Ligand-dependent ribozymes

Tapping the potential of synthetic riboswitches: reviewing the versatility of the tetracycline aptamer

Synthetic riboswitches are a versatile class of regulatory elements that are becoming increasingly established in synthetic biology applications. They are characterized by their compact size and independence from auxiliary protein factors. While naturally occurring riboswitches were mostly discovered in bacteria, synthetic riboswitches have been designed for all domains of life. Published design strategies far exceed the number of riboswitches found in nature. A core element of any riboswitch is a binding domain, called an aptamer, which is characterized by high specificity and affinity for its ligand. Aptamers can be selected de novo, allowing the design of synthetic riboswitches against a broad spectrum of targets. The tetracycline aptamer has proven to be well suited for riboswitch engineering. Since its selection, it has been used in a variety of applications and is considered to be well established and characterized. Using the tetracycline aptamer as an example, we aim to discuss a large variety of design approaches for synthetic riboswitch engineering and their application. We aim to demonstrate the versatility of riboswitches in general and the high potential of synthetic RNA devices for creating new solutions in both the scientific and medical fields.

Rational Design of Allosteric Nanodevices Based on DNA Triple Helix

Inspired by allosteric regulation of natural molecules, we present a rational design scheme to build synthetic nucleic acid allosteric nanodevices. The clearly specified conformational states of switches obtained from systematic screening and analyses make the ON-OFF transition clear-cut and quantification ready. Under the rational design scheme, we have developed a series of DNA switches with triplex-forming oligos as allosteric modulators and implemented designated allosteric transitions, allosteric coregulation, and reaction pathway control. In conjunction with toehold-mediated strand displacement, our design scheme has also been applied to synthetic nucleic acid computing including a set of logic operations and complex algorithm.

Assembly of long L-RNA by native RNA ligation

Due to their intrinsic nuclease resistance, L-oligonucleotides are being increasingly utilized in the development of molecular tools and sensors. Yet, it remains challenging to synthesize long L-oligonucleotides, potential limiting future applications. Herein, we report straightforward and versitile approach to assemble long L-RNAs from two or more shorter fragments using T4 RNA ligase 1. We show that this approach is compatible with the assembly of several classes of functional L-RNA, which we highlight by generating a 124 nt L-RNA biosensor that functions in serum.

Modular tuning engineering and versatile applications of genetically encoded biosensors

Genetically encoded biosensors have a diverse range of detectable signals and potential applications in many fields, including metabolism control and high-throughput screening. Their ability to be used in situ with minimal interference to the bioprocess of interest could revolutionize synthetic biology and microbial cell factories. The performance and functions of these biosensors have been extensively studied and have been rapidly improved. We review here current biosensor tuning strategies and attempt to unravel how to obtain ideal biosensor functions through experimental adjustments. Strategies for expanding the biosensor input signals that increases the number of detectable compounds have also been summarized. Finally, different output signals and their practical requirements for biotechnology and biomedical applications and environmental safety concerns have been analyzed. This in-depth review of the responses and regulation mechanisms of genetically encoded biosensors will assist to improve their design and optimization in various application scenarios.

Identification of over 200-fold more hairpin ribozymes than previously known in diverse circular RNAs

Self-cleaving ribozymes are catalytic RNAs that cut themselves at a specific inter-nucleotide linkage. They serve as a model of RNA catalysis, and as an important tool in biotechnology. For most of the nine known structural classes of self-cleaving ribozymes, at least hundreds of examples are known, and some are present in multiple domains of life. By contrast, only four unique examples of the hairpin ribozyme class are known, despite its discovery in 1986. We bioinformatically predicted 941 unique hairpin ribozymes of a different permuted form from the four previously known hairpin ribozymes, and experimentally confirmed several diverse predictions. These results profoundly expand the number of natural hairpin ribozymes, enabling biochemical analysis based on natural sequences, and suggest that a distinct permuted form is more biologically relevant. Moreover, all novel hairpins were discovered in metatranscriptomes. They apparently reside in RNA molecules that vary both in size—from 381 to 5170 nucleotides—and in protein content. The RNA molecules likely replicate as circular single-stranded RNAs, and potentially provide a dramatic increase in diversity of such RNAs. Moreover, these organisms have eluded previous attempts to isolate RNA viruses from metatranscriptomes—suggesting a significant untapped universe of viruses or other organisms hidden within metatranscriptome sequences.

