The p53 tumour suppressor gene and tumour prognosis: is there a relationship?

Metalloproteinase-1, Metalloproteinase-7, and p53 Immunoexpression and their Correlation with Clinicopathological Prognostic Factors in Colorectal Adenocarcinoma

Aim

The aim of this study was to analyze the immunoexpression of metalloproteinase-1, metalloproteinase-7, and p53 in colorectal adenocarcinoma, and to correlate this with clinicopathological prognostic factors.

Material and methods

Formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded tumor tissue from 82 patients was analyzed by means of immunohistochemistry, using the streptavidin-biotin method and the tissue microarray technique. Protein tissue expression was correlated with the variables of the degree of cell differentiation, stage, relapse-free survival, recurrence, survival, and specific mortality.

Results

All of the tumors were positive for metalloproteinase-1, while 50 (61%) were positive for metalloproteinase-7, and 32 (39%) were negative for the latter. For p53, 70 (85.4%) of the tumors were positive and 12 (14.6%) were negative. Correlation of the marker expressions separately and in conjunction did not produce any statistically significant data.

Conclusion

The immunoexpression of metalloproteinase-1, metalloproteinase-7, and p53 did not correlate with recurrence, mortality, relapse-free survival, survival, degree of cell differentiation, or staging of colorectal cancer.

Assessment of the extent of unpublished studies in prognostic factor research: a systematic review of p53 immunohistochemistry in bladder cancer as an example

OBJECTIVES

When study groups fail to publish their results, a subsequent systematic review may come to incorrect conclusions when combining information only from published studies. p53 expression measured by immunohistochemistry is a potential prognostic factor in bladder cancer. Although numerous studies have been conducted, its role is still under debate. The assumption that unpublished studies too harbour evidence on this research topic leads to the question about the attributable effect when adding this information and comparing it with published data. Thus, the aim was to identify published and unpublished studies and to explore their differences potentially affecting the conclusion on its function as a prognostic biomarker.

DESIGN

Systematic review of published and unpublished studies assessing p53 in bladder cancer in Germany between 1993 and 2007.

RESULTS

The systematic search revealed 16 studies of which 11 (69%) have been published and 5 (31%) have not. Key reason for not publishing the results was a loss of interest of the investigators. There were no obviously larger differences between published and unpublished studies. However, a meaningful meta-analysis was not possible mainly due to the poor (ie, incomplete) reporting of study results.

CONCLUSIONS

Within this well-defined population of studies, we could provide empirical evidence for the failure of study groups to publish their results that was mainly caused by loss of interest. This fact may be coresponsible for the role of p53 as a prognostic factor still being unclear. We consider p53 and the restriction to studies in Germany as a specific example, but the critical issues are probably similar for other prognostic factors and other countries.

Review : p53 in the pathogenesis, diagnosis, and treatment of cancer

Objective. The cellular functions of p53, the conse quences of the loss of p53 function, and the potential impact of p53 in oncology are reviewed within the framework of an overview of the molecular basis of cancer and cell cycle control.

Data Sources. A MEDLINE search of articles from 1976 to the present was conducted using the terms p53 protein and p53 gene. The search was restricted to the English language. Oncology and molecular biology textbooks were used as additional references.

Data Extraction. We reviewed the literature to discuss the cellular function of p53, the mechanisms of p53 inactivation, the cellular consequences of the loss of p53 function, the role of p53 loss in tumori genesis, and the potential applications of this knowl edge.

Data Synthesis. p53 mutations are found in ~ 50% of human cancers. Knowledge of p53 functions and defects provides the basis for potential applica tions in the areas of cancer epidemiology, cancer diagnosis, and determination of prognosis. An under standing of the functions and defects of p53 also presents a host of opportunities for the design of novel cancer therapies. Therapeutic approaches be ing studied include the restoration of p53 by gene therapy, the alteration of mutant p53 expression by antisense therapy, and the use of p53 mutations as a target for directing therapy to cancer cells; some of these approaches are already under phase I investiga tion. As knowledge of p53 unfolds, additional thera peutic approaches will certainly be developed. The story of p53 illustrates that the manipulation of mo lecular interactions is a new frontier in therapeutics and offers an additional role for oncology pharmacy specialists.

MDM2 promoter polymorphism is associated with both an increased susceptibility to gastric carcinoma and poor prognosis

PURPOSE

Recently, a single-nucleotide polymorphism in the MDM2 promoter (SNP309) has been found to lower the age of onset of tumors and increase the occurrence of multiple primary tumors in Li-Fraumeni syndrome, and accelerate the development of sporadic adult soft tissue sarcoma. The aim of this study was to determine whether SNP309 is associated with susceptibility to gastric carcinoma and its prognosis.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

In a case-control study including 438 controls and 410 patients with sporadic gastric carcinoma, MDM2 SNP309 was genotyped. Serum pepsinogens (PGs) I and II were measured in 438 control subjects and 253 cases selected from 410 patients. Tumor tissue was immunostained with p53 and examined for mutations in exons 5 to 8 of p53 using polymerase chain reaction-based single strand conformational polymorphism analysis and direct sequencing.

