Use of post-exercise laryngoscopy to evaluate exercise induced dyspnea

Surgical intervention for exercise-induced laryngeal obstruction: A UK perspective

OBJECTIVES

Exercise-induced laryngeal obstruction (EILO) is a prevalent cause of exertional breathlessness and wheeze in young individuals. Typically diagnosed using the continuous laryngoscopy during exercise (CLE) test, treatment is largely based on breathing retraining promoting improved laryngeal function. In some cases, these techniques fail to alleviate symptoms, and surgical intervention with supraglottoplasty can be valuable in the supraglottic form of EILO. Globally, there is currently limited experience utilizing a surgical approach to EILO, and data regarding the optimum surgical technique and published outcomes and complication rates are thus limited.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective observational case series.

METHODS

In this report, we describe our experience as the only UK center undertaking supraglottoplasty for EILO. We report the surgical outcome of 19 patients (n = 16 female), mean age, 29.6 ± 13.1 years, referred for surgery with moderate to severe supraglottic EILO. Follow-up clinic ± CLE was performed within 4 months (median = 6 weeks), and CLE scores were evaluated before and following surgery.

RESULTS

We found a beneficial effect of surgery on supraglottic CLE scores (median score reducing from 3/3 to 1/3 postoperatively [P < .05] overall) with 79% (n = 15) of patients reporting an improvement in their exercise capacity. One patient developed an apparent increased tendency for glottic-level EILO following surgery; however, no voice- or swallowing-related complications were encountered.

CONCLUSIONS

This study is the first to report the UK experience, surgical technique, and outcome for EILO surgery. The findings indicate that EILO surgery appears to be a safe and effective option for individuals with moderate to severe supraglottic-type EILO who have failed initial conservative treatment.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

5 Laryngoscope, 130:E667-E673, 2020.

A systematic review of surgical treatment for supraglottic exercise-induced laryngeal obstruction

Objectives

Exercise‐induced laryngeal obstruction (EILO) is a condition causing breathing difficulties and stridor during exercise. The condition has in severe cases been treated surgically with supraglottoplasty. The purpose of this systematic review is to assess the evidence and recommendations for surgical intervention in treating patients with EILO.

Methods

A systematic search was performed in PubMed and Embase to identify relevant studies describing surgical treatment of patients diagnosed with severe EILO. According to eligibility criteria, data were independently extracted by two reviewers. To assess the risk of bias of each included study, the Newcastle‐Ottawa scale (NOS) was used.

Results

The screening process identified 11 observational studies with a total of 75 patients. Findings indicated that many beneficial outcomes are to be found in surgical treatment for EILO. These indications were found both on visual verification of improvement of the laryngeal obstruction during exercise and patient self‐reported symptom severity. The average NOS score (4.3) indicated low level of evidence in the included studies.

Conclusion

Studies reporting effects of surgical treatment of EILO have shown promising results in patients with laryngeal obstruction. However, the heterogeneity of study methodologies and the level of evidence precludes definitive recommendations for or against supraglottoplasty at this time; prospective and methodologically robust studies are now needed.

Level of Evidence

4

Exercise-Induced Laryngeal Obstruction: When Pediatric Exertional Dyspnea Does not Respond to Bronchodilators

Exertional dyspnea is a common complaint in general pediatric practice. While a high proportion of the general pediatric population has asthma, other diagnoses, including exercise-induced laryngeal obstruction should be considered, especially when asthma therapy is not sufficient to control symptoms. This review describes some of the key clinical features of exercised-induced laryngeal obstruction as well as preferred diagnostic and therapeutic approaches. Importantly, current diagnostic technology has considerably improved in the last decade at specialty centers. At the same time, infrastructure for clinical trials is emerging and there is not strong evidence to support specific therapies at the current time.

The Olin EILOBI Breathing Techniques: Description and Initial Case Series of Novel Respiratory Retraining Strategies for Athletes with Exercise-Induced Laryngeal Obstruction

INTRODUCTION

Exercise-induced laryngeal obstruction (EILO), the condition previously known as paradoxical vocal fold motion and vocal cord dysfunction, is characterized by inappropriate glottic or supraglottic obstruction during high-intensity exercise, causing exertional dyspnea, frequently with stridor. EILO is definitively diagnosed through upper-airway visualization during a characteristic episode. Although respiratory retraining is a primary therapy for EILO, many patients report symptom persistence despite adequate performance of traditional techniques. This report describes three novel breathing techniques for EILO, the Olin EILOBI (EILO biphasic inspiratory) breathing techniques. We include a teaching process and case series with patient-reported assessments.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Following descriptions of the techniques and teaching process, we present data from a questionnaire offered to all patients who learned at least one of the techniques between September 2015 and March 2017. Subjects evaluated (1) expectation setting, (2) teaching processes, (3) their ability to implement the techniques during high-intensity exercise, and (4) perceived clinical effectiveness.

RESULTS

Ninety-five percent of eligible patients participated, a primarily young, female, and Caucasian sample. Over 50% of subjects competed at the high school varsity level. Sixty-two percent of subjects perceived reasonable expectations, and 82% positively evaluated the teaching process. Seventy-nine percent were able to employ their technique in the high-intensity activity of choice, and 66% perceived clinical effectiveness with the techniques.

