Intramolecular localization of epitopes within an oligomeric protein by immunoelectron microscopy and image processing

The architecture of the DNA replication origin recognition complex in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

The origin recognition complex (ORC) is conserved in all eukaryotes. The six proteins of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae ORC that form a stable complex bind to origins of DNA replication and recruit prereplicative complex (pre-RC) proteins, one of which is Cdc6. To further understand the function of ORC we recently determined by single-particle reconstruction of electron micrographs a low-resolution, 3D structure of S. cerevisiae ORC and the ORC-Cdc6 complex. In this article, the spatial arrangement of the ORC subunits within the ORC structure is described. In one approach, a maltose binding protein (MBP) was systematically fused to the N or the C termini of the five largest ORC subunits, one subunit at a time, generating 10 MBP-fused ORCs, and the MBP density was localized in the averaged, 2D EM images of the MBP-fused ORC particles. Determining the Orc1-5 structure and comparing it with the native ORC structure localized the Orc6 subunit near Orc2 and Orc3. Finally, subunit-subunit interactions were determined by immunoprecipitation of ORC subunits synthesized in vitro. Based on the derived ORC architecture and existing structures of archaeal Orc1-DNA structures, we propose a model for ORC and suggest how ORC interacts with origin DNA and Cdc6. The studies provide a basis for understanding the overall structure of the pre-RC.

Limulus polyphemus Hemocyanin: 10 Å Cryo-EM Structure, Sequence Analysis, Molecular Modelling and Rigid-body Fitting Reveal the Interfaces Between the Eight Hexamers

The blue copper protein hemocyanin from the horseshoe crab Limulus polyphemus is among the largest respiratory proteins found in nature (3.5 MDa) and exhibits a highly cooperative oxygen binding. Its 48 subunits are arranged as eight hexamers (1x6mers) that form the native 8x6mer in a nested hierarchy of 2x6mers and 4x6mers. This quaternary structure is established by eight subunit types (termed I, IIA, II, IIIA, IIIB, IV, V, and VI), of which only type II has been sequenced. Crystal structures of the 1x6mer are available, but for the 8x6mer only a 40 A 3D reconstruction exists. Consequently, the structural parameters of the 8x6mer are not firmly established, and the molecular interfaces between the eight hexamers are still to be defined. This, however, is crucial for understanding how allosteric transitions are mediated between the different levels of hierarchy. Here, we show the 10 A structure (FSC(1/2-bit) criterion) of the oxygenated 8x6mer from cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) and single-particle analysis. Moreover, we show its molecular model as obtained by DNA sequencing of subunits II, IIIA, IV and VI, and molecular modelling and rigid-body fitting of all subunit types. Remarkably, the latter enabled us to improve the resolution of the cryo-EM structure from 11 A to the final 10 A. The 10 A structure allows firm assessment of various structural parameters of the 8x6mer, the 4x6mer and the 2x6mer, and reveals a total of 46 inter-hexamer bridges. These group as 11 types of interface: four at the 2x6mer level (II-II, II-IV, V-VI, IV-VI), three form the 4x6mer (V-V, V-VI, VI-IIIB/IV/V), and four are required to assemble the 8x6mer (IIIA-IIIA, IIIA-IIIB, II-IV, IV-IV). The molecular model shows the amino acid residues involved, and reveals that several of the interfaces are intriguingly histidine-rich and likely to transfer allosteric signals between the different levels of the nested hierarchy.

Comparison of three methods for competitive binding of monoclonal antibodies. The localization of antigenic sites for monoclonal antibodies on Panulirus interruptus hemocyanin

The competitive binding of a panel of monoclonal antibodies against hemocyanin of Panulirus interruptus hemocyanin was investigated with three different methods. A competitive-binding immunoassay method was more successful in the determination of ternary complexes than gel electrophoresis and gel filtration. The latter two methods could only be applied with antibodies possessing a higher affinity. Eleven monoclonal antibodies were assigned to groups on the basis of their interactions with five antigenic regions.