RESULTS

The risk of overall gastric carcinoma for SNP309 (G/G) was significantly increased when compared with T carriers (P = .039), especially carcinomas with extragastric tumors (P = .005), carcinoma with severe atrophic gastritis positive for PG assay (PG I level < 70 ng/mL and PG I/II < 3.0; P = .005), antral carcinoma (P = .020), intestinal-type carcinoma (P = .023), p53-immunopositive carcinoma (P = .007), and carcinoma with p53 mutations (P = .007). No significant difference in age at diagnosis was observed among genotypes. SNP309 (G/G) was an independent marker of poor overall survival in advanced carcinoma (hazard ratio, 3.16; 95% CI, 1.22 to 8.20; P = .018).

CONCLUSION

This study provides evidence supporting the association of SNP309 with gastric carcinogenesis via p53 tumor suppressor pathway, extragastric tumorigenesis, and poor prognosis.

TP53 mutations and S-phase fraction but not DNA-ploidy are independent prognostic indicators in laryngeal squamous cell carcinoma

To prospectively evaluate the prognostic significance of TP53, H-, K-, and N-Ras mutations, DNA-ploidy and S-phase fraction (SPF) in patients affected by locally advanced laryngeal squamous cell carcinoma (LSCC). Eight-one patients (median follow-up was 71 months) who underwent resective surgery for primary operable locally advanced LSCC were analyzed. Tumor DNA was screened for mutational analysis by PCR/SSCP and sequencing. DNA-ploidy and SPF were performed by flow cytometric analyses. Thirty-six patients (44%) had, at least, a mutation in the TP53 gene. Of them, 22% (8/36) had double mutations and 3% (1/36) had triple mutations. In total, 46 TP53 mutations were observed. The majority (41%) of these occur in exon 5 (19/46), while the mutations in exons 6, 7, and 8 were represented in 14, 7, and 6 patients, respectively (31%, 15%, and 16%). Five LSCC patients (6%) showed a mutation in H-Ras gene. Sixty-three percent of the cases (51/81) were DNA aneuploidy, 14% of these (7/51) were multiclonal. Thirty-nine patients (48%) had an high SPF value. At Univariate analysis, the DNA aneuploidy, high SPF (>15.1%), TP53 mutations and, in particular, the mutations that occur in exons 5 and 8 were significantly related to quicker disease relapse and short OS. At Multivariate analysis, the major significant predictors for both disease relapse and death were high SPF and any TP53 mutations. While histological grade G3 was an independent factor only for relapse. In conclusions, any TP53 mutations and high SPF are important biological indicators to predict the outcome of LSCC patients.

Testing of Functional Integrity of p53 Protein in Primary Breast Cancer by a Rapid Quantitative p53-p21^WAF1 Double Assay May Improve the Clinical Value of p53

We hypothesized that inclusion of p21(WAF1), an indicator of biological function, into the p53 assay might improve the clinical value of p53 in breast cancer diagnosis. In primary breast carcinomas (n = 146) and healthy/benign controls (n = 40), the p53 protein was quantified by luminescence immunoassay. The p21 protein was simultaneously measured by quantitative ELISA in a representative subgroup of breast cancers (n = 52) and controls (n = 17). In controls, p53 but not p21 was detectable. In almost all cancer tissues, p53 and p21 expression could be quantified. There was no correlation between the concentrations of both proteins. However, if p53 exceeded a threshold of 1.0 ng/mg protein, p21 expression was significantly reduced compared with samples with p53 below threshold. p21 was normally distributed in the low-p53 subpopulation, but not in the high-p53 group. The histologic parameter 'grade III' was more often found (p = 0.002) in tumors with p53 >1.0 ng/mg protein than in those with p53 below the threshold. Histological criteria of high tumor malignancy were found more often in cases with high p53 but low p21. Consequently, in clinical routine, a quantitative double assay of p53 and p21(WAF1) might help to discriminate breast cancers with preserved or impaired/lost p53 function.

Correlations of cell cycle regulators (p53, p21, pRb and mdm2) and c-erbB-2 with biological markers of proliferation and overall survival in breast cancer

AIM

The biological impact of cell cycle regulatory proteins on breast cancer progression is widely recognised, although mostly unclear. The aim of this preliminary study was to investigate the correlations of several cell cycle modulators (p53, p21, pRb, and mdm2) and c-erbB-2 expression with cell proliferation markers (S-phase fraction [SPF] and Ki-67) and overall survival in breast cancer.

METHODS

The series comprised 50 women with stage I-II invasive ductal breast carcinoma (median follow-up 87 months), who were selected for their tumour proliferative characteristics (15 low, 15 high, and 20 intermediate proliferative tumours). Tumour differentiation was assessed following the Nottingham grading criteria. Cell cycle regulators, oestrogen receptor status, and Ki-67 index were analysed by immunohistochemistry on paraffin embedded material (cut-offs 10%). c-erbB-2 was evaluated according to a standardised immunohistochemical assay and borderline cases were confirmed by FISH analysis. Ploidy and SPF were determined by DNA flow cytometry on frozen samples. Chi-square test and Fisher's exact test were applied to analyse the statistical significance of data.

