Examination of polypeptide substrate specificity for Escherichia coli ClpB

AAA+ proteins: one motor, multiple ways to work

Numerous ATPases associated with diverse cellular activities (AAA+) proteins form hexameric, ring-shaped complexes that function via ATPase-coupled translocation of substrates across the central channel. Cryo-electron microscopy of AAA+ proteins processing substrate has revealed non-symmetric, staircase-like hexameric structures that indicate a sequential clockwise/2-residue step translocation model for these motors. However, for many of the AAA+ proteins that share similar structural features, their translocation properties have not yet been experimentally determined. In the cases where translocation mechanisms have been determined, a two-residue translocation step-size has not been resolved. In this review, we explore Hsp104, ClpB, ClpA and ClpX as examples to review the experimental methods that have been used to examine, in solution, the translocation mechanisms employed by AAA+ motor proteins. We then ask whether AAA+ motors sharing similar structural features can have different translocation mechanisms. Finally, we discuss whether a single AAA+ motor can adopt multiple translocation mechanisms that are responsive to different challenges imposed by the substrate or the environment. We suggest that AAA+ motors adopt more than one translocation mechanism and are tuned to switch to the most energetically efficient mechanism when constraints are applied.

A Review: Molecular Chaperone-mediated Folding, Unfolding and Disaggregation of Expressed Recombinant Proteins

The advancements in biotechnology over time have led to an increase in the demand of pure, soluble and functionally active proteins. Recombinant protein production has thus been employed to obtain high expression of purified proteins in bulk. E. coli is considered as the most desirable host for recombinant protein production due to its inexpensive and fast cultivation, simple nutritional requirements and known genetics. Despite all these benefits, recombinant protein production often comes with drawbacks, such as, the most common being the formation of inclusion bodies due to improper protein folding. Consequently, this can lead to the loss of the structure-function relationship of a protein. Apart from various strategies, one major strategy to resolve this issue is the use of molecular chaperones that act as folding modulators for proteins. Molecular chaperones assist newly synthesized, aggregated or misfolded proteins to fold into their native conformations. Chaperones have been widely used to improve the expression of various proteins which are otherwise difficult to produce in E. coli. Here, we discuss the structure, function, and role of major E. coli molecular chaperones in recombinant technology such as trigger factor, GroEL, DnaK and ClpB.

Kinetic Analysis of AAA+ Translocases by Combined Fluorescence and Anisotropy Methods

The multitude of varied, energy-dependent processes that exist in the cell necessitate a diverse array of macromolecular machines to maintain homeostasis, allow for growth, and facilitate reproduction. ATPases associated with various cellular activity are a set of protein assemblies that function as molecular motors to couple the energy of nucleoside triphosphate binding and hydrolysis to mechanical movement along a polymer lattice. A recent boom in structural insights into these motors has led to structural hypotheses on how these motors fulfill their function. However, in many cases, we lack direct kinetic measurements of the dynamic processes these motors undergo as they transition between observed structural states. Consequently, there is a need for improved techniques for testing the structural hypotheses in solution. Here, we apply transient-state fluorescence anisotropy and total fluorescence stopped-flow methods to the analysis of polypeptide translocation catalyzed by these ATPase motors. We specifically focus on the Hsp100-Clp protein system of ClpA, which is a well-studied, model ATPases associated with various cellular activity system that has both eukaryotic and archaea homologs. Using this system, we show that we can reproduce previously established kinetic parameters from the simultaneous analysis of fluorescence anisotropy and total fluorescence and overcome previous limitations of our previous approach. Specifically, for the first time, to our knowledge, we obtain quantitative interpretations of the translocation of polypeptide substrates longer than 100 aa.

Role of ClpB From Corynebacterium crenatum in Thermal Stress and Arginine Fermentation

ClpB, an ATP-dependent molecular chaperone, is involved in metabolic pathways and plays important roles in microorganisms under stress conditions. Metabolic pathways and stress resistance are important characteristics of industrially -relevant bacteria during fermentation. Nevertheless, ClpB-related observations have been rarely reported in industrially -relevant microorganisms. Herein, we found a homolog of ClpB from Corynebacterium crenatum. The amino acid sequence of ClpB was analyzed, and the recombinant ClpB protein was purified and characterized. The full function of ClpB requires DnaK as chaperone protein. For this reason, dnaK/clpB deletion mutants and the complemented strains were constructed to investigate the role of ClpB. The results showed that DnaK/ClpB is not essential for the survival of C. crenatum MT under pH and alcohol stresses. The ClpB-deficient or DnaK-deficient C. crenatum mutants showed weakened growth during thermal stress. In addition, the results demonstrated that deletion of the clpB gene affected glucose consumption and L-arginine, L-glutamate, and lactate production during fermentation.

