The final stages of folding of the membrane protein bacteriorhodopsin occur by kinetically indistinguishable parallel folding paths that are mediated by pH

Structural insight into co-translational membrane protein folding

Membrane protein folding studies lag behind those of water-soluble proteins due to immense difficulties of experimental study, resulting from the need to provide a hydrophobic lipid-bilayer environment when investigated in vitro. A sound understanding of folding mechanisms is important for membrane proteins as they contribute to a third of the proteome and are frequently associated with disease when mutated and/or misfolded. Membrane proteins largely consist of α-helical, hydrophobic transmembrane domains, which insert into the membrane, often using the SecYEG/Sec61 translocase system. This mini-review highlights recent advances in techniques that can further our understanding of co-translational folding and notably, the structure and insertion of nascent chains as they emerge from translating ribosomes. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Molecular biophysics of membranes and membrane proteins.

Bicelle size modulates the rate of bacteriorhodopsin folding

The conformational equilibria of integral membrane proteins have proven extremely difficult to characterize within native lipid bilayers. To circumvent technical issues, investigations of the structure and stability of α-helical membrane proteins are often carried out in mixed micelle or bicelle solvents that mimic the membrane and facilitate measurements of reversible folding. Under these conditions, the energetics of membrane protein folding are typically proportional to the mole fraction of an anionic detergent in the micelle. However, investigations of the folding and unfolding of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) surprisingly revealed that the folding rate is also highly sensitive to the bulk molar concentration of lipids and detergents. We show here that this rate enhancement coincides with changes in bicelle size and suggest this effect arises through restriction of the conformational search space during folding. In conjunction with previous mutagenic studies, these results provide additional evidence that a topological search limits the rate of bR folding. Furthermore, this finding provides insights into the manner by which micellar and bicellar environments influence the conformational stability of polytopic membrane proteins.

C-terminal tail insertion of Bcl-xL in membrane occurs via partial unfolding and refolding cycle associating microsolvation

Insertion of the Bcl-x_L C-terminal into the mitochondrial outer membrane is found to be guided by the partial unfolding–refolding cycle, assisted by micro-solvation.

The safety dance: biophysics of membrane protein folding and misfolding in a cellular context

Most biological processes require the production and degradation of proteins, a task that weighs heavily on the cell. Mutations that compromise the conformational stability of proteins place both specific and general burdens on cellular protein homeostasis (proteostasis) in ways that contribute to numerous diseases. Efforts to elucidate the chain of molecular events responsible for diseases of protein folding address one of the foremost challenges in biomedical science. However, relatively little is known about the processes by which mutations prompt the misfolding of α-helical membrane proteins, which rely on an intricate network of cellular machinery to acquire and maintain their functional structures within cellular membranes. In this review, we summarize the current understanding of the physical principles that guide membrane protein biogenesis and folding in the context of mammalian cells. Additionally, we explore how pathogenic mutations that influence biogenesis may differ from those that disrupt folding and assembly, as well as how this may relate to disease mechanisms and therapeutic intervention. These perspectives indicate an imperative for the use of information from structural, cellular, and biochemical studies of membrane proteins in the design of novel therapeutics and in personalized medicine.

Molecular dynamics simulation of the unfolding of individual bacteriorhodopsin helices in sodium dodecyl sulfate micelles

We report molecular dynamics simulations of the trends in the changes in secondary structure of the seven individual helices of bacteriorhodopsin when inserted into sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) micelles, and their dependence on the amino acid sequence. The results indicate that the partitioning of the helices in the micelles and their stability are dependent on the hydrophobicity of the transmembrane segments. Helices A, B, and E are stable and retain their initial secondary structure throughout the 100 ns simulation time. In contrast, helices C, D, F, and G show structural perturbations within the first 10 ns. The instabilities are localized near charged residues within the transmembrane segments. The overall structural instability of the helix is correlated with its partitioning to the surface of the micelle and its interaction with polar groups there. The in silico experiments were performed to complement the in vitro experiments that examined the partial denaturation of bacteriorhodopsin in SDS described in the preceding article (DOI 10.1021/bi201769z ). The simulations are consistent with the trends revealed by the experimental results but strongly underestimate the extent of helix to extended coil transformation. The reason may be either that the sampling time was not sufficiently long or, more interestingly, that interhelix residue interactions play a role in the unfolding of the helices.