RESULTS

Positive immunostaining was observed in nine (18%) p53+, 30 (60%) p21+, 13 (26%) pRb+, and one (2%) mdm2+ cases. c-erbB-2 expression was considered positive in 11 (22%) cases. In the subset of patients dead of the disease, a high incidence of c-erbB-2 over-expression (7/10, 70%) was verified. In general, no significant correlations among cell cycle regulators or between the latter and histopathological or proliferative characteristics were found. Only the p53-/p21+ phenotype significantly correlated with low SPF (p=0.048), and p21 positivity showed a trend to be associated with low SPF (p=0.083). No statistically significant correlations between cell cycle inhibitors and clinical outcome were found. On the contrary, c-erbB-2 over-expression showed significant correlations with DNA aneuploidy (p<0.001), high SPF (p<0.001), high tumour grading (p=0.008), lack of oestrogen receptors (p=0.036), and poor overall survival (p<0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

The results seem to indicate the lack of correlations of cell cycle regulatory proteins with cell proliferation markers and overall survival in breast cancer, in contrast to c-erbB-2 over-expression which was found to be associated with increased proliferation rate and worse prognosis.

The expression of p53 and bcl-2 in gastrointestinal stromal tumours is associated with anatomical site, and p53 expression is associated with grade and clinical outcome

AIMS

To compare the expression of p53 and bcl-2 in gastrointestinal stromal tumours (GISTs) with anatomical site, National Institutes of Health (NIH) risk category (grade), pathological features, and clinical outcome.

METHODS AND RESULTS

The immunohistochemical expression of p53 and bcl-2 in 105 GISTs (71 gastric, 20 small intestinal, four colonic, 10 rectal) was recorded. When all GISTs were assessed, there was p53 positivity in 28% and bcl-2 positivity in 77%. Gastric tumours had a lower prevalence of p53 positivity (20%) than intestinal (40-50%). Rectal GISTs had the lowest prevalence of bcl-2 positivity (20%) and gastric and small intestinal the highest (80% and 90%, respectively). In GISTs from all sites, p53 positivity was associated with size > 50 mm, epithelioid cell shape, nuclear atypia, mucosal invasion, and mitotic count > 5/50 high-power fields. In gastric GISTs the associations were the same, apart from size and mitotic count. In GISTs from all sites and in gastric GISTs, p53 expression correlated with NIH risk category. When GISTs from all sites were subjected to univariate survival analysis, an adverse outcome was associated with p53 positivity, NIH risk category, and several established prognostic factors. When gastric GISTs were assessed, the associations were similar although size was not prognostic. In multivariate survival analysis, p53 expression was independently prognostic for gastric GISTs in some models, while it was never independently prognostic for GISTs from all sites. Whether all GISTs or gastric GISTs were assessed, bcl-2 showed no association with clinical outcome or risk category.

CONCLUSIONS

Anatomical site influences p53 and bcl-2 expression in GISTs. p53 expression is associated with NIH risk category, various pathological features, and clinical outcome, and may be independently prognostic for gastric GISTs. Bcl-2 expression has no prognostic value.

Cell kinetics and apoptosis in laryngeal carcinoma patients

Cellular proliferation and apoptosis are both implicated in the process of carcinogenesis. The objective of this study was to access the prognostic significance of the expression of proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) and the apoptosis-related genes (bax, bcl-2, and p53) in laryngeal carcinoma patients. Thirty consecutive patients with stage I to IV squamous cell laryngeal carcinoma were treated in our department from 1992 to 1994. We immunohistochemically studied the expression of PCNA and bax, bcl-2, and p53 genes in their tumor specimens. Five healthy men were used as the control group. The staining results were correlated with clinicopathologic data. The PCNA protein expression was correlated with a significantly worse survival in those patients who were bax-negative (0% versus 42.86%, p = .0445). Similarly, the presence of PCNA led to an unfavorable clinical outcome in those patients who were bax-negative, bcl-2-negative, and p53-negative (0% versus 50%, p = .0278). Expression of bcl-2 protein was found to be an independent prognostic factor related to an unfavorable clinical outcome (p = .0262). The expression of bcl-2 protein appears to predict survival in laryngeal carcinoma patients. Furthermore, the combined study of proliferation markers and apoptosis-related genes helped us to identify a high-risk group of patients who may benefit from a more aggressive treatment protocol.

An immunohistochemical study of p21 and p53 expression in primary node-positive breast carcinoma

AIMS

p21, an inhibitor of cyclin-dependent kinase, is involved in the p53 pathway of growth control. Its expression has been linked to cellular differentiation. It has been implicated in p53-mediated growth arrest following DNA damage and in terminally differentiated cells. This study analysed p21 and p53 expression, in a series of node-positive patients with breast carcinoma and examined histopathological parameters of the tumour and the prognostic implications of p21 and p53 expression.

METHODS

One hundred and five consecutive patients with node-positive disease and at least 3 years follow-up were identified. Sections were stained for p53 and p21 using monoclonal antibodies. Results were expressed as percentage positive cells, and over 20% considered positive for p53 and over 10% considered for p21.

RESULTS

p21 was overexpressed (>10% of cells positive) in 65% of patients and p53 was overexpressed (>20% of cells positive in 68%. The mean (SEM) level of p21 staining was 5.7(0.8)% and was 54.9(4.0)% for p53. There was no correlation between p21 and p53 expression (r=0.071 P=0.5). There were no significant differences in demographic criteria between patients that were p21 positive or negative and p53 positive or negative. There were no significant differences in tumour type, grade or stage between the groups. p21 expression did not have prognostic significance; however, p53 positivity was associated with a worse prognosis, which remained when controlled for stage.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrated p21 overexpression in 65% of patients with node-positive breast carcinoma. Levels did not correlate with p53 status and unlike p53 failed to have prognostic significance.

p53 gene alteration and protein expression in Iranian women with infiltrative ductal breast carcinoma

