Morphogenesis of retinoic acid-induced postaxial polydactyly in mice

Retinoic Acid-Mediated Regulation of GLI3 Enables Efficient Motoneuron Derivation from Human ESCs in the Absence of Extrinsic SHH Activation

The derivation of somatic motoneurons (MNs) from ES cells (ESCs) after exposure to sonic hedgehog (SHH) and retinoic acid (RA) is one of the best defined, directed differentiation strategies to specify fate in pluripotent lineages. In mouse ESCs, MN yield is particularly high after RA + SHH treatment, whereas human ESC (hESC) protocols have been generally less efficient. In an effort to optimize yield, we observe that functional MNs can be derived from hESCs at high efficiencies if treated with patterning molecules at very early differentiation steps before neural induction. Remarkably, under these conditions, equal numbers of human MNs were obtained in the presence or absence of SHH exposure. Using pharmacological and genetic strategies, we demonstrate that early RA treatment directs MN differentiation independently of extrinsic SHH activation by suppressing the induction of GLI3. We further demonstrate that neural induction triggers a switch from a poised to an active chromatin state at GLI3. Early RA treatment prevents this switch by direct binding of the RA receptor at the GLI3 promoter. Furthermore, GLI3 knock-out hESCs can bypass the requirement for early RA patterning to yield MNs efficiently. Our data demonstrate that RA-mediated suppression of GLI3 is sufficient to generate MNs in an SHH-independent manner and that temporal changes in exposure to patterning factors such as RA affect chromatin state and competency of hESC-derived lineages to adopt specific neuronal fates. Finally, our work presents a streamlined platform for the highly efficient derivation of human MNs from ESCs and induced pluripotent stem cells.

SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT

Our study presents a rapid and efficient protocol to generate human motoneurons from embryonic and induced pluripotent stem cells. Surprisingly, and in contrast to previous work, motoneurons are generated in the presence of retinoic acid but in the absence of factors that activate sonic hedgehog signaling. We show that early exposure to retinoic acid modulates the chromatin state of cells to be permissive for motoneuron generation and directly suppresses the induction of GLI3, a negative regulator of SHH signaling. Therefore, our data point to a novel mechanism by which retinoic acid exposure can bypass the requirement for extrinsic SHH treatment during motoneuron induction.

Pathogenesis of retinoic acid-induced abnormal pad patterns on mouse volar skin

BACKGROUND

Abnormal dermatoglyphs on human volar skin have been reported in many syndromes, but little is known about the pathogenesis. Patterns of pads on rodent limb volar skin are homologous to human dermatoglyphs.

METHODS

In previous studies, we showed that transplacental exposure to teratogens induced abnormal pads in mouse fetuses. Moreover, teratogens caused abnormal pad patterns at levels below those that caused skeletal malformations. In this study, we examined morphology and cytokinetics in developing abnormal pads. Pregnant mice were treated with all-trans-retinoic acid at 20 mg/kg orally at embryonal day (E) 12.5 (vaginal plug = E0). The hindlimbs of the embryos were harvested and observed under a light microscope and by scanning electron microscopy. Cell proliferation and cell death were estimated by 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine (BrdU) labeling, Nile blue A vital staining, and terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated dUTP nick end labeling (TUNEL).

RESULTS

Retinoic acid induced aplasia of the fibular tarsal pad and supernumerary interdigital pads on hindlimbs. Cell proliferation was observed in the area of developing pad, but cell death was very rarely seen in either normal or abnormal pads.

CONCLUSIONS

Retinoic acid disturbed pad patterning as a whole rather than individual pad formation.

Lack of evidence of a major gene acting on postaxial polydactyly in South America

Data on polydactyly were obtained from two large samples: the Latin American Collaborative Study of Congenital Malformations (ECLAMC), and from a migrant Northeastern Brazilian population of rural origin (Hospedaria). ECLAMC is a case-control clinical epidemiological program comprising 10,035 individuals distributed among 2,030 segregating nuclear families. Hospedaria data consisted of 6,586 examined individuals belonging to 1,040 nuclear families. Using complex segregation analysis methodology we found no evidence of two loci (a major gene and a modifier locus) acting on postaxial polydactyly in the present study. Very high heritability values (in a classical multifactorial model) of postaxial polydactyly were detected, for several sets of analyses in ECLAMC and in Hospedaria. For the whole ECLAMC sample there is a peculiar suggestion of a major recessive gene effect responsible for the trait; however, no comparison with a model involving transmission probabilities (tau) was possible in this highly heterogeneous sample. If the whole ECLAMC sample is divided in subsamples, according to Black admixture proportions, the same multifactorial picture emerges. Two different inheritance patterns were verified for hand (HP) and foot (FP) postaxial polydactyly: For HP there is evidence of a non-Mendelian transmission mechanism, while for FP the parental/sib transmission appears to be due only to multifactorial causes.

Hand and foot postaxial polydactyly: two different traits

The aim of this work was to test whether postaxial hexadactyly had different clinical and epidemiological characteristics depending on hand or foot involvement. In the period 1967-1993, the Latin-American Collaborative Study of Congenital Malformations (ECLAMC) enrolled 1,582,289 births, and 2,271 cases with isolated (nonsyndromal) postaxial polydactyly (5th-digit hexadactyly). The prevalence was 14.3/10,000 births. Postaxial polydactyly (PP) of the hand (HPP) was the most frequent type (N:1,733; 76.3%; prevalence: 11.0/10,000), followed by foot PP (FPP=N:351; 15.5%; prevalence: 2.2), and hand and foot PP (BPP=N:187; 8.2%; prevalence: 1.2). Unlike HPP (55.0% bilateral; 77.2% left), FPP was less frequently bilateral (19.4%), with lower preference for the left side (55.5%). As expected, HPP was associated with African Black ethnicity, male sex, twinning, low maternal education, parental consanguinity, and there was frequent recurrence in 1st-degree relatives. Conversely, FPP was associated with Amerindian racial background, parental subfertility, and bleeding in the 1st trimester of pregnancy. BPP displayed the highest frequency of associated congenital defects (23.4%, vs HPP:6.6%, FPP: 15.4%). In its isolated form, BPP resembled HPP more than FPP with respect to left preference (90.9%), familial recurrence (11.0% of 1st degree relatives), and low maternal education. Although male sex preference and high frequency of twinning was observed in the 3 PP subtypes, statistical significance was present only in HPP. None of the 3 PP subtypes showed abnormal values for perinatal mortality, birth weight, length of gestation, parental ages, or parity. A logistic regression analysis showed Black race only to be associated with HPP, parental subfertility with FPP, parental consanguinity with BPP, and non-Black race with both FPP and BPP. The data presented here are the first indication that HPP and FPP are 2 different entities, with a larger genetic component in HPP than in FPP.