Atomically Precise Prediction of 2D Self-Assembly of Weakly Bonded Nanostructures: STM Insight into Concentration-Dependent Architectures

Phase Transitions of Naphthalene-2,3-carbonitride Steered by Solvent Effects and Metal Ion Concentration Variation

The delicate regulation of structural phase transition can provide advanced approaches for fabricating desired and well-organized nanoarchitectures on surfaces. Introduction of metal ions into pure organic systems can facilitate the phase transition from hydrogen-bonded structures to metal-organic structures by coordinating with organic molecules. However, it remains a challenge to attain a phase transition dominated by variable metal coordination configurations through adjustment of the metal ion concentration. Herein, we report the phase transitions of naphthalene-2,3-carbonitride (2,3-DCN) molecules on highly oriented pyrolytic graphite (HOPG) under varying solvents and Cu2+ ion concentrations. By integrating data from scanning tunneling microscopy imaging and density functional theory calculations, it is demonstrated that phase transitions of 2,3-DCN occur through forming diverse coordination configurations where Cu2+ ions can coordinate with 2,3-DCN and 1-nonanoic acid or Cl- ions to form different ligand components with a coordination number of 4 when varying the molar ratios of 2,3-DCN to Cu2+ ion in the 1-nonanoic acid solvent. However, in the case of 1-heptanoic acid as a solvent, the self-assembly structure of 2,3-DCN only changes via the alteration of hydrogen bonding sites and Cu2+ ions do not coordinate with 2,3-DCN molecules. These findings provide valuable insights into the coordination behavior of metal ions in different solvents.

Equilibrium structure of a dense trimesic acid monolayer on a homogeneous solid surface: from atomistic simulation to thermodynamics

A general methodology for determining the thermodynamic characteristics of rigid organic crystals on the atomistic level is presented. The proposed approach is based on a combination of grid interpolation of the precalculated intermolecular potential and kinetic Monte Carlo simulation of the gas-crystal system with an explicit interphase. The two-phase system is stabilized in a wide range of external parameters with an imposed external potential and damping field. The damping field reduces the intermolecular potential at the edges of the crystals and turns it off in the gas phase. To determine the thermodynamic characteristics of a crystal the conditions of equality of chemical potentials in coexisting phases are used. The intermolecular pairwise potential can be calculated on the atomistic or quantum level. In the kinetic Monte Carlo simulations, a grid interpolation of the precalculated potential is performed on each iteration of the algorithm. We have applied the approach to the thermodynamic analysis of a dense monolayer of trimesic acid on a homogeneous surface. The calculated free energy and entropy for the dense "superflower" and filled chicken-wire phases obey the Gibbs-Duhem equation, which confirms the thermodynamic consistency of our approach. Using the proposed approach, we have revealed that the dense "superflower" phase becomes metastable at zero pressure and 470-500 K. Under these conditions, the filled chicken-wire structure with partially released hexagonal cages is thermodynamically favourable. The proposed approach is a potentially universal tool for the thermodynamic analysis of crystals formed by "rigid" organic molecules of any complexity on the atomistic level.

Tensor renormalization group study of orientational ordering in simple models of adsorption monolayers

A simple lattice model of the orientational ordering in organic adsorption layers that considers the directionality of intermolecular interactions is proposed. The symmetry and the number of rotational states of the adsorbed molecule are the main parameters of the model. The model takes into account both the isotropic and directional contributions to the molecule-molecule interaction potential. Using several special cases of this model, we have shown that the tensor renormalization group (TRG) approach can be successfully used for the analysis of orientational ordering in organic adsorption layers with directed intermolecular interactions. Adsorption isotherms, potential energy, and entropy have been calculated for the model adsorption layers differing in the molecule symmetry and the number of rotational states. The calculated thermodynamic characteristics show that entropy effects play a significant role in the self-assembly of dense phases of the molecular layers. All the results obtained with the TRG have been verified by the standard Monte Carlo method. The proposed model reproduces the main features of the phase behavior of the real adsorption layers of benzoic, terephthalic, and trimesic acids on a homogeneous surface of metal single crystals and graphite.

