Characteristic negative ion fragmentations of deprotonated peptides containing post-translational modifications: mono-phosphorylated Ser, Thr and Tyr. A joint experimental and theoretical study

Negative ion cleavages of (M-H)- anions of peptides. Part 3. Post-translational modifications

It is now 25 years since we commenced the study of the negative-ion fragmentations of peptides and we have recently concluded this research with investigations of the negative-ion chemistry of most post-translational functional groups. Our first negative-ion peptide review (Bowie, Brinkworth, & Dua, 2002) dealt with the characteristic backbone fragmentations and side-chain cleavages from (M-H)^- ions of underivatized peptides, while the second (Bilusich & Bowie, 2009) included negative-ion backbone cleavages for Ser and Cys and some initial data on some post-translational groups including disulfides. This third and final review provides a brief summary of the major backbone and side chain cleavages outlined before (Bowie, Brinkworth, & Dua, 2002) and describes the quantum mechanical hydrogen tunneling associated with some proton transfers in enolate anion/enolate systems. The review then describes, in more depth, the negative-ion cleavages of the post-translational groups Kyn, isoAsp, pyroglu, disulfides, phosphates, and sulfates. Particular emphasis is devoted to disulfides (both intra- and intermolecular) and phosphates because of the extensive and spectacular anion chemistry shown by these groups. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Mass Spec Rev.

Characterisation of phosphorylated nucleotides by collisional and electron-based tandem mass spectrometry

RATIONALE

Tandem mass spectrometry of phosphorylated ions can often yield a limited number of product ions owing to the labile nature of phosphate groups. Developing techniques to improve dissociation for this type of ion has implications for the structural characterisation of many different phosphorylated ions, such as those from nucleotides, pharmaceutical compounds, peptides and polymers.

METHODS

Solutions of adenosine monophosphate, diphosphate and triphosphate (AMP, ADP and ATP) were studied in a hybrid linear ion trap-Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (FTICR) mass spectrometer. Precursor ions with an overall single positive charge, including protonated nucleotides or nucleotide cations containing one, two or three sodium atoms, were isolated for tandem mass spectrometry. Collision-induced dissociation (CID) was performed in the linear ion trap, with electron-induced dissociation (EID) being conducted in the FTICR cell.

RESULTS

EID resulted in many product ions not seen in CID. EID product ion spectra were seen to vary for AMP, ADP and ATP when the nucleotide cation contained zero, one, two or three sodiums. Precursor cations that contain two or three sodiums mainly formed product ions derived from the phosphate group. Conversely, when a precursor ion containing no sodium underwent EID, product ions mainly relating to the non-phosphate end of the ion were observed. The number of phosphate groups was not seen to greatly affect either CID or EID product ion spectra.

CONCLUSIONS

The presence of sodium in a precursor ion directs electron-induced bond dissociation, thus enabling targeted, and therefore tuneable, fragmentation of groups within that precursor ion. For all precursor ions, the most useful product ion spectra were obtained by EID for a precursor ion containing one sodium, with bond dissociation occurring across the entire nucleotide cation. The findings of this study can be used to improve the structural elucidation of many phosphorylated molecules by broadening the range of product ions achievable. © 2016 The Authors. Rapid Communications in Mass Spectrometry Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

Femtosecond laser-induced ionization/dissociation tandem mass spectrometry (fsLID-MS/MS) of deprotonated phosphopeptide anions

RATIONALE

Radical-directed dissociation techniques provide structural information which is complementary to that from conventional collision-induced dissociation (CID). The analysis of phosphopeptide anions is warranted due to their relatively acidic character. As femtosecond laser-induced ionization/dissociation tandem mass spectrometry (fsLID-MS/MS) is uniquely initiated by field ionization, an investigation is warranted to determine whether fsLID may provide novel analytical utility for phosphopeptide anions.

METHODS

Twenty-three synthetic deprotonated phosphopeptide anions were introduced into a three-dimensional quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometer via electrospray ionization. The ion trap was interfaced with a near-IR (802 nm) ultrashort-pulsed (35 fs FWHM) ultrahigh-powered (peak power ~10(14)  W/cm(2)) laser system. Performance comparisons are made with other techniques applied to phosphopeptide anion analysis, including CID, electron detachment dissociation (EDD), negative electron transfer dissociation (NETD), activated electron photodetachment dissociation (activated-EPD), and ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD).

RESULTS

FsLID-MS/MS of multiply deprotonated phosphopeptide anions provides sequence information via phosphorylation-intact a/x ions in addition to other sequence ions, satellite ions, and side-chain losses. Novel fragmentation processes include selective c-ion formation N-terminal to Ser/Thr and a phosphorylation-specific correlation between xn -98 ion abundances and phosphorylation at the n(th) residue. Sequencing-quality data required about 30 s of signal averaging. fsLID-MS/MS of singly deprotonated phosphopeptides did not yield product anions with stable trajectories, despite significant depletion of the precursor.