Hsp104 and Potentiated Variants Can Operate as Distinct Nonprocessive Translocases

Heat shock protein (Hsp) 104 is a hexameric ATPases associated with diverse cellular activities motor protein that enables cells to survive extreme stress. Hsp104 couples the energy of ATP binding and hydrolysis to solubilize proteins trapped in aggregated structures. The mechanism by which Hsp104 disaggregates proteins is not completely understood but may require Hsp104 to partially or completely translocate polypeptides across its central channel. Here, we apply transient state, single turnover kinetics to investigate the ATP-dependent translocation of soluble polypeptides by Hsp104 and Hsp104^A503S, a potentiated variant developed to resolve misfolded conformers implicated in neurodegenerative disease. We establish that Hsp104 and Hsp104^A503S can operate as nonprocessive translocases for soluble substrates, indicating a "partial threading" model of translocation. Remarkably, Hsp104^A503S exhibits altered coupling of ATP binding to translocation and decelerated dissociation from polypeptide substrate compared to Hsp104. This altered coupling and prolonged substrate interaction likely increases entropic pulling forces, thereby enabling more effective aggregate dissolution by Hsp104^A503S.

ATP hydrolysis inactivating Walker B mutation perturbs E. coli ClpA self-assembly energetics in the absence of nucleotide

E. coli ClpA is an AAA+ (ATPase Associated with diverse cellular Activities) chaperone that catalyzes the ATP-dependent unfolding and translocation of substrate proteins for the purposes of proper proteome maintenance. Biologically active ClpA hexamers contain two nucleotide binding domains (NBD) per protomer, D1 and D2. Despite extensive study, complete understanding of how the twelve NBDs within a ClpA hexamer coordinate ATP binding and hydrolysis to polypeptide translocation is currently lacking. To examine nucleotide binding and coordination at D1 and D2, ClpA Walker B variants deficient in ATP hydrolysis at one or both NBDs have been employed in various studies. In the presence of ATP, it is widely assumed that ClpA Walker B variants are entirely hexameric. However, a thermodynamically rigorous examination of the self-assembly mechanism has not been obtained. Differences in the assembly due to the mutation can be misattributed to the active NBD, leading to potential misinterpretations of kinetic studies. Here we use sedimentation velocity studies to quantitatively examine the self-assembly mechanism of ClpA Walker B variants deficient in ATP hydrolysis at D1, D2, and both NBDs. We found that the Walker B mutations had clear, if modest, effects on the assembly. Most notably, the Walker B mutation stabilizes the population of a larger oligomer in the absence of nucleotide, that is not present for analogous concentrations of wild type ClpA. Our results indicate that Walker B mutants, widely used in studies of AAA+ family proteins, require additional characterization as the mutation affects not only ATP hydrolysis, but also the ligand linked assembly of these complexes. This linkage must be considered in investigations of unfolding or other ATP dependent functions.

Interaction of substrate-mimicking peptides with the AAA+ ATPase ClpB from Escherichia coli

A molecular chaperone ClpB disaggregates and reactivates aggregated proteins in cooperation with DnaK, DnaJ, and GrpE. Within a cellular environment, ClpB must distinguish between properly folded and aggregated proteins by recognizing specific physical and/or chemical surface properties of the aggregates. However, the molecular mechanism of substrate binding to ClpB is poorly understood. We hypothesized that ClpB recognizes those polypeptide segments that promote protein aggregation because they are likely present at the surface of growing aggregates. We used an algorithm TANGO (Fernandez-Escamilla et al., Nat. Biotech. 2004, 22, 1302) to predict the aggregation-prone segments within the model ClpB-binding peptides and investigated interactions of the FITC-labeled peptides with ClpB using fluorescence anisotropy. We found that ClpB binds the substrate-mimicking peptides with positive cooperativity, which is consistent with an allosteric linkage between substrate binding and ClpB oligomerization. The apparent affinity towards ClpB for peptides displaying different predicted aggregation propensities correlates with the peptide length. However, discrete aggregation-prone segments within the peptides are neither sufficient nor necessary for efficient interaction with ClpB. Our results suggest that the substrate recognition mechanism of ClpB may rely on global surface properties of aggregated proteins rather than on local sequence motifs.

