The power of energy-resolved tandem mass spectrometry experiments for resolution of isomers: the case of drug plasma stability investigation of multidrug resistance inhibitors

Removal of isobaric interference using pseudo-multiple reaction monitoring and energy-resolved mass spectrometry for the isotope dilution quantification of a tryptic peptide

Energy-resolved mass spectrometry (ERMS) and an isotopically labelled internal standard were successfully combined to accurately quantify a tryptic peptide despite the presence of an isobaric interference. For this purpose, electrospray ionisation tandem mass spectrometry (ESI-MS/MS) experiments were conducted into an ion trap instrument using an unconventional 8 m/z broadband isolation window, which encompassed both the tryptic peptide and its internal standard. Interference removal was assessed by determining an excitation voltage that was high enough to maintain a constant value for the analyte/internal standard peaks intensity ratio, thus ensuring accurate quantification even in the presence of isobaric contamination. Pseudo-multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) was employed above this excitation voltage to quantify the trypic peptide. The internal standard calibration model showed no lack of fit and exhibited a linear dynamic range from 0.5 μM up to 2.5 μM. The detection limit was 0.08 μM. The accuracy of the method was evaluated by quantifying the tryptic peptide of three reference samples intentionally contaminated with the isobaric interference. All the reference samples were accurately quantified with ∼1% deviation despite the isobaric contamination. Furthermore, we have demonstrated that this methodology can also be applied to quantify the isobaric peptide by standard additions down to 0.2 μM. Finally, liquid chromatography ERMS (LC ERMS) experiments yielded similar results, suggesting the potential of the proposed methodology for analysing complex samples.

LC-MS accurate quantification of a tryptic peptide co-eluted with an isobaric interference by using in-source collisional purification

Interferences from isobaric and isomeric compounds represent a common problem in liquid chromatography coupled to mass spectrometry (LC-MS). In this paper, in-source purification and chromatographic separation were combined with the aim of identifying isobaric contamination and quantifying accurately a compound despite the presence of an isobaric co-eluted interference. This is achieved by totally fragmenting in-source the precursor ions of the isobaric interference providing then LC-pseudo-MS2 capability, which allows an accurate quantification without the need for optimizing the chromatographic conditions to separate the co-eluted interference. To illustrate this concept, mixtures of tryptic and non-tryptic peptides were used. The ratio of peak areas of the tryptic peptide and its isotopically labelled internal standard was used not only for quantification with an internal standard calibration curve but also to know (1) if an isobaric interference co-eluted with the tryptic peptide; and (2) what is the minimum cone voltage necessary to ensure the complete removal of isobaric interference. This strategy was applied to quantify the tryptic peptide of two standards with known concentrations and, intentionally contaminated with the isobaric interference. The confidence intervals of the concentrations calculated with the internal standard calibration curve were 8.0 ± 0.5 μM (prepared at 8.0 μM) and 15.7 ± 0.5 μM (prepared at 16.1 μM) that confirm the tryptic peptide can be correctly quantified by in-source purification without the need for improving the chromatographic separation from its isobaric interference.

Study of Mono and Di-O-caffeoylquinic Acid Isomers in Acmella oleracea Extracts by HPLC-MS/MS and Application of Linear Equation of Deconvolution Analysis Algorithm for Their Characterization

Chlorogenic acids, the esters of caffeic and quinic acids, are the main phenolic acids detected in Acmella oleracea extracts and have gained increasing interest in recent years due to their important biological activities. Given their structural similarity and instability, the correct analysis and identification of these compounds in plants is challenging. This study aimed to propose a simple and rapid determination of the A. oleracea caffeoylquinic isomers, applying an HPLC-MS/MS method supported by a mathematical algorithm (Linear Equation of Deconvolution Analysis (LEDA)). The three mono- and the three di-caffeoylquinic acids in roots of Acmella plants were studied by an ion trap MS analyzer. A separation by a conventional chromatographic method was firstly performed and an MS/MS characterization by energetic dimension of collision-induced dissociation mechanism was carried out. The analyses were then replicated using a short HPLC column and a fast elution gradient (ten minutes). Each acquired MS/MS data were processed by LEDA algorithm which allowed to assign a relative abundance in the reference ion signal to each isomer present. Quantitative results showed no significant differences between the two chromatographic systems proposed, proving that the use of LEDA algorithm allowed the distinction of the six isomers in a quarter of the time.

