Utility of fetal whole exome sequencing in the etiological evaluation and outcome of nonimmune hydrops fetalis

A systematic review to assess the utility of genomic autopsy using exome or genome sequencing in cases of congenital anomalies and perinatal death

PURPOSE

Exome or genome sequencing (ES or GS) can identify genetic causes of otherwise unexplained congenital anomaly and perinatal death (PND) but is not routine practice. The evidence base for "genomic autopsy" after termination of pregnancy for fetal anomaly (TOPFA) and PND has been synthesized to determine the value of this investigation.

METHODS

We conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis of studies meeting prespecified inclusion criteria and containing ≥10 cases of TOPFA or PND (with or without major congenital abnormality), in which ES or GS was conducted. We determined test performance, including diagnostic yield, accuracy, and reliability. We also reported outcomes associated with clinical utility and harms, where described.

RESULTS

From 2245 potentially eligible studies, 32 publications were eligible and had data extracted, representing 2120 cases that could be meta-analyzed. No diagnostic accuracy or comparative studies were identified, although some analysis of concordance between different ES/GS methodologies could be performed. Studies reporting parent-related outcomes or long-term follow-up did not do so in a systematic or quantifiable manner.

CONCLUSION

Evidence suggests that approximately one-fourth to one-third of fetal losses associated with TOPFA or unexplained PND are associated with a genetic cause identifiable on ES or GS-albeit this estimate varies depending on phenotypic and background risk factors. Despite the large body of evidence on ES and GS, little research has attempted to validate the accuracy of testing, nor measure the clinical or societal outcomes in families that follow the diagnostic investigation in this context.

RASopathies are the most common set of monogenic syndromes identified by exome sequencing for nonimmune hydrops fetalis: A systematic review and meta-analysis

RASopathies are a group of malformation syndromes known to lead to nonimmune hydrops fetalis (NIHF) in severe presentations. Pathogenic variants can be de novo or parentally inherited. Despite being a known frequent presentation, the fraction of monogenic NIHF cases due to RASopathies is limited in the literature. Also, the specific parental contribution of RASopathies to NIHF is not well described. Our objective was to review pooled exome sequencing (ES) diagnostic yield of RASopathies for NIHF and to determine the parental contribution of RASopathy to NIHF. We performed a systematic review of prenatal ES studies from January 1, 2000 to August 1, 2022. Thirty-six studies met inclusion criteria. Cases with RASopathy gene variants were reviewed. NIHF cases were further classified as isolated or non-isolated. Thirty-six ES studies including 46 pregnancies with NIHF and a diagnosed RASopathy were reviewed. Forty-four diagnostic variants and 2 variants of uncertain significance in 12 RASopathy genes were identified. Expanding on what was previously published, a total of 506 NIHF cases were extracted with 191 cases yielding a positive diagnosis by ES. The overall rate of RASopathy diagnosis in clinically diagnosed NIHF cases was 9% (44/506). The rate of RASopathy diagnosis among NIHF cases with positive genetic diagnosis by ES was 23% (44/191). Of the 46 cases identified, 13 (28%) variants were parentally inherited; specifically, 5/13 (38%) maternal, 3/13 (23%) paternal, 2/13 (15%) biparental, and 3/13 (23%) unspecified. Majority of NIHF cases 29/46 (63%) were isolated. Among NIHF cases with positive ES diagnoses, RASopathy diagnostic yield by ES was 23%. NIHF secondary to RASopathies was parentally inherited in 28% of cases. Most cases of NIHF due to RASopathy were isolated, with no prenatal detection of associated anomalies.

PIEZO1 is the most common monogenic etiology of non-immune hydrops fetalis detected by prenatal exome sequencing

OBJECTIVE

To clarify the relevance of PIEZO1 variants detected by prenatal exome in the context of non-immune hydrops fetalis (NIHF).

