS

From 2929 abstracts screened, 418 patients were identified with ambulatory status data (LOA: 265 [63.4%]). Cardiac and/or respiratory function was reported for 142 patients (34.0%; all with LOA). Among these, respiratory involvement was most frequent in LGMDR3-6 (74.1%; mean [SD] age 23.9 [11.0] years) and cardiac in LGMDR9 (73.3%; mean [SD] age 23.7 [17.7] years). Involvement was less common in patients without LOA except in LGMDR9 (71.4% respiratory and 52.4% cardiac).

CONCLUSIONS

This study described the co-occurrence of LOA, cardiac, and respiratory involvement in LGMDR and provides greater understanding of the clinical progression of LGMDR.

Progression to Loss of Ambulation Among Patients with Autosomal Recessive Limb-girdle Muscular Dystrophy: A Systematic Review

Background

The impact of age at autosomal recessive limb girdle muscular dystrophy (LGMDR) onset on progression to loss of ambulation (LOA) has not been well established, particularly by subtype.

Objectives:

To describe the characteristics of patients with adult-, late childhood-, and early childhood-onset LGMDR by subtype and characterize the frequency and timing of LOA.

Methods:

A systematic review was conducted in MEDLINE, Embase and the Cochrane library. Frequency and timing of LOA in patients with LGMDR1, LGMDR2/Miyoshi myopathy (MM), LGMDR3-6, LGMDR9, and LGMDR12 were synthesized from published data.

Results:

In 195 studies, 695 (43.4%) patients had adult-, 532 (33.2%) had late childhood-, and 376 (23.5%) had early childhood-onset of disease across subtypes among those with a reported age at onset (n = 1,603); distribution of age at onset varied between subtypes. Among patients with LOA (n = 228), adult-onset disease was uncommon in LGMDR3-6 (14%) and frequent in LGMDR2/MM (42%); LGMDR3-6 cases with LOA primarily had early childhood-onset (74%). Mean (standard deviation [SD]) time to LOA varied between subtypes and was shortest for patients with early childhood-onset LGMDR9 (12.0 [4.9] years, n = 19) and LGMDR3-6 (12.3 [10.7], n = 56) and longest for those with late childhood-onset LGMDR2/MM (21.4 [11.5], n = 36).

Conclusions:

This review illustrated that patients with early childhood-onset disease tend to have faster progression to LOA than those with late childhood- or adult-onset disease, particularly in LGMDR9. These findings provide a greater understanding of progression to LOA by LGMDR subtype, which may help inform clinical trial design and provide a basis for natural history studies.

CAPN3: A muscle‑specific calpain with an important role in the pathogenesis of diseases (Review)

Calpains are a family of Ca²⁺‑dependent cysteine proteases that participate in various cellular processes. Calpain 3 (CAPN3) is a classical calpain with unique N‑terminus and insertion sequence 1 and 2 domains that confer characteristics such as rapid autolysis, Ca²⁺‑independent activation and Na⁺ activation of the protease. CAPN3 is the only muscle‑specific calpain that has important roles in the promotion of calcium release from skeletal muscle fibers, calcium uptake of sarcoplasmic reticulum, muscle formation and muscle remodeling. Studies have indicated that recessive mutations in CAPN3 cause limb‑girdle muscular dystrophy (MD) type 2A and other types of MD; eosinophilic myositis, melanoma and epilepsy are also closely related to CAPN3. In the present review, the characteristics of CAPN3, its biological functions and roles in the pathogenesis of a number of disorders are discussed.

Patient-specific iPSC-derived cellular models of LGMDR1

Limb-girdle muscular dystrophy recessive 1 (LGMDR1) represents one of the most common types of LGMD in the population, where patients develop a progressive muscle degeneration. The disease is caused by mutations in calpain 3 gene, with over 500 mutations reported to date. However, the molecular events that lead to muscle wasting are not clear, nor the reasons for the great clinical variability among patients, and this has so far hindered the development of effective therapies. Here we generate human induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) from skin fibroblasts of 2 healthy controls and 4 LGMDR1 patients with different mutations. The generated lines were able to differentiate into myogenic progenitors and myotubes in vitro and in vivo, upon a transient PAX7 overexpressing protocol. Thus, we have generated myogenic cellular models of LGMDR1 that harbor different CAPN3 mutations within a human genetic background, and which do not derive from muscular biopsies. These models will allow us to investigate disease mechanisms and test therapies. Despite the variability found among iPSC lines that was unrelated to CAPN3 mutations, we found that patient-derived myogenic progenitors and myotubes express lower levels of DMD, which codes a key protein in satellite cell regulation and myotube maturation.