Isomers Recognition in HPLC-MS/MS Analysis of Human Plasma Samples by Using an Ion Trap Supported by a Linear Equations-Based Algorithm

The tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) approach employing an ion trap mass analyzer (IT) was evaluated in isomers recognition. The proposed approach consists of sole, simple, and rapid liquid chromatographic separation (HPLC) without requiring resolution between the analytes. Then, the MS/MS properties were optimized to solve the signal assignment using post-processing data elaboration (LEDA). The IT-MS/MS experiment uses the same site, helium as collision gas, and different time steps to modify the applied conditions on the studied ions. Nevertheless, helium cannot ensure the quick energization of the precursor ion due to its small cross-section. Then, different combinations between excitation amplitude (ExA) and excitation time (ExT) were tested to achieve the activation of the fragmentation channels and the formation of the MS/MS spectrum. Usually, the IT-MS/MS acquisition cycle is longer for other multistage instruments, decreasing the frequency of sample data collection and influencing the chromatographic profile. To solve these problems, two time segments were set up, and the elution conditions were optimized with a compromise between peaks distinction and run time reduction. The developed HPLC-MS/MS method was checked and applied to analyze a series of human plasma samples spiked with an equimolar mixture of pair of isomers.

Tandem mass spectrometry approaches for recognition of isomeric compounds mixtures

The present review aims to collect the published literature pertaining the recognition of isobaric compounds (isomers or stereoisomers) using the features of tandem mass spectrometry (MS) experiments without any chromatographic separation or chemical modification (derivatization or isotopic enrichment) of the analytes. MS/MS methods possess high selectivity, wide dynamic range and high throughput capabilities. Generally, tandem MS has limited capability for distinguishing isomers that fragment similarly. However, some MS/MS methods have been developed and positively applied to isomers discrimination. Among the literature on this topic, the applications that fit on the review subject can be summarized as follow: (1) chiral discrimination by the kinetic method, (2) the use energy-resolved tandem mass spectra and the survival yield (SY) representation, (3) the kinetics evaluation of the ion-molecule interaction and (4) the postprocessing mathematical algorithm to resolve the isomers in MS/MS signal.

Application of LEDA algorithm for the recognition of P-glycoprotein and Carbonic Anhydrase hybrid inhibitors and evaluation of their plasma stability by HPLC-MS/MS analysis

Design and synthesis of new candidate drugs produces a large number of compounds that must be qualified and tested to evaluate their characteristics and potential applications. Therefore, many studies will be scheduled and, consequently, it will be necessary to arrange specific, reliable, fast and relatively cheap analytic methods to support this research. The manuscript proposes a new approach in the HPLC-MS/MS analysis by using a sole chromatographic set up, tuned to minimize the run time, without requiring high efficiency or resolution between the analytes. The chromatographic column was used only to avoid or limit the interference of sample matrix towards the analyte ionization process (matrix-effects). Then, the MS/MS properties were explored to solve the signal assignment, by performing a series of energy resolved experiments to optimize the parameters and applying an interesting post-processing data elaboration tool (LEDA). The reliability of the new approach was evaluated in a chemical stability study in PBS and human plasma samples of a series of isomeric compounds P-glycoprotein/Carbonic Anhydrase (P-gp/CA) hybrid inhibitors. The obtained results demonstrated the effectiveness (reliability 97%-100%) of the LEDA algorithm to recognize and to separate the possible isomers present in the samples. The obtained matrix-effects values (ME 96%-106%) established that the chromatographic set up (short column and fast elution gradient) was proper to avoid the matrix interferences, while recovery values (RE 88%-108%) indicate a suitable sample preparation, despite only a protein precipitation was carried out. The quantitative performances of proposed HPLC-MS/MS methods showed an accuracy ranging between 92% and 108% and a precision lower than 13% that allows to be confident on the determination of new P-gp/CA hybrid inhibitors in the degradation study. Therefore, the general procedure proposed was found adequate to study a series of isomeric compounds without their chromatographic separation but only by applying and developing the MS/MS features.

Structure-fragmentation study of pentacyclic triterpenoids using electrospray ionization quadrupole time-of-flight tandem mass spectrometry (ESI-QTOFMS/MS)

RATIONALE

Pentacyclic triterpenoids are secondary plant metabolites widespread in fruit peel, leaves, and stem bark. Due to their important biological activities, these compounds are widely screened using advance analytical techniques like electrospray ionization (ESI) mass spectrometry. Over the past few decades, the practice of ESI has been refined into a versatile ionization technique for a wide variety of analytes differing in their chemical makeup, size, complexity, and bimolecular stability.

