Are solvent effects important for intramolecular C—H···O − hydrogen bonding interactions?

The Stability of Hydrogen-Bonded Ion-Pair Complex Unexpectedly Increases with Increasing Solvent Polarity

The generally observed decrease of the electrostatic energy in the complex with increasing solvent polarity has led to the assumption that the stability of the complexes with ion-pair hydrogen bonds decreases with increasing solvent polarity. Besides, the smaller solvent-accessible surface area (SASA) of the complex in comparison with the isolated subsystems results in a smaller solvation energy of the latter, leading to a destabilization of the complex in the solvent compared to the gas phase. In our study, which combines Nuclear Magnetic Resonance, Infrared Spectroscopy experiments, quantum chemical calculations, and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, we question the general validity of this statement. We demonstrate that the binding free energy of the ion-pair hydrogen-bonded complex between 2-fluoropropionic acid and n-butylamine (CH3CHFCOO-…NH3But+) increases with increased solvent polarity. This phenomenon is rationalized by a substantial charge transfer between the subsystems that constitute the ion-pair hydrogen-bonded complex. This unexpected finding introduces a new perspective to our understanding of solvation dynamics, emphasizing the interplay between solvent polarity and molecular stability within hydrogen-bonded systems.

The unusual stability of H-bonded complexes in solvent caused by greater solvation energy of complex compared to those of isolated fragments

Here, the effect of solvent on the stability of non-covalent complexes, was studied. These complexes were from previously published S22, S66, and X40 datasets, which include hydrogen-, halogen- and dispersion-bonded complexes. It was shown that the charge transfer in the complex determines whether the complex is stabilized or destabilized in solvent.

Unexpected Strengthening of the H-Bond Complexes in a Polar Solvent Due to a More Efficient Solvation of the Complex Compared to Isolated Monomers

It is generally assumed that hydrogen-bonded complexes are less stable in solvents than in the gas phase and that their stability decreases with increasing solvent polarity. This assumption is based on the size of the area available to the solvent, which is always smaller in the complex compared to the subsystems, thereby reducing the solvation energy. This reduction prevails over the amplification of the electrostatic hydrogen bond by the polar solvent. In this work, we show, using experimental IR spectroscopy and DFT calculations, that there are hydrogen-bonded complexes whose stability becomes greater with increasing solvent polarity. The explanation for this surprising stabilization is based on the analysis of the charge redistribution in the complex leading to increase of its dipole moment and solvation energy. Constrained DFT calculations have shown a dominant role of charge transfer over polarization effects for dipole moment and solvation energy.