Towards a rational design of resolving agents. Part II: Correlation between resolution results and physical properties of diastereomeric salts

Discrimination in resolving systems. VI. Comparison of the diastereomers of deoxyephedrinium and ephedrinium 4'-fluoromandelates

(-)-(R)-Deoxyephedrine forms poorly discriminating diastereomeric salts with 4'-fluoromandelic acid from 95% ethanol. Both less-soluble (L) (S)-4'-fluoromandelate and more-soluble (M) (R)-4'-fluoromandelate phases are monoclinic and unsolvated. Their solubility ratio (M/L) in 95% ethanol is only 1.2, which correlates with the similarity and small differences in their respective heats of fusion and fusion temperatures. The (R)-deoxyephedrinium and the related (1R;2S)-ephedrinium 4'-fluoromandelate systems show L-salts with higher ion-pair volumes and lower densities than their M-salts. (R)-Deoxyephedrinium salts have higher volumes than the comparable (1R;2S)-ephedrinium salts even though the resolving base (R)-deoxyephedrine lacks the benzylic hydroxy. In the solids, bilayered structures segregate polar and nonpolar molecular regions. The principle interionic interactions are hydrogen bonds between protonated secondary ammonium ions and carboxylates forming infinite chains with a six-atom repeating unit H-N(+)-H...O-C(-)-O [C(2)(2)(6)]. These are buttressed by mandelate hydroxy to carboxylate hydrogen bonds. Differing interactions between phenyl and 4'-fluorophenyl rings in the nonpolar layers of the salts correlate with the density and stability inversion.

Discrimination in resolving systems. V. Pseudoephedrine - fluoromandelic acid diastereomers

Resolution of the isomeric 2'-, 3'-, and 4'-fluoromandelic acids with (+)-(1S;2S)-pseudoephedrine in 95% ethanol produces both well and poorly discriminating, hydrated and unsolvated binary salts. Seven observed diastereomeric phases are represented by five crystal structure types including three of the four types observed in the pseudoephedrine mandelates. Type a: monoclinic hemihydrate less-soluble (L) (R)-3'-fluoromandelate and more-soluble (M) (R)-4'-fluoromandelate (I); type b: orthorhombic unsolvated M (S)-2'-fluoromandelate; type c: orthorhombic unsolvated L (R)-2'-fluoromandelate; type d: orthorhombic dihydrate M (S)-3'-fluoromandelate and L (S)-4'-fluoromandelate; type e: monoclinic unsolvated M (R)-4'-fluoromandelate (II). Largest (15-fold) discriminating solubilities in 95% ethanol are found between the diastereomers with 2'-fluoromandelic acid, 50% more than in the corresponding ephedrine system. Principle interionic interactions are hydrogen-bonds between protonated secondary ammonium ions and carboxylates. Infinite chains of these are found in type c, with a four-atom repeating unit H-N(+)-H.O(-C(-)-O) [C(2)(1)(4)], and in types b and d, with a six-atom repeating unit H-N(+)-H.O-C(-)-O [C(2)(2)(6)]. Water of crystallization intervenes in the chains of type a but not of type d hydrated salts, according with higher average dehydration temperatures in the former. Hydrated salts in general are excessively soluble in 95% ethanol.

Discrimination in resolving systems. II: Ephedrine-substituted mandelic acids

Binary diastereomeric (-) (1R,2S)-ephedrine salts of various mandelic acids obtained from 95% ethanol show considerable differences in solubility. Structures and some properties of the less-soluble (L) and more-soluble (M) solid phases of (-)-ephedrine with unsubstituted mandelic acid, 2-, 3-, and 4-monosubstituted halo (F, Cl, Br) mandelic acids, and 3- and 4-methylmandelic acids have been determined. Salts were found to be binary, without solvent of crystallization, and composed of double-layered arrays of alternating anions and cations linked by H-bonds normal to the layers. H-bonding links charged donors and acceptors usually along a crystallographic 2-fold screw axis. A striking discrimination is evident in that the (2R)-mandelate salts typically display a compact four-atom chain as the H-bonding repeating unit [+N--H...O(-C(-)--O)...H-N', C2(1)(4)] while the (2S)-mandelate salts adopt a more dimensionally variable six-atom chain repeating unit [+N--H...O--C(-)--O...H--N', C2(2)(6)]. Two distinct packing schemes display the shorter H-bonding chain of the (2R)-mandelates which always occurs with ephedrinium ions in the fully extended conformation. Slightly greater packing efficiency and H-bonding energies of the (2R)-mandelate salts correlates with increased fusion points, lower solubilities (95% ethanol), and higher heats of fusion relative to the phase adopted by their diastereoisomers. In contrast, (2S)-mandelate salts exhibit considerably more structural variability involving all three major ephedrinium conformations, and at least four distinct packing motifs. Mandelates with larger 3'-substituents (Cl, Br, methyl) show similar property discriminations, but these occur with an opposing trend, that is, between phases in which the less-soluble salts contain (2S)-mandelates. Salts with 2-bromomandelate do not show property disparities and their structures are dissimilar to the other phases.