Triangles on a triangular lattice: Insights into self-assembly in two dimensions driven by shape complementarity

A series of models for reversible filling of a triangular lattice with equilateral triangles has been developed and investigated. There are eight distinct models that vary in the set of prohibitions. In zeroth approximation, these models allow one to estimate the influence of the particles' shape and complementarity of their pair configurations on the self-assembly of dense monolayers formed by reversible filling. The most symmetrical models were found to be equivalent to hard-disk models on the hexagonal lattice. When any contact of hard triangles by vertices is prohibited, the dense monolayers are disordered, and their entropy tends to the constant. If only one pair configuration is prohibited, the close-packed layer appears through the continuous phase transition. In other cases, the weak first-order transition resulting in the self-assembly of close-packed layers is observed.

Molecular patterns of oligopeptide hydrocarbons on graphite

Graphitic materials including graphene, carbon nanotubes and fullerenes, are promising for use in nanotechnology and biomedicine. Non-covalent functionalization by peptides and other organic molecules allows changing the properties of graphitic surfaces in a controlled manner and represents a big potential for fundamental research and applications. Recently described oligopeptide-hydrocarbon derivative N,N'-(decane-1,10-diyl)bis(tetraglycineamide) (GM) is highly prospective for the development of graphitic interfaces in biosensor application as well as in structural biology for improving the quality of high-resolution atomic force microscopy (AFM) visualization of individual biomacromolecules. However, molecular organization of GM on graphitic surfaces is still unknown. In this work, the molecular model of GM at the water/highly oriented pyrolytic graphite (HOPG) interface has been developed basing on the high-resolution AFM and full-atom molecular modeling data. This model explains two periodicities observed in AFM images by GM self-assembly on a HOPG surface with formation of the stacks with the lateral shifts. The obtained results reveal the particular patterns and dynamics of GM molecules adsorbed on graphite and unravel the puzzle of peptide self-assembly on graphitic surfaces.

Simulations of the 2D self-assembly of tripod-shaped building blocks

We introduce a molecular dynamics (MD) coarse-grained model for the description of tripod building blocks. This model has been used by us already for linear, V-shape, and tetratopic molecules. We wanted to further extend its possibilities to trifunctional molecules to prove its versatility. For the chosen systems we have also compared the MD results with Monte Carlo results on a triangular lattice. We have shown that the constraints present in the latter method can enforce the formation of completely different structures, not reproducible with off-lattice simulations. In addition to that, we have characterized the obtained structures regarding various parameters such as theoretical diffraction pattern and average association number.

Polymorphic self-assembly of pyrazine-based tectons at the solution-solid interface

Exploring the surface self-assembly of small molecules that act as building blocks (tectons) for complex supramolecular structures is crucial for realizing surface-supported functional molecular devices. Here, we report on the synthesis and surface self-assembly of a new pyrazine-derived molecule with pyridine pendants. Ambient scanning tunneling microscopy investigation at the solution-solid interface reveals polymorphic self-assembly of these molecules on a HOPG substrate. Two different molecular packing structures with equal distribution are observed. Detailed analysis of the STM images emphasizes the crucial role of weak intermolecular hydrogen bonding, and molecule-substrate interactions in the formation of the observed polymorphs. Such weak hydrogen bonding interactions are highly desirable for the formation of modular supramolecular architectures since they can provide sufficiently robust molecular structures and also facilitate error correction.

Advances in the regulation of bipyridine derivatives on two-dimensional (2D) supramolecular nanostructures

In this review, we discuss a series of two-dimensional (2D) supramolecular nanostructures prepared on highly oriented pyrolytic graphite (HOPG) by STM.

On-surface self-assembly of tetratopic molecular building blocks

Self-assembly of functional molecules on solid substrates has recently attracted special attention as a versatile method for the fabrication of low dimensional nanostructures with tailorable properties. In this contribution, using theoretical modeling, we demonstrate how the architecture of 2D molecular assemblies can be predicted based on the individual properties of elementary building blocks at play. To that end a model star-shaped tetratopic molecule is used and its self-assembly on a (111) surface is simulated using the lattice Monte Carlo method. Several test cases are studied in which the molecule bears terminal arm centers providing interactions with differently encoded directionality. Our theoretical results show that manipulation of the interaction directions can be an effective way to direct the self-assembly towards extended periodic superstructures (2D crystals) as well as to create assemblies characterized by a lower degree of order, including glassy overlayers and quasi one-dimensional molecular connections. The obtained structures are described and classified with respect to their main geometric parameters. A small library of the tetratopic molecules and the corresponding superstructures is provided to categorize the structure-property relationship in the modeled systems. The results of our simulations can be helpful to 2D crystal engineering and surface-confined polymerization techniques as they give hints on how to functionalize tetrapod organic building blocks which would be able to create superstructures with predefined spatial organization and range of order.

