Evaluating the ecotoxicological effects of Pb contamination on the resistance against Lymantria dispar in forest plant, Larix olgensis

The exposure risk of heavy metals to insect pests and their impact on pests occurrence and cross-tolerance to insecticides: A review

Heavy metal (HM) pollution is a severe global environmental issue. HMs in the environment can transfer along the food chain, which aggravates their ecotoxicological effect and exposes the insects to heavy metal stress. In addition to their growth-toxic effects, HMs have been reported as abiotic environmental factors that influence the implementation of integrated pest management strategies, including microbial control, enemy insect control, and chemical control. This will bring new challenges to pest control and further highlight the ecotoxicological impact of HM pollution. In this review, the relationship between HM pollution and insecticide tolerance in pests was analyzed. Our focus is on the risks of HM exposure to pests, pests tolerance to insecticides under HM exposure, and the mechanisms underlying the effect of HM exposure on pests tolerance to insecticides. We infer that HM exposure, as an initial stressor, induces cross-tolerance in pests to subsequent insecticide stress. Additionally, the priming effect of HM exposure on enzymes associated with insecticide metabolism underlies cross-tolerance formation. This is a new interdisciplinary field between pollution ecology and pest control, with an important guidance value for optimizing pest control strategies in HM polluted areas.

Cadmium exposure-triggered growth retardation in Hyphantria cunea larvae involves disturbances in food utilization and energy metabolism

Serious environmental pollution in the ecosystem makes phytophagous insects face a great risk of exposure to pollutants, especially heavy metals. This study aims to understand the effects of Cd exposure on the growth and development of Hyphantria cunea and to elucidate the mechanism of growth toxicity induced by Cd from the perspective of food utilization and energy metabolism. Our results showed that the larval basal growth data, growth index, fitness index, and standard growth index were significantly decreased after feeding on Cd-containing artificial diets. The Cd-treated larvae had significantly higher digestibility than the untreated larvae. However, the food consumption, efficiency of conversion of digested food, and efficiency of conversion of ingested food were significantly lower than those of untreated larvae. Eight key metabolites in the glycolysis pathway and six key metabolites in the tricarboxylic acid cycle pathway were significantly reduced in Cd-treated larvae. The mRNA expression levels of two regulatory genes (6-phosphofructokinase 1 and hexokinase-1) belonging to two key enzymes in the glycolysis pathway and four regulatory genes (isocitrate dehydrogenase-1, isocitrate dehydrogenase-3, citrate synthase, and oxoglutarate dehydrogenase) belonging to three key enzymes in the tricarboxylic acid cycle pathway were significantly lower in the Cd-treated group than in the control group. Furthermore, most fitness-related traits were significantly and positively correlated with food utilization (except approximate digestibility) or energy metabolism parameters. Taken together, Cd exposure-triggered growth retardation of H. cunea larvae is a consequence of disturbances in food utilization and energy metabolism, thereby emphasizing the toxicity of heavy metals.

Defense response of Fraxinus mandshurica seedlings to Hyphantria cunea larvae under Cd stress: A contradiction between attraction and resistance

Heavy metal pollution, as a common and serious environmental problem worldwide, has been regarded as an abiotic stimulus that can affect plant insect resistance and pest occurrence. This study evaluated the defense response of Fraxinus mandshurica seedlings to Hyphantria cunea larvae under Cd stress, with consideration given to chemical defense, physical defense, and elemental defense. Our results showed that the H. cunea larvae had a strong preference for Cd-treated F. mandshurica seedlings, but there was a significant reduction in body weight and survival rate in larvae that fed on leaves of Cd-treated seedlings. Under Cd treatment, the increase in attractant metabolites (e.g., styrene, dibutyl phthalate, and d-limonene) and the decrease in repellent metabolites (e.g., aromadendrene, heptadecane, and camphene) in leaf volatiles were responsible for the high attractant activity to H. cunea larvae. Based on leaf physicochemical properties, tissue structure, and phenolic acid content, an overall reduction in physical defense, chemical defense and their combination in F. mandshurica seedlings exposed to Cd stress was identified by Technique for Order of Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS) analysis. Elemental defense occurred in Cd-treated F. mandshurica seedlings, as evidenced by the high concentration of Cd in leaves and H. cunea larvae under Cd treatment. Taken together, these findings demonstrate that under Cd stress, elemental defense replaces the dominant role of basic defense in F. mandshurica seedlings and accounts for the enhanced ability to defend against H. cunea larvae.