Structural changes in bacteriorhodopsin during in vitro refolding from a partially denatured state

We report on the formation of the secondary and tertiary structure of bacteriorhodopsin during its in vitro refolding from an SDS-denatured state. We used the mobility of single spin labels in seven samples, attached at various locations to six of the seven helical segments to engineered cysteine residues, to follow coil-to-helix formation. Distance measurements obtained by spin dipolar quenching in six samples labeled at either the cytoplasmic or extracellular ends of pairs of helices revealed the time dependence of the recovery of the transmembrane helical bundle. The secondary structure in the majority of the helical segments refolds with a time constant of <100-140 ms. Recovery of the tertiary structure is achieved by sequential association of the helices and occurs in at least three distinct steps with time constants of 1), well below 1 s; 2), 3-4 s; and 3), 60-130 s (the latter depending on the helical pair). The slowest of these processes occurs in concert with recovery of the retinal chromophore.

Kinetic folding mechanism of an integral membrane protein examined by pulsed oxidative labeling and mass spectrometry

We report the application of pulsed oxidative labeling for deciphering the folding mechanism of a membrane protein. SDS-denatured bacteriorhodopsin (BR) was refolded by mixing with bicelles in the presence of free retinal. At various time points (20 ms to 1 day), the protein was exposed to a microsecond ·OH pulse that induces oxidative modifications at solvent-accessible methionine side chains. The extent of labeling was determined by mass spectrometry. These measurements were complemented by stopped-flow spectroscopy. Major time-dependent changes in solvent accessibility were detected for M20 (helix A) and M118 (helix D). Our kinetic data indicate a sequential folding mechanism, consistent with models previously suggested by others on the basis of optical data. Yet, ·OH labeling provides additional structural insights. An initial folding intermediate I(1) gets populated within 20 ms, concomitantly with formation of helix A. Subsequent structural consolidation leads to a transient species I(2). Noncovalent retinal binding to I(2) induces folding of helix D, thereby generating an intermediate I(R). In the absence of retinal, the latter transition does not take place. Hence, formation of helix D depends on retinal binding, whereas this is not the case for helix A. As the cofactor settles deeper into its binding pocket, a final transient species I(R) is generated. This intermediate converts into native BR within minutes by formation of the retinal-K216 Schiff base linkage. The combination of pulsed covalent labeling and optical spectroscopy employed here should also be suitable for exploring the folding mechanisms of other membrane proteins.

Folding scene investigation: membrane proteins

Investigations into protein folding have concentrated on experimentally tractable proteins with the result that membrane protein folding remains unsolved. New evidence is providing insight into the nature of the interactions stabilising the folded state of α-helical membrane proteins as well as giving hints on the character of the folding transition state. These developments show that classical methods used for water-soluble proteins can be successfully adapted for membrane proteins. The advances, coupled with increasing numbers of solved crystal structures, augur well for future research into the mechanisms of membrane protein folding.

Self-assembly of a simple membrane protein: coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations of the influenza M2 channel

The transmembrane (TM) domain of the M2 channel protein from influenza A is a homotetrameric bundle of alpha-helices and provides a model system for computational approaches to self-assembly of membrane proteins. Coarse-grained molecular dynamics (CG-MD) simulations have been used to explore partitioning into a membrane of M2 TM helices during bilayer self-assembly from lipids. CG-MD is also used to explore tetramerization of preinserted M2 TM helices. The M2 helix monomer adopts a membrane spanning orientation in a lipid (DPPC) bilayer. Multiple extended CG-MD simulations (5 x 5 micros) were used to study the tetramerization of inserted M2 helices. The resultant tetramers were evaluated in terms of the most populated conformations and the dynamics of their interconversion. This analysis reveals that the M2 tetramer has 2x rotationally symmetrical packing of the helices. The helices form a left-handed bundle, with a helix tilt angle of approximately 16 degrees. The M2 helix bundle generated by CG-MD was converted to an atomistic model. Simulations of this model reveal that the bundle's stability depends on the assumed protonation state of the H37 side chains. These simulations alongside comparison with recent x-ray (3BKD) and NMR (2RLF) structures of the M2 bundle suggest that the model yielded by CG-MD may correspond to a closed state of the channel.