Intragenic complementation of amino and carboxy terminal SMN missense mutations can rescue Smn null mice

Spinal muscular atrophy is caused by reduced levels of SMN resulting from the loss of SMN1 and reliance on SMN2 for the production of SMN. Loss of SMN entirely is embryonic lethal in mammals. There are several SMN missense mutations found in humans. These alleles do not show partial function in the absence of wild-type SMN and cannot rescue a null Smn allele in mice. However, these human SMN missense allele transgenes can rescue a null Smn allele when SMN2 is present. We find that the N- and C-terminal regions constitute two independent domains of SMN that can be separated genetically and undergo intragenic complementation. These SMN protein heteromers restore snRNP assembly of Sm proteins onto snRNA and completely rescue both survival of Smn null mice and motor neuron electrophysiology demonstrating that the essential functional unit of SMN is the oligomer.

Bovine CAPN3 core promoter initiates expression of foreign genes in skeletal muscle cells by MyoD transcriptional regulation

Activating foreign genes in bovine skeletal muscle is necessary in the study of the role of related genes in skeletal muscle development and the effects on skeletal muscle formation, especially in the study of transgenic cattle. At this time, a skeletal muscle-specific promoter should be selected to initiate a functional foreign gene. Here, calpain3 (CAPN3) was found to be highly expressed in skeletal muscle and skeletal muscle cells by real-time PCR. Next, 5' deletion analysis of the bovine CAPN3 promoter was performed and showed that Q5(-495/+40) region was the core promoter of the bovine CAPN3. A key regulatory site (-465/-453) in CAPN3 core promoter was associated with the transcription factor, MyoD, which is a skeletal muscle-specific transcription factor. Furthermore, the mRNA and protein expression levels of MyoD and CAPN3 were positively correlated during skeletal muscle cell differentiation. The overexpression of MyoD enhanced the activity of the bovine CAPN3 core promoter. The core promoter Q5(-495/+40) could drive the exogenous gene EGFP and the fat-specific expression gene PPARγ in skeletal muscle cells. In summary, our study obtained a bovine skeletal muscle-specific promoter and provided a basis for studying the role of functional genes in the growth and development of skeletal muscle. It also provides a basis for studying the transcriptional regulation mechanism of CAPN3.

Calcium Mechanisms in Limb-Girdle Muscular Dystrophy with CAPN3 Mutations

Limb-girdle muscular dystrophy recessive 1 (LGMDR1), previously known as LGMD2A, is a rare disease caused by mutations in the CAPN3 gene. It is characterized by progressive weakness of shoulder, pelvic, and proximal limb muscles that usually appears in children and young adults and results in loss of ambulation within 20 years after disease onset in most patients. The pathophysiological mechanisms involved in LGMDR1 remain mostly unknown, and to date, there is no effective treatment for this disease. Here, we review clinical and experimental evidence suggesting that dysregulation of Ca2+ homeostasis in the skeletal muscle is a significant underlying event in this muscular dystrophy. We also review and discuss specific clinical features of LGMDR1, CAPN3 functions, novel putative targets for therapeutic strategies, and current approaches aiming to treat LGMDR1. These novel approaches may be clinically relevant not only for LGMDR1 but also for other muscular dystrophies with secondary calpainopathy or with abnormal Ca2+ homeostasis, such as LGMD2B/LGMDR2 or sporadic inclusion body myositis.

Calpain research for drug discovery: challenges and potential

Calpains are a family of proteases that were scientifically recognized earlier than proteasomes and caspases, but remain enigmatic. However, they are known to participate in a multitude of physiological and pathological processes, performing 'limited proteolysis' whereby they do not destroy but rather modulate the functions of their substrates. Calpains are therefore referred to as 'modulator proteases'. Multidisciplinary research on calpains has begun to elucidate their involvement in pathophysiological mechanisms. Therapeutic strategies targeting malfunctions of calpains have been developed, driven primarily by improvements in the specificity and bioavailability of calpain inhibitors. Here, we review the calpain superfamily and calpain-related disorders, and discuss emerging calpain-targeted therapeutic strategies.