Identification of two antibody-interaction sites on the surface of Panulirus interruptus hemocyanin

Negatively stained complexes of Panulirus interruptus (spiny lobster) hemocyanin with two different monoclonal antibodies, named E and J, were studied by electron microscopy and image processing. The attachment site of the antibodies to the hexameric hemocyanin molecule was deduced from two perpendicular views of hemocyanin/antibody complexes, in which either the threefold axis or one of the twofold axes was oriented perpendicular to the supporting film. Images of complexes in these orientations were searched with reference images simulated from the known X-ray structure of P. interruptus hemocyanin. The two sites were further characterized by combining our results from electron microscopy with structural data obtained by X-ray diffraction and other methods. These two antibodies recognize different non-overlapping epitopes. The epitope for clone E is located on domain 3 at the surface of the beta barrel and consists of certain loops, which form connections between beta-strand structures. The epitope for clone J is situated on domain 1 at the surface of an alpha-helical region and consists mainly of certain alpha-helices connecting loops. The orientation of the hemocyanin hexamers in the two complexes is very different, as is demonstrated most clearly when they form chains. Clone E forms complexes with the threefold axes perpendicular to the chain direction, while for clone J the threefold axes seem to be parallel to the main direction. The angle between the Fab part of an IgG molecule and the threefold axis of the hexamer is 60 +/- 5 degrees for clone E and 35 +/- 7 degrees for clone J. This observation is clearly related to the difference in orientation of the hexamers for the two complexes.

Immunoelectron microscopy of enzymes, multienzyme complexes, and selected other oligomeric proteins

The collective term "immunoelectron microscopy" subsumes a number of techniques in which the biological material is decorated with specific antibodies, prior to being visualized in the electron microscope. In this article, we have reviewed literature on immunoelectron microscopy that focusses on the analysis of the molecular architecture of proteins, in particular of enzymes and of multienzyme complexes. Molecular immunoelectron microscopy has been remarkably successful with multi-subunit enzymes of complex quaternary structures, and in many cases the data have been the basis for the eventual development of detailed three-dimensional molecular models. The elucidation of subunit composition and juxtaposition of a given enzyme, an important accomplishment in itself, has in turn stimulated and guided discussions on the catalytic mechanism; illustrative examples include F1 ATPase and citrate lyase, among others. Here we have chosen a variety of enzymes, multienzyme complexes, and non-enzymatic proteins to demonstrate the versatility of immunoelectron microscopy, to illustrate methodological prerequisites and limitations, and to discuss significance and implications of individual immunoelectron microscopy studies.

Three-dimensional reconstruction of native Androctonus australis hemocyanin

A sample of native 4 x 6-meric hemocyanin of Androctonus australis was negatively stained with the double-layer technique, and was observed by transmission electron microscopy under low-dose conditions with a 50 degree and 0 degree tilt. The three-dimensional reconstruction method from "Single-exposure, random conical tilt series" was then applied. Independent three-dimensional reconstructions were obtained from the top, side and 45 degree views. Despite a pronounced flattening effect, presumably due to the specimen preparation technique, the positions of the 24 subunits composing the oligomer were unequivocally determined. This experiment definitely solves the problem of the architectural organization of the subunits in the cheliceratan 4 x 6-meric hemocyanins. Moreover, distinction between the flip and flop faces and an attenuated rocking effect were observed.

Classification of macromolecular assemblies studied as 'single particles'

In order to study proteins that do not occur in two- or three-dimensionally ordered form, one may take two different approaches: either search for conditions that induce the formation of crystals, and proceed with the established methods of X-ray or electron crystallography, or attempt to study the molecules in the form of single particles with the EM. Although many proteins have been successfully crystallized, and some general recipes for inducing ordered arrangement have been found (Mannella, 1984; Uzgiris & Kornberg, 1983), there exists a large number of proteins and protein assemblies that have resisted such attempts for a long time. Furthermore, there are macromolecular assemblies, associated with membranes and engaged in switching or gating, whose function is tied to their occurrence in isolated form, and hence are best studied without extraction from the membrane. For these reasons, the single-particle approach to the study of macromolecular structure (Franket al.1978, 1981; Radermacheret al.1987a, b; for recent reviews, see Franket al.1985, 1988e; Frank, 1989) has found numerous applications after initial technical and conceptual hurdles were overcome. Although atomic resolution cannot be achieved with this approach for a variety of reasons, a quantitative description of architecture on the quaternary level is nevertheless possible, as exemplified in the 3D studies of ribosomal particles (overviews, see Franket al.1988a) and, most recently, the junctional channel complex (Wagenknechtet al.1989a).

