Protein kinase inhibition in G2 causes mammalian Mcm proteins to reassociate with chromatin and restores ability to replicate

Quality control in the initiation of eukaryotic DNA replication

Origins of DNA replication must be regulated to ensure that the entire genome is replicated precisely once in each cell cycle. In human cells, this requires that tens of thousands of replication origins are activated exactly once per cell cycle. Failure to do so can lead to cell death or genome rearrangements such as those associated with cancer. Systems ensuring efficient initiation of replication, while also providing a robust block to re-initiation, play a crucial role in genome stability. In this review, I will discuss some of the strategies used by cells to ensure once per cell cycle replication and provide a quantitative framework to evaluate the relative importance and efficiency of individual pathways involved in this regulation.

G2 phase chromatin lacks determinants of replication timing

Chromatin spatial organization helps establish the replication timing decision point at early G1. However, at G2, although retained, chromatin organization is no longer necessary or sufficient to maintain the replication timing program.

DNA replication in all eukaryotes follows a defined replication timing program, the molecular mechanism of which remains elusive. Using a Xenopus laevis egg extract replication system, we previously demonstrated that replication timing is established during early G1 phase of the cell cycle (timing decision point [TDP]), which is coincident with the repositioning and anchorage of chromatin in the newly formed nucleus. In this study, we use this same system to show that G2 phase chromatin lacks determinants of replication timing but maintains the overall spatial organization of chromatin domains, and we confirm this finding by genome-wide analysis of rereplication in vivo. In contrast, chromatin from quiescent cells retains replication timing but exhibits disrupted spatial organization. These data support a model in which events at the TDP, facilitated by chromatin spatial organization, establish determinants of replication timing that persist independent of spatial organization until the process of chromatin replication during S phase erases those determinants.

Cell cycle regulation of DNA replication

Eukaryotic DNA replication is regulated to ensure all chromosomes replicate once and only once per cell cycle. Replication begins at many origins scattered along each chromosome. Except for budding yeast, origins are not defined DNA sequences and probably are inherited by epigenetic mechanisms. Initiation at origins occurs throughout the S phase according to a temporal program that is important in regulating gene expression during development. Most replication proteins are conserved in evolution in eukaryotes and archaea, but not in bacteria. However, the mechanism of initiation is conserved and consists of origin recognition, assembly of prereplication (pre-RC) initiative complexes, helicase activation, and replisome loading. Cell cycle regulation by protein phosphorylation ensures that pre-RC assembly can only occur in G1 phase, whereas helicase activation and loading can only occur in S phase. Checkpoint regulation maintains high fidelity by stabilizing replication forks and preventing cell cycle progression during replication stress or damage.

An essential role for Cdk1 in S phase control is revealed via chemical genetics in vertebrate cells

In vertebrates Cdk1 is required to initiate mitosis; however, any functionality of this kinase during S phase remains unclear. To investigate this, we generated chicken DT40 mutants, in which an analog-sensitive mutant cdk1 as replaces the endogenous Cdk1, allowing us to specifically inactivate Cdk1 using bulky ATP analogs. In cells that also lack Cdk2, we find that Cdk1 activity is essential for DNA replication initiation and centrosome duplication. The presence of a single Cdk2 allele renders S phase progression independent of Cdk1, which suggests a complete overlap of these kinases in S phase control. Moreover, we find that Cdk1 inhibition did not induce re-licensing of replication origins in G2 phase. Conversely, inhibition during mitosis of Cdk1 causes rapid activation of endoreplication, depending on proteolysis of the licensing inhibitor Geminin. This study demonstrates essential functions of Cdk1 in the control of S phase, and exemplifies a chemical genetics approach to target cyclin-dependent kinases in vertebrate cells.

Strength in numbers: preventing rereplication via multiple mechanisms in eukaryotic cells

In eukaryotic cells, prereplication complexes (pre-RCs) are assembled on chromatin in the G1 phase, rendering origins of DNA replication competent to initiate DNA synthesis. When DNA replication commences in S phase, pre-RCs are disassembled, and multiple initiations from the same origin do not occur because new rounds of pre-RC assembly are inhibited. In most experimental organisms, multiple mechanisms that prevent pre-RC assembly have now been identified, and rereplication within the same cell cycle can be induced through defined perturbations of these mechanisms. This review summarizes the diverse array of inhibitory pathways used by different organisms to prevent pre-RC assembly, and focuses on the challenge of understanding how in any one cell type, various mechanisms cooperate to strictly enforce once per cell cycle regulation of DNA replication.