The case of the missing allosteric ribozymes

The RNA World theory encompasses the hypothesis that sophisticated ribozymes and riboswitches were the primary drivers of metabolic processes in ancient organisms. Several types of catalytic RNAs and many classes of ligand-sensing RNA switches still exist in modern cells. Curiously, allosteric ribozymes formed by the merger of RNA enzyme and RNA switch components are largely absent in today's biological systems. This is true despite the striking abundances of various classes of both self-cleaving ribozymes and riboswitch aptamers. Here we present the known types of ligand-controlled ribozymes and riboswitches and discuss the possible reasons why fused ribozyme-aptamer constructs have been disfavored through evolution.

A cell-based ribozyme reporter system employing a chromosomally-integrated 5' exonuclease gene

Background

Bioinformatic genome surveys indicate that self-cleaving ribonucleic acids (ribozymes) appear to be widespread among all domains of life, although the functions of only a small number have been validated by biochemical methods. Alternatively, cell-based reporter gene assays can be used to validate ribozyme function. However, reporter activity can be confounded by phenomena unrelated to ribozyme-mediated cleavage of RNA.

Results

We established a ribozyme reporter system in Escherichia coli in which a significant reduction of reporter activity is manifest when an active ribozyme sequence is fused to the reporter gene and the expression of a foreign Bacillus subtilis RNaseJ1 5′ exonuclease is induced from a chromosomally-integrated gene in the same cell.

Conclusions

The reporter system could be useful for validating ribozyme function in candidate sequences identified from bioinformatics.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12860-021-00357-7.

Conditional gene expression in invertebrate animal models

A mechanistic understanding of biology requires appreciating spatiotemporal aspects of gene expression and its functional implications. Conditional expression allows for (ir)reversible switching of genes on or off, with the potential of spatial and/or temporal control. This provides a valuable complement to the more often used constitutive gene (in)activation through mutagenesis, providing tools to answer a wider array of research questions across biological disciplines. Spatial and/or temporal control are granted primarily by (combinations of) specific promoters, temperature regimens, compound addition, or illumination. The use of such genetic tool kits is particularly widespread in invertebrate animal models because they can be applied to study biological processes in short time frames and on large scales, using organisms amenable to easy genetic manipulation. Recent years witnessed an exciting expansion and optimization of such tools, of which we provide a comprehensive overview and discussion regarding their use in invertebrates. The mechanism, applicability, benefits, and drawbacks of each of the systems, as well as further developments to be expected in the foreseeable future, are highlighted.

Visualizing a viral genome with contrast variation small angle X-ray scattering

Despite the threat to human health posed by some single-stranded RNA viruses, little is understood about their assembly. The goal of this work is to introduce a new tool for watching an RNA genome direct its own packaging and encapsidation by proteins. Contrast variation small-angle X-ray scattering (CV-SAXS) is a powerful tool with the potential to monitor the changing structure of a viral RNA through this assembly process. The proteins, though present, do not contribute to the measured signal. As a first step in assessing the feasibility of viral genome studies, the structure of encapsidated MS2 RNA was exclusively detected with CV-SAXS and compared with a structure derived from asymmetric cryo-EM reconstructions. Additional comparisons with free RNA highlight the significant structural rearrangements induced by capsid proteins and invite the application of time-resolved CV-SAXS to reveal interactions that result in efficient viral assembly.

Aptamer-Mediated Control of Polyadenylation for Gene Expression Regulation in Mammalian Cells

Small aptamer-based regulatory devices can be designed to control a range of RNA-dependent cellular processes and emerged as promising tools for fine-tuning gene expression in synthetic biology. Here, we design a conceptually new riboswitch device that allows for the conditional regulation of polyadenylation. By making use of ligand-induced sequence occlusion, the system efficiently controls the accessibility of the eukaryotic polyadenylation signal. Undesirable 3'-extended read-through products are counteracted by the downstream insertion of a microRNA target site. We demonstrate the modularity of the system with regard to sensor aptamers and polyadenylation signals used and combine the newly designed riboswitch with well-known aptazymes to yield superior composite systems. In addition, we show that the switches can be used to control alternative polyadenylation. The presented genetic switches require very little coding space and can be easily optimized by rational adjustments of the thermodynamic stability. The polyadenylation riboswitch extends the repertoire of RNA-based regulators and opens new possibilities for the generation of complex synthetic circuits.