METHODS

The structure-fragmentation relationships (SFRs) of 16 pentacyclic triterpenoids were studied using a positive ion ESI quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometry (ESI-QqTOFMS/MS) hybrid instrument.

RESULTS

ESI-QqTOFMS (positive ion mode) showed the presence of the protonated molecules [M + H]⁺ of most of analyzed compounds. Low-energy collision-induced dissociation MS/MS analysis of these molecules indicated multiple losses of water molecules and the loss of the formic acid moiety [M + H - HCOOH]⁺ and other substituents as the predominant pathway for further fragmentation. Key product ions were identified which resulted from the retro-Diels-Alder cleavage of the ring system. SFRs of all the compounds analyzed were also developed.

CONCLUSIONS

We developed a fragmentation pattern of pentacyclic triterpenoids using the ESI-QqTOFMS/MS technique. It was concluded that the formation of key product ions and loss of characteristic neutrals can give detailed insight into structural information about the basic structure and attached substituents.

Structural analysis of a compound despite the presence of an isobaric interference by using in-source Collision Induced Dissociation and tandem mass spectrometry

The presence of an isobaric contaminant can drastically affect MS and MS/MS patterns leading to erroneous structural and quantitative analysis, which is a real challenge in mass spectrometry. Herein, we demonstrate that MS and MS/MS structural analysis of a compound can be successfully performed despite the presence of an isobaric interference with as low as few millidaltons mass difference by using pseudo-MS³ . To this end, in-source collisional excitation (in-source CID) and the Survival Yield (SY) technique (energy-resolved collision induced dissociation MS/MS) were performed on two different source geometries: a Z-spray and an orthogonal spray (with a transfer capillary) ionization sources on two different mass spectrometers. By using soft ionization conditions, the SY curve for the mixture is a linear combination of the SY curves from the pure compounds demonstrating the presence of two components in the mixture. In the case of harsher ionization conditions, the SY curve of the mixture perfectly overlaps the SY curve from the pure analyte. This observation demonstrates the isobaric interference has been completely removed by in-source CID fragmentation, independently of the source design, leaving then the analyte precursor ions only. Therefore, by measuring the MS spectrum in harsh ionization conditions and according to SY criterium, the compound of interest can be made free from isobaric interference paving the way for, for example, unequivocal HPLC-MS as well as HPLC-MS/MS structural and quantitative analysis despite the presence of a co-eluting isobaric interference.

Determination of coeluted isomers in wine samples by application of MS/MS deconvolution analysis

Two organic acids isomers, 3-isopropylmalic acid (3-IPMA) and 2-isopropylmalic acid (2-IPMA), were identified and quantified in wine samples by using an LC-MS/MS method without any chromatographic separation, but processing the MS/MS data with a recently developed deconvolution algorithm (LEDA: linear equations deconvolution analysis), thus decreasing the time necessary for the process. In particular, the LEDA tool processes the MS/MS signals and assigns the relative concentrations (abundances) of the isomers in the sample, at the mg L^-1 level. The efficiency of MS/MS signal assignment was improved by introducing five linear equations to define the LEDA matrix. Then, as a novel approach, an overdetermined system of linear equations was applied for the deconvolution of isomers. The use of LEDA to identify and quantify the isomers in wine samples, together with the choice of a short LC column and a fast elution gradient, simplifies the process and shortens the time needed. Furthermore, it was evaluated the quantitative determination of the IPMA isomers by using the calibration curve provided by the precursor ion MRM transition data. The calculated values of accuracy (recovery between 82.6% and 99.8%) and precision (RSD between 0.4% and 4.0%) confirm the validity of this quantitative approach and the ability of LEDA to establish the correct percentage of the MS/MS signal for each isomer. Finally, to compare the conventional LC-MS/MS method and our proposed method of LC-MS/MS coupled with LEDA post-processing elaboration, a series of real wine samples were analysed by both methods, and the results were compared.