The Croonian Lecture 2001 hunting the antisocial cancer cell: MCM proteins and their exploitation

Replicating large eukaryotic genomes presents the challenge of distinguishing replicated regions of DNA from unreplicated DNA. A heterohexamer of minichromosome maintenance (MCM) proteins is essential for the initiation of DNA replication. MCM proteins are loaded on to unreplicated DNA before replication begins and displaced progressively during replication. Thus, bound MCM proteins license DNA for one, and only one, round of replication and this licence is reissued each time a cell divides. MCM proteins are also the best candidates for the replicative helicases that unwind DNA during replication, but interesting questions arise about how they can perform this role, particularly as they are present on only unreplicated DNA, rather than clustered at replication forks. Although MCM proteins are bound and released cyclically from DNA during the cell cycle, higher eukaryotic cells retain them in the nucleus throughout the cell cycle. In contrast, MCMs are broken down when cells exit the cycle by quiescence or differentiation. We have exploited these observations to develop screening tests for the common carcinomas, starting with an attempt to improve the sensitivity of the smear test for cervical cancer. MCM proteins emerge as exceptionally promising markers for cancer screening and early diagnosis.

Eukaryotic DNA Replication in a Chromatin Context

There has been remarkable progress in the last 20 years in defining the molecular mechanisms that regulate initiation of DNA synthesis in eukaryotic cells. Replication origins in the DNA nucleate the ordered assembly of protein factors to form a prereplication complex (preRC) that is poised for DNA synthesis. Transition of the preRC to an active initiation complex is regulated by cyclin-dependent kinases and other signaling molecules, which promote further protein assembly and activate the mini chromosome maintenance helicase. We will review these mechanisms and describe the state of knowledge about the proteins involved. However, we will also consider an additional layer of complexity. The DNA in the cell is packaged with histone proteins into chromatin. Chromatin structure provides an additional layer of heritable information with associated epigenetic modifications. Thus, we will begin by describing chromatin structure, and how the cell generally controls access to the DNA. Access to the DNA requires active chromatin remodeling, specific histone modifications, and regulated histone deposition. Studies in transcription have revealed a variety of mechanisms that regulate DNA access, and some of these are likely to be shared with DNA replication. We will briefly describe heterochromatin as a model for an epigenetically inherited chromatin state. Next, we will describe the mechanisms of replication initiation and how these are affected by constraints of chromatin. Finally, chromatin must be reassembled with appropriate modifications following passage of the replication fork, and our third major topic will be the reassembly of chromatin and its associated epigenetic marks. Thus, in this chapter, we seek to bring together the studies of replication initiation and the studies of chromatin into a single holistic narrative.

CDKs promote DNA replication origin licensing in human cells by protecting Cdc6 from APC/C-dependent proteolysis

Cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs) restrict DNA replication origin firing to once per cell cycle by preventing the assembly of prereplicative complexes (pre-RCs; licensing) outside of G1 phase. Paradoxically, under certain circumstances, CDKs such as cyclin E-cdk2 are also required to promote licensing. Here, we show that CDK phosphorylation of the essential licensing factor Cdc6 stabilizes it by preventing its association with the anaphase promoting complex/cyclosome (APC/C). APC/C-dependent Cdc6 proteolysis prevents pre-RC assembly in quiescent cells and, when cells reenter the cell cycle from quiescence, CDK-dependent Cdc6 stabilization allows Cdc6 to accumulate before the licensing inhibitors geminin and cyclin A which are also APC/C substrates. This novel mechanism for regulating protein stability establishes a window of time prior to S phase when pre-RCs can assemble which we propose represents a critical function of cyclin E.