Natural history of LGMD2A for delineating outcome measures in clinical trials

Objective

Limb‐girdle muscular dystophy 2A (LGMD2A, OMIM) is a slowly progressive myopathy caused by the deficiency in calpain 3, a calcium‐dependent cysteine protease of the skeletal muscle.

Methods

In this study, we carried out an observational study of clinical manifestations and disease progression in genetically confirmed LGMD2A patients for up to 4 years. A total of 85 patients, aged 14–65 years, were recruited in three centers located in metropolitan France, the Basque country, and the Reunion Island. They were followed up every 6 months for 2 years and a subgroup was assessed annually thereafter for two more years. Data collected for all patients included clinical history, blood parameters, muscle strength assessed by manual muscle testing (MMT) and quantitative muscle testing, functional scores, and pulmonary and cardiac functions. In addition, CT scans of the lower limbs were performed in a subgroup of patients.

Results

Our study confirms the clinical description of a slowly progressive disorder with onset in the first or second decade of life with some degree of variability related to gender and mutation type. The null mutations lead to a more severe phenotype while compound heterozygote patients are the least affected. Muscle weakness is remarkably symmetrical and predominant in the axial muscles of the trunk and proximal muscles of the lower limb. There was a high correlation between the weakness at individual muscle level as assessed by MMT and the loss of density in CT scan analysis.

Interpretation

All the generated data will help to determine the endpoints for further clinical studies.

The N- and C-terminal autolytic fragments of CAPN3/p94/calpain-3 restore proteolytic activity by intermolecular complementation

CAPN3/p94/calpain-3, a calpain protease family member predominantly expressed in skeletal muscle, possesses unusually rapid and exhaustive autolytic activity. Mutations in the human CAPN3 gene impairing its protease functions cause limb-girdle muscular dystrophy type 2A (LGMD2A); yet, the connection between CAPN3's autolytic activity and the enzyme's function in vivo remain unclear. Here, we demonstrated that CAPN3 protease activity was reconstituted by intermolecular complementation (iMOC) between its two autolytic fragments. Furthermore, the activity of full-length CAPN3 active-site mutants was surprisingly rescued through iMOC with autolytic fragments containing WT amino acid sequences. These results provide evidence that WT CAPN3 can be formed by the iMOC of two different complementary CAPN3 mutants. The finding of iMOC-mediated restoration of calpain activity indicates a novel mechanism for the genotype-phenotype links in LGMD2A.

Calpain 3 is important for muscle regeneration: evidence from patients with limb girdle muscular dystrophies

Background

Limb girdle muscular dystrophy (LGMD) type 2A is caused by mutations in the CAPN3 gene and complete lack of functional calpain 3 leads to the most severe muscle wasting. Calpain 3 is suggested to be involved in maturation of contractile elements after muscle degeneration. The aim of this study was to investigate how mutations in the four functional domains of calpain 3 affect muscle regeneration.

Methods

We studied muscle regeneration in 22 patients with LGMD2A with calpain 3 deficiency, in five patients with LGMD2I, with a secondary reduction in calpain 3, and in five patients with Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD) with normal calpain 3 levels. Regeneration was assessed by using the developmental markers neonatal myosin heavy chain (nMHC), vimentin, MyoD and myogenin and counting internally nucleated fibers.

Results

We found that the recent regeneration as determined by the number of nMHC/vimentin-positive fibers was greatly diminished in severely affected LGMD2A patients compared to similarly affected patients with LGMD2I and BMD. Whorled fibers, a sign of aberrant regeneration, was highly elevated in patients with a complete lack of calpain 3 compared to patients with residual calpain 3. Regeneration is not affected by location of the mutation in the CAPN3 gene.

Conclusions

Our findings suggest that calpain 3 is needed for the regenerative process probably during sarcomere remodeling as the complete lack of functional calpain 3 leads to the most severe phenotypes.