Concentration-dependent supramolecular patterns of C3 and C2 symmetric molecules at the solid/liquid interface

Here we report on a scanning tunnelling microscopy (STM) investigation on the self-assembly of C₃- and C₂-symmetric molecules at the solution/graphite interface. 1,3,5-tris((E)-2-(pyridin-4-yl)vinyl)benzene and 1,1,2,2-tetrakis(4-(pyridin-4-yl)phenyl)ethane are used as model systems. These molecules displayed a concentration dependent self-assembly behaviour on graphite, resulting in highly ordered supramolecular structures, which are stabilized jointly by van der Waals substrate-adsorbate interactions and in-plane intermolecular H-bonding. Denser packing is obtained when applying a relatively high concentration solution to the basal plane of the surface whereas a less dense porous network is observed upon lowering the concentration. We show that the molecular conformation does not influence the stability of the self-assembly and a twisted molecule can pack into dense and porous architectures under the concentration effect.

Dynamic and programmable morphology and size evolution via a living hierarchical self-assembly strategy

Recent advances in the preparation of shape-shifting and size-growing nanostructures are hot topics in development of nanoscience, because many intelligent functions are always relied on their shape and dimension. Here we report a tunable manipulation of sequential self-assembled transformation in situ via a hierarchical assembly strategy based on a living thiol-disulfide exchange reaction. By tailoring the external stimuli, the reactive points can be generated at the ends of initially unimolecular micelles, which subsequently drive the pre-assemblies to periodically proceed into the hierarchically micellar connection, axial growth, bending, and cyclization processes from nanoscopic assemblies to macroscopic particles. Of particular interest would be systems that acquired the shape control and size adjustment of self-assemblies after termination or reactivation of disulfide reshuffling reaction by regulating external stimuli whenever needed. Such a hierarchical strategy for self-assembled evolution is universally applicable not only for other disulfide-linked dendritic polymers but also for exploitation of biological applications.

Sequential nested assembly at the liquid/solid interface

Studying the stepwise assembly of a four component hybrid structure on Au(111)/mica, the pores of a hydrogen bonded bimolecular network of 3,4,9,10-perylenetetracarboxylic diimide (PTCDI) and 1,3,5-triazine-2,4,6-triamine (melamine) were partitioned by three and four-armed molecules based on oligo([biphenyl]-4-ylethynyl)benzene, followed by the templated adsorption of either C₆₀ fullerene or adamantane thiol molecules. The characterisation by ambient scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) reveals that the pore modifiers exhibit dynamics which pronouncedly depend on the molecular structure. The three-armed molecule 1,3,5-tris([1,1'-biphenyl]-4-ylethynyl)benzene (3BPEB) switches between two symmetry equivalent configurations on a time scale fast compared to the temporal resolution of the STM. Derivatisation of 3BPEB by hydroxyl groups substantially reduces the switching rate. For the four-armed molecule configurational changes are observed only occasionally. The observation of isolated fullerenes and small clusters of adamantane thiol molecules, which are arranged in a characteristic fashion, reveals the templating effect of the trimolecular supramolecular network. However, the fraction of compartments filled by guest molecules is significantly below one for both the thermodynamically controlled adsorption of C₆₀ and the kinetically controlled adsorption of the thiol with the latter causing partial removal of the pore modifier. The experiments, on the one hand, demonstrate the feasibility of templating by nested assembly but, on the other hand, also pinpoint the requirement for the energy landscape to be tolerant to variations in the assembly process.

