Progress and challenges in dual- and triple-isotope (δ18 O, δ2 H, Δ17 O) analyses of environmental waters: An international assessment of laboratory performance

Towards the compatibility of stable isotope data: review of related concepts, recent progress with reference materials and current challenges

Comparing and combining stable isotope datasets from different laboratories and different years is essential for many research areas, such as isotope hydrology, greenhouse gas observations, food studies, isotope forensics, palaeo-reconstructions, etc. Data compatibility (i.e. the ability to combine data) is related to the data quality. The prerequisite for data comparability is data normalization to a common stable isotope scale (often referred to as calibration) based on reliable reference materials (RMs) with accurately assigned values and uncertainties. Still, that does not guarantee the data compatibility (mutual agreement). Albeit metrological concepts related to data compatibility and measurement uncertainty have been developed and applied to analytical chemistry in general, these concepts have not yet been fully applied to stable isotope research. This can affect daily calibrations, analytical data and, therefore, data compatibility. In addition, IRMS users often prepare different laboratory standards themselves. Thereafter, users should then understand the contemporary concepts used for assigning RM value and uncertainty, as well as the limitations and potential problems associated with RMs. The history of RMs, preparation reports and also some problems in the past provide lessons to be learned. These include the δ13C drift of LSVEC (the second anchor on the δ13C scale before 2017), revisions to the value assignment principles, the introduction of replacements for LSVEC, related disputes and the potential underestimation of uncertainties for secondary RMs. The review describes metrological concepts related to isotopic scales, RMs and calibration hierarchies and data compatibility. The main RMs and their uncertainties are reviewed through the lens of metrology concepts. Additional focus is given to the VPDB scale for δ13C and issues of scale discontinuity, which can significantly reduce data compatibility in δ13C. The given examples of value and uncertainty assignment for RMs should be viewed as an example of value and uncertainty calculation in daily practice.

The exploratory dataset of isotopic composition of different water sources across Kazakhstan

This work presents the dataset of stable water isotopes of oxygen and hydrogen measured in water samples from different sources (precipitation, surface water, groundwater, tap water) across Kazakhstan from 2017 to 2018 and from 2020 to 2023. The dataset includes results on isotopic composition of 399 water samples, namely precipitation: event-based (n = 108), cumulative monthly (n = 22); surface water: lakes, reservoirs, brooks, rivers, channels (n = 175), groundwater: shallow and artesian groundwater, spring (n = 85), tapwater (n = 9). For each sample name of the source, location, latitude, longitude and date of sampling, measurement uncertainty (one standard deviation) are available. The samples were assessed by plotting the data in dual δ18O vs. δ2H isotope space with reference to values found in the published literature and fitting a linear regression equation for Astana (event) precipitation. Overall, this is the first dataset covering wide range of sources across Kazakhstan, which could be used by global and regional water resource assessments and studies such as tracing water sources, hydrograph separation and end-member analyses, isotope mass balance, evapotranspiration partitioning, residence time analysis and groundwater recharge.

A simple method for rapid removal of the memory effect in cavity ring-down spectroscopy water isotope measurements

RATIONALE

The accuracy determined in the routine analysis of water isotopes (δ17 O, δ18 O, δ2 H) using cavity ring-down spectroscopy is greatly affected by the memory effect (ME), a sample-to-sample carryover that biases measurements. This study aims to develop a simple method that rapidly removes the ME.

METHODS

We developed a method, designed for the Picarro L2140-i, that removes the ME by injecting small amounts of water with an extreme isotopic value ("kick") in the opposite direction of the ME. We conducted 11 experiments to identify the optimal kick for pairs of isotopically enriched and depleted samples. Once quantified, the optimal kick was used to create an ME-free, unbiased calibration curve, which was verified using international and internal lab standards.

RESULTS

Our kick method removes the ME very efficiently in half the time it takes for experiments without a kick. The optimal number of kick injections required to minimize stabilization time between standards of different compositions is three injections of δ2 H ≈ -1000‰ water per a 100‰ difference between standards. Three runs of routine measurements using the kick method resulted in uncertainties of 0.03‰, 0.2‰, and 5 permeg for δ18 O, δ2 H, and 17 O-excess, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates a new method for rapidly removing the ME. Our kick protocol is a readily available, cheap, and efficient approach to reduce instrumental bias and improve measurement accuracy.

Balancing precision and throughput of ..17O and .÷...17O analysis of natural waters by Cavity Ringdown Spectroscopy

δ ¹⁷O and Δ'¹⁷O are emerging tracers increasingly used in isotope hydrology, climatology, and biochemistry. Differentiating small relative abundance changes in the rare ¹⁷O isotope from the strong covariance with ¹⁸O imposes ultra-high precision requirements for this isotope analysis. Measurements of δ ¹⁷O by Cavity Ringdown Spectroscopy (CRDS) are attractive due to the ease of sample preparation, automated throughput, and avoidance of chemical conversions needed for isotope-ratio mass spectrometry. However, the CRDS approach requires trade-offs in measurement precision and uncertainty. In this protocol document, we present the following:•New analytical procedures and a software tool for conducting δ ¹⁷O and Δ'¹⁷O measurements by CRDS.•Outline a robust uncertainty framework for Δ'¹⁷O determinations.•Description of a CRDS performance framework for optimizing throughput, instrumental stability, and Δ'¹⁷O measurement precision and accuracy.

Stable isotope patterns of German rivers with aspects on scales, continuity and network status

In Germany, river monitoring for tritium started in the early 1970s. Today this monitoring network consists of 50 stations and includes stable isotopes. The stable isotope time series to the end of 2021 are at least four years and for some stations up to 30 years long. Daily river water samples were collected during an extraordinary dry season from October 2018 until end of January 2019 from six selected stations of the Rhine and five stations of the Elbe basin. The most dominating stable isotope effects in river water are the seasonal and altitude effects, but also a continental effect is visible. The isotopes indicate snow and ice melt contributions in the Rhine and Danube during the summer months and a consecutive dilution of these signals by mixing with tributary rivers. Close to the coasts in northern Germany, stable isotope patterns reflect influence of seawater and tides. Daily patterns during the dry season 2018/2019 surprisingly do not exhibit extreme changes but rather trends of enhanced groundwater contribution. Long-term continual data across scales are important for comparing and identifying hydrological processes in German river basins of different size and mean catchment altitudes, and highlight the benefits of a co-organized national network.