Cd exposure-triggered susceptibility to Bacillus thuringiensis in Lymantria dispar involves in gut microbiota dysbiosis and hemolymph metabolic disorder

The immunotoxicity induced by heavy metals on herbivorous insects reflect the alterations of the susceptibility to entomopathogenic agents in herbivorous insects exposed to heavy metal. In the present study, the susceptibility of gypsy moth larvae to Bacillus thuringiensis under Cd treatment at low and high dosages was investigated, and the gut microbiome-hemolymph metabolome responses that affected larval disease susceptibility caused by Cd exposure were examined. Our results showed that mortality of gypsy moth larvae caused by B. thuringiensis was significantly higher in larvae pre-exposed to Cd stress, and there was a synergistic effect between Cd pre-exposure and bacterial infection. Exposure to Cd significantly decreased the abundance of several probiotics (e.g., Serratia for the low Cd dosage and Weissella, Aeroonas, and Serratia for the high Cd dosage) and increased the abundances of several pathogenic bacteria (e.g., Stenotrophomonas, Gardnerella, and Cutibacterium for the low Cd dosage and Pluralibacter and Tsukamurella for the high Cd dosage) compared to the controls. Moreover, metabolomics analysis indicated that amino acid biosynthesis and metabolism were significantly perturbed in larval hemolymph under Cd exposure at both the low and high dosages. Correlation analysis demonstrated that several altered metabolites in larval hemolymph were significantly correlated with changes in the gut microbial community. The results demonstrate that prior exposure to Cd increases the susceptibility of gypsy moth larvae to B. thuringiensis in a synergistic fashion due to gut microbiota dysbiosis and hemolymph metabolic disorder, and thus microbial-based biological control may be the best pest control strategy in heavy metal-polluted areas.

Cd exposure-triggered metabolic disruption increases the susceptibility of Lymantria dispar (Lepidoptera: Erebidae) larvae to Mamestra brassicae nuclear polyhedrosis virus: A multi-omics study

Biological control is an environmentally friendly and effective pest control strategy, but it is often affected by a variety of abiotic factors in the pest control area. Here, the susceptibility of gypsy moth larvae to Mamestra brassicae nuclear polyhedrosis virus (MbNPV) under Cd treatment at the low and high dosages was investigated, and the mechanism of Cd stress affecting virus susceptibility of gypsy moth larvae was analyzed from a metabolic perspective by combining transcriptome and metabolome of the larval fat body. Our results showed that the mortality of MBNPV infection on gypsy moth larvae pre-exposed to Cd was significantly higher than that of larvae without Cd pre-exposure, and the joint effects of Cd exposure and virus infection on larval mortality were demonstrated to be synergistic. Transcriptome analysis revealed that amino acid and carbohydrate transport and metabolism accounted for most of the differently expressed genes in the low Cd and high Cd treatment groups. Consistent with the transcriptome results, metabolome analysis also showed that most metabolites affected by Cd exposure were involved in amino acid and carbohydrate metabolism. Function analysis showed that the contents of several amino acids (e.g. tryptophan and tyrosine) with antioxidant properties were significantly increased in Cd-treated gypsy moth larvae. Taken together, Cd exposure as an environmental factor, promotes the susceptibility of gypsy moth larvae to MbNPV, and metabolic disruption, especially amino acids and carbohydrates-related metabolism, is responsible for the increased susceptibility of gypsy moth larvae to virus under Cd stress.

Transcriptomic analysis of interactions between Lymantria dispar larvae and carvacrol