CONCLUSIONS

The Olin EILOBI breathing techniques are novel respiratory retraining techniques for use in high-intensity exercise. Case series subjects reported reasonable expectations, a helpful teaching process, the ability to use these techniques during high-intensity exercise, and perceived clinical effectiveness.

Exercise inducible laryngeal obstruction: diagnostics and management

Obstruction of the central airways is an important cause of exercise-induced inspiratory symptoms (EIIS) in young and otherwise healthy individuals. This is a large, heterogeneous and vastly understudied group of patients. The symptoms are too often confused with those of asthma. Laryngoscopy performed as symptoms evolve during increasing exercise is pivotal, since the larynx plays an important role in symptomatology for the majority. Abnormalities vary between patients, and laryngoscopic findings are important for correct treatment and handling. The simplistic view that all EIIS is due to vocal cord dysfunction [VCD] still hampers science and patient management. Causal mechanisms are poorly understood. Most treatment options are based on weak evidence, but most patients seem to benefit from individualised information and guidance. The place of surgery has not been settled, but supraglottoplasty may cure well-defined severe cases. A systematic clinical approach, more and better research and randomised controlled treatment trials are of utmost importance in this field of respiratory medicine.

Continuous laryngoscopy quantitates laryngeal behaviour in exercise and recovery

Exercise-induced laryngeal obstruction (E-ILO) causes exertional dyspnoea. There is no standardised methodology which characterises laryngeal obstruction in relation to exercise or links laryngeal obstruction and dyspnoea severity. Continuous laryngoscopy during exercise (CLE) may improve diagnostic sensitivity by enabling laryngeal visualisation at peak work capacity in patients with rapidly resolving obstruction. The time course of laryngeal obstruction across exercise and recovery has not been quantitated until this report.

Adolescents and young adults referred for CLE were laryngoscopically monitored across rest, maximal cycle ergometry exercise, and recovery. Three reviewers, blinded to time sequencing, rated inspiratory glottic and supraglottic obstruction during 10 windows of 15-s corresponding to rest, 25%, 50%, 75%, 90% and 100% of individual symptom-limited peak work capacity (expressed in Watts), and four consecutive recovery windows.

85 patients were screened and 71 included. Over 96% of time windows were interpretable. Laryngeal obstruction severity reached observed maximal levels at peak work capacity, and rapidly resolved. A spectrum of observed maximal obstruction was measured.

CLE provides interpretable data demonstrating laryngeal obstruction in patients with suspected E-ILO that is more severe at peak work capacity than during rest, submaximal exercise, or recovery. Observed maximal obstruction was infrequently severe and rapidly resolved.

ERS/ELS/ACCP 2013 international consensus conference nomenclature on inducible laryngeal obstructions

Individuals reporting episodes of breathing problems caused by re-occurring variable airflow obstructions in the larynx have been described in an increasing number of publications, with more than 40 different terms being used without consensus on definitions. This lack of an international consensus on nomenclature is a serious obstacle for the development of the area, as knowledge from different centres cannot be matched, pooled or readily utilised by others. Thus, an international Task Force has been created, led by the European Respiratory Society/European Laryngological Society/American College of Chest Physicians. This review describes the methods used to reach an international consensus on the subject and the resulting nomenclature, the 2013 international consensus conference nomenclature.

Pediatric Exercise Stress Laryngoscopy following Laryngotracheoplasty

Objective

Exercise-induced airway obstruction in pediatric patients is a unique phenomenon with multiple potential etiologies. An accurate diagnosis can be challenging to establish in pediatric patients because they are frequently asymptomatic at rest. Exercise stress laryngoscopy (ESL) is a modality by which pediatric patients can be evaluated under physiologic conditions that produce their symptoms. The purpose of this study was to demonstrate (1) the diagnostic effectiveness of pediatric ESL and (2) the ability of ESL to guide treatment for “normal” and post–airway reconstruction patients with exercise intolerance.

Study Design

Case series with chart review.

Setting

Tertiary care children’s hospital.

Subjects and Methods

Patients undergoing ESL for exercise intolerance were reviewed. Demographics, surgical history, examination findings, and management recommendations were extracted.

Results

Thirty-seven patients (average age, 13.5 years; range, 5-21 years) were included. There were 14 male and 23 female patients. Airway abnormalities became evident in 56% of patients. Of these, 24% had focal supraglottic collapse, 43% had evidence of paradoxical vocal fold motion, 24% had combined supraglottic and glottic dysfunction, and 9% had distal airway abnormalities. Overall, 18 patients had changes in management after ESL. Twelve patients in this review had histories of laryngotracheoplasty with equivocal findings on operative bronchoscopy. Of these patients, 10 (83%) received focal diagnoses after ESL.

Conclusion

ESL is a contemporary modality by which complex patients with undiagnosed exercise intolerance can be effectively evaluated. ESL can be an important tool used to guide treatment in pediatric patients with exercise-induced dyspnea after airway reconstruction.