Topological mapping of 13 epitopes on a subunit of Androctonus australis hemocyanin

A topological localization of epitopes on the surface of the Aa6 subunit of Androctonus australis hemocyanin has been carried out. First, immunocomplex strings composed of native hemocyanin and monoclonal antibodies were examined in the electron microscope and submitted to an image processing by correspondence analysis. The average images were then compared to a three-dimensional model of the 24-mer suggesting that 11 of the 13 epitopes are located in three zones of the subunit surface. Second, the overlaps between the epitopes were then studied by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, competitive binding inhibition, and immunoelectron microscopy. Four groups of epitopes were identified. One group was capable of binding exclusively to the free subunit. The other three groups were identical to those found in immunoelectron microscopy. The data are consistent with the existence of a small number of immunodominant regions on the surface of the Aa6 subunit.

Fuzzy sets-based classification of electron microscopy images of biological macromolecules with an application to ribosomal particles

Pattern recognition methods based on the theory of fuzzy sets are tested for their ability to classify electron microscopy images of biological specimens. The concept of fuzzy sets was chosen for its ability to represent classes of objects that are vaguely described from the measured data. A number of partitional clustering algorithms and an extensive set of cluster-validity functionals (some already reported and some newly developed) have been applied to a test-data set and to two real-data sets of images. One of the real-data sets corresponded to images of the Escherichia coli 50S ribosomal subunits depleted of proteins L7/L12 and the other set to images of the E. coli 70S monosome in the range of overlap views. These two latter sets had been previously studied by another clustering methodology. The new results obtained by the application of fuzzy clustering techniques will be compared to those previously obtained and some conclusions about the consistency of these classifications will be drawn from this comparison.

Concerning the axial rotational flexibility of the Fab regions of immunoglobulin G

By electron microscopy, we have observed immunocomplexes with both negative stain and in amorphous ice using monoclonal antibodies directed against one of the 24 subunits of scorpion haemocyanin. A copy of this subunit occurs at each of the corners of the square-shaped haemocyanin molecule. Three distinct orientations of adjacent haemocyanin molecules may be observed in immunocomplex pairs or chains using both the above-mentioned methods. These observations, coupled with low-resolution computer simulations of immunocomplex formation, argue strongly in favour of the existence of a considerable degree of rotational flexibility within the IgG molecule and around the long axis of the Fab arms, as was suggested by previous observations with negative stain. We find that the arms can rotate by up to 180 degrees with respect to the Fc region.

Image analysis of single macromolecules

A battery of sophisticated techniques is now available to extract three-dimensional structural information from electron micrographs of biological macromolecules occurring in the form of single particles. One of these techniques, the random-conical reconstruction method, which allows low-dose imaging, has been recently perfected and is being used routinely for the study of ribosomal architecture. The analysis of the 40S mammalian ribosomal subunit serves as an illustration of the various steps of image processing. The use of classification combined with 3-D reconstruction provides the means to investigate variations of the macromolecular structure (deformations, conformational changes, etc.) that are caused by the specimen preparation. An example is provided by the changes in the shape of the 70S monosome of E. coli as it changes its orientation on the carbon grid. The most challenging applications of the techniques discussed are in the area of cryo-microscopy of ice-embedded specimens. First studies of single macromolecules imaged in this way have indicated that the 3-D imaging methods and, specifically, the random-conical reconstruction method, will be applicable under these conditions.

Three-dimensional reconstruction of single particles from random and nonrandom tilt series

To overcome the radiation damage-induced limitations to the resolution of three-dimensional reconstructions from electron microscopic tilt series, novel reconstruction schemes have been developed that require only a single exposure of the specimen. The tilt series collected with these methods have random projection directions. First, three-dimensional reconstruction techniques are described that are applicable to data obtained from tilt series with regular tilt geometry, followed by the extensions of these techniques to permit analysis of projection series with randomly spaced tilts. The main emphasis is placed on the weighted back-projection methods, which have recently been extended so as to be applicable to random tilt series. Besides a description of the algorithms, the complete procedure for a three-dimensional reconstruction from a single-exposure, random conical tilt series is explained, including the determination of the azimuthal angles, the alignment scheme for conical tilt series, the dependence of the achievable resolution on the number of projections for regular conical and single-axis geometries, and the method to calculate the actual resolution of two-dimensional image averages and of three-dimensional reconstructions using the phase residual and Fourier ring correlation criteria. Examples are given of biological specimens to which these three-dimensional reconstruction methods have been applied.