Estimation of age effect with change-points on survival of cancer patients

Efficient estimation of Cox model with random change point

In clinical studies, the risk of a disease may dramatically change when some biological indexes of the human body exceed some thresholds. Furthermore, the differences in individual characteristics of patients such as physical and psychological experience may lead to subject-specific thresholds or change points. Although a large literature has been established for regression analysis of failure time data with change points, most of the existing methods assume the same, fixed change point for all study subjects. In this paper, we consider the situation where there exists a subject-specific change point and two Cox type models are presented. The proposed models also offer a framework for subgroup analysis. For inference, a sieve maximum likelihood estimation procedure is proposed and the asymptotic properties of the resulting estimators are established. An extensive simulation study is conducted to assess the empirical performance of the proposed method and indicates that it works well in practical situations. Finally the proposed approach is applied to a set of breast cancer data.

Survival analysis with a random change-point

Contemporary works in change-point survival models mainly focus on an unknown universal change-point shared by the whole study population. However, in some situations, the change-point is plausibly individual-specific, such as when it corresponds to the telomere length or menopausal age. Also, maximum-likelihood-based inference for the fixed change-point parameter is notoriously complicated. The asymptotic distribution of the maximum-likelihood estimator is non-standard, and computationally intensive bootstrap techniques are commonly used to retrieve its sampling distribution. This article is motivated by a breast cancer study, where the disease-free survival time of the patients is postulated to be regulated by the menopausal age, which is unobserved. As menopausal age varies across patients, a fixed change-point survival model may be inadequate. Therefore, we propose a novel proportional hazards model with a random change-point. We develop a nonparametric maximum-likelihood estimation approach and devise a stable expectation-maximization algorithm to compute the estimators. Because the model is regular, we employ conventional likelihood theory for inference based on the asymptotic normality of the Euclidean parameter estimators, and the variance of the asymptotic distribution can be consistently estimated by a profile-likelihood approach. A simulation study demonstrates the satisfactory finite-sample performance of the proposed methods, which yield small bias and proper coverage probabilities. The methods are applied to the motivating breast cancer study.

Multi-threshold proportional hazards model and subgroup identification

We propose a novel two-stage procedure for change point detection and parameter estimation in a multi-threshold proportional hazards model. In the first stage, we estimate the number of thresholds by formulating the threshold detection problem as a variable selection problem and applying the penalized partial likelihood approach. In the second stage, the change point locations are refined by a grid search and the standard inference for segment regression can then follow. The proposed model and estimation procedure could lend support to subgroup identification and personalized treatment recommendation in medical research. We establish the consistency of the threshold estimators and regression coefficient estimators under technical conditions. The finite sample performance of the method is demonstrated via simulation studies and two cancer data examples.

Testing for change-point in the covariate effects based on the Cox regression model

Models with change-point in covariates have wide applications in cancer research with the response being the time to a certain event. A Cox model with change-point in covariate is considered at which the pattern of the change-point effects can be flexibly specified. To test for the existence of the change-point effects, three statistical tests, namely, the maximal score, maximal normalized score, and maximal Wald tests are proposed. The asymptotic properties of the test statistics are established. Monte Carlo approaches to simulate the critical values are suggested. A large-scale simulation study is carried out to study the finite sample performance of the proposed test statistics under the null hypothesis of no change-points and various alternative hypothesis settings. Each of the proposed methods provides a natural estimate for the location of the change-point, but it is found that the performance of the maximal score test can be sensitive to the true location of the change-point in some cases, while the performance of the maximal Wald test is very satisfactory in general even in cases with moderate sample size. For illustration, the proposed methods are applied to two medical datasets concerning patients with primary biliary cirrhosis and breast cancer, respectively.

Survival analysis with change-points in covariate effects

We apply a maximal likelihood ratio test for the presence of multiple change-points in the covariate effects based on the Cox regression model. The covariate effect is assumed to change smoothly at one or more unknown change-points. The number of change-points is inferred by a sequential approach. Confidence intervals for the regression and change-point parameters are constructed by a bootstrap method based on Bernstein polynomials conditionally on the number of change-points. The methods are assessed by simulations and are applied to two datasets.