Function of tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase in splicing group I introns: an induced-fit model for binding to the P4-P6 domain based on analysis of mutations at the junction of the P4-P6 stacked helices

Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase (AARS) as an attractive drug target in neglected tropical trypanosomatid diseases-Leishmaniasis, Human African Trypanosomiasis and Chagas disease

TriTryp diseases (Leishmaniasis, Human African Trypanosomiasis (HAT), and Chagas disease) are devastating parasitic neglected tropical diseases (NTDs) that affect billions of people in developing countries, cause high mortality in humans, and impose a large socio-economic burden. The current treatment options against tritryp diseases are suboptimal and challenging due to the emergence of resistance against available tritryp drugs. Hence, designing and developing effective anti-tritryp drugs with novel targets are required. Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (AARSs) involved in specific aminoacylation of transfer RNAs (tRNAs), interrupt protein synthesis through inhibitors, and retard the parasite growth. AaRSs have long been studied as therapeutic targets in bacteria, and three aaRS inhibitors, mupirocin (against IleRS), tavaborole AN2690 (against LeuRS), and halofuginone (against ProRS), are already in clinical practice. The structural differences between tritryp and human aaRSs and the presence of unique sequences (N-terminal domain/C-terminal domain/catalytic domain) make them potential target for developing selective inhibitors. Drugs based on a single aaRS target developed by high-throughput screening (HTS) are less effective due to the emergence of resistance. However, designing multi-targeted drugs may be a better strategy for resistance development. In this perspective, we discuss the characteristics of tritryp aaRSs, sequence conservation in their orthologs and their peculiarities, recent advancements towards the single-target and multi-target aaRS inhibitors developed through rational design.

Better late than early: delayed translation of intron-encoded endonuclease I-TevI is required for efficient splicing of its host group I intron

The td group I intron interrupting the thymidylate synthase (TS) gene of phage T4 is a mobile intron that encodes the homing endonuclease I-TevI. Efficient RNA splicing of the intron is required to restore function of the TS gene, while expression of I-TevI from within the intron is required to initiate intron mobility. Three distinct layers of regulation temporally limit I-TevI expression to late in the T4 infective cycle, yet the biological rationale for stringent regulation has not been tested. Here, we deleted key control elements to deregulate I-TevI expression at early and middle times post T4 infection. Strikingly, we found that deregulation of I-TevI, or of a catalytically inactive variant, generated a thymidine-dependent phenotype that is caused by a reduction in td intron splicing. Prematurely terminating I-TevI translation restores td splicing, full-length TS synthesis, and rescues the thymidine-dependent phenotype. We suggest that stringent translational control of I-TevI evolved to prevent the ribosome from disrupting key structural elements of the td intron that are required for splicing and TS function at early and middle times post T4 infection. Analogous translational regulatory mechanisms in unrelated intron-open reading frame arrangements may also function to limit deleterious consequences on splicing and host gene function.

Protein roles in group I intron RNA folding: the tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase CYT-18 stabilizes the native state relative to a long-lived misfolded structure without compromising folding kinetics

The Neurospora crassa CYT-18 protein is a mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase that also promotes self-splicing of group I intron RNAs by stabilizing the functional structure in the conserved core. CYT-18 binds the core along the same surface as a common peripheral element, P5abc, suggesting that CYT-18 can replace P5abc functionally. In addition to stabilizing structure generally, P5abc stabilizes the native conformation of the Tetrahymena group I intron relative to a globally similar misfolded conformation that has only local differences within the core and is populated significantly at equilibrium by a ribozyme variant lacking P5abc (E(DeltaP5abc)). Here, we show that CYT-18 specifically promotes formation of the native group I intron core from this misfolded conformation. Catalytic activity assays demonstrate that CYT-18 shifts the equilibrium of E(DeltaP5abc) toward the native state by at least 35-fold, and binding assays suggest an even larger effect. Thus, similar to P5abc, CYT-18 preferentially recognizes the native core, despite the global similarity of the misfolded core and despite forming crudely similar complexes, as revealed by dimethyl sulfate footprinting. Interestingly, the effects of CYT-18 and P5abc on folding kinetics differ. Whereas P5abc inhibits refolding of the misfolded conformation by forming peripheral contacts that must break during refolding, CYT-18 does not display analogous inhibition, most likely because it relies to a greater extent on direct interactions with the core. Although CYT-18 does not encounter this RNA in vivo, our results suggest that it stabilizes its cognate group I introns relative to analogous misfolded intermediates. By specifically recognizing native structural features, CYT-18 may also interact with earlier folding intermediates to avoid RNA misfolding or to trap native contacts as they form. More generally, our results highlight the ability of a protein cofactor to stabilize a functional RNA structure specifically without incurring associated costs in RNA folding kinetics.