Escherichia coli DnaK Allosterically Modulates ClpB between High- and Low-Peptide Affinity States

ClpB and DnaKJE provide protection to Escherichia coli cells during extreme environmental stress. Together, this co-chaperone system can resolve protein aggregates, restoring misfolded proteins to their native form and function in solubilizing damaged proteins for removal by the cell's proteolytic systems. DnaK is the component of the KJE system that directly interacts with ClpB. There are many hypotheses for how DnaK affects ClpB-catalyzed disaggregation, each with some experimental support. Here, we build on our recent work characterizing the molecular mechanism of ClpB-catalyzed polypeptide translocation by developing a stopped-flow FRET assay that allows us to detect ClpB's movement on model polypeptide substrates in the absence or presence of DnaK. We find that DnaK induces ClpB to dissociate from the polypeptide substrate. We propose that DnaK acts as a peptide release factor, binding ClpB and causing the ClpB conformation to change to a low-peptide affinity state. Such a role for DnaK would allow ClpB to rebind to another portion of an aggregate and continue nonprocessive translocation to disrupt the aggregate.

Comparative Analysis of the Structure and Function of AAA+ Motors ClpA, ClpB, and Hsp104: Common Threads and Disparate Functions

Cellular proteostasis involves not only the expression of proteins in response to environmental needs, but also the timely repair or removal of damaged or unneeded proteins. AAA+ motor proteins are critically involved in these pathways. Here, we review the structure and function of AAA+ proteins ClpA, ClpB, and Hsp104. ClpB and Hsp104 rescue damaged proteins from toxic aggregates and do not partner with any protease. ClpA functions as the regulatory component of the ATP dependent protease complex ClpAP, and also remodels inactive RepA dimers into active monomers in the absence of the protease. Because ClpA functions both with and without a proteolytic component, it is an ideal system for developing strategies that address one of the major challenges in the study of protein remodeling machines: how do we observe a reaction in which the substrate protein does not undergo covalent modification? Here, we review experimental designs developed for the examination of polypeptide translocation catalyzed by the AAA+ motors in the absence of proteolytic degradation. We propose that transient state kinetic methods are essential for the examination of elementary kinetic mechanisms of these motor proteins. Furthermore, rigorous kinetic analysis must also account for the thermodynamic properties of these complicated systems that reside in a dynamic equilibrium of oligomeric states, including the biologically active hexamer.

Substrate Discrimination by ClpB and Hsp104

ClpB of E. coli and yeast Hsp104 are homologous molecular chaperones and members of the AAA+ (ATPases Associated with various cellular Activities) superfamily of ATPases. They are required for thermotolerance and function in disaggregation and reactivation of aggregated proteins that form during severe stress conditions. ClpB and Hsp104 collaborate with the DnaK or Hsp70 chaperone system, respectively, to dissolve protein aggregates both in vivo and in vitro. In yeast, the propagation of prions depends upon Hsp104. Since protein aggregation and amyloid formation are associated with many diseases, including neurodegenerative diseases and cancer, understanding how disaggregases function is important. In this study, we have explored the innate substrate preferences of ClpB and Hsp104 in the absence of the DnaK and Hsp70 chaperone system. The results suggest that substrate specificity is determined by nucleotide binding domain-1.

Examination of ClpB Quaternary Structure and Linkage to Nucleotide Binding

Escherichia coli caseinolytic peptidase B (ClpB) is a molecular chaperone with the unique ability to catalyze protein disaggregation in collaboration with the KJE system of chaperones. Like many AAA+ molecular motors, ClpB assembles into hexameric rings, and this reaction is thermodynamically linked to nucleotide binding. Here we show that ClpB exists in a dynamic equilibrium of monomers, dimers, tetramers, and hexamers in the presence of both limiting and excess ATPγS. We find that ClpB monomer is only able to bind one nucleotide, whereas all 12 sites in the hexameric ring are bound by nucleotide at saturating concentrations. Interestingly, dimers and tetramers exhibit stoichiometries of ∼3 and 7, respectively, which is one fewer than the maximum number of binding sites in the formed oligomer. This observation suggests an open conformation for the intermediates based on the need for an adjacent monomer to fully form the binding pocket. We also report the protein-protein interaction constants for dimers, tetramers, and hexamers and their dependencies on nucleotide. These interaction constants make it possible to predict the concentration of hexamers present and able to bind to cochaperones and polypeptide substrates. Such information is essential for the interpretation of many in vitro studies. Finally, the strategies presented here are broadly applicable to a large number of AAA+ molecular motors that assemble upon nucleotide binding and interact with partner proteins.

