Quantitative analysis of multiple-hit footprinting studies to characterize DNA conformational changes in protein-DNA complexes: application to DNA opening by Esigma70 RNA polymerase

Mechanism of bacterial transcription initiation: RNA polymerase - promoter binding, isomerization to initiation-competent open complexes, and initiation of RNA synthesis

Initiation of RNA synthesis from DNA templates by RNA polymerase (RNAP) is a multi-step process, in which initial recognition of promoter DNA by RNAP triggers a series of conformational changes in both RNAP and promoter DNA. The bacterial RNAP functions as a molecular isomerization machine, using binding free energy to remodel the initial recognition complex, placing downstream duplex DNA in the active site cleft and then separating the nontemplate and template strands in the region surrounding the start site of RNA synthesis. In this initial unstable "open" complex the template strand appears correctly positioned in the active site. Subsequently, the nontemplate strand is repositioned and a clamp is assembled on duplex DNA downstream of the open region to form the highly stable open complex, RP(o). The transcription initiation factor, σ(70), plays critical roles in promoter recognition and RP(o) formation as well as in early steps of RNA synthesis.

Time-resolved footprinting for the study of the structural dynamics of DNA–protein interactions

Transcription is often regulated at the level of initiation by the presence of transcription factors or nucleoid proteins or by changing concentrations of metabolites. These can influence the kinetic properties and/or structures of the intermediate RNA polymerase–DNA complexes in the pathway. Time-resolved footprinting techniques combine the high temporal resolution of a stopped-flow apparatus with the specific structural information obtained by the probing agent. Combined with a careful quantitative analysis of the evolution of the signals, this approach allows for the identification and kinetic and structural characterization of the intermediates in the pathway of DNA sequence recognition by a protein, such as a transcription factor or RNA polymerase. The combination of different probing agents is especially powerful in revealing different aspects of the conformational changes taking place at the protein–DNA interface. For example, hydroxyl radical footprinting, owing to their small size, provides a map of the solvent-accessible surface of the DNA backbone at a single nucleotide resolution; modification of the bases using potassium permanganate can reveal the accessibility of the bases when the double helix is distorted or melted; cross-linking experiments report on the formation of specific amino acid–DNA contacts, and DNase I footprinting results in a strong signal-to-noise ratio from DNA protection at the binding site and hypersensitivity at curved or kinked DNA sites. Recent developments in protein footprinting allow for the direct characterization of conformational changes of the proteins in the complex.

Modus operandi of the bacterial RNA polymerase containing the sigma54 promoter-specificity factor

Bacterial sigma (sigma) factors confer gene specificity upon the RNA polymerase, the central enzyme that catalyses gene transcription. The binding of the alternative sigma factor sigma(54) confers upon the RNA polymerase special functional and regulatory properties, making it suited for control of several major adaptive responses. Here, we summarize our current understanding of the interactions the sigma(54) factor makes with the bacterial transcription machinery.

DNA bending in transcription initiation

Electrophoretic mobility shift (bandshift) phasing analysis and rotational variant topological analysis were performed on initiation complexes formed on the bacteriophage lambda PR promoter. Both the open complex and an abortive complex containing a short RNA primer extending to +3 were characterized. The two methods were used to analyze a series of constructs containing tandemly repeated copies of the PR promoter, with the repeat length increased in single base pair increments to progressively change the rotational setting of adjacent copies. The phasing effect observed in bandshift analysis of open complexes formed on this set of constructs provided qualitative evidence for the presence of a bend. Subsequent rotational variant topological analysis confirmed this and quantified the overall bend angle in the open complex as well as in the +3 abortive complex: a bend of 49 degrees +/- 7 degrees was measured for the open complex, while a bend of 47 degrees +/- 11 degrees was measured for the +3 complex, i.e., the two bends are the same. However, the topological results are not consistent with extensive superhelical wrapping of DNA on either complex as has been proposed. The two complexes do differ in the size of the transcription bubble: the open complex contains a 10.4 +/- 0.1 bp bubble, while that of the +3 complex is 12.2 +/- 0.1 bp, a result consistent with "DNA scrunching" during the onset of transcription. A model for the overall path of the DNA in the open complex is presented that is consistent with the measured bend angle. Measurement of both bubble size and overall bend angle complements the results of crystal structures in providing an enhanced description of the solution structures of the intact initiation complexes.