Preparation of group I introns for biochemical studies and crystallization assays by native affinity purification

The study of functional RNAs of various sizes and structures requires efficient methods for their synthesis and purification. Here, 23 group I intron variants ranging in length from 246 to 341 nucleotides—some containing exons—were subjected to a native purification technique previously applied only to shorter RNAs (<160 nucleotides). For the RNAs containing both exons, we adjusted the original purification protocol to allow for purification of radiolabeled molecules. The resulting RNAs were used in folding assays on native gel electrophoresis and in self-splicing assays. The intron-only RNAs were subjected to the regular native purification scheme, assayed for folding and employed in crystallization screens. All RNAs that contained a 3′ overhang of one nucleotide were efficiently cleaved off from the support and were at least 90% pure after the non-denaturing purification. A representative subset of these RNAs was shown to be folded and self-splicing after purification. Additionally, crystals were grown for a 286 nucleotide long variant of the Clostridium botulinum intron. These results demonstrate the suitability of the native affinity purification method for the preparation of group I introns. We hope these findings will stimulate a broader application of this strategy to the preparation of other large RNA molecules.

Leucyl-tRNA synthetase-dependent and -independent activation of a group I intron

Leucyl-tRNA synthetase (LeuRS) is an essential RNA splicing factor for yeast mitochondrial introns. Intracellular experiments have suggested that it works in collaboration with a maturase that is encoded within the bI4 intron. RNA deletion mutants of the large bI4 intron were constructed to identify a competently folded intron for biochemical analysis. The minimized bI4 intron was active in RNA splicing and contrasts with previous proposals that the canonical core of the bI4 intron is deficient for catalysis. The activity of the minimized bI4 intron was enhanced in vitro by the presence of the bI4 maturase or LeuRS.

Structure of a tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase splicing factor bound to a group I intron RNA

The 'RNA world' hypothesis holds that during evolution the structural and enzymatic functions initially served by RNA were assumed by proteins, leading to the latter's domination of biological catalysis. This progression can still be seen in modern biology, where ribozymes, such as the ribosome and RNase P, have evolved into protein-dependent RNA catalysts ('RNPzymes'). Similarly, group I introns use RNA-catalysed splicing reactions, but many function as RNPzymes bound to proteins that stabilize their catalytically active RNA structure. One such protein, the Neurospora crassa mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (TyrRS; CYT-18), is bifunctional and both aminoacylates mitochondrial tRNA(Tyr) and promotes the splicing of mitochondrial group I introns. Here we determine a 4.5-A co-crystal structure of the Twort orf142-I2 group I intron ribozyme bound to splicing-active, carboxy-terminally truncated CYT-18. The structure shows that the group I intron binds across the two subunits of the homodimeric protein with a newly evolved RNA-binding surface distinct from that which binds tRNA(Tyr). This RNA binding surface provides an extended scaffold for the phosphodiester backbone of the conserved catalytic core of the intron RNA, allowing the protein to promote the splicing of a wide variety of group I introns. The group I intron-binding surface includes three small insertions and additional structural adaptations relative to non-splicing bacterial TyrRSs, indicating a multistep adaptation for splicing function. The co-crystal structure provides insight into how CYT-18 promotes group I intron splicing, how it evolved to have this function, and how proteins could have incrementally replaced RNA structures during the transition from an RNA world to an RNP world.