Ion trap MS using high trapping gas pressure enables unequivocal structural analysis of three isobaric compounds in a mixture by using energy-resolved mass spectrometry and the survival yield technique

Recently, it has been shown that energy-resolved mass spectrometry (MS) can provide quantitative information from two isomeric or isobaric compounds in mixtures by using the survival yield (SY) technique together with "gas-phase collisional purification" (GPCP) strategy (Anal. Chem., 2016, 88, p.10821). Herein, we present an improvement and an extension of this concept to the structural analysis of a model mixture of three isobaric compounds (two peptides and a polyether). By using default collision-induced dissociation (CID) tandem MS parameters on an ion trap instrument, the previous approach did not show any signs of isobaric contamination. However, by modifying CID conditions and using a threefold increase of the He trapping gas pressure (to reach 3.00·10^-5 mbar), the SY curve was unexpectedly and strongly shifted to higher excitation voltages with two plateaus appearing. Those plateaus, indicating clearly the presence of three isobaric compounds, were taken as reliable indicators to perform GPCP at carefully selected excitation voltages in order to selectively fragment one compound after the other. In this way, CID mass spectra of each compound were correctly recovered, both in terms of fragment ion peaks and in terms of relative intensities, from energy-resolved MSⁿ spectra of the three compounds mixture. This feature enables their unequivocal structural analysis as if samples were free from isobaric interferences. In this paper, we also discuss the possibility for recovering SY curves for pure compounds directly from the mixture. Clearly, in this case, the higher He trapping gas pressure made it possible to use the SY technique, for the first time, for the structural analysis in the case of mixtures of three isobaric compounds. This observation, quite unexpected, demonstrates that the trapping gas pressure is of paramount importance although it is usually not considered in energy-resolved MS for structural and/or quantitative analysis.

Internal Standard Quantification Using Tandem Mass Spectrometry of a Tryptic Peptide in the Presence of an Isobaric Interference

Model mixtures of isobaric peptides were studied to evaluate the possibility, using tandem mass spectrometry experiments, for internal standard quantification of a tryptic peptide in the presence of an isobaric interference. To this end, direct injection electrospray ionization-tandem mass spectrometry (ESI-MS/MS) experiments were performed on an ion trap instrument using a large mass-selection window (15 m/ z) encompassing the isobaric mixture and the internal standard; MS/MS experiments were carried out to remove completely the interference from the mixture by fragmenting it. This allowed for the correct intensity assignment for the protonated peptide peak and, thus, for the analyte to be quantified through the relative intensity estimate of this peak with respect to the internal standard. This was done by monitoring the 15 m/ z mass-selection window only and without the necessity for careful inspection of any fragment ions peaks. The interference removal was assessed by determining an excitation voltage large enough for the analyte/internal standard ratio to remain constant ensuring correct quantification despite isobaric contamination. A calibration curve was obtained to predict reference samples and compared to reference samples purposely spiked with the interference using the proposed methodology; internal standard quantification of the analyte was made possible with ∼1% deviation despite the isobaric contamination.

Resolution of co-eluting isomers of anti-inflammatory drugs conjugated to carbonic anhydrase inhibitors from plasma in liquid chromatography by energy-resolved tandem mass spectrometry

Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is a chronic inflammatory disease caused by a faulty autoimmune response. Recently, it was reported that some human carbonic anhydrases (CAs) isoforms are overexpressed in inflamed synovium of RA patients. New CA inhibitors (CAIs) incorporating CA-binding moiety and the cyclooxygenase inhibitor tail (nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug [NSAID] type) were studied. The aim of this work is the evaluation of the chemical stability of NSAID - CAI hybrids towards spontaneous or enzymatic hydrolysis by LC-MS/MS. The analytes are isomer pairs of 6- or 7-hydroxycoumarin, their different fragment ions abundances allowed the development of a mathematical tool (LEDA) to distinguish them. LEDA reliability at ng mL-1 level was checked (>90%), being proved the effectiveness in the correct assignment of the isomer present in the sample. The hybrids resulted stable in all tested matrices allowing us to conclude that these compounds reach the target tissues unmodified, opening perspectives for their development in the treatment of inflammation.