Late steps in the formation of E. coli RNA polymerase-lambda P R promoter open complexes: characterization of conformational changes by rapid [perturbant] upshift experiments

The formation of the transcriptionally competent open complex (RP(o)) by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase at the lambda P(R) promoter involves at least three steps and two kinetically significant intermediates (I(1) and I(2)). Understanding the sequence of conformational changes (rearrangements in the jaws of RNA polymerase, DNA opening) that occur in the conversion of I(1) to RP(o) requires: (1) dissecting the rate constant k(d) for the dissociation of RP(o) into contributions from individual steps and (2) isolating and characterizing I(2). To deconvolute k(d), we develop experiments involving rapid upshifts to elevated concentrations of RP(o)-destabilizing solutes ("perturbants": urea and KCl) to create a burst in the population of I(2). At high concentrations of either perturbant, k(d) approaches the same [perturbant]-independent value, interpreted as the elementary rate constant k(-2) for I(2)-->I(1). The large effects of [urea] and [salt] on K(3) (the equilibrium constant for I(2) is in equilibrium with RP(o)) indicate that a large-scale folding transition in polymerase occurs and a new interface with the DNA forms late in the mechanism. We deduce that I(2) at the lambda P(R) promoter is always unstable relative to RP(o), even at 0 degrees C, explaining previous difficulties in detecting it by using temperature downshifts. The division of the large positive enthalpy change between the late steps of the mechanism suggests that an additional unstable intermediate (I(3)) may exist between I(2) and RP(o).

Mg2+-modulated KMnO4 reactivity of thymines in the open transcription complex reflects variation in the negative electrostatic potential along the separated DNA strands. Footprinting of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase complex at the lambdaP(R) promoter revisited

There is still a controversy over the mechanism of promoter DNA strand separation upon open transcription complex (RPo) formation by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase: is it a single or a stepwise process controlled by Mg2+ ions and temperature? To resolve this question, the kinetics of pseudo-first-order oxidation of thymine residues by KMnO4 in the -11 ... +2 DNA region of RPo at the lambdaP(R) promoter was examined under single-hit conditions as a function of temperature (13-37 degrees C) in the absence or presence of 10 mm MgCl2. The reaction was also studied with respect to thymidine and its nucleotides (TMP, TTP and TpT) as a function of temperature and [MgCl2]. The kinetic parameters, (ox)k and (ox)E(a), and Mg-induced enhancement of (ox)k proved to be of the same order of magnitude for RPo-lambdaP(R) and the nucleotides. Unlike the complex, (ox)E(a) for the nucleotides was found to be Mg-independent. The isothermal increase in (ox)k with increasing [Mg2+] was thus interpreted in terms of a simple model of screening of the negative charges on phosphate groups by Mg2+ ions, lowering the electrostatic barrier to the diffusion of MnO4- anions to the reactive double bond of thymine. Similar screening isotherms were determined for the oxidation of two groups of thymines in RPo at a consensus-like Pa promoter, differing in the magnitude of the Mg effect. Together, the findings show that: (a) the two DNA strands in the -11...+2 region of RPo-lambdaP(R) are completely separated over the whole range of temperatures investigated (13-37 degrees C) in the absence of Mg2+ (b) Mg2+ ions induce an increase in the rate of the oxidation reaction by screening negatively charged phosphate and carboxylate groups; and (c) the observed thymine reactivity and the magnitude of the Mg effect reflect variation in the strength of the electrostatic potential along the separated DNA strands, in agreement with the current structural model of RPo.