RNA and protein folding: common themes and variations

Visualizing the navigation of an ensemble of unfolded molecules through the bumpy energy landscape in search of the native state gives a pictorial view of biomolecular folding. This picture, when combined with concepts in polymer theory, provides a unified theory of RNA and protein folding. Just as for proteins, the major folding free energy barrier for RNA scales sublinearly with the number of nucleotides, which allows us to extract the elusive prefactor for RNA folding. Several folding scenarios can be anticipated by considering variations in the energy landscape that depend on sequence, native topology, and external conditions. RNA and protein folding mechanism can be described by the kinetic partitioning mechanism (KPM) according to which a fraction (Phi) of molecules reaches the native state directly, whereas the remaining fraction gets kinetically trapped in metastable conformations. For two-state folders Phi approximately 1. Molecular chaperones are recruited to assist protein folding whenever Phi is small. We show that the iterative annealing mechanism, introduced to describe chaperonin-mediated folding, can be generalized to understand protein-assisted RNA folding. The major differences between the folding of proteins and RNA arise in the early stages of folding. For RNA, folding can only begin after the polyelectrolyte problem is solved, whereas protein collapse requires burial of hydrophobic residues. Cross-fertilization of ideas between the two fields should lead to an understanding of how RNA and proteins solve their folding problems.

The Neurospora crassa CYT-18 protein C-terminal RNA-binding domain helps stabilize interdomain tertiary interactions in group I introns

The Neurospora crassa mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (CYT-18 protein) promotes the splicing of group I introns by stabilizing the catalytically active RNA structure. To accomplish this, CYT-18 recognizes conserved structural features of group I intron RNAs using regions of the N-terminal nucleotide-binding fold, intermediate alpha-helical, and C-terminal RNA-binding domains that also function in binding tRNA(Tyr). Curiously, whereas the splicing of the N. crassa mitochondrial large subunit rRNA intron is completely dependent on CYT-18's C-terminal RNA-binding domain, all other group I introns tested thus far are spliced efficiently by a truncated protein lacking this domain. To investigate the function of the C-terminal domain, we used an Escherichia coli genetic assay to isolate mutants of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae mitochondrial large subunit rRNA and phage T4 td introns that can be spliced in vivo by the wild-type CYT-18 protein, but not by the C-terminally truncated protein. Mutations that result in dependence on CYT-18's C-terminal domain include those disrupting two long-range GNRA tetraloop/receptor interactions: L2-P8, which helps position the P1 helix containing the 5'-splice site, and L9-P5, which helps establish the correct relative orientation of the P4-P6 and P3-P9 domains of the group I intron catalytic core. Our results indicate that different structural mutations in group I intron RNAs can result in dependence on different regions of CYT-18 for RNA splicing.

Small structural costs for evolution from RNA to RNP-based catalysis

Typical RNA-based cellular catalysts achieve their active structures only as complexes with protein cofactors, implying that protein binding compensates for some structural deficiencies in the RNA. An unresolved question was the extent to which protein-facilitation imposes additional structural costs, by requiring that an RNA maintain structures required for protein binding, beyond those required for catalysis. We used nucleotide analog interference to identify initially 71 functional group substitutions at phosphate, 2'-ribose, and adenosine base positions that compromise RNA self-splicing in the bI5 group I intron. Protein-facilitated splicing by CBP2 suppresses 11 of 30 interfering substitutions at the RNA backbone and a greater fraction, 27 of 41, at the adenosine base, including at structures conserved among group I introns. Only one substitution directly interferes with protein binding but not with self-splicing. This substitution, plus three adenosine base modifications that interfere more strongly in CBP2-dependent splicing than in self-splicing, yield a cost for protein facilitation of only four functional groups, as approximated by this set of analogs. The small observed structural cost provides a strong physical rationale for the evolutionary drive from RNA to RNP-based function in biology. Remarkably, the four extra requirements do not appear to report disruption of direct protein-RNA contacts and instead likely reflect design against misfolding rather than for maintenance of a protein-binding site.

