Intrinsic radiosensitivity of head and neck carcinomas as predictive test for clinical tumor control:Comparative analysis and critical assessment of technical reliability

In vitro radiosensitivity of tumour cells and fibroblasts derived from head and neck carcinomas: mutual relationship and correlation with clinical data

The aim was to characterize the variation in the cellular in vitro radiosensitivities in squamous cell carcinomas of the head and neck, and to test for a possible correlation between different measures of radiosensitivity and the clinical and histopathological data. Cellular in vitro radiosensitivities were assessed in tumour biopsies from 71 patients using the modified Courtenay-Mills soft agar clonogenic assay combined with an immunocytochemical analysis. Radiosensitivity was quantified as the surviving fraction after a radiation dose of 2 Gy irrespective of cell type (overall SF2), or based on identification of cell type (tumour cell SF2, fibroblast SF2). Sixty-three biopsies were from primary tumours, and eight were from recurrences. Overall plating efficiency ranged from 0.005 to 1.60% with a median of 0.052%. The majority of the colonies obtained from the biopsies were fibroblast marker-positive; the proportion of tumour marker-positive colonies ranged from 1 to 88% with a median of 15%. The median overall SF2 was 0.47 (range 0.24-0.96), the median tumour cell SF2 was 0.50 (range 0.11-1.0) and the median fibroblast SF2 was 0.49 (range 0.24-1.0). Comparing data from independent experiments, the overall SF2 was significantly correlated with the SF2 of fibroblasts (2P = 0.006) but not with the tumour cell SF2. The tumour cell and fibroblast radiosensitivities measured in the same individuals were not correlated (r= 0.06, 95% CI [-0.19, 0.30]):This finding seems to preclude a strong correlation between the radiosensitivity of tumour cells and fibroblasts. Concerning the clinical characteristics, neither of the measures of tumour radiosensitivity was correlated with T- and N-category, stage, tumour size, sex and age. However, the tumour cell radiosensitivity decreased with increasing grade of histopathological differentiation (2P = 0.012). The same tendency was found in two independent analyses of the same patient material. This correlation was not significant in case of the overall SF2 or the fibroblast SF2.

Relationship between tumour cell in vitro radiosensitivity and clinical outcome after curative radiotherapy for squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Clinically, it is recognized that individual tumours respond differently to radiation treatment. Variation in tumour cell radiosensitivity is believed to be an important underlying factor. In the current study, cellular in vitro radiosensitivity was estimated as the fraction of surviving cells after a radiation dose of 2 Gy (SF2) and related to clinical outcome after curative radiotherapy.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Thirty-eight patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck were treated with curative radiotherapy alone. Pre-treatment biopsies were disaggregated to form a single-cell suspension and cells were cultured in the modified Courtenay-Mills soft agar clonogenic assay. Directly from this assay and with no respect to cell type, overall SF2 was assessed. By collecting the obtained colonies on a preparation slide using a colony-filter technique, and with immunocytochemical staining, it was possible to measure the surviving fraction of tumour cells selectively as tumour cell SF2.

RESULTS

Experimentally, a broad inter-tumour variation was found for both tumour cell SF2 and overall SF2. Using weighted linear regression, it was demonstrated that tumour cell SF2 and overall SF2 were two independent measures of tumour radiosensitivity. In general, the measures of tumour radiosensitivity were independent of patient sex and age, T- and N-category, disease stage, tumour size and plating efficiency. Among the 38 patients grouped in loco-regional failures and patients with loco-regional control, respectively, sex, age, total radiation dose, overall treatment time and tumour grade were equally distributed. Advanced stage, lymph node involvement and tumour size correlated statistically significantly with poor loco-regional control. Neither tumour cell SF2, overall SF2, nor plating efficiency predicted loco-regional tumour control probability. In a multivariate analysis with respect to the risk of loco-regional tumour failure, only disease stage yielded independent prognostic significance. This significance suggests that this patient sample was representative for the patient population with head and neck cancer.

CONCLUSION

In 38 patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck, the estimated tumour radiosensitivities were not statistically related to clinical outcome after curative radiotherapy alone.

Theory and practice of predictive assays in radiation therapy

PURPOSE

An overview of the field of predictive assays is presented. It has been written with the many clinicians and scientists in mind who would like to become better acquainted with the general scope, principles and themes in the field.