ClpB N-terminal domain plays a regulatory role in protein disaggregation

ClpB/Hsp100 is an ATP-dependent disaggregase that solubilizes and reactivates protein aggregates in cooperation with the DnaK/Hsp70 chaperone system. The ClpB-substrate interaction is mediated by conserved tyrosine residues located in flexible loops in nucleotide-binding domain-1 that extend into the ClpB central pore. In addition to the tyrosines, the ClpB N-terminal domain (NTD) was suggested to provide a second substrate-binding site; however, the manner in which the NTD recognizes and binds substrate proteins has remained elusive. Herein, we present an NMR spectroscopy study to structurally characterize the NTD-substrate interaction. We show that the NTD includes a substrate-binding groove that specifically recognizes exposed hydrophobic stretches in unfolded or aggregated client proteins. Using an optimized segmental labeling technique in combination with methyl-transverse relaxation optimized spectroscopy (TROSY) NMR, the interaction of client proteins with both the NTD and the pore-loop tyrosines in the 580-kDa ClpB hexamer has been characterized. Unlike contacts with the tyrosines, the NTD-substrate interaction is independent of the ClpB nucleotide state and protein conformational changes that result from ATP hydrolysis. The NTD interaction destabilizes client proteins, priming them for subsequent unfolding and translocation. Mutations in the NTD substrate-binding groove are shown to have a dramatic effect on protein translocation through the ClpB central pore, suggesting that, before their interaction with substrates, the NTDs block the translocation channel. Together, our findings provide both a detailed characterization of the NTD-substrate complex and insight into the functional regulatory role of the ClpB NTD in protein disaggregation.

Examination of the dynamic assembly equilibrium for E. coli ClpB

Escherichia coli ClpB is a heat shock protein that belongs to the AAA+ protein superfamily. Studies have shown that ClpB and its homologue in yeast, Hsp104, can disrupt protein aggregates in vivo. It is thought that ClpB requires binding of nucleoside triphosphate to assemble into hexameric rings with protein binding activity. In addition, it is widely assumed that ClpB is uniformly hexameric in the presence of nucleotides. Here we report, in the absence of nucleotide, that increasing ClpB concentration leads to ClpB hexamer formation, decreasing NaCl concentration stabilizes ClpB hexamers, and the ClpB assembly reaction is best described by a monomer, dimer, tetramer, hexamer equilibrium under the three salt concentrations examined. Further, we found that ClpB oligomers exhibit relatively fast dissociation on the time scale of sedimentation. We anticipate our studies on ClpB assembly to be a starting point to understand how ClpB assembly is linked to the binding and disaggregation of denatured proteins.

Analysis of Linked Equilibria

The ATPases associated with diverse cellular activities (AAA+) is a large superfamily of proteins involved in a broad array of biological processes. Many members of this family require nucleotide binding to assemble into their final active hexameric form. We have been studying two example members, Escherichia coli ClpA and ClpB. These two enzymes are active as hexameric rings that both require nucleotide binding for assembly. Our studies have shown that they both reside in a monomer, dimer, tetramer, and hexamer equilibrium, and this equilibrium is thermodynamically linked to nucleotide binding. Moreover, we are finding that the kinetics of the assembly reaction are very different for the two enzymes. Here, we present our strategy for determining the self-association constants in the absence of nucleotide to set the stage for the analysis of nucleotide binding from other experimental approaches including analytical ultracentrifugation.

Escherichia coli ClpB is a non-processive polypeptide translocase

Escherichia coli caseinolytic protease (Clp)B is a hexameric AAA+ [expanded superfamily of AAA (ATPase associated with various cellular activities)] enzyme that has the unique ability to catalyse protein disaggregation. Such enzymes are essential for proteome maintenance. Based on structural comparisons to homologous enzymes involved in ATP-dependent proteolysis and clever protein engineering strategies, it has been reported that ClpB translocates polypeptide through its axial channel. Using single-turnover fluorescence and anisotropy experiments we show that ClpB is a non-processive polypeptide translocase that catalyses disaggregation by taking one or two translocation steps followed by rapid dissociation. Using single-turnover FRET experiments we show that ClpB containing the IGL loop from ClpA does not translocate substrate through its axial channel and into ClpP for proteolytic degradation. Rather, ClpB containing the IGL loop dysregulates ClpP leading to non-specific proteolysis reminiscent of ADEP (acyldepsipeptide) dysregulation. Our results support a molecular mechanism where ClpB catalyses protein disaggregation by tugging and releasing exposed tails or loops.