Regulation of early events in chromosome replication

Eukaryotic genomes are replicated from large numbers of replication origins distributed on multiple chromosomes. The activity of these origins must be coordinated so that the entire genome is efficiently and accurately replicated yet no region of the genome is ever replicated more than once. The past decade has seen significant advances in understanding how the initiation of DNA replication is regulated by key cell-cycle regulators, including the cyclin dependent kinases (CDKs) and the anaphase promoting complex/cyclosome (APC/C). The assembly of essential prereplicative complexes (pre-RCs) at origins only occurs when CDK activity is low and APC/C activity is high. Origin firing, however, can only occur when the APC/C is inactivated and CDKs become active. This two step mechanism ensures that no origin can fire more than once in a cell cycle. In all eukaryotes tested, CDKs can contribute to the inhibition of pre-RC assembly. This inhibition is characterised both by high degrees of redundancy and evolutionary plasticity. Geminin plays a crucial role in inhibiting licensing in metazoans and, like cyclins, is inactivated by the APC/C. Strategies involved in preventing re-replication in different organisms will be discussed.

Deregulated G1-cyclin expression induces genomic instability by preventing efficient pre-RC formation

Although genomic instability is a hallmark of human cancer cells, the mechanisms by which genomic instability is generated and selected for during oncogenesis remain obscure. In most human cancers, the pathway leading to the activation of the G1 cyclins is deregulated. Using budding yeast as a model, we show that overexpression of the G1 cyclin Cln2 inhibits the assembly of prereplicative complexes (pre-RCs) and induces gross chromosome rearrangements (GCR). Our results suggest that deregulation of G1 cyclins, selected for in oncogenesis because it confers clonal growth advantage, may also provide an important mechanism for generating genomic instability by inhibiting replication licensing.

Phosphorylation of Mcm4 at specific sites by cyclin-dependent kinase leads to loss of Mcm4,6,7 helicase activity

Mcm proteins that play an essential role in eukaryotic DNA replication are phosphorylated in vivo, and cyclin-dependent protein kinase is at least in part responsible for the phosphorylation of Mcm4. Our group reported that the DNA helicase activity of Mcm4,6,7 complex, which may be involved in initiation of DNA replication, is inhibited following phosphorylation by Cdk2/cyclin A in vitro. Here, we further examined the interplay between mouse Mcm4,6,7 complex and cyclin-dependent kinases and determined the sites required for the phosphorylation of Mcm4. Six Ser and Thr residues, in all, were required for the phosphorylation. Inhibition of Mcm4,6,7 helicase activity by Cdk2/cyclin A was largely relieved by introducing mutations in these residues of Mcm4. Anti-phosphothreonine antibodies raised against one of these sites reacted with Mcm4 prepared from HeLa cells at mitotic phase but did not bind to those at G(1) and G(1)/S, suggesting that this site is mainly phosphorylated in the mitotic phase. Mcm4,6,7 complex purified from HeLa cells at the mitotic phase exhibited a low level of DNA helicase activity, compared with the complexes prepared from cells at other phases. These results suggest that phosphorylation of Mcm4 at specific sites leads to loss of Mcm4,6,7 DNA helicase activity.

MCM3AP, a novel acetyltransferase that acetylates replication protein MCM3

The MCM proteins are essential for the initiation of DNA replication. We have isolated an MCM3-associated protein (MCM3AP) in a two-hybrid screen using MCM3. Here we demonstrate that MCM3AP is an acetyltransferase which acetylates MCM3 and that chromatin-bound MCM3 is acetylated in vivo. The MCM3 acetylase, MCM3AP, is also chromatin-bound. This study also indicates that MCM3AP contains putative acetyl CoA binding motifs conserved within the GCN5-related N-acetyltransferase superfamily. Mutation of those motifs significantly inhibits the MCM3 acetylase activity. Over-expression of MCM3AP inhibits DNA replication, whereas mutation of the acetylase motifs abolishes this effect, suggesting that acetylation plays a role in DNA replication. Taken together, we suggest that MCM3 acetylation is a novel pathway which might regulate DNA replication.