Genetic alterations in the p53 tumor suppressor gene with or without protein overexpression have been reported to be associated with sporadic breast cancer. To assess the role of p53 in infiltrative ductal breast carcinoma among Iranian patients, p53 protein expression and p53 gene mutations were studied by immunohistochemical analysis and single-strand conformation polymorphism, respectively. The p53 protein was expressed in 25 out of 51 (49%) tumors and p53 gene mutations were detected in 17 out of 37 (46%) tested tumors. No significant correlation was observed between p53 gene mutations and p53 protein expression. There was no significant correlation between p53 abnormalities (mutation and expression) and tumor size, histological grade, nodal status, and progesterone receptor expression. However, a non-statistically significant trend of association (P=0.07) was observed between p53 gene mutations and lack of estrogen receptor. The high percentage of alterations both in p53 gene and protein among southern Iranian breast cancer patients suggests that p53 is probably one of the genes involved in sporadic breast cancer in this area.

p53 and P-glycoprotein expression are significant prognostic markers in advanced head and neck cancer treated with chemo/radiotherapy

The development of biological markers of response to chemo- and radiotherapy to judge benefit to risk ratios for toxic treatments is still at an experimental stage. Tumour cell death is largely by apoptosis and the p53 gene has a major influence on this. P-glycoprotein (P-gp) accumulation has been correlated with treatment failure in several types of cancer. p53 and P-gp expression were studied in 111 advanced head and neck cancers treated with radiotherapy and up to four courses of synchronous or sequential chemotherapy. The probability of survival at 5 years for patients in the trial as a whole was 27.7%, while the cohort used for this marker project was 29.4%. Among the subjects used for the marker study at the time of analysis, 13 remained disease-free and 18 were alive. Immunohistochemistry was used to assess p53 and P-gp expression; 27/111 (24%) head and neck cancers demonstrated p53/P-gp expression and 33/111 (30%) were both p53- and P-gp- negative. In univariate analysis, both p53 and P-gp expression were associated with reduced disease-free and overall survival. Multivariate analysis revealed tumour size, p53, and P-gp expression as the most powerful pretreatment prognosticators in the study cohort. Long-term follow-up results suggest that p53 and P-gp co-expression predicts the biological behaviour or the outcome following chemo/radiotherapy in advanced head and neck cancer.

Predicting the future: a critical appraisal of cancer prognosis studies

Many studies have attempted to define useful prognostic and predictive factors in cancer but few have achieved acceptance in clinical practice because of methodological weaknesses. These include failure to test clearly formulated hypotheses, inadequate sample size, inappropriate multiple significance testing, arbitrary definition of patient groups, inadequately reproducible assays, and failure to verify prognostic factors with data independent of the data which suggested the original hypothesis. This unsatisfactory situation will persist until critical attention is routinely paid to study design and prospective validation of supposed prognostic and predictive factors, without which classical approaches will be suboptimally exploited and the flood of data from new molecular technologies will not be used effectively. We propose that prognostic factors should be evaluated in three phases: I, assay definition; II, retrospective testing; III, prospective testing, ideally as a designed part of clinical trials.

bcl-2 protein expression is associated with better prognosis in colorectal cancer

AIMS

To investigate the expression of bcl-2 in colorectal carcinoma and to examine its association with mediators of apoptosis (p53 and mdm-2), clinicopathological features and long-term outcome.

METHODS AND RESULTS

We determined by immunohistochemistry the expression of bcl-2 in 102 colorectal carcinomas with 10-year follow-up. In 66 of these cases in which we had previously assessed p53 status, no correlation was seen between bcl-2 and p53. The mdm-2 protein was not detected in any of the 66 cases. Cytoplasmic staining of the bcl-2 gene product was seen in the tumour cells of 22 cases (22%). Using a polymerase chain reaction technique we showed that overexpression of bcl-2 was not due to rearrangement of the bcl-2 gene. Expression of bcl-2 protein was related to tumour grade but was unrelated to patient age, sex, tumour site, tumour size or Dukes' stage. There was a trend towards increased survival in those whose tumours expressed bcl-2 protein (P = 0.055). When entered into a multivariate analysis, this survival difference was independent of tumour stage (P = 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that bcl-2 expression in colorectal carcinoma is associated with a better long-term prognosis.

p53 expression in phyllodes tumours is associated with histological features of malignancy but does not predict outcome

AIMS

To study p53 protein expression in phyllodes tumours of the breast, with particular attention to its prevalence and to its relationship with histological features and clinical outcome.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Stromal and epithelial p53 immunohistochemical expression was studied in 57 phyllodes tumours (27 benign, 17 borderline, 13 malignant) using an avidin-biotin peroxidase method. High levels of expression (> 30% of stromal nuclei) were found in eight phyllodes tumours (14%). p53 expression was associated with tumour grade (P = 0.001), prominent stromal overgrowth (P = 0.0003), prominent stromal nuclear pleomorphism (P = 0.006), high stromal mitotic count (P = 0.05), and an infiltrative tumour margin (P = 0. 05). Six patients were lost to follow-up after surgery. Mean follow-up time of the remaining 51 patients was 7.3 years (median 4. 3, range 0.5-25) or until death. Sixteen patients (31%) experienced tumour recurrence. Recurrence was more likely if there was an infiltrative tumour margin (P = 0.006) or prominent stromal overgrowth (P = 0.04) but not p53 expression (P = 0.55). A minority of recurrences expressed p53 more extensively than their primary counterparts. There were five tumour-related deaths (10% of patients). Death was associated with high grade (P = 0.0002), prominent stromal overgrowth (P = 0.0001), an infiltrative margin (P = 0.0002), prominent nuclear pleomorphism (P = 0.005), a high mitotic count (P = 0.01) and tumour size (P = 0.03). Again, p53 expression was not associated with tumour-related survival (P = 0. 13).