GalR represses galP1 by inhibiting the rate-determining open complex formation through RNA polymerase contact: a GalR negative control mutant

GalR represses the galP1 promoter by a DNA looping-independent mechanism. Equilibrium binding of GalR and RNA polymerase to DNA, and real-time kinetics of base-pair distortion (isomerization) showed that the equilibrium dissociation constant of RNA polymerase-P1 closed complexes is largely unaffected in the presence of saturating GalR, indicating that mutual antagonism (steric hindrance) of the regulator and the RNA polymerase does not occur at this promoter. In fluorescence kinetics with 2-AP labeled P1 DNA, GalR inhibited the slower of the two-step base-pair distortion process. We isolated a negative control GalR mutant, S29R, which while bound to the operator DNA was incapable of repression of P1. Based on these results and previous demonstration that repression requires the C-terminal domain of the alpha subunit (alpha-CTD) of RNA polymerase, we propose that GalR establishes contact with alpha-CTD at the last resolved isomerization intermediate, forming a kinetic trap.

Inactivation and destruction by KMnO4 of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase open transcription complex: recommendations for footprinting experiments

Potassium permanganate oxidation of pyrimidine residues in single-stranded DNA is commonly used in footprinting studies on formation of open transcription complex (RPo) by RNA polymerases (RNAP) at cognate promoters. Our own experience and literature search led us to conclude that KMnO4 doses often used in such studies might cause multiple-hit oxidation of promoter DNA and oxidative damage to RNAP in RPo and lead to false interpretation of footprints. We have therefore studied as a function of KMnO4 dose (i) transcription activity of RPo formed by Escherichia coli RNAP at a model cognate promoter Pa and (ii) RPo's structural integrity, by gel electrophoresis and footprinting assays. Kinetics of formation of this complex and melting of DNA in the transcription bubble region were thoroughly characterized by us previously. Here we show that (i) RPo becomes completely inactivated at oxidant doses much lower than those needed to cause a detectable footprint of the melted DNA region, (ii) footprinting patterns of the melted promoter region remain practically unaffected by RNAP oxidation within a range of low oxidant doses causing single-hit oxidation of DNA, and (iii) at higher oxidant doses, corresponding to multiple-hit DNA oxidation, the gross structure of RPo changes progressively until its complete collapse and dissociation into constituent components, so that only approximate interpretation of the footprinting data for the melted DNA region is possible. A protocol for accurate RPo footprinting with low single-hit KMnO4 doses and interpretation of the footprinting data in terms of kinetics of oxidation of pyrimidine residues in promoter DNA is recommended.

Thermoirreversible and thermoreversible promoter opening by two Escherichia coli RNA polymerase holoenzymes

Promoter opening, in which the complementary DNA strands separate around the transcriptional start site, is generally thermoreversible. An exceptional case of thermoirreversible opening of the T4 late promoter has been analyzed by KMnO4 footprinting and transcription. T4 late promoters, which consist of an 8-base pair (bp) TATA box "-10" element, are recognized by the small, phage-encoded, highly diverged sigma-family initiation subunit gp55. The T4 late promoter only opens above 15-20 degrees C, but once it has been formed remains open and transcriptionally active for days at -0.5 degrees C. The low temperature-trapped open complex and its isothermally formed state are shown to be structurally distinctive. Two "extended -10" sigma 70 promoters, which, like the T4 late promoter, lack "-35" sites, have been subjected to a comparative analysis: the T4 middle promoter PrIIB2 opens and closes thermoreversibly under conditions of basal and MotA- and AsiA-activated transcription. The open galP1 promoter complex, whose transcription bubble is very AT-rich, also closes reversibly upon shift to -0.5 degrees C, but more slowly than does the rIIB2 promoter. Formation of a trapped-open low temperature state of the promoter complex appears to be a singular property of gp55-RNA polymerase holoenzyme.

The mechanism of transcriptional activation by the topologically DNA-linked sliding clamp of bacteriophage T4

Three viral proteins participate directly in transcription of bacteriophage T4 late genes: the sigma-family protein gp55 provides promoter recognition, gp33 is the co-activator, and gp45 is the activator of transcription; gp33 also represses transcription in the absence of gp45. Transcriptional activation by gp45, the toroidal sliding clamp of the T4 DNA polymerase holoenzyme, requires assembly at primer-template junctions by its clamp loader. The mechanism of transcriptional activation has been analyzed by examining rates of formation of open promoter complexes. The basal gp55-RNA polymerase holoenzyme is only weakly held in its initially formed closed promoter complex, which subsequently opens very slowly. Activation ( approximately 320-fold in this work) increases affinity in the closed complex and accelerates promoter opening. Promoter opening by gp55 is also thermo-irreversible: the T4 late promoter does not open at 0 degrees C, but once opened at 30 degrees C remains open upon shift to the lower temperature. At a hybrid promoter for sigma(70) and gp55-holoenzymes, only gp55 confers thermo-irreversibility of promoter opening. Interaction of gp45 with a C-terminal epitope of gp33 is essential for the co-activator function of gp33.