METHODS

A systematic review of prenatal exome studies from 1/1/2000-8/1/2022 was performed. Thirty-six studies met the inclusion criteria. PIEZO1 variants were categorized by disease mode (dominant (AD) versus recessive (AR)) and classified by the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG) guidelines.

RESULTS

Twenty-two pregnancies with 35 distinct PIEZO1 variants were included. We deemed PIEZO1 variants to be "likely diagnostic" in 12/22 pregnancies, "possibly diagnostic" in 7/22, and "unlikely diagnostic" in 3/22. In total, 19 of 191 NIHF cases diagnosed by prenatal exome were attributed to PIEZO1. Among likely diagnosed cases, the disease mode was AR in eight and AD in four. PIEZO1 variants causing AR NIHF were characterized by loss of function and isolated NIHF phenotype. PIEZO1 variants causing AD NIHF were characterized by gain of function in red blood cells, scarcity in databases, and sporadic inheritance. Missense variants associated with NIHF were clustered in three domains: transmembrane helical unit 4 (THU4), THU5, and the Cap.

CONCLUSION

PIEZO1 variants were reported in 10% of NIHF cases diagnosed by prenatal exome, making PIEZO1 the most common single gene reported in NIHF.

The Cardiovascular Profile Score in Patients with Non-immune Hydrops Fetalis and Cardiac Anomalies - a Pilot Study

The purpose of this paper is to explore whether the cardiovascular profile score (CVPS) correlates with fetal outcome in patients with non-immune hydrops fetalis (NIHF) and cardiac anomalies. In this retrospective study, we included fetuses with NIHF and the suspicion of a cardiac anomaly in prenatal ultrasound. The CVPS was calculated using information obtained by fetal echocardiographic examination. Feto-neonatal mortality (FNM) was defined as intrauterine fetal demise or death in the first 6 months of life. We reviewed 98 patients, who were referred to the Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology of the Johannes Gutenberg University in Mainz with the diagnosis of NIHF between January 2007 and March 2021. By eighteen of them, the suspicion of a cardiac anomaly was raised. After exclusion of six pregnancies (one termination of pregnancy and five because of incomplete data), 12 cases were left for analysis. Mean gestational age at which the CVPS was calculated was 29 + 2 weeks. Two fetuses died in utero. Of the remaining ten hydropic fetuses, three newborns died in the neonatal period, and seven survived after a 6-month surveillance period. Median CVPS of all fetuses was 6 points. Surviving fetuses showed statistically significantly higher CVPS values (median 8 points) than fetuses with FNM (median 5 points, p value = 0.009). Our results point towards a positive association between CVPS and fetal outcome in fetuses with NIHF and cardiac anomalies. The CVPS appears to be a useful marker in the assessment of heart failure in utero.

Diagnostic yield from prenatal exome sequencing for non-immune hydrops fetalis: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Non-immune hydrops fetalis (NIHF) has multiple genetic etiologies diagnosable by exome sequencing (ES). We evaluated the yield of prenatal ES for NIHF, and the contribution of additional clinical findings and history. Systematic review was performed with PROSPERO tag 232951 using CINAHL, PubMed, and Ovid MEDLINE from January 1, 2000 through December 1, 2021. Selected studies performed ES to augment standard prenatal diagnostic approaches. Cases meeting a strict NIHF phenotype were tabulated with structured data imputed from papers or requested from authors. Genetic variants and diagnostic outcomes were harmonized across studies using current ACMG and ClinGen variant classification guidelines. Thirty-one studies reporting 445 NIHF cases had a 37% (95% CI: 32%-41%) diagnostic rate. There was no significant difference between isolated NIHF and NIHF with fetal malformations or between recurrent and simplex cases. Diagnostic rate was higher for consanguineous than non-consanguineous cases. Disease categories included RASopathies (24%), neuromuscular (21%), metabolic (17%), lymphatic (13%), other syndromes (9%), cardiovascular (5%), hematologic (2%), skeletal (2%), and other categories (7%). Inheritance patterns included recessive (55%), dominant (41%), and X-linked (4%). ES should be considered in the diagnostic workup of NIHF with and without associated ultrasound findings regardless of history of recurrence or consanguinity.