Chromatin association of human origin recognition complex, cdc6, and minichromosome maintenance proteins during the cell cycle: assembly of prereplication complexes in late mitosis

Evidence obtained from studies with yeast and Xenopus indicate that the initiation of DNA replication is a multistep process. The origin recognition complex (ORC), Cdc6p, and minichromosome maintenance (MCM) proteins are required for establishing prereplication complexes, upon which initiation is triggered by the activation of cyclin-dependent kinases and the Dbf4p-dependent kinase Cdc7p. The identification of human homologues of these replication proteins allows investigation of S-phase regulation in mammalian cells. Using centrifugal elutriation of several human cell lines, we demonstrate that whereas human Orc2 (hOrc2p) and hMcm proteins are present throughout the cell cycle, hCdc6p levels vary, being very low in early G(1) and accumulating until cells enter mitosis. hCdc6p can be polyubiquitinated in vivo, and it is stabilized by proteasome inhibitors. Similar to the case for hOrc2p, a significant fraction of hCdc6p is present on chromatin throughout the cell cycle, whereas hMcm proteins alternate between soluble and chromatin-bound forms. Loading of hMcm proteins onto chromatin occurs in late mitosis concomitant with the destruction of cyclin B, indicating that the mitotic kinase activity inhibits prereplication complex formation in human cells.

Induction of DNA replication in the germinal vesicle of the growing mouse oocyte

Growing mouse oocytes are physiologically arrested in the G2 phase of prophase of the first meiotic division. Growing oocytes were isolated from ovaries of 9- to 12-day-old mice and fused with parthenogenetic one-cell eggs or two-cell embryos derived from fertilized eggs. Resulting hybrids were injected with Dig-11-dUTP and examined for DNA replication using immunofluorescence. Parthenogenetic one-cell eggs fused at telophase II, G1, and middle-to-late S phase, and also S-phase two-cell blastomeres, were able to trigger DNA synthesis in oocyte germinal vesicle (GV) in the majority of hybrids cultured to the end of the first cell cycle. Activation of replication in the GV occurred within 2-3 h after fusion of growing oocytes with S-phase eggs. We show indirectly that the reactivation of replication in GVs was not dependent on the breakdown of the GV envelope. Although GVs had the ability to renew DNA replication after fusion, the G2 blastomere nuclei were incapable of reinitiating DNA replication under the influence of S-phase one-cell eggs. We hypothesize that the nuclei of growing oocytes arrested in meiotic prophase are in a physiological state that is equivalent to replication-competent G1, and not G2, nuclei.

Chromatin-bound Cdc6 persists in S and G2 phases in human cells, while soluble Cdc6 is destroyed in a cyclin A-cdk2 dependent process

Cdc6 is essential for the initiation of DNA replication in all organisms in which it has been studied. In addition, recombinant Cdc6 can stimulate initiation in G(1) nuclei in vitro. We have analysed the behaviour of recombinant Cdc6 in mammalian cell extracts under in vitro replication conditions. We find that Cdc6 is imported into the nucleus in G(1)phase, where it binds to chromatin and remains relatively stable. In S phase, exogenous Cdc6 is destroyed in a process that requires import into the nucleus and phosphorylation by a chromatin-bound protein kinase. Recombinant cyclin A-cdk2 can completely substitute for the nucleus in promoting destruction of soluble Xenopus and human Cdc6. Despite this regulated destruction, endogenous Cdc6 persists in the nucleus after initiation, although the amount falls. Cdc6 levels remain constant in G(2) then fall again before mitosis. We propose that cyclin A-cdk2 phosphorylation results in destruction of any Cdc6 not assembled into replication complexes, but that assembled proteins remain, in the phosphorylated state, in the nucleus. This process could contribute to the prevention of reinitiation in human cells by making free Cdc6 unavailable for re-assembly into replication complexes after G(1) phase.