In-Situ GISAXS Study of Supramolecular Nanofibers having Ultrafast Humidity Sensitivity

Self assembled nanofibers derived from donor-acceptor (D-A) pair of dodecyl methyl viologen (DMV) and potassium salt of coronene tetracarboxylate (CS) is an excellent material for the development of organic electronic devices particularly for ultrafast response to relative humidity (RH). Here we have presented the results of in-situ grazing incidence small angle x-ray scattering (GISAXS) measurements to understand aridity dependent self reorganization of the nanofibers. The instantaneous changes in the organization of the nanofibers was monitored with different equilibrium RH conditions. Additionally formation of nanofibers during drying was studied by GISAXS technique - the results show two distinct stages of structural arrangements, first the formation of a lamellar mesophase and then, the evolution of a distorted hexagonal lattice. The RH dependent GISAXS results revealed a high degree of swelling in the lattice of the micelles and reduction in the distortion of the hexagonal structure with increase in RH. In high RH condition, the nanofibers show elliptical distortion but could not break into lamellar phase as observed during formation through drying. This observed structural deformation gives insight into nanoscopic structural changes of the micelles with change in RH around it and in turn explains ultrafast sensitivity in its conductivity for RH variation.

Halogen bonding versus hydrogen bonding induced 2D self-assembled nanostructures at the liquid-solid interface revealed by STM

We design a bifunctional molecule (5-bromo-2-hexadecyloxy-benzoic acid, 5-BHBA) with a bromine atom and a carboxyl group and its two-dimensional self-assembly is experimentally and theoretically investigated by using scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) and density functional theory (DFT) calculations. The supramolecular self-organization of 5-BHBA in two different solvents (1-octanoic acid and n-hexadecane) at the liquid-solid interface at different solution concentrations is obviously different due to the cooperative and competitive intermolecular halogen and hydrogen bonds. Three kinds of nanoarchitectures composed of dimers, trimers and tetramers are formed at the 1-octanoic acid/graphite interface based on -COOHHOOC-, triangular C[double bond, length as m-dash]OBrH-C, -BrO(H), BrBr, and OH interactions. Furthermore, by using n-hexadecane as the solvent, two kinds of self-assembled linear patterns can be observed due to the coadsorption, in which the dimers are formed by intermolecular -COOHHOOC- hydrogen bonds. The molecule-solvent and solvent-solvent van der Waals force and intermolecular hydrogen bonds dominate the formation of coadsorbed patterns. We propose that the cooperative and competitive halogen and hydrogen bonds are related to the polarity of the solvent and the type of molecule-solvent interaction. The intermolecular binding energy of different dimers and their stability are supported by theoretical calculations. The result provides a new and innovative insight to induce the 2D self-assembled nanostructures by halogen and hydrogen bonds at the liquid-solid interface.

2D self-assembly of phenylene-vinylene tectons at the liquid-highly oriented pyrolytic graphite interface: from chain length effects to anisotropic guest-host dynamics

Here we report the synthesis and characterization of a series of new phenylene-vinylene tectons. The study by scanning tunneling microscopy of their supramolecular self-assembly at the interface between a phenyloctane solution and highly oriented pyrolytic graphite  demonstrates that variation of concentration and length of alkyl chains led to the formation of different networks, a compact one and a nanoporous one, with a fine control of the lattice parameters. The study of guest-host properties of the nanoporous network revealed a selectivity toward guest compounds according to their shape and size. Moreover, the statistical analysis of pore-to-pore guest dynamics evidences an anisotropic diffusion process.

Perchlorination of Coronene Enhances its Propensity for Self-Assembly on Graphene

Providing a quantitative understanding of the thermodynamics involved in molecular adsorption and self-assembly at a nanostructured carbon material is of fundamental importance and finds outstanding applications in the graphene era. Here, we study the effect of edge perchlorination of coronene, which is a prototypical polyaromatic hydrocarbon, on the binding affinity for the basal planes of graphite. First, by comparing the desorption barrier of hydrogenated versus perchlorinated coronene measured by temperature-programmed desorption, we quantify the enhancement of the strength of physisorption at the single-molecule level though chlorine substitution. Then, by a thermodynamic analysis of the corresponding monolayers based on force-field calculations and statistical mechanics, we show that perchlorination decreases the free energy of self-assembly, not only enthalpically (by enhancing the strength of surface binding), but also entropically (by decreasing the surface concentration). The functional advantage of a chemically modulated 2D self-assembly is demonstrated in the context of the molecule-assisted liquid-phase exfoliation of graphite into graphene.