CONCLUSIONS

p53 abnormalities occur in a minority of borderline and malignant phyllodes tumours. p53 expression is associated with known negative prognostic factors, but does not appear to be a useful determinant of tumour recurrence or long-term survival.

The p53 pathway

Abnormalities of the p53 tumour suppressor gene are among the most frequent molecular events in human and animal neoplasia. Moreover, p53 is one of the most studied proteins in the whole of contemporary biology, with more than 12,500 papers so far written! In this review the choice has been deliberately made not to be fully comprehensive in the coverage of the huge p53 literature. Rather attention is focused on a small number of recent developments which are reviewed in the context of modern models of p53 function. Progress in the analysis of signalling to p53 including phosphorylation cascades, and interactions with proteins such as mdm2 and ARF are highlighted. The plethora of protein-protein interactions is discussed, as are the strategies for defining downstream targets of p53. Finally, the emerging biology of p53 homologues is considered. The need for bridging the gap between reductionist, biochemical and biophysical studies and biological and genetic analysis is emphasized. Only this will provide the needed framework for utilizing the information in clinical care.

The p53 pathway

Abnormalities of the p53 tumour suppressor gene are among the most frequent molecular events in human and animal neoplasia. Moreover, p53 is one of the most studied proteins in the whole of contemporary biology, with more than 12,500 papers so far written! In this review the choice has been deliberately made not to be fully comprehensive in the coverage of the huge p53 literature. Rather attention is focused on a small number of recent developments which are reviewed in the context of modern models of p53 function. Progress in the analysis of signalling to p53 including phosphorylation cascades, and interactions with proteins such as mdm2 and ARF are highlighted. The plethora of protein-protein interactions is discussed, as are the strategies for defining downstream targets of p53. Finally, the emerging biology of p53 homologues is considered. The need for bridging the gap between reductionist, biochemical and biophysical studies and biological and genetic analysis is emphasized. Only this will provide the needed framework for utilizing the information in clinical care.

An immunochemical analysis of mdm2 expression in human breast cancer and the identification of a growth-regulated cross-reacting species p170

mdm2 is a 491 amino acid nuclear protein which is involved in complex interactions with important cell-cycle and stress-response regulators including p53, Rb and E2F. Recent data implicate mdm2 in the regulation of both p53 activity and level, and burgeoning data suggest that mdm2 may be involved in human epithelial tumourigenesis, including breast cancer. In this study the expression of mdm2 protein has been investigated in a series of 54 human breast carcinomas using immunoblotting methods. Overexpression of the predominant p90 mdm2 isoform is common in breast cancer (54 per cent) and this is not frequently a consequence of gene amplification. There is no relationship between p90 expression and either p53 protein expression or p53 mutational status. Additional mdm2 immunoreactive species of differing mobilities are identifiable, greatly complicating the analysis. For example, a p170 form is seen in many breast cancer samples (44 per cent) using 2A10 but is not identified by 3G5. This 2A10 immunoreactive species, which is almost certainly not an mdm2 isoform, is a growth-regulated protein, being undetectable in resting peripheral blood lymphocytes and rising to high levels after PHA stimulation. In contrast to mdm2 (p90), p170 is not induced by DNA damage caused by UV light. p170 is identifiable in mdm2 null cells by immunoblotting and is detected as a nuclear protein. While mdm2 immunostaining studies are increasing, this report highlights the complexity of mdm2 analysis in vivo and emphasizes the need to correlate immunohistological and biochemical assays since, in some mdm2 (p90) negative tumours, nuclear immunoreactivity may be identified as a consequence of cross-reacting species such as p170.

The p53 tumour suppressor gene

BACKGROUND

Abnormalities of the p53 tumour suppressor gene are thought to be central to the development of a high proportion of human tumours. This article reviews current understanding of its function and potential clinical significance.

METHODS

Material was identified from previous review articles, references cited in original papers, a Medline search of the literature over the 12 months to January 1998, and by scanning the latest issues of relevant journals.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSION

p53 is considered to be a stress response gene, its product (the p53 protein) acting to induce cell cycle arrest or apoptosis in response to DNA damage, thereby maintaining genetic stability in the organism. These functions are executed by a complex and incompletely understood series of steps known as the 'p53 pathway', part of which involves induction of the expression of a number of other genes. As p53 is the most commonly mutated gene in human cancer, it has attracted a great deal of interest as a prognostic factor, diagnostic tool and therapeutic target. However, despite many promising studies, its potential in practical cancer management has still to be realized.

The challenge of p53: linking biochemistry, biology, and patient management

Abnormalities of the p53 tumor suppressor gene are the single most common molecular abnormality seen in human cancer. Considerable evidence indicates that the product of this gene has critical roles in coordinating the response of cells to a diverse range of environmental stresses. At present, there is a gamut of biochemical properties and interactions ascribed to p53, but the in vivo physiological relevance of many of these remains uncertain. The development of clinical applications and novel therapeutic strategies utilizing our knowledge of p53 is contingent upon bridging the gap between rigorous biochemistry and holistic in vivo studies.