Combined kinetic and thermodynamic analysis of alpha-helical membrane protein unfolding

The analytical toolkit developed for investigations into water-soluble protein folding has yet to be applied in earnest to membrane proteins. A major problem is the difficulty in collecting kinetic data, which are crucial to understanding any reaction. Here, we combine kinetic and thermodynamic studies of the reversible unfolding of an alpha-helical membrane protein to provide a definitive value for the reaction free energy and a means to probe the transition state. Our analyses show that the major unfolding step in the SDS-induced denaturation of bacteriorhodopsin involves a reduction in alpha-helical structure and proceeds with a large free-energy change; both our equilibrium and kinetic measurements predict that the free energy of unfolding in the absence of denaturant is +20 kcal.mol(-1), with an associated m-value of 25 kcal.mol(-1). The rate of unfolding in the absence of denaturant, k(u)(H(2)O), is surprisingly very slow ( approximately 10(-15) s(-1)). The kinetics also give information on the transition state for this major unfolding step, with a value for beta (m(f)/[m(f) + m(u)]) of approximately 0.1, indicating that the transition state is close to the unfolded state. We thus present a basis for mapping the structural and energetic properties of membrane protein folding by mutagenesis and classical kinetics.

Membrane proteins shape up: understanding in vitro folding

Progress in structural biology has begun to reveal the precise architecture of integral membrane proteins. However, the manner in which these complex structures are achieved remains unclear. Recent developments are starting to shed light on the unfolding and folding of a small but growing number of membrane proteins. Mechanistic details derived from kinetic and thermodynamic experiments now enable comparison of the folding of different membrane proteins and their water-soluble cousins. This work also has important implications for other structural and functional studies of membrane proteins in vitro.

Assembly of a transmembrane b-type cytochrome is mainly driven by transmembrane helix interactions

Folding, assembly and stability of alpha-helical membrane proteins is still not very well understood. Several of these membrane proteins contain cofactors, which are essential for their function and which can be involved in protein assembly and/or stabilization. The effect of heme binding on the assembly and stability of the transmembrane b-type cytochrome b'559 was studied by fluorescence resonance energy transfer. Cytochrome b'559 consists of two monomers of a 44 amino acid long polypeptide, which contains one transmembrane domain. The synthesis of two variants of the b'559 monomer, each carrying a specific fluorescent dye, allowed monitoring helix-helix interactions in micelles by resonance energy transfer. The measurements demonstrate that the transmembrane peptides dimerize in detergent in the absence and presence of the heme cofactor. Cofactor binding only marginally enhances dimerization and, apparently, the redox state of the heme group has no effect on dimerization.

Kinetics of an individual transmembrane helix during bacteriorhodopsin folding

The kinetics of an individual helix of bacteriorhodopsin have been monitored during folding of the protein into lipid bilayer vesicles. A fluorescence probe was introduced at individual sites throughout helix D of bacteriorhodopsin and the changes in the fluorescence of the label were time-resolved. Partially denatured, labelled bacteriorhodopsin in SDS was folded directly into phosphatidylcholine lipid vesicles. Stopped-flow mixing of the reactants allowed the folding kinetics to be monitored with millisecond time resolution by time-resolving changes in the label fluorescence, intrinsic protein fluorescence as well as in the absorption of the retinal chromophore. Monitoring specific positions on helix D showed that two kinetic phases were altered compared to those determined by monitoring the average protein behaviour. These two phases, of 6.7 s(-1) and 0.33 s(-1), were previously assigned to formation of a key apoprotein intermediate during bacteriorhodopsin folding. The faster 6.7s(-1) phase was missing when time-resolving fluorescence changes of labels attached to the middle of helix D. The amplitude of the 0.33 s(-1) phase increased along the helix, as single labels were attached in turn from the cytoplasmic to the extracellular side. An interpretation of these results is that the 6.7 s(-1) phase involves partitioning of helix D within the lipid headgroups of the bilayer vesicle, while the 0.33 s(-1) phase could reflect transmembrane insertion of this helix. In addition, a single site on helix G was monitored during folding. The results indicate that, unlike helix D, the insertion of helix G cannot be differentiated from the average protein behaviour. The data show that, while folding of bacteriorhodopsin from SDS into lipids is a co-operative process, it is nevertheless possible to obtain information on specific regions of a membrane protein during folding in vitro.

