Bile duct warmer in hepatic cryosurgery--a pig liver model

Prevention of biliary lesions that may occur during radiofrequency ablation of the liver: study on the pig

OBJECTIVE

To prevent bile duct injury by using a cold 5% glucose isotonic solution cooling in the bile ducts when radiofrequency (RF) is performed in a porcine model.

SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA

Complications that may arise during liver RF ablation include biliary stenosis and abscesses.

METHODS

The RITA 1500 generator was used for the experiments. Two lesions were performed in the left liver. The pigs were killed 1 or 3 weeks after the procedure. An ex vivo cholangiogram was obtained by direct injection into the main bile duct. Samples of RF lesions, of liver parenchyma near and at a distance from the RF lesions, underwent pathologic studies. Two groups of 20 pigs each were treated: one without perfusion of the bile ducts and the other with perfusion of cold 5% glucose isotonic solution into the bile ducts. The Pringle maneuver was used in 50% of the RF procedures. Radiologic lesions were classified as biliary stenosis, complete interruption of the bile duct, or extravasation of the radiologic contrast liquid.

RESULTS

Histologic lesions of the bile ducts were observed near the ablated RF lesion site and at a distance from the RF lesions when a Pringle maneuver was performed. Radiologic and histologic lesions of the bile ducts were significantly reduced (P < 0.0001) when the bile ducts were cooled.

CONCLUSIONS

Cooling of the bile ducts with a cold 5% glucose isotonic solution significantly protects the intrahepatic bile ducts from damages caused by the heat generated by RF when performed close to the bile ducts.

Electrical isolation during radiofrequency ablation: 5% dextrose in water provides better protection than saline

We quantify the ability of 0.9% NaCl (saline) and 5% dextrose in water (D5W) to protect tissues during RF ablation. Using computer simulations and phantom experiments, we determined that D5W provides significantly more electrical isolation than saline, which reduces unwanted heating of the adjacent tissue. Saline actually increased the amount of RF current in the adjacent tissue. Based on these results, we conclude that D5W is preferable to saline as a protective fluid.

Outcome of regional and local ablative therapies for hepatocellular carcinoma: a collective review

BACKGROUND

Transcatheter arterial (chemo) embolization (TACE), cryoablation (CA) and percutaneous ethanol injection (PEI) were the first regional and local ablative techniques that came into use for irresectable HCC. Radiofrequency ablation (RFA) and interstitial laser coagulation (ILC) followed and have now evolved rapidly. It would not be ethical to compare resection with ablation in patients well enough to undergo major surgery. Therefore, hepatic resection and hepatic transplantation remain the only curative treatment options for HCC.

METHODS

On the basis of a Medline literature search and the authors' experiences, the principles, current status and prospects of TACE and local ablative techniques in HCC are reviewed.

RESULTS

Complete tumour necrosis can be achieved in 60-100% of patients treated with PEI (70-100%), cryoablation (60-85%), RFA (80-90%) or ILC (70-97%). After TACE significant tumour response is achieved in 17-61.9% but complete tumour response is rare (0-4.8%) as viable tumour cells remain after TACE. Five-year survival rates are available for TACE (1-8%), PEI (0-70%) and cryoablation (40%). Only PEI and RFA were compared in one RCT. RFA was associated with fewer treatment sessions and a higher complete necrosis rate. Furthermore, all techniques are associated with low morbidity and mortality, but cryoablation seems to be associated with a higher morbidity rate.

CONCLUSION

TACE has shown to be a valuable therapy with survival benefits in strictly selected patients with unresectable HCC. RFA and PEI are now considered as the local ablative techniques of choice for the treatment of, preferably small, HCC. When tumours are located close to bile ducts or large vessels, PEI remains a valuable therapy. Completeness of ablation can be more easily monitored during cryoablation and another advantage of cryoablation is the possibility of edge freezing. The results of ILC are comparable to RFA with only few side effects and high tumour response rates.

Cryotherapy for liver tumors: current status, perspectives, clinical results, and review of literature

Cryotherapy has gained importance as a locally ablative treatment option for patients with non-resectable liver tumors, especially metastases from colorectal cancer. We have used this technique since 1996 for the treatment of 77 patients with malignant liver tumors. Patient data was prospectively recorded and follow-up was until September 2002 or death. Fifty-five patients had colorectal cancer liver metastases, 16 metastases from other primaries and 6 had hepatoma. Forty patients had cryotherapy only and 37 had an additional liver resection. Morbidity and mortality were 22% and 1.3%, respectively. In 68% of patients with colorectal liver metastases and an elevated serum carcinoembryonic antigen-level preoperatively, it returned to the normal range following cryosurgery. For all 77 patients, median survival was 28 months with a 3- and 5-year-survival rate of 39% and 26%, respectively, and median survival was 29 months with a 3- and 5-year-survival rate of 44% and 26%, respectively, for the 55 patients with colorectal liver metastases. Local recurrence at the cryosite was observed in 13 of 65 patients (20%) with initially complete treatment. For cryotherapy to further establish as a treatment for malignant liver tumors in a time where many new local ablative techniques are developing, different goals need to be achieved. The trauma of the procedure and local treatment failure need to be minimized and survival results need to be optimized. Published studies and new possible fields of research regarding these goals are discussed.

Comparison of iceball diameter and temperature distribution achieved with 3-mm accuprobe cryoprobes in porcine and human liver tissue and human colorectal liver metastases in vitro

We aimed to assess the thermal profile and size of iceballs produced by Accuprobe cryoprobes in fresh porcine and human liver and human colorectal cancer liver metastases in vitro to allow better planning of cryosurgical treatment of liver metastases. Iceballs were produced by a 20-min single freeze cycle using 8-mm cryoprobes in pig liver in a waterbath at 37 degrees C (n = 8) and 3-mm cryoprobes in pig liver (n = 8), human liver (n = 3), and human colorectal cancer liver metastases (n = 8). The iceball diameters and the temperatures at different distances from the cryoprobe were measured. Mean iceball diameters produced by 8-mm cryoprobes in pig liver were 56.3 mm and varied from 38.7 to 39.6 mm for 3-mm cryoprobes in the different tissues used. There was no significant difference in iceball size in the different tissues. The diameter of the zone of -40 degrees C or less was approximately 44 mm using 8-mm cryoprobes in porcine liver and between 27 and 31 mm using 3-mm cryoprobes in the different tissues examined. The results may allow better preoperative planning of the cryosurgical treatment of liver metastases with Accuprobe cryoprobes.