Clinical relevance of p53 and bcl-2 protein over-expression in laryngeal squamous-cell carcinoma

We investigated immunohistochemically the clinical relevance of the over-expression of the apoptosis-regulating proteins p53 and bcl-2 in a homogeneous series of 149 laryngeal squamous-cell carcinomas. p53 was over-expressed in 75 cases and bcl-2 in 39 cases. p53 and bcl-2 co-expression was found in 21 cases. p53 and bcl-2 immunoreactivity was significantly associated with poor histological differentiation and lymph-node metastases. Moreover, a significant statistical correlation was found between bcl-2 expression, supraglottic tumor site and advanced disease stage. p53/bcl-2 co-expression was significantly associated with poor differentiation, tumor extension, the presence of lymph-node metastases and advanced clinical stage. Univariate analysis showed that a lower probability of survival was significantly associated with supraglottic site, tumor extension, advanced clinical stage and p53/bcl-2 co-expression, but not with p53 or bcl-2 considered separately. In multivariate analysis, only tumor extension and supraglottic site retained their prognostic value. Our data suggest that clinical staging remains the most reliable predictive indicator of survival in patients with laryngeal carcinoma.

Molecular assessment of p53 abnormalities at the invasive front of oral squamous cell carcinomas

BACKGROUND

The prognostic significance of the invasive tumor front in squamous cell carcinomas has recently been recognized. The aim of the present study was to investigate possible molecular mechanisms underlying the significance of this area in oral squamous cell carcinomas.

METHODS

We used immunohistochemical and molecular genetic techniques to investigate whether p53 alterations at the invasive tumor front could determine the aggressiveness of oral cancers.

RESULTS

p53 Overexpression was detected in 52% to 56% (four different p53 antibodies) of 100 carcinomas studied. The concordance rate between results of immunohistochemistry and genetic analysis was 60%. No correlation was found between p53 status of the tumors and clinicopathologic parameters analyzed statistically.

CONCLUSIONS

p53 Alterations have no prognostic impact in oral squamous cell carcinomas and apparently do not represent a molecular basis for the biologic significance of the invasive tumor front. The detection of discordant p53 aberrations between primary and second primary carcinomas in some patients provide evidence for their independent origin, with possible impact on prevention and therapy.

Biochemical and molecular mechanisms regulating apoptosis

In eukaryotes, the regulation of tissue cell numbers is a critical homeostatic objective that is achieved through tight control of apoptosis, mitosis and differentiation. While much is known about the genetic regulation of cell growth and differentiation, the molecular basis of apoptosis is less well understood. Genes involved in both cell proliferation and apoptosis reflect the role of some stimuli in both of these processes, the cell response depending on the overall cellular milieu. Recent research has given fascinating insights into the complex genetic and molecular mechanisms regulating apoptosis. A picture is emerging of the initiation in certain cells, after an apoptotic trigger, of sequential gene expression and specific signal transduction cascades that guide cells along the cell death pathway. Changes in gene expression precede the better known biochemical and morphological changes of apoptosis. It seems possible that, as a result of increased understanding of the cellular events preceding cell death, apoptosis may become more amenable to manipulation by appropriate drug- and gene-based therapies.

Drug resistance in ovarian cancer - the role of p53

The aims were to determine the importance of p53 and bcl-2 expression on the response to chemotherapy with alkylating agents in patients with ovarian cancer. We have followed the response to chemotherapy in a series of 59 patients with ovarian adenocarcinoma designated as p53 and bcl-2 positive or negative by immunocytochemistry. Of these cases, 50 received either cisplatin + treosulfan or treosulfan alone. Immunocytochemistry for p53 was positive in 28/59 tumors. Patients were grouped according to their response to chemotherapy (stable or progressive disease) assessed at 6, 12, and 18 months. There was increasing divergence of p53+ and p53- tumors over time. Of those which were p53+, 25% showed progression at 6 months, 80% at 12 months and 89% progression at 18 months. In contrast, 23%, 50%, and 67% of p53- tumors showed progression at 6, 12 and 18 months respectively. For bcl-2, in 23/55 positive tumors there was progression in 35%, 78% and 94% compared with 25%, 57% and 59% in bcl-2 negative tumors at 6,12 and 18 months respectively. Those tumors which were bcl-2 and p53 negative were most likely to progress, while those which were bcl-2 and p53 positive had the best prognosis. These differences did not translate into increased overall survival with minimum follow-up of 12 months. This data lends support to our suggestion that despite initially increased susceptibility to alkylating agents, enhanced genomic instability due to p53 inactivation may render tumors more likely to develop resistance to chemotherapy over time. This effect may be altered by bcl-2 function, lack of which will lead to a good response to chemotherapy as the tumor's ability to undergo apoptosis will not be compromised.

Analysis of p53 expression in osteosarcoma of the jaw: correlation with clinicopathologic and DNA ploidy findings

The objective of this study was to determine whether p53 expression correlated with clinicopathological and DNA ploidy in osteosarcoma of the jaw, a particular subtype of osteosarcoma associated with an older age at presentation, longer median survival, rare metastasis, and death due to uncontrolled local recurrence. Seventeen cases of osteosarcoma of the jaw were stained for p53 using CM1 antibody (Novocastra). Eight cases (47.5%) showed nuclear staining in more than 10% of the neoplastic nuclei. Ploidy analysis showed 13 aneuploid (eight p53+) and three diploid (none p53+) tumors. No significant relationship was found between p53 positivity and clinicomorphological features, DNA ploidy or survival. p53-positive cases were, however, more commonly associated with aneuploidy and chondroblastic differentiation. These results indicate that p53 immunostaining does not seem to provide prognostic information in osteosarcoma of the jaw.

