Evaluation of six synthetic surgical meshes implanted subcutaneously in a rat model

Different cellular and immunohistochemical abdominal wall cicatrization parameters evaluation in comparison with sublay, onlay, and ipom technique in an experimental rat model

PURPOSE

Incisional hernia (IH) occurs when there is a partial or complete solution of continuity of a fascia previously incised. Systematic reviews demonstrate that surgical treatment of IHs with the use of meshes are approximately 16%. Meta-analyses have demonstrated the superiority of mesh placement using sublay technique, but without a pathophysiological explanation. Thus, we aim to evaluate the different techniques of mesh positioning in an experimental model.

METHODS

Fifty rats were distributed into five groups; control; simulation (SM)-submitted to laparotomy only; onlay-the mesh was positioned in onlay fashion; retromuscular (SL)-the mesh was positioned in a sublay fashion; intraperitoneal (IPOM)-positioning of the mesh adjacent to the transversalis fascia, inside the cavity. After 60 days, adhesions, tensiometry, histology, and immunohistochemistry were addressed.

RESULTS

The IPOM group had the most adhesions, together with the SL group, with significantly relevant results. The SL group had higher values of tensiometric evaluation, while the IPOM group had the lowest mean in the tensiometry evaluation, being even lower than the SM group. Regarding histological and immunohistochemical findings, the SL group had a higher pixel number count compared to the groups, with statistical significance, in addition to higher expression of polymorphonuclear infiltrate and CD68 markers.

CONCLUSION

The mesh positioning in sublay compartment is associated with the development of more pronounce minimum tensile force required for detaching the surrounding abdominal wall tissues it was incorporated. The intensity of these findings correlates to the different histological and immunohistochemical profiles observed following each repair, since SL group was characterized by a higher proportion of collagen, inflammatory, and reparative elements. Characterizing these pro-healing elements and its counterparts will allow the development of new therapeutic tools which could be added to the still far-from-ideal current therapeutic options for IH treatment.

In Vivo Comparison of Synthetic Macroporous Filamentous and Sponge-like Skin Substitute Matrices Reveals Morphometric Features of the Foreign Body Reaction According to 3D Biomaterial Designs

Synthetic macroporous biomaterials are widely used in the field of skin tissue engineering to mimic membrane functions of the native dermis. Biomaterial designs can be subclassified with respect to their shape in fibrous designs, namely fibers, meshes or fleeces, respectively, and porous designs, such as sponges and foams. However, synthetic matrices often have limitations regarding unfavorable foreign body responses (FBRs). Severe FBRs can result in unfavorable disintegration and rejection of an implant, whereas mild FBRs can lead to an acceptable integration of a biomaterial. In this context, comparative in vivo studies of different three-dimensional (3D) matrix designs are rare. Especially, the differences regarding FBRs between synthetically derived filamentous fleeces and sponge-like constructs are unknown. In the present study, the FBRs on two 3D matrix designs were explored after 25 days of subcutaneous implantation in a porcine model. Cellular reactions were quantified histopathologically to investigate in which way the FBR is influenced by the biomaterial architecture. Our results show that FBR metrics (polymorph-nucleated cells and fibrotic reactions) were significantly affected according to the matrix designs. Our findings contribute to a better understanding of the 3D matrix tissue interactions and can be useful for future developments of synthetically derived skin substitute biomaterials.

Porcine dermis implants in soft-tissue reconstruction: current status

Soft-tissue reconstruction for a variety of surgical conditions, such as abdominal wall hernia or pelvic organ prolapse, remains a challenge. There are numerous meshes available that may be simply categorized as either synthetic or biologic. Within biologic meshes, porcine dermal meshes have come to dominate the market. This review examines the current evidence for their use and the limitations of knowledge. Although there is increasing evidence to support their safety, long-term follow-up studies that support their efficacy are lacking. Numerous clinical trials that remain ongoing may help elucidate their precise role in soft-tissue reconstruction.

In vitro and in vivo characterization of a fully resorbable and composite surgical mesh

Fully resorbable and composite synthetic meshes are intended to provide advantages over nonabsorbable synthetic meshes, such as minimization of visceral adhesions and improved biocompatibility, but the inflammatory response to these materials has not previously been fully characterized. We compared resorbable and composite synthetic meshes using in vitro characterization and evaluated the host response in a nonhuman primate acute abdominal wall defect. After a 2-week in vitro incubation, resorbable synthetic mesh mechanical strength decreased to 0.12 ± 0.09 N (0.25% of initial strength), which preceded acidification and a fractured morphology at 1 month. The composite synthetic mesh strength decreased to 10.0 ± 3.2 N (41.1% of initial strength), coincident with morphological changes. In vivo, resorbable synthetic mesh elicited an intense yet transient foreign-body response, with macrophages and myofibroblasts persisting through 3 months of implantation. At 6 months, resorbable synthetic mesh was undetectable and the mesh–host tissue interface strength (14.7 ± 7.9 N) was equivalent to that of primary repair (21.4 ± 4.9 N). The composite synthetic mesh elicited a significant foreign-body response following 1 month of implantation. By 3 months, the composite synthetic mesh resorbable films had fully degraded, with foreign-body reaction localized to polypropylene fibers. By 6 months, macrophages had surrounded these polypropylene fibers, with a myofibroblast-positive capsule encircling a macrophage-rich layer. Resorbable and composite synthetic meshes may ultimately not be the most ideal biomaterials in situations where the biological response is expected to lead to a regeneration of host soft tissues.