Risks of transabdominal chorionic villus sampling before the 12th week of amenorrhea

Feasibility, accuracy and safety of chorionic villus sampling: a report of 10741 cases

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the feasibility, accuracy and safety of chorionic villus sampling (CVS).

METHODS

Ten thousand seven hundred and forty one singleton pregnancies at risk of chromosome abnormalities (96.3%) and gene disorders (2.8%) were referred from 1990 to 1999 to the fetal medicine unit of a teaching hospital. CVS was performed transabdominally after 11 weeks, using a modified freehand ultrasonographically guided technique by 5 operators. Fetal karyotyping was obtained using a direct method before 1995 and was completed by cell culture after 1996. Failed results, feto-placental discrepancy and fetal loss were assessed.

RESULTS

Villi were sampled using extra-amniotic puncture (89.4%) and one sampling-device insertion (92.3%). The mean weight of the specimen was 15.2 +/- 6.0 mg. All attempts at sampling were successful, except eight (0.07%). The number of failed results following direct preparation, cell culture and both methods was 20 (0.19%), 23 (0.21%) and 2 (0.02%), respectively. Light maternal cell contamination occurred in less than 1% of the samplings after microscopic selection of the villi, and never interfered with the assessment of karyotyping. All 3 false-negative results (0.03%) were recorded after direct preparation and 2 were corrected by culture. The rate of chromosomal abnormalities confined to the placenta decreased from 1.08% before 1995 to 0.73% after 1996. True fetal mosaicisms were recorded in 7 cases (0.06%). The rate of fetal loss at <28 weeks was 1.64% in all pregnancies and 1.92% when CVS was performed before 13 weeks. Advanced maternal age was the single factor significantly associated with fetal loss.

CONCLUSIONS

CVS was feasible, accurate and safe in our institution, as a result of the increasing experience of the operators and the cytogeneticists.

Prenatal diagnosis of trisomy 9. Six cases and a review of the literature

Six prenatally diagnosed cases of trisomy 9 are reported and 22 previously reported cases are reviewed; the difficulty of genetic counselling for such cases and the variation in the percentage of trisomic cells in different tissues, thus making accurate diagnosis of trisomy 9 difficult, are emphasized. In addition to karyotyping results, ultrasound findings are important in achieving diagnoses. Finally, a course of action when prenatal trisomy 9 is detected is proposed.

Implications of maternal serum alpha-fetoprotein elevation caused by transabdominal and transcervical CVS

Of 2882 women allocated to either transabdominal CVS (TA) or transcervical CVS (TC) at two large obstetric centres in Denmark, 2707 had blood samples drawn before and 30 min after CVS for maternal serum-alpha-fetoprotein (MSAFP) measurement. 2535 of these women had cytogenetically normal pregnancies and 2091 of them went on to have samples drawn at the 18-20 week follow-up. Post-procedure MSAFP values were correlated to the biopsy method used, with mean MSAFP values significantly higher after TA than TC, 33 and 15 kU/l, respectively (P < 0.001). Following TA procedures, 18 per cent of cases had feto-maternal transfusion higher than 0.1 ml; this occurred in only 5 per cent of TC cases. MSAFP levels were associated with spontaneous fetal loss in the TA group but not in the TC group. TC, however, was followed by more losses than TA. The post-CVS MSAFP value was positively correlated with the amount of villi aspirated. The difference in post-procedure elevation in MSAFP 30 min later (average 18 kU/l higher for TA than for TC) was not reflected in raised levels at the 18-20 week follow-up. Study medians at mid-trimester did not differ from reference group medians established from a group of singleton pregnancies with sonographically determined gestational age who did not experience invasive procedures and delivered normal infants. Our findings suggest that CVS does not compromise mid-trimester MSAFP for screening for neural tube defects (NTDs). Extremely high mid-trimester MSAFP values in the TC group could predict imminent loss.

Terminal transverse limb defects and early chorionic villus sampling: evaluation of 4,300 cases with completed follow-up

Data from 4,300 consecutive cases following prenatal diagnosis by transcervical (TC) CVS (n = 1,570) and transabdominal (TA) CVS (n = 2,370) were evaluated. In the follow-up study only infants examined by a physician were included. Gestational age varied between 8.5 and 11.6 weeks (mean 10.3 weeks) for TC-CVS and between 9.3 and 20 weeks (mean 12.3 weeks) for TA-CVS 98% of TC-CVS was performed at 9-10 weeks, 80.7% of TA-CVS procedures were carried out at 12-15 weeks. Selective termination took place in 97 cases of TC-CVS (6.1%) and in 72 cases of TA-CVS (2.6%). Another 8 women had a termination for psychosocial reasons, resulting in 4,123 (1,469 TC, 2,654 TA) continuing pregnancies. The overall fetal loss rate < 28 weeks was 5.4% (n = 80) for TC-CVS and 2.6% (n = 70) for TA-CVS. The overall incidence of congenital abnormalities after birth was 0.9%. Two terminal transversal limb defects were detected in the TC-CVS group (0.14%) against one (0.04%) in the TA-CVS group.