Functional Constitutional Dynamic Networks Revealing Evolutionary Reproduction/Variation/Selection Principles

Within the broad research efforts to engineer chemical pathways to yield high-throughput evolutionary synthesis of genes and their screening for dictated functionalities, we introduce the evolution of nucleic-acid-based constitutional dynamic networks (CDNs) that follow reproduction/variation/selection principles. These fundamental principles are demonstrated by assembling a library of nucleic-acid strands and hairpins as functional modules for evolving networks. Primary T1-initiated selection of components from the library assembles a parent CDN X, where the evolved constituents exhibit catalytic properties to cleave the hairpins in the library. Cleavage of the hairpins yields fragments, which reproduces T1 to replicate CDN X, whereas the other fragments T2 and T3 select other components to evolve two other CDNs, Y and Z (variation). By applying appropriate counter triggers, we demonstrate the guided selection of networks from the evolved CDNs. By integrating additional hairpin substrates into the system, CDN-dictated emergent catalytic transformations are accomplished. The study provides pathways to construct evolutionary dynamic networks revealing enhanced gated and cascaded functions.

Intracellular Selection of Theophylline-Sensitive Hammerhead Aptazyme

Hammerhead ribozyme-based aptazyme (HHAz), inheriting the advantages of small size and high efficiency from the RNA-cleaving ribozyme and the specific recognition ability of aptamers to specific targets, exhibits the huge potential to be a transgene expression regulator. Herein, we report a selection strategy for HHAz by using a toxin protein IbsC as the reporter to offer a positive phenotype, thus realizing an easy-operating, time- and labor-saving selection of HHAz variants with desired properties. Based on this strategy, we obtained a new HHAz (TAP-1), which could react sensitively toward the extracellular regulatory molecule, theophylline, both in prokaryotic and eukaryotic systems. With fluorescent protein reporter, the intracellular switching efficiencies of TAP-1 and other reported theophylline-dependent HHAzs has been quantitatively evaluated, showing that TAP-1 not only exhibits the best downregulating ability at high concentration of theophylline but also maintains high activity with 0.1 mM theophylline, which is a safe concentration in the human body.

Riboswitch regulation mechanisms: RNA, metabolites and regulatory proteins

Riboswitches are RNA sensors that have been shown to modulate the expression of downstream genes by altering their structure upon metabolite binding. Riboswitches are unique among cellular regulators in that metabolite detection is strictly performed using RNA interactions with the sensed metabolite and in which no regulatory protein is needed to mediate the interaction. However, recent studies have shed light on riboswitch control mechanisms relying on protein regulators to harness metabolite binding for the mediation of gene expression, thereby increasing the range of cellular factors involved in riboswitch regulation. The interaction between riboswitches and proteins adds another level of evolutionary pressure as riboswitches must maintain key residues for metabolite detection, structural switching and protein binding sites. Here, we review regulatory mechanisms involving Escherichia coli riboswitches that have recently been shown to rely on regulatory proteins. We also discuss the implication of such protein-based riboswitch regulatory mechanisms for genetic regulation.

Crucial Roles of Two Hydrated Mg2+ Ions in Reaction Catalysis of the Pistol Ribozyme

Pistol ribozymes constitute a new class of small self‐cleaving RNAs. Crystal structures have been solved, providing three‐dimensional snapshots along the reaction coordinate of pistol phosphodiester cleavage, corresponding to the pre‐catalytic state, a vanadate mimic of the transition state, and the product. The results led to the proposed underlying chemical mechanism. Importantly, a hydrated Mg²⁺ ion remains innersphere‐coordinated to N7 of G33 in all three states, and is consistent with its likely role as acid in general acid base catalysis (δ and β catalysis). Strikingly, the new structures shed light on a second hydrated Mg²⁺ ion that approaches the scissile phosphate from its binding site in the pre‐cleavage state to reach out for water‐mediated hydrogen bonding in the cyclophosphate product. The major role of the second Mg²⁺ ion appears to be the stabilization of product conformation. This study delivers a mechanistic understanding of ribozyme‐catalyzed backbone cleavage.