Synthesis and analytical characterization of new thiazol-2-(3H)-ones as human neutrophil elastase (HNE) inhibitors

Human neutrophil elastase (HNE) is a potent serine protease belonging to the chymotrypsin family and is involved in a variety of pathologies affecting the respiratory system. Thus, compounds able to inhibit HNE proteolytic activity could represent effective therapeutics. We present here the synthesis of new thiazol-2-(3H)-ones as an elaboration of potent HNE inhibitors with an isoxazol-5-(2H)-one scaffold that we recently identified. Two-dimensional NMR spectroscopic techniques and tandem mass spectrometry allowed us to correctly assign the structure of the final compounds arising from both tautomers of the thiazol-2-(3H)-one nucleus (N-3 of the thiazol-2-(3H)-one and 3-OH of the thiazole). All new compounds were tested as HNE inhibitors, and no activity was found at the highest concentration used (40 µM), demonstrating that the thiazol-2-(3H)-one is not a good scaffold for HNE inhibitors. Molecular modelling experiments indicate that the low-energy pose might limit the nucleophilic attack on the endocyclic carbonyl group of the thiazolone-based compounds by HNE catalytic Ser195, in contrast to isoxazol-5-(2H)-one analogues.

Purification and Quantification of an Isomeric Compound in a Mixture by Collisional Excitation in Multistage Mass Spectrometry Experiments

The differentiation, characterization, and quantification of isomers and/or isobars in mixtures is a recurrent problem in mass spectrometry and more generally in analytical chemistry. Here we present a new strategy to assess the purity of a compound that is susceptible to be contaminated with another isomeric side-product in trace levels. Providing one of the isomers is available as pure sample, this new strategy allows the detection of isomeric contamination. This is done thanks to a "gas-phase collisional purification" inside an ion trap mass spectrometer paving the way for an improved analysis of at least similar samples. This strategy consists in using collision induced dissociation (CID) multistage mass spectrometry (MS² and MS³) experiments and the survival yield (SY) technique. It has been successfully applied to mixtures of cyclic poly(_L-lactide) (PLA) with increasing amounts of its linear topological isomer. Purification in gas phase of PLA mixtures was established based on SY curves obtained in MS³ mode: all samples gave rise to the same SY curve corresponding then to the pure cyclic component. This new strategy was sensitive enough to detect traces of linear PLA (<3%) in a sample of cyclic PLA that was supposedly pure according to other characterization techniques (¹H NMR, MALDI-HRMS, and size-exclusion chromatography). Moreover, in this case, the presence of linear isomer was undetectable according to MS/MS or MS/MS/MS analysis only as fragment ions are also of the same m/z values. This type of approach could easily be implemented in hyphenated mass spectrometric techniques to improve the structural and quantitative analysis of complex samples.

Energy resolved tandem mass spectrometry experiments for resolution of isobaric compounds: a case of cis/trans isomerism

A series of N-alkanol-N-cyclohexanol amine aryl esters cis/trans isomers that showed high efficacy to reverse the acquired resistance of cancer cells during chemotherapeutic therapy (MDR mechanism) was studied. These compounds were two 1,4 cyclohexane cis/trans derivatives (named ELF26A and ELF26B, respectively), and their positional isomers (named ELF34A and ELF34B, respectively) where the aryl-moieties were exchanged. In order to evaluate the behaviour of these compounds during biological tests, a method based on liquid chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry (LC-MS), operating in tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) mode, was developed. A unique chromatographic method suitable to separate the two pairs of cis/trans isomers was not achieved and the MS/MS experiments of the different compounds was not always able to characterise the different isomers. Therefore, a system of linear equations of deconvolution analysis (LEDA) tool was proposed to determine the relative proportions of individual cis/trans isomers in the sample. Considering the pharmaceutical interest of the compounds under investigation, the analytical method developed was tested to be effective at the active concentration levels, corresponding to a concentration of ng mL^-1 of compound in a processed sample. Precision and accuracy of the LEDA algorithm at three levels of relative concentrations of analytes were checked, i.e. low-level (about 25% in the mixture), mid-level (about 50% in the mixture) and high-level (about 70% in the mixture). Evaluation of performances of the algorithm proved that the accuracy (between 88.3% and 99.9%) and precision (between 2.0% and 3.7%) for simultaneous analysis of the mixtures of the four isomers is feasible. It is worth highlighting that the choice of characteristic product ions and optimal abundance ratios plays an important role in the application of the LEDA approach. Therefore, performing an investigation on the energetics of fragmentation pathway allowed the selection of the better product ions for each analyte in terms of both sensitivity of detection and specificity, i.e. the capability to distinguish between isomeric compounds. Finally, the developed approach was applied to determine the relative proportions of individual cis/trans isomers in spiked human plasma samples. The results obtained confirm the reliability of the proposed method in biological samples as well.