Randomised comparison of amniocentesis and transabdominal and transcervical chorionic villus sampling

We have compared three methods of prenatal diagnosis in two large obstetric centres in Denmark. Women were randomly assigned transabdominal (TA) chorionic villus sampling (CVS), transcervical (TC) CVS, or second-trimester amniocentesis (AC); women at high genetic risk were randomised between the two CVS groups only. Analysis of 45 epidemiological variables showed the three procedure groups to be similar at enrollment. All women were followed up until completion of pregnancy. Among 3079 women at low genetic risk total fetal loss rates were 10.9% for TC CVS, 6.3% for TA CVS, and 6.4% for AC (p < 0.001). More women had bleeding after the procedure in the CVS groups (p < 0.001), whereas more amniotic fluid leakage (p < 0.001) was reported after AC. No uterine infections occurred in any group. No case of oromandibular-limb abnormality was seen in the CVS groups, but 1 child in the AC group had aplasia of the right hand. The two CVS approaches were compared among 2882 women at low and high genetic risk who were found to have cytogenetically normal fetuses. Rates of unintentional loss after the procedure were 7.7% for TC CVS and 3.7% for TA CVS (p < 0.001; 95% Cl of difference 2.3-5.8%). At baseline ultrasound scanning after establishment of optimum sampling conditions, more TC than TA procedures (p < 0.001) were judged not to be feasible. We found that TA CVS allows better access to the placental site than TC sampling, is an easier skill to acquire, and has the potential that more villi can be aspirated when needed. The risk of fetal loss is similar after TA CVS and AC. However, losses after AC are at a later stage and are therefore more distressing. TA procedures remain the first choice for prenatal diagnosis. Since, in our hands, TC sampling carries a greater risk to the fetus, we have abandoned TC CVS in our two study centres.

Transabdominal chorionic villus sampling: fetal loss rate in relation to maternal and gestational age

In this paper we report the fetal loss rate in relation to both maternal and gestational age in 1764 pregnant women who underwent transabdominal chorionic villus sampling (TA-CVS) between January 1986 and August 1990. The fetal loss rate, considered as a proportion of continuing pregnancies, decreased with advancing gestational age at sampling from 4.3 per cent before 9 weeks to 0.4 per cent at or after 13 weeks, the difference being statistically significant (p < 0.025). The fetal loss rate increased from 1.6 per cent in women under 30 to 2.4 per cent in women of 40 years or over, but the difference was not statistically significant. Considering that the total fetal loss rate before 28 weeks' gestation was on average 1.91 per cent (1.3 per cent under 35 years and 2.8 per cent in women of 35 or over), we believe that TA-CVS is a safe and effective technique for prenatal diagnosis of genetic diseases.

Factors associated with multiple-pass procedures during chorionic villus sampling: a video analysis

Multiple placental passes during chorionic villus sampling (CVS) increase the risk of fetal loss; however, specific factors that predispose to repeat aspiration have not been delineated. To identify anatomic and technical variables associated with multiple-pass procedures, a detailed review of 205 videotaped CVS procedures (single pass = 163; multiple pass = 42) was performed, blinded to pregnancy outcome. The route of sampling did not influence the need for multiple aspiration attempts (transabdominal--30/135; transcervical--12/70), nor was placental location alone discriminatory. However, the combination of a posterior placenta and uterine retroversion was observed more frequently in the multiple-pass cohort (8/42 vs. 9/163; p less than 0.05). In transabdominal cases, suboptimal needle placement (e.g., perpendicular to the placental long axis) was more common in the initial aspiration of a multiple-pass procedure (21/30 vs. 38/105; p less than 0.01), while limited penetration of the catheter tip (e.g., just inside the placental edge) characterized a majority of multiple-pass cases in the transcervical subset (7/12 vs. 3/58; p less than 0.0001). A case-control cohort was constructed to evaluate the impact of these technical variables on sampling efficacy, independent of the influence of uterine position and placental site. In that analysis, suboptimal location and/or orientation of the sampling device remained characteristic of multiple-pass cases. We conclude that further reduction in the frequency of multiple-pass procedures might be achieved by consistent placement of the device tip in the central placental mass. Unlike amniocentesis, where any point of amnion entry will suffice, this technical nuance should be emphasized with CVS to maximize the single-pass success rate.