Due to its biological activity, carvacrol (CAR) is widely used in medicine, agriculture, and forestry. Our previous studies showed that in Lymantria dispar larvae, CAR treatment can induce the production of antifeedants and lead to growth inhibition and death of larvae. However, the effect CAR exerts on RNA levels in L. dispar larvae remains unclear. In this study, the Illumina HiSeq4000 sequencing platform was used to sequence the total RNA of L. dispar larvae. A total of six cDNA libraries (three treatments and three controls) were established and 39,807 genes were generated. Compared with the control group, 296 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) (142 up-regulated and 154 down-regulated) were identified after CAR treatment. GO and KEGG enrichment analyses showed that these DEGs mainly clustered in the metabolism of xenobiotics, carbohydrates, and lipids. Furthermore, 12 DEGs were found to be involved in detoxification, including six cytochrome P450s, two esterases, one glutathione peroxidase, one UDP-glycosyltransferase gene, and two genes encoding heat shock proteins. The expression levels of detoxification genes changed under CAR treatment (especially P450s), which further yielded candidate genes for explorations of the insecticidal mechanism of CAR. The reliability of transcriptome data was verified by qRT-PCR. The enzyme activities of CYP450 and acid phosphatase significantly increased (by 38.52 U/mg·prot and 0.12 μmol/min·mg, respectively) 72 h after CAR treatment. However, the activity of alkaline phosphatase did not change significantly. These changes in enzyme activity corroborated the reliability of the transcriptome data at the protein level. The results of GO enrichment analysis of DEGs indicated that CAR influenced the oxidation-reduction process in L. dispar larvae. Furthermore, CAR can cause oxidative stress in L. dispar larvae, identified through the determination of peroxidase and polyphenol oxidase activities, total antioxidant capacity, and hydrogen peroxide content. This study provides useful insight into the insecticidal mechanism of CAR.

Sexual differences in above- and belowground herbivore resistance between male and female poplars as affected by soil cadmium stress

Dioecious plant species presented sexual differences in metal accumulation and allocation between male and female conspecifics that grown on metal contaminated soil. As the Elemental defense hypothesis postulates that metals accumulated in plant tissues could protect plants from herbivory, whether such sexual dimorphism in response to metal stress of a dioecious plant will lead to differences in herbivore resistance between male and female conspecifics is still unknown. In this study, we used female and male siblings of Populus deltoides to investigate the effect of plant sex on the growth and feeding preferences of four leaf herbivores and a root herbivore under soil cadmium (Cd) stress. The results showed that the male plants accumulated significantly higher Cd in the leaves while the females allocated more Cd in the roots. Leaf herbivores fed on male leaves grew worse than those fed on female leaves under Cd exposure, while the root herbivore showed the opposite results. In addition, all leaf herbivores strongly preferred the leaves from Cd-stressed female plants than male ones. The quantification of gene expression further showed that Cd stress could significantly upregulate more genes involved in Cd uptake, transport and detoxification pathways in male leaves and female roots. In combination with the correlation tests, we postulated that such sexual differences in herbivore resistance between the two plant sexes was most likely due to the different Cd allocation patterns in plant leaves and roots.

Defense responses of arbuscular mycorrhizal fungus-colonized poplar seedlings against gypsy moth larvae: a multiomics study

Arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) fungi may help protect plants against herbivores; however, their use for the pest control of woody plants requires further study. Here, we investigated the effect of Glomus mosseae colonization on the interactions between gypsy moth larvae and Populus alba × P. berolinensis seedlings and deciphered the regulatory mechanisms underlying the mycorrhizal-induced resistance in the leaves of mycorrhizal poplar using RNA-seq and nontargeted metabolomics. The resistance assay showed that AM fungus inoculation protected poplar seedlings against gypsy moth larvae, as evidenced by the decreased larval growth and reduced larval survival. A transcriptome analysis revealed that differentially expressed genes (DEGs) were involved in jasmonic acid biosynthesis (lipoxygenase, hydroperoxide dehydratase, and allene oxide cyclase) and signal transduction (jasmonate-ZIM domain and transcription factor MYC2) and identified the genes that were upregulated in mycorrhizal seedlings. Except for chalcone synthase and anthocyanidin synthase, which were downregulated in mycorrhizal seedlings, all DEGs related to flavonoid biosynthesis were upregulated, including 4-coumarate-CoA ligase, chalcone isomerase, flavanone 3-hydroxylase, flavonol synthase, and leucoanthocyanidin reductase. The metabolome analysis showed that several metabolites with insecticidal properties, including coumarin, stachydrine, artocarpin, norizalpinin, abietic acid, 6-formylumbelliferone, and vanillic acid, were significantly accumulated in the mycorrhizal seedlings. These findings suggest the potential of mycorrhiza-induced resistance for use in pest management of woody plants and demonstrate that the priming of JA-dependent responses in poplar seedlings contributes to mycorrhiza-induced resistance to insect pests.