RESULTS

Predictive assays have yielded much valuable information about the radiobiology of tumors e.g. the overall treatment time for rapidly proliferating tumors should be kept to a minimum. However, alteration of current treatment protocols based on results from predictive assays is still a matter of debate. What justification do we have to change established treatment protocols? A necessary and sufficient justification would be when the test value indicated an alternative treatment producing a better outcome, i.e. higher survival, improved local control, etc. Necessary but not always sufficient justification is correlation between the parameter measured and clinical outcome, if insufficient clinical benefit can be derived even when this is known. It is not sufficient that a test be demonstrated to be discriminatory. It must discriminate a sufficient number of patients, and its use must provide the patient with useful therapeutic alternatives. These parameters measured by predictive assays may well interact radiobiologically, and restricting observations to just one assay is probably insufficient for reliable indications. In the future, it is more likely that a panel of tests will be performed, and clinical decisions based on multi-parametric analysis of biopsy material.

CONCLUSION

In the following overview general predictive assay theory is presented followed by a brief introduction to some of the more established assays and finally some guidelines are suggested for the development of new assays.

Accelerated radiation therapy for locally advanced squamous cell carcinomas of the oral cavity and oropharynx selected according to tumor cell kinetics--a phase II multicenter study

PURPOSE

A Phase II multicenter trial testing an accelerated regimen of radiotherapy in locally advanced and inoperable cancers of the head and neck, in patients selected on the basis of 5-bromo-2-deoxyuridine/DNA flow cytometry-derived tumor potential doubling time (Tpot).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

From September 1992 to September 1993, 23 patients consecutively diagnosed to have locally advanced, inoperable carcinomas of the oral cavity and the oropharynx, with Tpot of < or = 5 days, received an accelerated radiotherapy regimen (AF) based on a modification of the concomitant boost technique: 2 Gy/fraction once a day, delivered 5 days a week up to 26 Gy, followed by 2 Gy/fraction twice a day, with a 6-h interval, one of the two fractions being delivered as a concomitant boost to reduced fields, up to 66 Gy total dose (off-cord reduction at 46 Gy), shortening the overall treatment time to 4.5 weeks. A contemporary control group of 46 patients with Tpot of >5 days or unknown was treated with conventional fractionation (CF): 2 Gy/fraction once a day, 5 days a week, up to 66 Gy in 6.5 weeks, with fields shrinkage after 46 Gy.

RESULTS

All patients completed the accelerated regimen according to protocol and in the prescribed overall treatment time. Immediate tolerance was fairly good: 65% of the patients in the AF group experienced Grade 3 mucositis vs. 45% in the CF group (p = n.s.). Symptoms related to mucosal reactions seemed to persist longer in AF than in CF patients. The crude proportion of mild (Grades 1 and 2) late effects on skin (p < 0.01) and salivary glands (p < 0.05) was higher in AF than in CF patients, although these reactions did not exceed the limits of tolerance. Three patients in the AF and 1 in the CF arm experienced a late Grade 4 bone complication. Actuarial estimates of severe (Grades 3 and 4) late complications showed a 2-year hazard of 33.3% in the AF arm and 49.7% in CF (p = NS). The actuarial 2-year local control rate of the AF patients was 49.4%, while actuarial 2-year overall survival for the same patients was 43.5%.

CONCLUSION

The results suggested that this accelerated regimen is worth testing in a controlled randomized trial to compare different accelerated schedules. Our findings also confirmed the 5-bromo-2-deoxyuridine/DNA flow cytometry technique as a suitable method of evaluating tumor cell kinetics in multicenter clinical studies, on condition that all measurements are carried out by one most experienced laboratory.

[Recent progress in radiotherapy]

Radiation therapy has considerably evolved in 1 century. After the revolution due to cobalt in the beginning of the sixties, we are now entering the 2nd revolution in three fields in external radiotherapy.

METHODOLOGY

the development of quality assurance programmes gives the guarantee that the treatment is done as it is prescribed. Technology: recent developments allow conformal radiation therapy which permits to increase the dose without increasing side effects. Biology: the implementation of predictive assays will permit to choose the best modality of treatment for each patient. In brachytherapy, the use of high dose rate radioactive sources increases indications in locations not yet accessible. Pulse dose rate brachytherapy increases radio-protection and will make optimization possible in complex volumes. In the future, indications of curative radiotherapy will probably increase in regard to earlier diagnosis of many cancers and to increase of efficacy of general treatments on metastatic disease.