Aptamers in RNA-based switches of gene expression

The ability to control gene expression via small molecule effectors is important in basic research as well as in future gene therapy applications. Although transcription factor-based systems are widely used, they are not well suited for certain applications due to a lack of functionality, limited available coding space, and potential immunogenicity of the regulatory proteins. RNA-based switches fill this gap since they can be designed to respond to effector compounds utilizing ligand-sensing aptamers. These systems are very modular since the aptamer can be combined with a variety of different expression platforms. RNA-based switches have been constructed that allow for controlling gene expression in diverse contexts. Here we discuss latest developments and applications of aptamer-based gene expression switches in eukaryotes.

Aptazymes: Expanding the Specificity of Natural Catalytic Nucleic Acids by Application of In Vitro Selected Oligonucleotides

Aptazymes are synthetic molecules composed of an aptamer domain and a catalytic active nucleic acid unit, which may be a ribozyme or a DNAzyme. In these constructs the aptamer domain serves as a molecular switch that can regulate the catalytic activity of the ribozyme or DNAzyme subunit. This regulation is triggered by binding of the aptamers target molecule, which causes significant structural changes in the aptamer and thus in the entire aptazyme. Therefore, aptazymes function similar to allosteric enzymes, whose catalytic activity is regulated by binding of ligands (effectors) to allosteric sites due to alteration of the three-dimensional structure of the active site of the enzyme. In case of aptazymes, the allosteric site is composed of an aptamer. Aptazymes can be designed for different applications and have already been used in analytical assays as well as for the regulation of gene expression.

Generation of small molecule-binding RNA arrays and their application to fluorogen-binding RNA aptamers

The discovery and engineering of more and more functions of RNA has highlighted the utility of RNA-targeting small molecules. Recently, several fluorogen-binding RNA aptamers have been developed that have been applied to live cell imaging of RNA and metabolites as RNA tags or biosensors, respectively. Although the design and application of these fluorogen-binding RNA aptamer-based devices is straightforward in theory, in practice, careful optimisation is required. For this reason, high throughput in vitro screening techniques, capable of quantifying fluorogen-RNA aptamer interactions, would be beneficial. We recently developed a method for generating functional-RNA arrays and demonstrated that they could be used to detect fluorogen-RNA aptamer interactions. Specifically, we were able to visualise the interaction between malachite green and the malachite green-binding aptamer. Here we expand this study to demonstrate that functional-RNA arrays can be used to quantify fluorogen-aptamer interactions. As proof-of-concept, we provide detailed protocols for the production of malachite green-binding RNA aptamer and DFHBI-binding Spinach RNA aptamer arrays. Furthermore, we discuss the potential utility of the technology to fluorogen-binding RNA aptamers, including application as a molecular biosensor platform. We anticipate that functional-RNA array technology will be beneficial for a wide variety of biological disciplines.

Strategies to Increase On-Target and Reduce Off-Target Effects of the CRISPR/Cas9 System in Plants

The CRISPR/Cas9 system (clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeat-associated protein 9) is a powerful genome-editing tool in animals, plants, and humans. This system has some advantages, such as a high on-target mutation rate (targeting efficiency), less cost, simplicity, and high-efficiency multiplex loci editing, over conventional genome editing tools, including meganucleases, transcription activator-like effector nucleases (TALENs), and zinc finger nucleases (ZFNs). One of the crucial shortcomings of this system is unwanted mutations at off-target sites. We summarize and discuss different approaches, such as dCas9 and Cas9 paired nickase, to decrease the off-target effects in plants. According to studies, the most effective method to reduce unintended mutations is the use of ligand-dependent ribozymes called aptazymes. The single guide RNA (sgRNA)/ligand-dependent aptazyme strategy has helped researchers avoid unwanted mutations in human cells and can be used in plants as an alternative method to dramatically decrease the frequency of off-target mutations. We hope our concept provides a new, simple, and fast gene transformation and genome-editing approach, with advantages including reduced time and energy consumption, the avoidance of unwanted mutations, increased frequency of on-target changes, and no need for external forces or expensive equipment.

