Speciation of uranium-mandelic acid complexes using electrospray ionization mass spectrometry and density functional theory

Thorium Complexation with Aliphatic and Aromatic Hydroxycarboxylates: A Combined Experimental and Theoretical Study

Hydroxycarboxylic acids, viz., α-hydroxyisobutyric acid (HIBA) and mandelic acid (MA), have been widely employed as eluents for inner transition metal separation studies. Both extractants have identical functional groups (OH and COOH) with different side-chains. Despite their similarities in binding motifs, they show different retention behaviors for thorium and uranium in liquid chromatography. To understand the mechanism behind the trend, a detailed study on the aqueous phase interaction of thorium with both extractants is carried out by speciation, spectroscopy, and density functional theory-based calculations. Potentiometric titration experiments are carried out to reveal the stability and species formed. Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry is performed to identify the formation of different species by Th with both HIBA and MA. It is seen that for Th-HIBA and Th-MA, the dominating species are ML3 and ML4, respectively. A similar pattern observed in potentiometric speciation analysis supports the tendency of Th to form higher stoichiometric species with MA than with HIBA. The difference in the dominating species thus helps in explaining the reversal in the retention behavior of uranium and thorium in the reverse-phase liquid chromatographic separation. The results obtained are corroborated with extended X-ray absorption fine structure spectroscopic measurements and density functional theory (DFT) calculations.

Role of O Substitution in Expanded Porphyrins on Uranyl Complexation: Orbital- and Density-Based Analyses

Search for new U(VI) sequestering macrocyclic ligands is an important area of research due to manifold applications. Besides hard- or soft-donor-based ligands, mixed-donor ligands are also gaining popularity in achieving optimized performances. However, how the combination of hard-soft-donor centers alters the bonding interactions with U(VI) is still not well-understood. Moreover, a consensus is yet to be reached on the nature and role of underlying covalent interactions in mixed N,O-donor ligands. In this work, using the relativistic density functional theory (DFT), we attempted to address these intriguing issues by investigating the subtle change in bonding characteristics of the uranyl ion upon binding with an expanded porphyrin, viz. sapphyrin, with subsequent O substitutions at the cavity. The results obtained from a range of modern analysis tools suggest that in the O-substituted sapphyrin variants, UO₂²⁺ prefers to bind with N over O, and an increase in the number of O-donor sites at the cavity prompts UO₂²⁺ to have a better interaction with the rest of the N-donor-centers. Although O donors are involved in more numbers of mixed molecular orbitals, the variation in the amplitude of overlap and the better σ-donation ability favor N to have stronger bonding interactions with uranyl. Molecular orbital (MO) and density of states (DOS) analyses show favorable participation of U(d), and the involvement of U(f) orbitals in bonding is of a low extent but non-negligible. Although electrostatic interaction dominates at U-O/N bonds in the equatorial plane, the quantum theory of atoms in molecules descriptors, MO analysis, and overlap-integral calculations confirm the presence of underlying near-degeneracy-driven covalent interactions.

Recent Approaches for Chemical Speciation and Analysis by Electrospray Ionization (ESI) Mass Spectrometry

In recent years, the chemical speciation of several species has been increasingly monitored and investigated, employing electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS). This soft ionization technique gently desolvates weak metal–ligand complexes, taking them in the high vacuum sectors of mass spectrometric instrumentation. It is, thus, possible to collect information on their structure, energetics, and fragmentation pathways. For this reason, this technique is frequently chosen in a synergistic approach to investigate competitive ligand exchange-adsorption otherwise analyzed by cathodic stripping voltammetry (CLE-ACSV). ESI-MS analyses require a careful experimental design as measurement may face instrumental artifacts such as ESI adduct formation, fragmentation, and sometimes reduction reactions. Furthermore, ESI source differences of ionization efficiencies among the detected species can be misleading. In this mini-review are collected and critically reported the most recent approaches adopted to mitigate or eliminate these limitations and to show the potential of this analytical technique.

Matrix-Assisted Ionization of Molecular Uranium Species

Matrix-assisted ionization (MAI) demonstrates high sensitivity for a variety of organic compounds; however, few studies have reported the application of MAI for the detection and characterization of inorganic analytes. Trace-level uranium analysis is important in the realms of nuclear forensics, nuclear safeguards, and environmental monitoring. Traditional mass spectrometry methods employed in these fields require combinations of extensive laboratory chemistry sample preparation and destructive ionization methods. There has been recent interest in exploring ambient mass spectrometry methods that enable timely sample analysis and higher sensitivity than what is attainable by field-portable radiation detectors. Rapid characterization of uranium at nanogram levels is demonstrated in this study using MAI techniques. Mass spectra were collected on an atmospheric pressure mass spectrometer for solutions of uranyl nitrate, uranyl chloride, uranyl acetate, and uranyl oxalate utilizing 3-nibrobenzonitrile as the ionization matrix. The uranyl complexes investigated were detectable, and the chemical speciation was preserved. Sample analysis was accomplished in a matter of seconds, and limits of detection of 5 ng of uranyl nitrate, 10 ng of uranyl oxalate, 100 ng of uranyl chloride, and 200 ng of uranyl acetate were achieved. The observed gas-phase speciation was similar to negative-ion electrospray ionization of uranyl compounds with notable differences. Six matrix-derived ions were detected in all negative-ion mass spectra, and some of these ions formed adducts with the uranyl analyte. Subsequent analysis of the matrix suggests that these molecules are not matrix contaminants and are instead created during the ionization process.