Kinetic studies and structural models of the association of E. coli sigma(70) RNA polymerase with the lambdaP(R) promoter: large scale conformational changes in forming the kinetically significant intermediates

The kinetics of interaction of Esigma(70) RNA polymerase (R) with the lambdaP(R) promoter (P) were investigated by filter binding over a broad range of temperatures (7.3-42 degrees C) and concentrations of RNA polymerase (1-123 nM) in large excess over promoter DNA. Under all conditions examined, the kinetics of formation of competitor-resistant complexes (I(2), RP(o)) are single-exponential with first order rate constant beta(CR). Interpretation of the polymerase concentration dependence of beta(CR) in terms of the three step mechanism of open complex formation yields the equilibrium constant K(1) for formation of the first kinetically significant intermediate (I(1)) and the forward rate constant (k(2)) for the conformational change converting I(1) to the second kinetically significant intermediate I(2): R + P-->(K(1))<--I(1)(k(2))-->I(2). Use of rapid quench mixing allows K(1) and k(2) to be individually determined over the entire temperature range investigated, previously not possible at this promoter using manual mixing. Given the large (>60 bp) interface formed in I(1), its relatively small binding constant K(1) at 37 degrees C at this [salt] (approximately 6 x 10(6) M(-1)) strongly argues that binding free energy is used to drive large-scale structural changes in polymerase and/or promoter DNA or other coupled processes. Evidence for coupling of protein folding is provided by the large and negative activation heat capacity of k(a)[DeltaC(o,++)(a)= -1.5(+/-0.2)kcal K(-1)], now shown to originate directly from formation of I(1) [DeltaC(o)(1)= -1.4(+/-0.3)kcal K(-1)] rather than from the formation of I(2) as previously proposed. The isomerization I(1)-->I(2) exhibits relatively slow kinetics and has a very large temperature-independent Arrhenius activation energy [E(act)(2)= 34(+/-2)kcal]. This kinetic signature suggests that formation of the transition state (I(1)-I(2)++ involves large conformational changes dominated by changes in the exposure of polar and/or charged surface to water. Structural and biochemical data lead to the following hypotheses to interpret these results. We propose that formation of I(1) involves coupled folding of unstructured regions of polymerase (beta, beta' and sigma(70)) and bending of promoter DNA (in the -10 region). We propose that interactions with region 2 of sigma(70) and possibly domain 1 of beta induce a kink at the -11/-12 base pairs of the lambdaP(R) promoter which places the downstream DNA (-5 to +20) in the jaws of the beta and beta' subunits of polymerase in I(1). These early interactions of beta and beta' with the DNA downstream of position -5 trigger jaw closing (with coupled folding) and subsequent steps of DNA opening.

In vivo topography of Rap1p-DNA complex at Saccharomyces cerevisiae TEF2 UAS(RPG) during transcriptional regulation

We have analyzed in detail the structure of RAP1-UAS(RPG) complexes in Saccharomyces cerevisiae cells using multi-hit KMnO(4), UV and micrococcal nuclease high-resolution footprinting. Three copies of the Rap1 protein are bound to the promoter simultaneously in exponentially growing cells, as shown by KMnO(4) multi-hit footprinting analysis, causing extended and diagnostic changes in the DNA structure of the region containing the UAS(RPG). Amino acid starvation does not cause loss of Rap1p from the complex; however, in vivo UV-footprinting reveals the occurrence of structural modifications of the complex. Moreover, low-resolution micrococcal nuclease digestion shows that the chromatin of the entire region is devoid of positioned nucleosomes but is susceptible to changes in accessibility to the nuclease upon amino acid starvation. The implications of these results for the mechanism of Rap1p action are discussed.