Riboswitch identification using Ligase-Assisted Selection for the Enrichment of Responsive Ribozymes (LigASERR)

In vitro selection of ligand-responsive ribozymes can identify rare, functional sequences from large libraries. While powerful, key caveats of this approach include lengthy and demanding experimental workflows; unpredictable experimental outcomes and unknown functionality of enriched sequences in vivo. To address the first of these limitations, we developed Ligase-Assisted Selection for the Enrichment of Responsive Ribozymes (LigASERR). LigASERR is scalable, amenable to automation and requires less time to implement compared to alternative methods. To improve the predictability of experiments, we modeled the underlying selection process, predicting experimental outcomes based on sequence and population parameters. We applied this new methodology and model to the enrichment of a known, in vitro-selected sequence from a bespoke library. Prior to implementing selection, conditions were optimized and target sequence dynamics accurately predicted for the majority of the experiment. In addition to enriching the target sequence, we identified two new, theophylline-activated ribozymes. Notably, all three sequences yielded riboswitches functional in Escherichia coli, suggesting LigASERR and similar in vitro selection methods can be utilized for generating functional riboswitches in this organism.

A tetracycline-dependent ribozyme switch allows conditional induction of gene expression in Caenorhabditis elegans

The nematode Caenorhabditis elegans represents an important research model. Convenient methods for conditional induction of gene expression in this organism are not available. Here we describe tetracycline-dependent ribozymes as versatile RNA-based genetic switches in C. elegans. Ribozyme insertion into the 3’-UTR converts any gene of interest into a tetracycline-inducible gene allowing temporal and, by using tissue-selective promoters, spatial control of expression in all developmental stages of the worm. Using the ribozyme switches we established inducible C. elegans polyglutamine Huntington’s disease models exhibiting ligand-controlled polyQ-huntingtin expression, inclusion body formation, and toxicity. Our approach circumvents the complicated expression of regulatory proteins. Moreover, only little coding space is necessary and natural promoters can be utilized. With these advantages tetracycline-dependent ribozymes significantly expand the genetic toolbox for C. elegans.

Tools for conditional induction of gene expression in C. elegans are limited compared to other organisms. Here the authors present a tetracycline-dependent ribozyme that allows conditional control of a gene of interest.

Attempted use of PACE for riboswitch discovery generates three new translational theophylline riboswitch side products

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this project was to use an in vivo method to discover riboswitches that are activated by new ligands. We employed phage-assisted continuous evolution (PACE) to evolve new riboswitches in vivo. We started with one translational riboswitch and one transcriptional riboswitch, both of which were activated by theophylline. We used xanthine as the new target ligand during positive selection followed by negative selection using theophylline. The goal was to generate very large M13 phage populations that contained unknown mutations, some of which would result in new aptamer specificity. We discovered side products of three new theophylline translational riboswitches with different levels of protein production.

RESULTS

We used next generation sequencing to identify M13 phage that carried riboswitch mutations. We cloned and characterized the most abundant riboswitch mutants and discovered three variants that produce different levels of translational output while retaining their theophylline specificity. Although we were unable to demonstrate evolution of new riboswitch ligand specificity using PACE, we recommend careful design of recombinant M13 phage to avoid evolution of "cheaters" that short circuit the intended selection pressure.

Distinct modulation of group I ribozyme activity among stereoisomers of a synthetic pentamine with structural constraints

Among cationic molecules that can modulate ribozyme activities, polyamines act as both activator and inhibitor of ribozyme reactions partly due to their structural flexibility. Restriction of structural flexibility of polyamines may allow them to emphasize particular modulation effects. We examined eight stereoisomers of a synthetic pentamine bearing three cyclopentane rings. In the reaction of a structurally unstable group I ribozyme, three stereoisomers exhibited distinct effects as inhibitor, an additive with a neutral effect, and also as an activator.