The coordination chemistry of lanthanide and actinide metal ions with hydroxypyridinone-based decorporation agents: orbital and density based analyses

In the context of the mitigation of the biological effects of internal radionuclide contamination and for efficient decorporation, the design and development of efficient chelators for lanthanide and actinide metal ions has become a central issue. The pioneering work of Raymond and coworkers (Chem. Rev., 2003, 103, 4207-4282) led to the development of siderophore-related hydroxypyridinonate ligands for possible treatment of internalized radionuclides. However, the structure-function relationship of Ln/An bound to these ligands, particularly the bonding and coordination aspects are not clearly understood at the atomic level. Here, we have investigated the structure, binding and energetics of trivalent and tetravalent Ln/An (Sm3+, Eu3+, Am3+, Cm3+, Th4+, Pu4+) ions with spermine-based octadentate hydroxypyridinonate chelators, namely 3,4,3-LI(1,2-HOPO) and its 3,3,3 variant, using relativistic density functional theory (DFT). Furthermore, we have performed orbital and density based analyses to elucidate the nature of bonding in these complexes. In accordance with the experimental stability constant, we found the maximum binding free energy for An4+ (Pu4+, Th4+) as compared to trivalent metal ions. CDA and ECDA analyses along with orbital-based population analyses confirmed the higher ligand to metal charge transfer for An4+ than for trivalent metal ions. Furthermore, the aromaticity index analysis suggested the presence of crucial chelatoaromatic stabilization for all these metal ions with the maximum for An4+. QTAIM descriptors indicated that the binding of An/Ln with the hard oxygen donor of the ligands is of the donor-acceptor type but a higher degree of covalency exists for actinides as compared to lanthanides. Furthermore, QTAIM and molecular orbital analysis confirmed that such covalency is of the energy-driven type and strictly originates from the orbital mixing event of An-5f orbitals with the ligand orbitals.

Collision-induced dissociation of [UVI O2 (ClO4 )]+ revisited: Production of [UVI O2 (Cl)]+ and subsequent hydrolysis to create [UVI O2 (OH)]. RAPID COMMUNICATIONS IN MASS SPECTROMETRY : RCM 2018;32:1085-1091. [PMID: 29645301 DOI: 10.1002/rcm.8135] [Citation(s) in RCA: 0] [Impact Index Per Article: 0]

RATIONALE

In a previous study [Rapid Commun Mass Spectrom. 2004;18:3028-3034], collision-induced dissociation (CID) of [U^VI O₂ (ClO₄ )]⁺ appeared to be influenced by the high levels of background H₂ O in a quadrupole ion trap. The CID of the same species was re-examined here with the goal of determining whether additional, previously obscured dissociation pathways would be revealed under conditions in which the level of background H₂ O was lower.

METHODS

Water- and methanol-coordinated [U^VI O₂ (ClO₄ )]⁺ precursor ions were generated by electrospray ionization. Multiple-stage tandem mass spectrometry (MSⁿ ) for CID and ion-molecule reaction (IMR) studies was performed using a linear ion trap mass spectrometer.

RESULTS

Under conditions of low background H₂ O, CID of [U^VI O₂ (ClO₄ )]⁺ generates [U^VI O₂ (Cl)]⁺ , presumably by elimination of two O₂ molecules. Using low isolation/reaction times, we found that [U^VI O₂ (Cl)]⁺ will undergo an IMR with H₂ O to generate [U^VI O₂ (OH)]⁺ .

CONCLUSIONS

With lower levels of background H₂ O, CID experiments reveal that the intrinsic dissociation pathway for [U^VI O₂ (ClO₄ )]⁺ leads to [U^VI O₂ (Cl)]⁺ , apparently by loss of two O₂ molecules. We propose that the results reported in the earlier CID study reflected a two-step process: initial formation of [U^VI O₂ (Cl)]⁺ by CID, followed by a very rapid hydrolysis reaction to leave [U^VI O₂ (OH)]⁺ .

Influence of Background H2O on the Collision-Induced Dissociation Products Generated from [UO2NO3]<sup/>

Developing a comprehensive understanding of the reactivity of uranium-containing species remains an important goal in areas ranging from the development of nuclear fuel processing methods to studies of the migration and fate of the element in the environment. Electrospray ionization (ESI) is an effective way to generate gas-phase complexes containing uranium for subsequent studies of intrinsic structure and reactivity. Recent experiments by our group have demonstrated that the relatively low levels of residual H₂O in a 2-D, linear ion trap (LIT) make it possible to examine fragmentation pathways and reactions not observed in earlier studies conducted with 3-D ion traps (Van Stipdonk et al. J. Am. Soc. Mass Spectrom. 14, 1205-1214, 2003). In the present study, we revisited the dissociation of complexes composed of uranyl nitrate cation [U^VIO₂(NO₃)]⁺ coordinated by alcohol ligands (methanol and ethanol) using the 2-D LIT. With relatively low levels of background H₂O, collision-induced dissociation (CID) of [U^VIO₂(NO₃)]⁺ primarily creates [UO₂(O₂)]⁺ by the ejection of NO. However, CID (using He as collision gas) of [U^VIO₂(NO₃)]⁺ creates [UO₂(H₂O)]⁺ and UO₂⁺ when the 2-D LIT is used with higher levels of background H₂O. Based on the results presented here, we propose that product ion spectrum in the previous experiments was the result of a two-step process: initial formation of [U^VIO₂(O₂)]⁺ followed by rapid exchange of O₂ for H₂O by ion-molecule reaction. Our experiments illustrate the impact of residual H₂O in ion trap instruments on the product ions generated by CID and provide a more accurate description of the intrinsic dissociation pathway for [U^VIO₂(NO₃)]⁺. Graphical Abstract ᅟ.