CONCLUSIONS

Multiply deprotonated phosphopeptide anions were sequenced via negative-mode fsLID-MS/MS, with phosphosite localization facilitated by a/x ion series in addition to diagnostic x(n)-98 ions. fsLID-MS/MS is qualitatively competitive with other techniques. Further efficiency enhancements (e.g., implementation on a linear trap or/and higher pulse frequencies) may permit sequence analyses on chromatographic timescales.

Can collision-induced negative-ion fragmentations of [M-H](-) anions be used to identify phosphorylation sites in peptides?

A joint experimental and theoretical investigation of the fragmentation behaviour of energised [M-H](-) anions from selected phosphorylated peptides has confirmed some of the most complex rearrangement processes yet to be reported for peptide negative ions. In particular: pSer and pThr (like pTyr) may transfer phosphate groups to C-terminal carboxyl anions and to the carboxyl anion side chains of Asp and Glu, and characteristic nucleophilic/cleavage reactions accompany or follow these rearrangements. pTyr may transfer phosphate to the side chains of Ser and Thr. The reverse reaction, namely transfer of a phosphate group from pSer or pThr to Tyr, is energetically unfavourable in comparison. pSer can transfer phosphate to a non-phosphorylated Ser. The non-rearranged [M-H](-) species yields more abundant product anions than its rearranged counterpart. If a peptide containing any or all of Ser, Thr and Tyr is not completely phosphorylated, negative-ion cleavages can determine the number of phosphated residues, and normally the positions of Ser, Thr and Tyr, but not which specific residues are phosphorylated. This is in accord with comments made earlier by Lehmann and coworkers.

Diagnostic di- and triphosphate cyclisation in the negative ion electrospray mass spectra of phosphoSer peptides

It has been shown previously that [M-H](-) anions of small peptides containing two phosphate residues undergo cyclisation of the phosphate groups, following collision-induced dissociation (CID), to form a characteristic singly charged anion A (H3P2O7(-), m/z 177). In the present study it is shown that the precursor anions derived from the diphosphopeptides of caerin 1.1 [GLLSVLGSVAKHVLPHVVPVIAEHL(NH2)] and frenatin 3 [GLMSVLGHAVGNVLGGLFKPKS(OH)] also form the characteristic product anion A (m/z 177). Both of the precursor peptides show random structures in water, but partial helices in membrane-mimicking solvents [e.g. in d3-trifluoroethanol/water (1:1)]. In both cases the diphosphopeptide precursor anions must have flexible conformations in order to allow approach of the phosphate groups with consequent formation of A: for example, the two pSer groups of 4,22-diphosphofrenatin 3 are seventeen residues apart. Finally, CID tandem mass spectrometric (MS/MS) data from the [M-H](-) anion of the model triphosphoSer-containing peptide GpSGLGpSGLGpSGL(OH) show the presence of both product anions A (m/z 177) and D (m/z 257, H4P3O10(-)). Ab initio calculations at the HF/6-31+G(d)//AM1 level of theory suggest that cyclisation of the three phosphate groups occurs by a stepwise cascade mechanism in an energetically favourable reaction (ΔG = -245 kJ mol(-1)) with a maximum barrier of +123 kJ mol(-1).

Diagnostic cyclisation reactions which follow phosphate transfer to carboxylate anion centres for energised [M-H]- anions of pTyr-containing peptides

The low-energy negative ion phosphoTyr to C-terminal -CO(2)PO(3)H(2) rearrangement occurs for energised peptide [M-H](-) anions even when there are seven amino acid residues between the pTyr and C-terminal amino acid residues. The rearranged C-terminal -CO(2)PO(2)H(O(-)) group effects characteristic S(N)i cyclisation/cleavage reactions. The most pronounced of these involves the electrophilic central backbone carbon of the penultimate amino acid residue. This reaction is aided by the intermediacy of an H-bonded intermediate in which the nucleophilic and electrophilic reaction centres are held in proximity in order for the S(N)i cyclisation/cleavage to proceed. The ΔG(reaction) is +184 kJ mol(-1) with the barrier to the S(N)i transition state being +240 kJ mol(-1) at the HF/6-31 + G(d)//AM1 level of theory. A similar phosphate rearrangement from pTyr to side chain CO(2)(-) (of Asp or Glu) may also occur for energised peptide [M-H](-) anions. The reaction is favourable: ΔG(reaction) is -44 kJ mol(-1) with a maximum barrier of +21 kJ mol(-1) (to the initial transition state) when Asp and Tyr are adjacent. The rearranged species R(1)-Tyr-NHCH(CH(2)CO(2)PO(3)H(-))COR(2) (R(1)  = CHO; R(2)  = OCH(3)) may undergo an S(N)i six-centred cyclisation/cleavage reaction to form the product anion R(1)-Tyr(NH(-)). This process has a high energy requirement [ΔG(reaction)  = +224 kJ mol(-1), with the barrier to the S(N)i transition state being +299 kJ mol(-1)].