Solving the membrane protein folding problem

One of the great challenges for molecular biologists is to learn how a protein sequence defines its three-dimensional structure. For many years, the problem was even more difficult for membrane proteins because so little was known about what they looked like. The situation has improved markedly in recent years, and we now know over 90 unique structures. Our enhanced view of the structure universe, combined with an increasingly quantitative understanding of fold determination, engenders optimism that a solution to the folding problem for membrane proteins can be achieved.

Defining the Structural Basis for Assembly of a Transmembrane Cytochrome

To define the structural basis for cofactor binding to membrane proteins, we introduce a manageable model system, which allows us, for the first time, to study the influence of individual transmembrane helices and of single amino acid residues on the assembly of a transmembrane cytochrome. In vivo as well as in vitro analyses indicate central roles of single amino acid residues for either interaction of the transmembrane helices or for binding of the cofactor. The results clearly show that interaction of the PsbF transmembrane helix is independent from binding of the heme cofactor. On the other hand, binding of the cofactor highly depends on helix-helix interactions. By site-directed mutagenesis critical amino acid residues were identified, which are involved in the assembly of a functional transmembrane cytochrome. Especially, a highly conserved glycine residue is critical for interaction of the transmembrane helices and assembly of the cytochrome. Based on the two-stage-model of alpha-helical membrane protein folding, the presented results clearly indicate a third stage of membrane protein folding, in which a cofactor binds to a pre-assembled transmembrane protein.

Insertion kinetics of a denatured alpha helical membrane protein into phospholipid bilayer vesicles

Membrane protein folding has suffered from a lack of detailed kinetic studies, particularly with regard to the insertion of denatured protein into lipid bilayers. We present a detailed in vitro kinetic study of the association of a denatured, transmembrane alpha helical protein with lipid vesicles. The mechanism of folding of Escherichia coli diacylglycerol kinase from a partially denatured state in urea has been investigated. The protein associates with lipid vesicles to give a protein, vesicle complex with an apparent association constant of 2 x 10(6) M(-1) s(-1). This association rate approaches the diffusion limit of the protein, vesicle reaction. The association of the protein with lipid vesicles is followed by a slower process occurring at observed rate of 0.031 s(-1), involving insertion into the bilayer and generation of a functional oligomer of diacylglycerol kinase. Protein aggregation competes with vesicle insertion. The urea-denatured protein monomers begin to aggregate as soon as the urea is diluted. This aggregation is faster than the association of the protein with vesicles so that most protein aggregates before it inserts into a vesicle. Increasing the vesicle concentration favours insertion of protein monomers, but at high vesicle concentrations monomers are primarily in separate vesicles and do not associate to form functional oligomers. Irreversible aggregation limits the yield of functional protein, while the data also suggest that lipid vesicles can reverse another aggregation reaction, leading to the recovery of correctly folded protein.

Insight into the structural role of carotenoids in the photosystem I: a quantum chemical analysis

The structural stabilization role of carotenoids in the formation of photosynthetic pigment-protein complexes is investigated theoretically. The pi-pi stacking and CH-pi interactions between beta-carotenes and their surrounding chlorophylls (and/or aromatic residues) in Photosystem I (PS1) from the cyanobacterium Synechococcus elongatus were studied by means of the supermolecular approach at the level of the second-order Møller-Plesset perturbation method. PS1 features a core integral antenna system consisting of 22 beta-carotenes intertwined with 90 chlorophyll molecules. The binding environments of all 22 beta-carotenes were systematically analyzed. For 21 out of the 22 cases, one or more chlorophyll molecules exist within van der Waals' contacts of the beta-carotene molecule. The calculated strengths of pi-pi stacking interactions between the conjugated core of beta-carotene and the aromatic tetrapyrrole rings of chlorophyll are substantial, ranging from -3.54 kcal/mol for the perpendicular-positioned BCR4004...CHL1217 pair to -16.01 kcal/mol for the parallel-oriented BCR4007...CHL1122 pair. A strong dependence of the pi-pi stacking interaction energies on the intermolecular configurations of the two interacting pi-planes is observed. The parallel-oriented beta-carotene and chlorophyll pair is energetically much more stable than the perpendicular-positioned pair. The larger the extent of pi-pi overlapping, the stronger the interaction strength. In many cases, the beta-ring ends of beta-carotene molecules are found to interact with the tetrapyrrole rings of chlorophyll via CH-pi interactions. For the latter interactions, the calculated interaction strengths vary from -7.03 to -11.03 kcal/mol, depending on the intermolecular configuration. This work leads to the conclusion that pi-pi stacking and CH-pi interactions between beta-carotene and their surrounding chlorophylls and aromatic residues play an essential role in binding beta-carotenes in PS1 from S. elongatus. Consequently, the molecular basis of the structural stabilization function of carotenoids in formation of the photosynthetic pigment-protein complexes is established.