Interaction of RNA polymerase with forked DNA: evidence for two kinetically significant intermediates on the pathway to the final complex

RNA polymerase forms competitor-resistant complexes with "forked DNA" templates that are double-stranded from the -35 promoter region through the first base pair of the -10 region, with an additional unpaired A at the 3' end of the nontemplate strand. These types of substrates were introduced recently as model templates for the study of DNA-protein interactions occurring in the early stages of the formation of RNA polymerase-promoter open complexes. We have performed kinetic and equilibrium measurements of interactions of wild-type and mutant RNA polymerases bearing substitutions in the sigma(70) initiation factor, with forked DNA of wild-type and mutant sequence. Our observations reveal that formation of a competitor-resistant complex between RNA polymerase and forked DNA, similar to the formation of open complexes at promoters, is a multistep process, and some of the sequentially formed intermediates along the two pathways share common properties. This work establishes, for the forked template, progression through these intermediates in the absence of downstream DNA and validates the use of forked DNA to determine the effects of changes in promoter or RNA polymerase sequence on the process of open complex formation.

Chemical reagents for investigating the major groove of DNA

Chemical modification provides an inexpensive and rapid method for characterizing the structure of DNA and its association with drugs and proteins. Numerous conformation-specific probes are available, but most investigations rely on only the most common and readily available of these. The major groove of DNA is typically characterized by reaction with dimethyl sulfate, diethyl pyrocarbonate, potassium permanganate, osmium tetroxide, and, quite recently, bromide with monoperoxysulfate. This commentary discusses the specificity of these reagents and their applications in protection, interference, and missing contact experiments.

RNA polymerase III transcription complexes on chromosomal 5S rRNA genes in vivo: TFIIIB occupancy and promoter opening

Quantitative analysis of multiple-hit potassium permanganate (KMnO(4)) footprinting has been carried out in vivo on Saccharomyces cerevisiae 5S rRNA genes. The results fix the number of open complexes at steady state in exponentially growing cells at between 8 and 17% of the 150 to 200 chromosomal copies. UV and dimethyl sulfate footprinting set the transcription factor TFIIIB occupancy at 23 to 47%. The comparison between the two values suggests that RNA polymerase III binding or promoter opening is the rate-limiting step in 5S rRNA transcription in vivo. Inhibition of RNA elongation in vivo by cordycepin confirms this result. An experimental system that is capable of providing information on the mechanistic steps involved in regulatory events in S. cerevisiae cells has been established.

Differential melting of the transcription start site associated with changes in RNA polymerase-promoter contacts in initiating transcription complexes

Formaldehyde cross-linking was used in a kinetic analysis of RNA polymerase-lacUV5 promoter interactions in open complexes (RP(o)). RP(o) quenched from 37 degrees C to 14 degrees C isomerised to a closed, competitor resistant, complex (RP(LT)). We observed that contacts of the beta' and sigma subunits with the positions -3, -5 of the non-template DNA strand disappeared very quickly during the first 30 seconds after the temperature downshift. The re-annealing of the DNA downstream of the transcription start site takes place in the same time scale. However re-annealing of the upstream part of the transcription bubble was slower and completed within five minutes. The results support a two-step model of promoter melting and suggest that conformational changes in the RNA polymerase occur concurrently with the melting around the transcription start site.

Monomer/dimer ratios of replication protein modulate the DNA strand-opening in a replication origin

DNA opening is an essential step in the initiation of replication via the Cairns mode of replication. The opening reaction was investigated in a gamma ori system by using hyperactive variants of plasmid R6K-encoded initiator protein, pi. Reactivity to KMnO4 (indicative of opening) within gamma ori DNA occurred in both strands of a superhelical template upon the combined addition of wt pi, DnaA and integration host factor (IHF), each protein known to specifically bind gamma ori. IHF, examined singly, enhanced reactivity to KMnO4. The IHF-dependent reactive residues, however, are distinct from those dependent on pi (wt and hyperactive variants). Remarkably, the DNA helix opening does not require IHF and/or DnaA when hyperactive variants of pi were used instead of wt protein. We present three lines of evidence consistent with the hypothesis that DNA strand separation is facilitated by pi monomers despite the fact that both monomers and dimers of the protein can bind to iterons (pi binding sites). Taken together, our data suggest that pi elicits its ability to modulate plasmid copy number at the DNA helix-opening step.