Analyzing and Tuning Ribozyme Activity by Deep Sequencing To Modulate Gene Expression Level in Mammalian Cells

Self-cleaving ribozymes, in combination with aptamers and various classes of RNAs, have been heavily engineered to create RNA devices to control gene expression. Although understanding of sequence-function relationships of ribozymes is critical for such efforts, our current knowledge of self-cleaving ribozymes is mostly limited to the results from small scale mutational studies performed under different conditions, or qualitative results of mutate-and-select experiments that may contain experimental biases. Here, we applied our strategy based on deep sequencing to comprehensively assay a large number of mutants to systematically examine the effect of the P4 stem sequence on the activity of an HDV-like ribozyme. We discovered that the ribozyme activity is highly sensitive to the sequence and the apparent stability of the varied positions. Furthermore, we demonstrated that the collection of the ribozyme variants with different activities can be used as a convenient device to fine-tune the level of gene expression in mammalian cells.

Highly motif- and organism-dependent effects of naturally occurring hammerhead ribozyme sequences on gene expression

Recent bioinformatics studies have demonstrated a wide-spread occurrence of the hammerhead ribozyme (HHR) and similar small endonucleolytic RNA motifs in all domains of life. It is becoming increasingly evident that such ribozyme motifs participate in important genetic processes in diverse organisms. Although the HHR motif has been studied for more than three decades, only little is known about the consequences of ribozyme activity on gene expression. In the present study we analysed eight different naturally occurring HHR sequences in diverse genetic and organismal contexts. We investigated the influence of active ribozymes incorporated into mRNAs in mammalian, yeast and bacterial expression systems. The experiments show an unexpectedly high degree of organism-specific variability of ribozyme-mediated effects on gene expression. The presented findings demonstrate that ribozyme cleavage profoundly affect gene expression. However, the extent of this effect varies and depends strongly on the respective genetic context. The fast-cleaving type 3 HHRs [CChMVd(-) and sLTSV(-)] generally tended to cause the strongest effects on intracellular gene expression. The presented results are important in order to address potential functions of naturally occurring ribozymes in RNA processing and post-transcriptional regulation of gene expression. Additionally, our results are of interest for biotechnology and synthetic biology approaches that aim at the utilisation of self-cleaving ribozymes as widely applicable tools for controlling genetic processes.

Deep Sequencing Analysis of Aptazyme Variants Based on a Pistol Ribozyme

Chemically regulated self-cleaving ribozymes, or aptazymes, are emerging as a promising class of genetic devices that allow dynamic control of gene expression in synthetic biology. However, further expansion of the limited repertoire of ribozymes and aptamers, and development of new strategies to couple the RNA elements to engineer functional aptazymes are highly desirable for synthetic biology applications. Here, we report aptazymes based on the recently identified self-cleaving pistol ribozyme class using a guanine aptamer as the molecular sensing element. Two aptazyme architectures were studied by constructing and assaying 17 728 mutants by deep sequencing. Although one of the architectures did not yield functional aptazymes, a novel aptazyme design in which the aptamer and the ribozyme were placed in tandem yielded a number of guanine-inhibited ribozymes. Detailed analysis of the extensive sequence-function data suggests a mechanism that involves a competition between two mutually exclusive RNA structures reminiscent of natural bacterial riboswitches.

Synthetic Riboswitches: From Plug and Pray toward Plug and Play

In synthetic biology, metabolic engineering, and gene therapy, there is a strong demand for orthogonal or externally controlled regulation of gene expression. Here, RNA-based regulatory devices represent a promising emerging alternative to proteins, allowing a fast and direct control of gene expression, as no synthesis of regulatory proteins is required. Besides programmable ribozyme elements controlling mRNA stability, regulatory RNA structures in untranslated regions are highly interesting for engineering approaches. Riboswitches are especially well suited, as they show a modular composition of sensor and response elements, allowing a free combination of different modules in a plug-and-play-like mode. The sensor or aptamer domain specifically interacts with a trigger molecule as a ligand, modulating the activity of the adjacent response domain that controls the expression of the genes located downstream, in most cases at the level of transcription or translation. In this review, we discuss the recent advances and strategies for designing such synthetic riboswitches based on natural or artificial components and readout systems, from trial-and-error approaches to rational design strategies. As the past several years have shown dramatic development in this fascinating field of research, we can give only a limited overview of the basic riboswitch design principles that is far from complete, and we apologize for not being able to consider every successful and interesting approach described in the literature.

Direct screening for ribozyme activity in mammalian cells

Using deep sequencing, 3001 natural and synthetic ribozymes were screened for self-cleaving activity directly in mammalian cells.