Isolation and physical characterization of random insertions in Staphylococcal nuclease

The tolerance of a modular protein to duplication and deletion of internal repeats

Ankyrin repeat polypeptides contain repeated structural elements that pack to produce modular architectures lacking in close contacts between distant segments of the polypeptide chain. Despite this lack of sequence-distant contacts, ankyrin repeat polypeptides have been shown to fold in a cooperative manner. To determine the distance over which cooperative interactions can be propagated in a repeat protein, and to investigate the tolerance to internal duplication and deletion of modules, we have constructed a series of ankyrin repeat variants of the Notch ankyrin domain in which repeat number is varied by duplication and deletion of internal repeats. A construct with two copies of the fifth ankyrin repeat shows a modest increase in stability compared to the parent construct and retains apparent two-state unfolding behavior. Although constructs containing three and four copies of the fifth repeat retain this increased resistance to urea, they exhibit broad, multi-state unfolding transitions compared to the parent construct. For the Notch ankyrin domain, these larger constructs may represent a limit beyond which full cooperativity cannot be maintained. Deletions of internal repeats from the Notch ankyrin domain significantly destabilize the domain. This severe destabilization, which is larger than that resulting from end-repeat deletion, may arise from unfavorable interactions within the new non-native interfaces produced by internal repeat deletion. These results demonstrate both an asymmetry between the duplication and deletion of internal repeats, and a difference between deletion of internal and end-repeats, suggesting preferred mechanisms for evolution of repeat proteins.

Creation of an Allosteric Enzyme by Domain Insertion

Two allosteric enzymes have been created by the covalent linkage of non-interacting, monomeric proteins with the prerequisite effector-binding and catalytic functionalities, respectively. This was achieved through a combinatorial process called random domain insertion. The fragment of the TEM-1 beta-lactamase gene coding for the mature protein lacking its signal sequence was randomly inserted into the Escherichia coli maltose-binding protein (MBP) gene to create a domain insertion library. This library's diversity derived both from the site of insertion and from a distribution of tandem duplications or deletions of a portion of the MBP gene at the insertion site. From a library of approximately 2 x 10(4) in-frame fusions, approximately 800 library members conferred a phenotype to E.coli cells that was consistent with the presence of bifunctional fusions that could hydrolyze ampicillin and transport maltose in E.coli. Partial screening of this bifunctional sublibrary resulted in the identification of two enzymes in which the presence of maltose modulated the rate of nitrocefin hydrolysis. For one of these enzymes, the presence of maltose increased k(cat) by 70% and k(cat)/K(m) by 80% and resulted in kinetic parameters that were almost identical to TEM-1 beta-lactamase. Such an increase in activity was only observed with maltooligosaccharides whose binding to MBP is known to induce a conformational change. Modulation of the rate of nitrocefin hydrolysis could be detected at maltose concentrations less than 1 microM. Intrinsic protein fluorescence studies were consistent with a conformational change being responsible for the modulation of activity.

Crystal structures of a T4-lysozyme duplication-extension mutant demonstrate that the highly conserved beta-sheet region has low intrinsic folding propensity

Residues 24 to 35 of T4 lysozyme correspond to the second and third strands of a region of beta-sheet that is highly conserved in all known lysozyme and chitinase structures. To evaluate the intrinsic propensity of these amino acid residues to form a defined structure they were added at the C terminus of the native protein, together with a dipeptide linker. Two crystal structures of this active, mutant protein were obtained, to 1.9A and 2.3A resolution, respectively. Even though the crystal conditions are similar, the appended sequence adopts very different secondary structures. In one case it is weakly structured and appears to extend through the active-site cleft, perhaps in part adding an extra strand to the original beta-sheet. In the other crystal form the extension is largely alpha-helical. The formation of these alternative structures shows that the sequence does not have a strong intrinsic propensity to form a unique fold (either beta-sheet or otherwise). The results also suggest that structural conservation during evolution does not necessarily depend on sequence conservation or the conservation of folding propensity.

The duplication of an eight-residue helical stretch in Staphylococcal nuclease is not helical: a model for evolutionary change

A common method of evolutionary change is gene duplication, followed by other events that lead to new function, decoration of folds, oligomerization, or other changes. As part of a study on the potential for evolutionary change created by duplicated sequences, we have carried out a crystallographic study on a mutant of Staphylococcal nuclease in which residues 55-62 have been duplicated in a wild-type variant termed PHS. In the parental protein (PHS) these residues form the first two turns of a helix running from residue 54 to 68 (hereafter designated as helix I). The crystal structure of the mutant is very similar to that of the parental, with helix I being unaltered. The duplicated residues are accommodated by expanding an existing loop N-terminal to helix I. In addition, circular dichroism (CD) studies have been carried out on a parental peptide containing helix I with six flanking residues at each terminus (residues 48-74) and on the same peptide expanded by the duplication, as a function of 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol (TFE) concentration. Each peptide possesses only modest helical propensity in solution. Our data, which is different from what was observed in T4 lysozyme, show that the conformation of the duplicated sequence is determined by a balance of sequential and longer-range effects. Thus duplicating sequence need not mean duplicating structure. Proteins 2000;40:465-472.

Structural characterization of an engineered tandem repeat contrasts the importance of context and sequence in protein folding

To test a different approach to understanding the relationship between the sequence of part of a protein and its conformation in the overall folded structure, the amino acid sequence corresponding to an alpha-helix of T4 lysozyme was duplicated in tandem. The presence of such a sequence repeat provides the protein with "choices" during folding. The mutant protein folds with almost wild-type stability, is active, and crystallizes in two different space groups, one isomorphous with wild type and the other with two molecules in the asymmetric unit. The fold of the mutant is essentially the same in all cases, showing that the inserted segment has a well-defined structure. More than half of the inserted residues are themselves helical and extend the helix present in the wild-type protein. Participation of additional duplicated residues in this helix would have required major disruption of the parent structure. The results clearly show that the residues within the duplicated sequence tend to maintain a helical conformation even though the packing interactions with the remainder of the protein are different from those of the original helix. It supports the hypothesis that the structures of individual alpha-helices are determined predominantly by the nature of the amino acids within the helix, rather than the structural environment provided by the rest of the protein.