Competition between covalent and noncovalent bond cleavages in dissociation of phosphopeptide-amine complexes

Interactions between quaternary amino or guanidino groups with anions are ubiquitous in nature and have been extensively studied phenomenologically. However, little is known about the binding energies in non-covalent complexes containing these functional groups. Here, we present a first study focused on quantifying such interactions using complexes of phosphorylated A(3)pXA(3)-NH(2) (X = S, T, Y) peptides with decamethonium (DCM) or diaguanidinodecane (DGD) ligands as model systems. Time- and collision energy-resolved surface-induced dissociation (SID) of the singly charged complexes was examined using a specially configured Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometer (FTICR-MS). Dissociation thresholds and activation energies were obtained from RRKM modeling of the experimental data that has been described and carefully characterized in our previous studies. For systems examined in this study, covalent bond cleavages resulting in phosphate abstraction by the cationic ligand are characterized by low dissociation thresholds and relatively tight transition states. In contrast, high dissociation barriers and large positive activation entropies were obtained for cleavages of non-covalent bonds. Dissociation parameters obtained from the modeling of the experimental data are in excellent agreement with the results of density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Comparison between the experimental data and theoretical calculations indicate that phosphate abstraction by the ligand is rather localized and mainly affected by the identity of the phosphorylated side chain. The hydrogen bonding in the peptide and ligand properties play a minor role in determining the energetics and dynamics of the phosphate abstraction channel.

Negative ion fragmentations of deprotonated peptides containing post-translational modifications. An unusual cyclisation/rearrangement involving phosphotyrosine; a joint experimental and theoretical study

The characteristic fragmentations of a pTyr group in the negative ion electrospray mass spectrum of the [M-H](-) anion of a peptide or protein involve the formation of PO(3) (-) (m/z 79) and the corresponding [(M-H)(-)-HPO(3)](-) species. In some tetrapeptides where pTyr is the third residue, these characteristic anion fragmentations are accompanied by ions corresponding to H(2)PO(4) (-) and [(M-H)(-)-H(3)PO(4)](-) (these are fragmentations normally indicating the presence of pSer or pThr). These product ions are formed by rearrangement processes which involve initial nucleophilic attack of a C-terminal -CO(2) (-) [or -C(==NH)O(-)] group at the phosphorus of the Tyr side chain [an S(N)2(P) reaction]. The rearrangement reactions have been studied by ab initio calculations at the HF/6-31+G(d)//AM1 level of theory. The study suggests the possibility of two processes following the initial S(N)2(P) reaction. In the rearrangement (involving a C-terminal carboxylate anion) with the lower energy reaction profile, the formation of the H(2)PO(4) (-) and [(M-H)(-)-H(3)PO(4)](-) anions is endothermic by 180 and 318 kJ mol(-1), respectively, with a maximum barrier (to a transition state) of 229 kJ mol(-1). The energy required to form H(2)PO(4) (-) by this rearrangement process is (i) more than that necessary to effect the characteristic formation of PO(3) (-) from pTyr, but (ii) comparable with that required to effect the characteristic alpha, beta and gamma backbone cleavages of peptide negative ions.

Negative ion fragmentations of deprotonated peptides containing post-translational modifications: diphosphorylated systems containing Ser, Thr and Tyr. A characteristic phosphate/phosphate cyclisation. A joint experimental and theoretical study

[M-H](-) anions from small diphosphopeptides (phosphate groups on Ser, Thr or Tyr) show characteristic peaks corresponding to m/z 177 (H(3)P(2)O(7) (-)), 159 (HP(2)O(6) (-)) and sometimes [(M-H)(-)-H(4)P(2)O(7)](-). M/z 177 and m/z 159 are major peaks in the spectra of small peptides with 1,2, 1,3, 1,4, 1,5 and 1,6 diphosphate substitution, which means that the decomposing [M-H](-) anions must have flexible structures in order for the two phosphate groups to interact with each other. Peptides where the two phosphate groups are more than six amino acid residues apart have not been studied. Theoretical calculations indicate that m/z 177 is formed in a strongly exothermic reaction involving facile nucleophilic interaction between the two phosphate groups: m/z 159 is formed by loss of water from energised m/z 177.