Second-look surgery for recurrent colorectal carcinoma: is it worthwhile?

Patients at risk for peritoneal surface malignancy of colorectal cancer origin: the role of second look laparotomy

Peritoneal surface malignancy (PSM) is a frequent occurrence in the natural history of colorectal cancer (CRC). Although significant advances have been made in screening of CRC, similar progress has yet to be made in the early detection of PSM of colorectal cancer origin. The fact that advanced CRC can be confined to the peritoneal surface without distant dissemination forms the basis for aggressive multi-modality therapy consisting of cytoreductive surgery (CRS) plus hyperthermic intra-peritoneal chemotherapy (HIPEC), and neoadjuvant and/or adjuvant systemic therapy. Reported overall survival with complete CRS+HIPEC exceeds that of systemic therapy alone for the treatment of PSM from CRC, underscoring the advantage of this multi-modality therapeutic approach. Patients with limited peritoneal disease from CRC can undergo complete cytoreduction, which is associated with the best reported outcomes. As early or limited peritoneal carcinomatosis is undetectable by conventional imaging modalities, second look laparotomy is an important means to identify disease in high-risk patients at a stage most amenable to complete cytoreduction. This review focuses on the identification of patients at risk for PSM from CRC and discusses the role of second look laparotomy.

Resection of pulmonary metastases from colorectal carcinoma

A retrospective study was made on 22 patients who underwent surgery (28 operations) for lung metastases of colorectal origin from 1986 to 1995 at the Department of Surgery II, Padova University. The overall 5-year survival (OS) following pulmonary resection was 62% and the 5-year disease-free interval after metastasectomy (DFIM) 45%. The median survival was 23.6 months and the median DFIM 15.3 months. Univariate (Mantel Cox) and multivariate (Cox's model) analyses were used to identify any prognostic factors significant for OS and DFIM. Site and stage of primary colorectal carcinoma, number of pulmonary metastases at presentation, disease-free intervals between treatment of primary tumour and diagnosis of lung metastases (DFIP) appeared to have no influence on OS and DFIM. However, patients who underwent radical resection for metastases had a significantly longer DFIM than those who underwent 'non-radical' resections (P = 0.02), but radical resection had no significant positive effect on OS. A short DFIP, multiple and/or bilateral lesions, lung metastases occurring after liver resection with a curative aim are not contraindications to surgery in patients with pulmonary metastases from colorectal cancer, the main criterion for selection of patients being the possibility of performing 'radical' resection.

Results of surgical treatment of nonhepatic recurrence of colorectal carcinoma

The sites of first recurrence of colorectal cancer include liver (more than 30%), lung and locoregional disease (20-25%), other intraabdominal sites (15-20%), and elsewhere (10%). Isolated locoregional disease accounts for 5-19% of colon recurrences and 7-33% of rectal recurrences. Between 7% and 20% of locally recurrent colorectal cancer can be resected with curative intent. Overall, complete resection of a localized recurrence yields a mean survival of 33-59 months, with long-term survival achieved in 30-50% of patients. Regional recurrence of rectal cancer may require abdominal-sacral resection for adequate margins, with 5-year survival of 18-24%. Early identification (by close monitoring) and accurate staging of recurrence are essential for potentially curative resection. Long-term survival depends on extent of recurrence and completeness of resection. Symptomatic recurrence to the ovaries that requires reoperation occurs in approximately 2% of patients; presentation usually is as part of a diffuse intraabdominal process, and resection is rarely curative. Isolated pulmonary metastases occur in 2-4% of patients experiencing disease recurrence; such tumors are resectable in half of the patients. After the tumors are surgically resected, long-term survival can be expected in 30-40% of patients, with prognosis variably associated with disease-free interval, number and size of lung metastases, and location and stage of the primary tumor. Newer techniques of postoperative monitoring after resection of the primary lesion, more sensitive preoperative and intraoperative staging of recurrences, and the use of intraoperative radiation therapy may increase surgical salvage of recurrent colorectal cancer.