The replication capacity of intact mammalian nuclei in Xenopus egg extracts declines with quiescence, but the residual DNA synthesis is independent of Xenopus MCM proteins

In eukaryotes, the initiation of DNA synthesis requires the assembly of a pre-replicative complex (pre-RC) at origins of replication. This involves the sequential binding of ORC (origin-recognition-complex), Cdc6 and MCM proteins, a process referred to as licensing. After origin firing, the Cdc6 and MCM proteins dissociate from the chromatin, and do not rebind until after the completion of mitosis, thereby restricting replication to a single round in each cell cycle. Although nuclei normally become licensed for replication as they enter G(1), the extent to which the license is retained when cells enter the quiescent state (G(0)) is controversial. Here we show that the replication capacity of nuclei from Swiss 3T3 cells, in Xenopus egg extracts, is not lost abruptly with the onset of quiescence, but instead declines gradually. The decline in replication capacity, which affects both the number of nuclei induced to replicate and their subsequent rate of DNA synthesis, is accompanied by a fall in the level of chromatin-bound MCM2. When quiescent nuclei are incubated in egg extracts, they do not bind further MCMs unless the nuclei are first permeabilized. The residual replication capacity of intact nuclei must therefore be dependent on the remaining endogenous MCMs. Although high levels of Cdk activity are known to block MCM binding, we show that the failure of intact nuclei in egg extracts to increase their bound MCMs is not due to their uptake and accumulation of Cdk complexes. Instead, the failure of binding must be due to exclusion of some other binding factor from the nucleus, or to the presence within nuclei of an inhibitor of binding other than Cdk activity. In contrast to the situation in Xenopus egg extracts, following serum stimulation of intact quiescent cells, the level of bound MCMs does increase before the cells reach S phase, without any disruption of the nuclear envelope.

Interaction of Xenopus Cdc2 x cyclin A1 with the origin recognition complex

The initiation of DNA replication in eukaryotes is regulated in a minimum of at least two ways. First, several proteins, including origin recognition complex (ORC), Cdc6 protein, and the minichromosome maintenance (MCM) protein complex, need to be assembled on chromatin before initiation. Second, cyclin-dependent kinases regulate DNA replication in both a positive and a negative way by inducing the initiation of DNA replication at G(1)/S transition and preventing further rounds of origin firing within the same cell cycle. Here we characterize a link between the two levels. Immunoprecipitation of Xenopus origin recognition complex with anti-XOrc1 or anti-XOrc2 antibodies specifically co-immunoprecipitates a histone H1 kinase activity. The kinase activity is sensitive to several inhibitors of cyclin-dependent kinases including 6-dimethylaminopurine (6-DMAP), olomoucine, and p21(Cip1). This kinase activity also copurifies with ORC over several fractionation steps and was identified as a complex of the Cdc2 catalytic subunit and cyclin A1. Neither Cdk2 nor cyclin E could be detected in ORC immunoprecipitations. Reciprocal immunoprecipitations with anti-Xenopus Cdc2 or anti-Xenopus cyclin A1 antibodies specifically co-precipitate XOrc1 and XOrc2. Our results indicate that Xenopus ORC and Cdc2 x cyclin A1 physically interact and demonstrate a physical link between an active cyclin-dependent kinase and proteins involved in the initiation of DNA replication.

Initiation of DNA replication in eukaryotes: questioning the origin

Although proteins involved in DNA replication in yeast have counterparts in multicellular organisms, the definition of an origin of DNA replication and its control in higher eukaryotes might obey to different rules. Origins of DNA replication that are site-specific have been found, supporting the notion that specific DNA regions are used to initiate DNA synthesis along metazoan chromosomes. However, the notion that specific sequences will define origins is still being debated. The variety and complexity of transcriptional programs that have to be regulated in multicellular organisms may impose a plasticity that would not be compatible with a fixed origin simply defined at the sequence level. Such a plasticity would be essential to developmental programs where the control of DNA replication could be more integrated to the control of gene expression than in unicellular eukaryotes.

Cdc6 protein causes premature entry into S phase in a mammalian cell-free system

We exploit an improved mammalian cell-free DNA replication system to analyse quiescence and Cdc6 function. Quiescent 3T3 nuclei cannot initiate replication in S phase cytosol from HeLa or 3T3 cells. Following release from quiescence, nuclei become competent to initiate semiconservative DNA replication in S phase cytosol, but not in G0 phase cytosol. Immunoblots show that quiescent cells lack Cdc6 and that minichromosome maintenance (MCM) proteins are not associated with chromatin. Competence of G1 phase nuclei to replicate in vitro coincides with maximum Cdc6 accumulation and MCM protein binding to chromatin in vivo. Addition of recombinant Cdc6 to permeabilized, but not intact, G1 nuclei causes up to 82% of the nuclei to initiate and accelerates G1 progression, making nuclei competent to replicate prematurely.