Folding kinetics of an alpha helical membrane protein in phospholipid bilayer vesicles

We report a detailed kinetic study of the folding of an alpha-helical membrane protein in a lipid bilayer environment. SDS denatured bacteriorhodopsin was folded directly into phosphatidylcholine lipid vesicles by stopped-flow mixing. The folding kinetics were monitored with millisecond time resolution by time-resolving changes in protein fluorescence as well as in the absorption of the retinal chromophore. The kinetics were similar to those previously reported for folding bacteriorhodopsin in detergent or lipid micelles, except for the presence of an additional apoprotein intermediate. We suggest this intermediate is a result of the greater internal two-dimensional pressure present in these lipid vesicles as compared to micelles. These results lay the groundwork for future studies aimed at understanding the mechanistic origin of the effect of lipid bilayer properties on protein folding. Furthermore, the use of biologically relevant phosphatidylcholine lipids, together with a straightforward rapid mixing process to initiate the folding reaction, means the method is generally applicable, and thus paves the way for an improved understanding of the in vitro folding of transmembrane alpha-helical proteins.

Controlling the folding efficiency of an integral membrane protein

Research into the folding mechanisms of integral membrane proteins lags far behind that of water-soluble proteins, to the extent that the term protein folding is synonymous with water-soluble proteins. Hydrophobic membrane proteins, and particularly those with transmembrane alpha-helical motifs, are frequently considered too difficult to work with. We show that the stored curvature elastic stress of lipid bilayers can be used to guide the design of efficient folding systems for these integral membrane proteins. The curvature elastic stress of synthetic phosphatidylcholine/phosphatidylethanolamine lipid bilayers can be used to control both the rate of folding and the yield of folded protein. The use of a physical bilayer property generalises this approach beyond the particular chemistry of the lipids involved.

Assembly and overexpression of membrane proteins in Escherichia coli

The bacterium Escherichia coli is one of the most popular model systems to study the assembly of membrane proteins of the so-called helix-bundle class. Here, based on this system, we review and discuss what is currently known about the assembly of these membrane proteins. In addition, we will briefly review and discuss how E. coli has been used as a vehicle for the overexpression of membrane proteins.

Sequential vs. parallel protein-folding mechanisms: experimental tests for complex folding reactions

The recent emphasis on rough energy landscapes for protein folding reactions by theoreticians, and the many observations of complex folding kinetics by experimentalists provide a rationale for a brief literature survey of various empirical approaches for validating the underlying mechanisms. The determination of the folding mechanism is a key step in defining the energy surface on which the folding reactions occurs and in interpreting the effects of amino acid replacements on this reaction. Case studies that illustrate methods for differentiating between sequential and parallel channel folding mechanisms are presented. The ultimate goal of such efforts is to understand how the one-dimensional information contained in the amino acid sequence is rapidly and efficiently translated into three-dimensional structure.

Membrane proteins: shaping up

Over recent years, much progress has been made in the identification and characterization of factors involved in the biosynthesis of integral membrane proteins of the helix-bundle type. In addition, our knowledge of membrane protein structure and the forces stabilizing helix-helix interactions in a lipid environment is expanding rapidly. However, it is still not clear how a membrane protein folds into its final form in vivo, nor what constraints there are on the folded structure that results from the mechanistic details of translocon-mediated assembly rather than simply from the thermodynamics of protein-lipid interactions.