Mutations at position -10 in the lambda PR promoter primarily affect conversion of the initial closed complex (RPc) to a stable, closed intermediate (RPi)

The effects of mutations of --10 T:A to A:T, C:G, or G:C in the lambda P(R) promoter on formation of transcriptionally competent open complexes were studied by DNAse I footprinting, KMnO(4)-sensitivity, and abortive initiation kinetic analysis. The mutations --10A (T:A --> A:T) and --10C significantly reduce k(f), the composite rate constant for conversion of closed complexes (RP(c)) to open complexes (RP(o)) but do not affect K(B), the equilibrium constant for formation of closed complexes. Unlike the other mutants or wild-type P(R), the mutation with the largest effect on open complex formation, --10G (T:A --> G:C), substantially decreases the occupancy of the promoter. When reduced occupancy is taken into account, the calculated effect of the mutation on k(f) is a 20-fold reduction. Analysis of open complex formation by a three-step pathway that includes an additional intermediate, RP(i), indicates that the primary effect of all three mutations is a reduction in the rate of isomerization of RP(c) to RP(i), which precedes DNA strand separation. Thus, RNA polymerase holoenzyme must recognize specific base pairs in the --10 region of P(R) while the DNA is still double-stranded. Comparison of the observed level of stable complexes (RP(i) plus RP(o)) with the level of productive complexes (RP(o)) indicates that the --10G mutation may also affect the equilibrium between RP(i) and RP(o) at 37 degrees. Open complexes formed at the three mutant promoters are approximately 3-5 times less stable at 37 degrees than those formed at wild-type P(R).

Topography of lacUV5 initiation complexes

Formation of a transcriptionally competent open complex is a highly regulated multistep process involving at least two intermediates. The rate of formation and stability of the intermediate complexes often determine promoter strength. However, the detailed mechanism of formation of the open complex and the high resolution structures of these intermediates are not known. In this study the structures of the open and intermediate complexes formed on the lacUV5 promoter by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase were analyzed using 'zero length' DNA-protein cross-linking. In both the open and the intermediate complexes the core subunits (ss' and ss) interact with lacUV5 DNA in a similar way, forming DNA-protein contacts flanking the initiation site. At the same time, the recognition (sigma(70)) subunit closely interacts with the promoter only in the open complex. In combination with our previous results, the data suggest that during promoter recognition contacts of the sigma subunit with core RNA polymerase and promoter DNA are rearranged in concert. These rearrangements constitute a landmark of transition from the intermediate to the open complex, identifying the sigma subunit as a key player directing formation of the open complex.

Changes in the 17 bp spacer in the P(R) promoter of bacteriophage lambda affect steps in open complex formation that precede DNA strand separation

Tau plots and temperature-shift experiments were used to determine which step in the formation of transcriptionally-competent open complexes is affected by changing the length of the 17 bp spacer separating the -10 and -35 consensus regions of the P(R) promoter of bacteriophage lambda. Abortive initiation assays at 37 degrees C indicate that the primary effect of insertion of a base-pair, thereby increasing spacer length to 18 bp, is a decrease in k(f), the rate constant for conversion from closed (RP(c)) to open (RP(o)) complexes, by approximately a factor of 4. The mutation did not significantly affect K(B), the equilibrium constant for formation of closed complexes, and decreased K(B)k(f) by a factor of 3. Deletion of a bp to create a 16 bp spacer had a much greater effect, decreasing the measured value of k(f) by a factor of about 25 to 30, and K(B)k(f) by a factor of 7 to 8. When the values of the parameters for the deletion mutant were corrected for incomplete occupancy of RP(o) at equilibrium, the effects of the deletion were even greater. In particular, the corrected value of K(B)k(f) was about 15 times lower than the corresponding value for two promoters with wild-type spacing. Based on temperature shift experiments, the changes in spacer length did not affect the equilibrium at 20 degrees C between RP(i), a stable intermediate in which DNA strands are not separated, and RP(o). Although differential sensitivity of single-stranded bases to KMnO(4) indicated that in about 20% of the open complexes at 20 degrees C the DNA strands are not fully separated (RP(o1)), the distribution between these complexes and RP(o2) (DNA strands fully separated) was also not affected significantly by changes in spacer length. Thus, changes in spacer length primarily affect k(2), the rate constant for conversion of RP(c) to RP(i), which corresponds to a nucleation of DNA strand-separation. Application of published data and/or algorithms for determining effects of nucleotide sequence on twist angle or rise at individual bp steps does not provide a simple explanation of the difference in promoter strength between P(R) derivatives with 16 bp spacing and those with 18 bp spacing.

