The outcomes of three buccal mucosal graft urethroplasty techniques in women with urethral stricture disease

Comparison Of Ventral Inlay and Dorsal Onlay Urethroplasty For Female Urethral Stricture

OBJECTIVE

To compare the outcomes of Ventral inlay buccal mucosal graft urethroplasty (VIBMGU) with dorsal onlay buccal mucosal graft urethroplasty (DOBMGU) for the treatment of Female urethral stricture (FUS).

MATERIAL AND METHODS

This study included women who underwent either VIBMGU or DOBMGU between January 2016 and June 2023. The preoperative AUA symptom scores, maximal urinary flow rate (Qmax), post-void residual volume (PVR) on ultrasonography, and length and location of the stricture were obtained from a prospectively maintained electronic database. The data obtained from the patient's last visit was compared with the preoperative values for this study. The primary outcome was the success rate. The secondary outcomes were changes in AUA score, PVR, and Qmax. The patient's last follow-up visit was considered for the duration of the follow-up.

RESULTS

Seventy-three patients were treated for BMGU for FUS. Forty-six patients underwent VIBMGU, and 27 patients underwent DOBMGU. The median duration of follow-up was 27.5 11.00-55.00) versus 14 (7.00-17.00) months respectively. The success rates of VIBMGU and DOBMGU were 89.13% and 88.89% respectively. There was a reduction in AUA scores and PVR and an improvement in Qmax postoperatively in both groups. The difference in the reduction in AUA scores between the VIBMGU and DOBMGU groups was statistically significant. The difference was not statistically significant in terms of reduction in PVR and improvement in Qmax between the two groups.

CONCLUSION

The ventral inlay technique can provide equal results to the dorsal technique with the added advantage of vaginal sparing. This is the single largest series in the literature on female urethral stricture with the largest follow-up period of 90 months.

Long-term Sexual Function and Quality of Life in Women Following Substitution Urethroplasty

PURPOSE

To assess the long-term quality of life (QOL) and sexual function (SF) in women who underwent either dorsal on-lay (DO) or ventral inlay (VI) urethroplasty for urethral stricture disease.

METHODOLOGY

Between January 2016 and September 2022, women who underwent either dorsal on-lay (DO) or ventral inlay (VI) urethroplasties and had at least a six-month follow-up been included. Using the Female Sexual Function Index (FSFI) and WHO-QOL bref questionnaires, the QOL and SF were evaluated. Scores were compared between the two groups after being examined for internal validity. A sub-group analysis was carried out based on the procedure's success.

RESULTS

With follow-up periods ranging from 6 to 86 months, 25 patients who received VI urethroplasty and 10 patients who underwent DO urethroplasty were included. Both scores demonstrated strong internal consistency. The cumulative QOL and FSFI scores were comparable in both groups (p = 0.53 and p = 0.83, respectively). Significantly high scores were noted in the physical health domain (76.5 ± 9.9 vs 62.33 ± 10.97; p = 0.03; (95% CI = 0.72-24.4)) and the environmental domain (75.75 ± 3.84 vs 66.00 ± 4.24; p = 0.01 (95% CI = 2.64-16.85) in patients with successful VI and DO urethroplasties respectively. Addictions, low socioeconomic status and protracted symptom duration were associated with low QOL scores. Old age was related to low FSFI scores.

CONCLUSION

Substitution urethroplasty, despite the approach, showed good QOL and SF scores. Long symptom duration, addictions, and poor socioeconomic status were associated with low QOL whereas old age independently influenced low FSFI scores.

Surgery for female urethral stricture

BACKGROUND

Female urethral stricture (FUS) is a rare entity that causes great morbidity and suffering in those affected. As the available scientific data is sparce, there are no formal guidelines or standard of care for this disease.

METHODS

This is a narrative review of the surgical management for female urethral stricture. The literature review was performed on PubMed. Articles were limited to English, but there was no limitation in terms of date.

RESULTS

Management of FUS is divided between endoscopic and open surgical repair. Urethral dilation with or without urethrectomy can be offered as a first-line treatment. However, the rate of success of this procedure remains inferior to open surgical repair, and its efficacy decreases with the number of previous dilations. For distal urethral strictures, distal urethrectomy and advancement meatoplasty may be considered. Vaginal flaps are readily available, easy to harvest, well-vascularized, and allow for a dorsal or ventral orientation urethroplasty. The results of this procedure are promising, but most studies are small and retrospective. Labia flaps are easily accessible, wet, hairless, and elastic. The main limitations with the use of vaginal or labial tissues are co-existing conditions such as lichen sclerosis or vaginal atrophy, which may affect future results. Vaginal and labial graft urethroplasty can be used when it is not possible to mobilize an adequate flap. Stricture-free rates of this technique are variable. In cases of more severe stricture, an augmentation urethroplasty using buccal mucosa graft may be necessary. The techniques used in FUS replicate those for male urethral strictures, where both ventral and dorsal approaches can be utilized.

CONCLUSIONS

Although there is growing interest in the field, the optimal management of FUS remains to be determined.

Long-term follow-up and success rate of ventral inlay buccal mucosal graft urethroplasty for female urethral stricture disease

OBJECTIVE

To determine the long-term success of ventral inlay buccal-mucosal graft urethroplasty (Vi-BMGU) for female urethral strictures (FUS).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We performed a retrospective analysis of prospectively maintained data on patients who underwent Vi-BMGU between May 2016 and January 2020 with a minimum follow-up of 2 years. The primary outcome was the long-term success after 2 to 5 years of surgery. Patients were followed with American Urological Association (AUA) symptom score, uroflowmetry, and post-void residual (PVR) urine measurement. Failure (recurrence) was defined by an increase in the AUA symptoms score by 3 on subsequent follow-up visits and Qmax <12cc/s and inability to calibrate with an 18 Fr catheter.

RESULTS

Twenty-one patients were included. The Median follow-up was 42 months (range: 24-64 months). The AUA symptom scores, Q_max, and PVR, improved in all except three patients. The median AUA score fell from 27 (range 18-34) at diagnosis to 9 (range 6-24), at the last follow-up. Similarly, the median PVR values decreased from 138 ml (34-290) to 24 ml (19-360) and the mean Q_max improved from 7.7±2.2 ml/s to 22.6±5 ml/s. None experienced urinary incontinence. There were two failures, one at six months and the other at 24 months. The overall success rate was 90.5 %. Success rates on life table analysis were 95%, 85%, 85%, 85%, and 85% after 1,2,3,4 and 5 years respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

The 95% success at 1 year and 85% sustained success at 2 to 5 years of follow-up establishes the long-term success of Vi-BMGU.