Biological indicators of survival in patients treated by surgery for squamous cell carcinoma of the oral cavity and oropharynx

Squamous cell carcinomas of the head and neck are a heterogeneous group of tumours with regard to anatomical site, natural history and response to various treatments. Assessment of the role of biomarkers as indicators of prognosis or response to treatment is thus complex. In the last decade, different biomarkers have been investigated in the search for objective and reproducible indicators of prognosis. In 69 squamous cell carcinomas of the oral cavity or oropharynx from patients treated with radical surgery alone, we determined cell kinetics, evaluated as in vitro 3H-thymidine labelling index (TLI), p53, bcl-2 and glutathione S-transferase pi (GST pi) expression, by using immunohistochemical methods. The biological variables were unrelated to one another or to established clinical and pathological prognostic factors. Univariate analysis showed that a low proliferative activity was associated to a significantly higher risk of death than that observed in patients with a high TLI, whereas p53, bcl-2 and GST pi expression did not provide prognostic information. Multivariate analysis showed that cell proliferation, gender and nodal status retained their clinical relevance. In the subset of node-negative patients, TLI and p53 expression were indicators of survival. Moreover, the combined analysis of TLI and p53 expression identified a subgroup of node-negative patients with slowly proliferating and highly p53-expressing tumours who died within 1 year of radical surgery. These results indicate that in patients with operable oral cavity and oropharyngeal cancer, biomarkers can provide important information on clinical outcome.

Antigen retrieval immunohistochemistry: past, present, and future

The antigen retrieval (AR) technique, which is predominantly based on high-temperature heating of tissues, is used as a non-enzymatic pretreatment for immunohistochemical staining of formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue sections. It has been widely applied in pathology and analytical morphology. The existence of a growing body of literature on the AR technique raises a number of interesting issues for the further development of AR. These issues include the use of a "test battery" and the concept of "maximal retrieval" applied to the selection of optimal test protocols for the standardization of AR.

Prognostic markers for colorectal cancer: expression of P53 and BCL2

P53 is a tumor suppressor gene that has been implicated in the pathogenesis of a wide range of tumor types including colorectal cancers. bcl2 is a proto-oncogene that inhibits apoptosis. Immunostaining for P53 and BLC2 protein product was performed in a retrospective series of 80 colorectal carcinomas with a minimum follow-up of 5 years. The aim of the study was to evaluate the prognostic significance of P53 and BCL2 protein expression and their correlation with clinicopathologic variables such as pathologic disease stage (Dukes system), histologic grade, and vascular invasion. The patients were 41 to 76 years of age, and the follow-up ranged between 5 and 10 years. Among the 80 cases, 30 were Dukes stage A and 50 stage B. We found vascular invasion in 21.2%. P53 and BCL2 expression was detected, respectively, in 30.0% and 8.8%. We concluded that the P53 and BCL2 expression detected by immunohistochemistry in routinely processed, paraffin-embedded tissues: (1) has no prognostic significance; and (2) was not correlated with pathologic disease stage, histologic grade, or vascular invasion. Nevertheless, the number of patients in our study was small, and we believe that investigation of a larger series of patients is indicated.

Expression of p53 in adrenocortical tumours: clinicopathological correlations

There are limited data to suggest that abnormalities of p53 expression may be a late event in the development of adrenocortical tumours. This has been investigated further by examining a series of adrenocortical adenomas and carcinomas by immunohistochemistry for p53 expression and a subset for evidence of mutation in exons 5-8 of the p53 gene using polymerase chain reaction/single strand conformational polymorphism (PCR/SSCP). In carcinomas, the findings have been correlated with survival data and with tumour ploidy. Immunopositivity for p53 was seen in 4 of 34 adenomas and 22 of 42 carcinomas. Mobility shifts were identified in 1 of 4 adenomas and 10 of 21 carcinomas. There was no correlation between immunostaining pattern or PCR/SSCP evidence of mutation and either survival or disease-free survival in carcinoma. There was also no correlation between p53 status and tumour ploidy. While these findings support a role for p53 in tumour progression, abnormal p53 expression does not appear to have any significant prognostic effect in carcinoma.

The molecular epidemiology of p53 gene mutations in human breast cancer

The P53 tumor-suppressor gene is an advantageous tool for analyzing the molecular epidemiology of cancer. We describe the utility of the P53 gene as a 'mutagen test' and a prognostic indicator in breast cancer. Aspects of study design and methodology are discussed. Two major conclusions emerge: (1) there is an extraordinary diversity of mutational patterns among cohorts, hinting that the unique biology of mammary cells results in exposure to high doses of a diversity of ingested lipophilic mutagens; and (2) mutations in the P53 gene predict poor outcome in breast cancer.