Evidence for different MCM subcomplexes with differential binding to chromatin in Xenopus

MCM proteins are molecular components of the DNA replication licensing system in Xenopus. These proteins comprise a conserved family made up of six distinct members which have been found to associate in large protein complexes. We have used a combination of biochemical and cytological methods to study the association of soluble and chromatin-bound Xenopus MCM proteins during the cell cycle. In interphase, soluble MCM proteins are found organized in a core salt-resistant subcomplex that includes MCM subunits which are known to have high affinity for histones. The interphasic complex is modified at mitosis and the subunit composition of the resulting mitotic subcomplexes is distinct, indicating that the stability of the MCM complex is under cell cycle control. Moreover, we provide evidence that the binding of MCM proteins to chromatin may occur in sequential steps involving the loading of distinct MCM subunits. Comparative analysis of the chromatin distribution of MCM2, 3, and 4 shows that the binding of MCM4 is distinct from that of MCM2 and 3. Altogether, these data suggest that licensing of chromatin by MCMs occurs in an ordered fashion involving discrete subcomplexes.

Cdk2 activity is dispensable for the onset of DNA replication during the first mitotic cycles of the sea urchin early embryo

Earlier work reported the important role of Cdk2 as a regulator of DNA replication in somatic cells and in Xenopus extracts. In the present report we analyze in vivo the involvement of Cdk2 in DNA replication during early embryogenesis using the first mitotic cycles of sea urchin embryos. Unfertilized Sphaerechinus granularis eggs are arrested after the second meiotic cytokinesis. Fertilization resumes the block and induces DNA replication after a short lag period, making sea urchin early embryo a good model for studying in vivo the onset of DNA replication. We show that Cdk2 as well as its potential partner cyclin A are present in the nucleus in G1 and S phase and therefore available for DNA replication. In accordance with data obtained in Xenopus egg extracts we observed that Cdk2 kinase activity is low and stable during the entire cycle. However, in contrast with this in vitro system in which Cdk2 activity is required for the onset of DNA replication, the specific inhibition of Cdk2 kinase by microinjection of the catalytically inactive Cdk2-K33R or the inhibitor p21(Cip1) does not prevent DNA replication. Because olomoucine, DMAP, and emetine treatments did not preclude DNA synthesis, neither cyclin A/Cdk1 nor cyclin B/Cdk1 kinase activities are necessary to replace the absence of Cdk2 kinase in promoting DNA replication. These data suggest that during early embryogenesis Cdks activities, in particular Cdk2, are dispensable in vivo for the initiation step of DNA replication. However, the specific localization of Cdk2 in the nucleus from the beginning of M phase to the end of S phase suggests its involvement in other mechanisms regulating DNA replication such as inhibition of DNA re-replication and/or that its regulating role is achieved through a pathway independent of the kinase activity. We further demonstrate that even after inhibition of Cdk activities, the permeabilization of the nuclear membrane is required to allow a second round of DNA replication. However, in contrast to Xenopus egg extracts, re-replication can take place in the absence of DMAP-sensitive kinase.

Mobilization of chromatin-bound Mcm proteins by micrococcal nuclease

Mcm (minichromosome maintenance) proteins are important components of the eukaryotic replication initiation apparatus. We investigate the binding of human Mcm proteins to HeLa cell chromatin using micrococcal nuclease as a tool. In previous work we prepared chromatin under low ionic strength conditions. The use of a low salt buffer was necessary to prevent the dissociation of Mcm proteins. Here we use chromatin prepared at more physiological salt concentrations (100 mM NaCl) following the procedure of Fujita et al. (J. Biol. Chem. 272, 10928-10935; 1997) who had shown that ATP stabilizes the interaction of Mcm proteins with chromatin. We show here that micrococcal nuclease released Mcm proteins early during the digestion process suggesting that Mcm proteins reside on chromatin sites which are more open to nuclease attack than bulk chromatin. Released Mcm proteins sedimented through glycerol gradients as a multiprotein complex comprising several of the six known human Mcm proteins.