First-trimester diagnosis of Menkes disease: intermediate copper values in chorionic villi from three affected male fetuses

Menkes disease: what a multidisciplinary approach can do

Disorders of copper homeostasis are currently recognized across the life span. Their recognition and links to human disease have spanned several decades, beginning with the recognition of a degenerative disorder in the offspring of sheep grazing in copper-deficient pastures, through to the description of infants suffering from a progressive neurodegenerative disorder characterized by epileptic seizures, developmental regression, failure to thrive, and an unusual hair quality (giving the condition its distinctive label of “kinky hair disease”). In this review, we trace the historical background and describe the biochemistry and physiology of copper metabolism and transport, inheritance patterns, molecular genetics, and genotype–phenotype correlations based on current understanding of the disorder. It is clear from the clinical presentations and variants that disorders of copper homeostasis include phenotypes ranging from mild occipital horn syndrome to intermediate and severe forms of classical Menkes disease. The symptoms involve multiple organ systems such as brain, lung, gastrointestinal tract, urinary tract, connective tissue, and skin. A multisystem disorder needs a multidisciplinary approach to care, as treatment interventions permit longer survival for some individuals. Animal models have been developed to help screen treatment options and provide a better understanding of these disorders in the laboratory. Finally, we propose a multidisciplinary approach to promote continued research (both basic and clinical) to improve survival, quality of life, and care for these conditions.

Clinical manifestations and treatment of Menkes disease and its variants

The clinical manifestations of classical Menkes disease, mild Menkes disease and occipital horn syndrome are reviewed. Menkes disease is a neurodegenerative disease with X-linked recessive inheritance. Orally administered copper accumulates in the intestine, resulting in the failure of copper absorption. The primary metabolic defect that causes copper accumulation in the intestine is present in almost all extrahepatic tissues. The blood, liver and brain are in a state of copper deficiency, which is due to defective copper absorption. The characteristic features, including neurological disturbances, arterial degeneration and hair abnormalities, can be explained by the decrease in cuproenzyme activities. DNA-based diagnosis is now possible. Mild Menkes disease and occipital horn syndrome, which show milder forms than Menkes disease, have been identified as genetic disorders resulting from mutations in the Menkes disease gene. Because the clinical spectrum of Menkes disease is wide, males with mental retardation and connective tissue abnormalities should be evaluated for biochemical evidence of defective copper transport. The treatment accepted currently is parenteral administration of copper. When treatment is started in patients with classical Menkes disease above the age of 2 months, it does not improve the neurological degeneration. When the treatment is initiated in newborn babies affected with this disease, the neurological degeneration can be prevented in some, but not all, cases. Moreover, early treatment cannot improve non-neurological problems, such as connective tissue laxity. Therefore, alternative therapies for Menkes disease and occipital horn syndrome should be studied.

Recent developments in Menkes disease

Recent studies on Menkes disease are reviewed, focusing especially on copper transport in the cells. A large amount of copper accumulated in the organelle-free cytoplasm, whereas mitochondria were in a state of copper deficiency, indicating that Menkes mutation probably affects copper transport from the cytosol to the organelles in the cells. Microscopic observation of the brain of the macular mouse showed that copper accumulates in the blood vessels. Observation of the brain tissue of the macular mouse after intraventricular administration of copper revealed that copper accumulates in the glia as well as the blood vessels. Copper accumulation was also observed in cultured astrocytes, a type of glial cell, indicating that the affected astrocytes accumulate blood-borne copper and release little of it in the patients with Menkes disease. Thus the effective treatment of Menkes disease could possibly be to release trapped copper from the blood vessels and glia into the neurons.

Incidence of Menkes disease

We have calculated the incidence of Menkes disease for Denmark, France, The Netherlands, the United Kingdom and West Germany, based on known Menkes patients born during the time period 1976-87. Considering live-born Menkes patients, the combined incidence for these five countries is 1 Menkes patient per 298,000 live-born babies. If the number of affected aborted fetuses are taken into account, the incidence is 1 Menkes per 254,000 live-born babies. This incidence, which is 2-4 times lower than earlier published incidence figures, places Menkes disease as an extremely rare disease. The mutation rate for Menkes disease is estimated to be 1.96 x 10(-6), based on the number of isolated Menkes cases born during the time period 1976-87 and the total number of newborn males during this time.

Prenatal and postnatal diagnosis of Menkes disease, an inherited disorder of copper metabolism

105 patients with Menkes disease have been diagnosed from 64Cu-uptake studies in fibroblasts. These results are presented together with chase results following removal of 64Cu from the medium for 16 Menkes patients. Second-trimester prenatal diagnosis has been performed in 80 pregnancies with male karyotype. These 64Cu-uptake results show some overlap between the upper end of the normal range and the lower end of the Menkes range. Results are presented to show that a combination of 64Cu-uptake and chase results offers a better diagnostic potential than 64Cu-uptake per se. Chorionic villus copper values from 53 first-trimester prenatal diagnoses are presented. Maternal deciduum from some of these pregnancies contain similar high amounts of copper as found in the chorionic villus samples from affected fetuses. 64Cu-uptake in cultured chorionic villi from affected fetuses and unaffected fetuses is not discriminatory. Chase results seem however to offer a better diagnostic potential.