Molecular abnormalities of the p53 pathway in dedifferentiated liposarcoma

Dedifferentiated liposarcoma represents a distinct subtype of liposarcoma and is characterized by the presence of abrupt transition from well-differentiated liposarcoma to high-grade pleomorphic sarcoma (mostly MFH-like). A key role for p53 in tumour progression of this subset of liposarcomas has been suggested on the basis of p53 immunopositivity. A series of 14 dedifferentiated liposarcomas has been investigated by analysing the p53 gene and protein together with the p53-related molecules p21Waf1 and mdm2, to verify whether the p53 pathway is involved in the development and progression of this tumour type. The results indicate that the p53 gene is rarely involved in dedifferentiated liposarcoma (7 per cent of cases analysed) and that low percentages of p53 immunopositivity are still compatible with integrity of the p53 gene. This concept is also supported by the observed preservation of p21Waf1 immunoreactivity in all but the p53-mutated cases. By contrast, mdm2 overexpression emerges as the most frequent abnormality in dedifferentiated liposarcoma (57 and 78 per cent of cases in well-differentiated and high-grade areas, respectively).

Prognostic significance of p53 abnormalities in colorectal carcinoma detected by PCR-SSCP and immunohistochemical analysis

Abnormalities in the p53 tumour suppressor gene and in the expression of its protein are common in colorectal carcinoma. The prognostic significance of these p53 abnormalities was studied in 66 patients with colorectal cancer, followed for more than 10 years. Single-strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) analysis was used to detect alterations in exons 5-8 of the p53 gene. Paraffin sections were examined immunohistochemically for p53 overexpression with the monoclonal antibody DO-7 (Dako) both with and without microwave antigen retrieval. Abnormalities of the p53 gene were found in 41 per cent of cases by SSCP analysis. Outcome was unrelated to SSCP abnormalities (P = 0.19), except for the Dukes' A and B subgroup, where decreased survival was found in cases with abnormal SSCP (P = 0.01). Overexpression of p53 protein was seen by immunohistochemistry in 47 per cent of cases without, and in 52 per cent of cases with microwave antigen retrieval. Immunohistochemical overexpression of p53 protein either with or without microwave antigen retrieval was an independent prognostic indicator of poor survival. These results suggest that for routine purposes, immunohistochemical detection of the p53 protein product may be more useful than SSCP analysis of the encoding p53 gene in identifying those at high risk of colorectal cancer recurrence and death.

p53 expression in carcinoma of the cervix

AIM

To assess overexpression of the proposed tumour suppressor gene product p53 using the mouse monoclonal antibody DO-7 in the three main subtypes of carcinoma of the uterine cervix and to evaluate its value as a prognostic indicator.

METHODS

Eighty two cases of FIGO Stage IB/IIA uterine cervical carcinoma were studied retrospectively. The tumours had been previously typed into adenocarcinomas, squamous carcinomas and adenosquamous carcinomas after the tissue had been fixed in formalin and embedded in paraffin wax. p53 protein expression was assessed using a standard immunohistochemical technique and the findings were correlated with tumour type, lymph node status and clinical outcome.

RESULTS

In total, the p53 gene product was overexpressed in 17.1% (14/82) of all carcinomas and also in areas of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade III adjacent to invasive squamous carcinoma. Where present, the normal epithelium was uniformly negative. No association was found between p53 overexpression and tumour subtype, lymph node status or clinical outcome.

CONCLUSIONS

It seems unlikely that p53 analysis will be of value in determining prognosis in carcinoma of the uterine cervix.

The p53 gene as a modifier of intrinsic radiosensitivity: implications for radiotherapy

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Experimental studies have implicated the normal or "wild type' p53 protein (i.e. WTp53) in the cellular response to ionizing radiation and other DNA damaging agents. Whether altered WTp53 protein function can lead to changes in cellular radiosensitivity and/or clinical radiocurability remains an area of ongoing study. In this review, we describe the potential implications of altered WTp53 protein function in normal and tumour cells as it relates to clinical radiotherapy, and describe novel treatment strategies designed to re-institute WTp53 protein function as a means of sensitizing cells to ionizing radiation.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

A number of experimental and clinical studies are critically reviewed with respect to the role of the p53 protein as a determinant of cellular oncogenesis, genomic stability, apoptosis, DNA repair and radioresponse in normal and transformed mammalian cells.

RESULTS

In normal fibroblasts, exposure to ionizing radiation leads to a G1 cell cycle delay (i.e. a "G1 checkpoint') as a result of WTp53 mediated inhibition of G1-cyclin-kinase and retinoblastoma (pRb) protein function. The G1 checkpoint response is absent in tumour cells which express a mutant form of the p53 protein (i.e. MTp53), leading to acquired radioresistance in vitro. Depending on the cell type studied, this increase in cellular radiation survival can be mediated through decreased radiation-induced apoptosis, or altered kinetics of the radiation-induced G1 checkpoint. Recent biochemical studies support an indirect role for the p53 protein in both nucleotide excision and recombinational DNA repair pathways. However, based on clinicopathologic data, it remains unclear as to whether WTp53 protein function can predict for human tumour radiocurability and normal tissue radioresponse.

CONCLUSIONS

Alterations in cell cycle control secondary to aberrant WTp53 protein function may be clinically significant if they lead to the acquisition of mutant cellular phenotypes, including the radioresistant phenotype. Pre-clinical studies suggest that these phenotypes may be reversed using adenovirus-mediated gene therapy or pharmacologic strategies designed to re-institute WTp53 protein function. Our analysis of the published data strongly argues for the use of functional assays for the determination of WTp53 protein function in studies which attempt to correlate normal and tumour tissue radioresponse with p53 genotype, or p53 protein expression.