Effects of exogenous spermidine on poplar resistance to leaf and root herbivory as affected by soil cadmium stress

Elemental defense hypothesis (EDH) proposed that metal accumulation in plants could increase plant resistance to herbivores. However, the over-accumulation of metals in low-accumulators such as woody plants will cause adverse effects on plant health. Thus, the application of EDH on low-accumulators in metal contaminated areas is strongly limited. Since the supplement of exogenous spermidine (Spd) was reported to alleviate metal-induced toxicity in plants while stimulating metal accumulation in plant tissues, we hypothesized that such application will further improve plant resistance to herbivores. In this study, we employed a woody plant species, Populus yunnanensis, to test this hypothesis. We first tested a Spd concentration series applied on plants subjected to soil cadmium (Cd) stress and found that the 1 mM Spd strongly promoted plant growth while stimulated Cd accumulation in plant leaves and roots. We further conducted herbivore bioassays to test the growth performance and feeding preference of two leaf herbivore species and a root herbivore species that fed on plants from different treatments. The results showed that the inhibition effect of Cd stressed-plants on herbivore growth was significantly magnified by the addition of Spd. The growth weight of all the three tested herbivores were negatively correlated with increased Cd concentrations in plant tissues. In addition, the feeding preferences of the two leaf herbivore species were strongly repelled by leaf discs from Cd-treated plants with Spd supplement. The results suggested that the application of exogenous Spd at a certain dose could enhance elemental defense of plants against herbivory.

The susceptibility of Lymantria dispar larvae to Beauveria bassiana under Cd stress: A multi-omics study

Insect susceptibility to entomopathogenic microorganisms under heavy metal stress, as well as its regulatory mechanism is still poorly understood. This study aims to investigate the susceptibility of gypsy moth larvae to Beauveria bassiana under cadmium (Cd) stress (at 3.248 or 44.473 mg Cd/kg fresh food), and reveal the potential molecular mechanisms underlying the Cd effect on the larval susceptibility to B. bassiana via combined transcriptome and proteome analyses. Our results showed that pre-exposure to Cd increased the susceptibility of gypsy moth larvae to B. bassiana, and there was an additive effect between Cd exposure and B. bassiana infection on the larval mortality. Under the Cd stress at low and high concentrations, 138 and 899 differentially expressed genes (DEGs), as well as 514 and 840 differentially expressed proteins (DEPs) were identified, respectively. Immunotoxic effects induced by Cd exposure at the transcription level increased in a negative dose-response manner, with no immunity-related DEGs obtained at the low Cd concentration and a high number of immunity-related DEGs down-regulated at the high Cd concentration. In contrast, a potentially suppressed or stimulated trend in the Toll and Imd signaling pathway at protein level was revealed under low or high concentration of Cd treatment. Analysis of xenobiotics biodegradation-related pathways at both transcription and translation levels revealed that the gypsy moth larvae possessed an efficient homeostasis regulatory mechanism to the low-level Cd exposure, but exhibited a reduced xenobiotics biodegradation capability to the Cd stress at high levels. Together, these findings demonstrate Cd contamination promote the microbial-based biocontrol efficacy, and unravel the molecular regulatory network of heavy metal exposures that affects susceptibility of insects to pathogenic diseases.

Transfer of heavy metal along food chain: a mini-review on insect susceptibility to entomopathogenic microorganisms under heavy metal stress

The development and physiological status of pest insects are important factors that affect the effectiveness of biological control. Current knowledge reveals that heavy metals can be transferred to phytophagous insects through food chains and cause various chronic toxicological effects on the growth and physiology of phytophagous insects. These findings potentially attribute heavy metal contamination to an environmental factor governing biocontrol efficiency against pest insects, pointing to an urgent demand to better understand the effects of heavy metal exposure on insect susceptibility to entomopathogenic microorganisms. Here we discuss the transfer characteristics of heavy metals along the food chains to phytophagous insects and conclude that heavy metal exposure may promote insect susceptibility to entomopathogenic microorganisms in the heavy metal-contaminated regions. Furthermore, we propose a 'combined effect' hypothesis that combination of entomopathogenic agent and heavy metal stress can cause a much higher overall insect mortality than does the entomopathogenic agent or the heavy metal stress alone. This is a new and relatively unexplored area in the microbial-based biocontrol research, which might have great potential for future optimization of biocontrol strategies against economically and ecologically important agricultural or forest pests in the heavy metal polluted areas. © 2020 Society of Chemical Industry.