Ratiometric single-molecule studies of freely diffusing biomolecules

We outline recent developments in biological single-molecule fluorescence detection with particular emphasis on observations by ratiometric fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) of biomolecules freely diffusing in solution. Single-molecule-diffusion methodologies were developed to minimize perturbations introduced by interactions between molecules and surfaces. Confocal microscopy is used in combination with sensitive detectors to observe bursts of photons from fluorescently labeled biomolecules as they diffuse through the focal volume. These bursts are analyzed to extract ratiometric observables such as FRET efficiency and polarization anisotropy. We describe the development of single-molecule FRET methodology and its application to the observation of the Förster distance dependence and the study of protein folding and polymer physics problems. Finally, we discuss future advances in data acquisition and analysis techniques that can provide a more complete picture of the accessible molecular information.

Structure and function in bacteriorhodopsin: the effect of the interhelical loops on the protein folding kinetics

The loops connecting the seven transmembrane helices of bacteriorhodopsin have each been replaced in turn by structureless linkers of Gly-Gly-Ser repeat sequences, and the effect on the protein folding kinetics has been determined. An SDS-denatured state of each loop mutant bacterio-opsin was folded in l-alpha-1,2-dihexanoylphosphatidylcholine/l-alpha-1,2-dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine micelles, containing retinal, to give functional bacteriorhodopsin. Stopped-flow mixing was used to initiate the folding reaction, giving a time resolution of milliseconds, and changes in protein fluorescence were used to monitor folding. All loop mutant proteins folded according to the same reaction scheme as wild-type protein. The folding kinetics of the AB, BC and DE loop mutants were the same as wild-type protein, despite the blue-shifted chromophore band of the BC loop mutant bR state. A partially folded apoprotein intermediate state of the AB loop mutant did however appear to decay in the absence of retinal. The most significant effects on the folding kinetics were seen for mutant protein with structureless linkers in place of the CD, EF and FG loops. The rate-limiting apoprotein folding step of the CD loop mutant was about ten times slower than wild-type, whilst that of the EF loop mutant was almost four times slower than wild-type. Wild-type behaviour was observed for the other folding and retinal binding events of the CD and EF loop mutant proteins. These effects of the CD and EF loop mutations on apoprotein folding correlate with the fact that these two loop mutants also have the least stable, partially folded apoprotein intermediate of all the loop mutants, and are the most affected by a decrease in lipid lateral pressure. In contrast, the FG loop mutant exhibited wild-type apoprotein folding, but altered covalent binding of retinal and final folding to bacteriorhodopsin. This correlates with the fact that the FG loop mutant bacteriorhodopsin is the most susceptible to denaturation by SDS of all the loop mutants, but its partially folded apoprotein intermediate is more stable than that of the CD and EF mutants. Thus the CD and EF loops may contribute to the transition state for the rate-limiting apoprotein folding step and the FG loop to that for final folding and covalent binding of retinal.

Proline residues in transmembrane alpha helices affect the folding of bacteriorhodopsin

Proline residues occur frequently in transmembrane alpha helices, which contrasts with their behaviour as helix-breakers in water-soluble proteins. The three membrane-embedded proline residues of bacteriorhodopsin have been replaced individually by alanine and glycine to give P50A, or P50G on helix B, P91A, or P91G on helix C, and P186A or P186G on helix F, and the effect on the protein folding kinetics has been investigated. The rate-limiting apoprotein folding step, which results in formation of a seven transmembrane, alpha helical state, was slower than wild-type protein for the Pro50 and Pro91 mutants, regardless of whether they were mutated to Ala or Gly. These proline residues give rise to several inter-helix contacts, which are therefore important in folding to the seven transmembrane helix state. No evidence for cis-trans isomerisations of the peptidyl prolyl bonds was found during this rate-limiting apoprotein folding step. Mutations of all three membrane-embedded proline residues affected the subsequent retinal binding and final folding to bacteriorhodopsin, suggesting that these proline residues contribute to formation of the retinal binding pocket within the helix bundle, again via helix/helix interactions. These results point to proline residues in transmembrane alpha helices being important in the folding of integral membrane proteins. The helix/helix interactions and hydrogen bonds that arise from the presence of proline residues in transmembrane alpha helices can affect the formation of transmembrane alpha helix bundles as well as cofactor binding pockets.