General method of analysis of kinetic equations for multistep reversible mechanisms in the single-exponential regime: application to kinetics of open complex formation between Esigma70 RNA polymerase and lambdaP(R) promoter DNA

A novel analytical method based on the exact solution of equations of kinetics of unbranched first- and pseudofirst-order mechanisms is developed for application to the process of Esigma70 RNA polymerase (R)-lambdaPR promoter (P) open complex formation, which is described by the minimal three-step mechanism with two kinetically significant intermediates (I1, I2), [equation: see text], where the final product is an open complex RPo. The kinetics of reversible and irreversible association (pseudofirst order, [R] >> [P]) to form long-lived complexes (RPo and I2) and the kinetics of dissociation of long-lived complexes both exhibit single exponential behavior. In this situation, the analytical method provides explicit expressions relating observed rate constants to the microscopic rate constants of mechanism steps without use of rapid equilibrium or steady-state approximations, and thereby provides a basis for interpreting the composite rate constants of association (ka), isomerization (ki), and dissociation (kd) obtained from experiment for this or any other sequential mechanism of any number of steps. In subsequent papers, we apply this formalism to analyze kinetic data obtained in the reversible and irreversible binding regimes of Esigma70 RNA polymerase (R)-lambdaP(R) promoter (P) open complex formation.

DNA footprints of the two kinetically significant intermediates in formation of an RNA polymerase-promoter open complex: evidence that interactions with start site and downstream DNA induce sequential conformational changes in polymerase and DNA

Kinetic studies of formation and dissociation of open-promoter complexes (RPo) involving Esigma70 RNA polymerase (R) and the lambdaPR promoter (P) demonstrate the existence of two kinetically significant intermediates, designated I1 and I2, and facilitate the choice of conditions under which each accumulates. For such conditions, we report the results of equilibrium and transient DNase I and KMnO4 footprinting studies which characterize I1 and I2. At 0 degreesC, where extrapolation of equilibrium data indicates I1 is the dominant complex, DNA bases in the vicinity of the transcription start site (+1) do not react with KMnO4, indicating that this region is closed in I1. However, the DNA backbone in I1 is extensively protected from DNase I cleavage; the DNase I footprint extends approximately 30 bases downstream and at least approximately 40 bases upstream from the start site. I1 has a short lifetime (</=15 seconds), based on its sensitivity to competition with heparin. Shortly after a temperature downshift from 37 degreesC to 0 degreesC, in the time-range where we conclude that the dominant, transiently accumulated complex is I2, DNase I and KMnO4 footprinting reveal a complex with a closed-start site and an extended DNase I footprint like that of I1. However, unlike I1, I2 is insensitive to heparin competition and has a much longer dissociation lifetime at 0 degreesC. Based on footprinting, kinetic and thermodynamic studies, we conclude that in the short-lived intermediate I1 the promoter start site and downstream region are bound in a cleft defined by the open clamp-like jaws of Esigma70. We propose that binding of the start site and downstream DNA in this cleft triggers massive, relatively slow conformational changes which likely include RNA polymerase jaw closing with coupled folding. These proposed conformational changes occur prior to opening of the promoter start site region, and are responsible for the much longer lifetime of I2. Closing of the jaws of polymerase around the downstream region of promoter DNA appears to trigger opening of the start site region. From a quantitative analysis of the biphasic decay of KMnO4 reactivity of RPo at 0 degreesC, we obtain the equilibrium constant K3 for the conversion of I2 to RPo and the rate constant k-2 for the conversion of I2 to I1 (i.e. jaw opening). These quantitative results were previously unavailable at any temperature, and are necessary for the dissection of dissociation kinetic data at higher temperatures.