Diagnostic yield of exome sequencing for prenatal diagnosis of fetal structural anomalies: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Objectives

We conducted a systematic review and meta‐analysis to determine the diagnostic yield of exome sequencing (ES) for prenatal diagnosis of fetal structural anomalies, where karyotype/chromosomal microarray (CMA) is normal.

Methods

Following electronic searches of four databases, we included studies with ≥10 structurally abnormal fetuses undergoing ES or whole genome sequencing. The incremental diagnostic yield of ES over CMA/karyotype was calculated and pooled in a meta‐analysis. Sub‐group analyses investigated effects of case selection and fetal phenotype on diagnostic yield.

Results

We identified 72 reports from 66 studies, representing 4350 fetuses. The pooled incremental yield of ES was 31% (95% confidence interval (CI) 26%–36%, p < 0.0001). Diagnostic yield was significantly higher for cases pre‐selected for likelihood of monogenic aetiology compared to unselected cases (42% vs. 15%, p < 0.0001). Diagnostic yield differed significantly between phenotypic sub‐groups, ranging from 53% (95% CI 42%–63%, p < 0.0001) for isolated skeletal abnormalities, to 2% (95% CI 0%–5%, p = 0.04) for isolated increased nuchal translucency.

Conclusion

Prenatal ES provides a diagnosis in an additional 31% of structurally abnormal fetuses when CMA/karyotype is non‐diagnostic. The expected diagnostic yield depends on the body system(s) affected and can be optimised by pre‐selection of cases following multi‐disciplinary review to determine that a monogenic cause is likely.

What's already known about this topic?

Prenatal exome sequencing (ES) increases genetic diagnoses in fetuses with structural abnormalities and a normal karyotype and chromosomal microarray.

Published diagnostic yields from ES are varied and may be influenced by study size, case selection and fetal phenotype.

What does this study add?

This study provides a comprehensive systematic review of the literature to date and investigates the diagnostic yield of ES for a range of isolated system anomalies, to support clinical decision‐making on how to offer prenatal ES.

Clinical Course and Outcome of Non-Immune Fetal Hydrops in Singleton Pregnancies

Nonimmune fetal hydrops is a condition defined by abnormal fluid accumulation in two or more body compartments. The aim is to evaluate factors associated with adverse outcome in diagnosed fetal hydrops and to investigate the aspects for the decision making in the case of termination of pregnancy. Therefore, a retrospective data analysis of pregnancies complicated by non-immune hydrops fetalis between 2004 and 2018 was performed in a single tertiary referral center. Of 361 pregnancies with diagnosed fetal hydrops, in 183 cases (50.7%), the parents decided to terminate the pregnancy. A strong relationship between etiology and termination of pregnancy was demonstrated, whereas the highest rates of termination of pregnancy were found if a chromosomal aberration was diagnosed. Of the remaining 178 cases, 51 cases (28.7%) had a miscarriage, 33 cases (18.5%) had an intrauterine fetal death, and 94 cases (52.8%) were live born, whereas 26 (27.7%) of these offspring died within the first week of life. The risk of an adverse outcome increased with lower gestational age at diagnosis (p < 0.001). A nuchal translucency thickness greater than 2.5 mm was associated with an adverse outcome (p < 0.01). Furthermore, pregnancies with adverse outcome had significantly more affected compartments (median: 3; IQR 2), compared with live born cases (median: 2; IQR 1; p < 0.01). In conclusion, adverse outcome in pregnancies with fetal hydrops was associated with a lower gestational age at diagnosis, nuchal translucency greater than 2.5 mm and a higher count of affected compartments. These results confirm that a precise clinical workup to identify the underlying etiology of non-immune fetal hydrops is essential for a better prognostic assessment and accurate counselling of parents.