Exploration of the transition state for tertiary structure formation between an RNA helix and a large structured RNA

Docking of the P1 duplex into the pre-folded core of the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme exemplifies the formation of tertiary interactions in the context of a complex, structured RNA. We have applied Phi-analysis to P1 docking, which compares the effects of modifications on the rate constant for docking (k(dock)) with the effects on the docking equilibrium (K(dock)). To accomplish this we used a single molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer assay that allows direct determination of the rate constants for formation of thermodynamically favorable, as well as unfavorable, states. Modification of the eight groups of the P1 duplex that make tertiary interactions with the core and changes in solution conditions decrease K(dock) up to 500-fold, whereas k(dock) changes by </=2-fold. The absence of effects on k(dock), both from atomic modifications and global perturbations, strongly suggests that the transition state for docking is early and does not closely resemble the docked state. These results, the slow rate of docking of 3s(-1), and the observation that a modification that is expected to increase the degrees of freedom between the P1 duplex and the ribozyme core accelerates docking, suggest a model in which a kinetic trap(s) slows docking substantially. Nonetheless, urea does not increase k(dock), suggesting that there is little change in the exposed surface area between the trapped, undocked state and the transition state. The findings highlight that urea and temperature dependencies can be inadequate to diagnose the presence of kinetic traps in a folding process. The results described here, combined with previous work, provide an in-depth view of an RNA tertiary structure formation event and suggest that large, highly structured RNAs may have local regions that are misordered.

The ubiquitous nature of RNA chaperone proteins

RNA chaperones are ubiquitous and abundant proteins found in all living organisms and viruses, where they interact with various classes of RNA. These highly diverse families of nucleic acid-binding proteins possess activities enabling rapid and faithful RNA-RNA annealing, strand transfer, and exchange and RNA ribozyme-mediated cleavage under physiological conditions. RNA chaperones appear to be critical to functions as important as maintenance of chromosome ends, DNA transcription, preRNA export, splicing and modifications, and mRNA translation and degradation. Here we review some of the properties of RNA chaperones in RNA-RNA interactions that take place during cellular processes and retrovirus replication. Examples of cellular and viral proteins are dicussed vis à vis the relationships between RNA chaperone activities in vitro and functions. In this new "genomic era" we discuss the possible use of small RNA chaperones to improve the synthesis of cDNA libraries for use in large screening reactions using DNA chips.

Monitoring intermediate folding states of the td group I intron in vivo

Group I introns consist of two major structural domains, the P4-P6 and P3-P9 domains, which assemble through interactions with peripheral extensions to fold into an active ribozyme. To assess group I intron folding in vivo, we probed the structure of td wild-type and mutant introns using dimethyl sulfate. The results suggest that the majority of the intron population is in the native state in accordance with the current structural model, which was refined to include two novel tertiary contacts. The importance of the loop E motif in the P7.1-P7.2 extension in assisting ribozyme folding was deduced from modeling and mutational analyses. Destabilization of stem P6 results in a deficiency in tertiary structure formation in both major domains, while weakening of stem P7 only interferes with folding of the P3-P9 domain. The different impact of mutations on the tertiary structure suggests that they interfere with folding at different stages. These results provide a first insight into the structure of folding intermediates and suggest a putative order of events in a hierarchical folding pathway in vivo.

RNA chaperone StpA loosens interactions of the tertiary structure in the td group I intron in vivo

Efficient splicing of the td group I intron in vivo is dependent on the ribosome. In the absence of translation, the pre-mRNA is trapped in nonnative-splicing-incompetent conformations. Alternatively, folding of the pre-mRNA can be promoted by the RNA chaperone StpA or by the group I intron-specific splicing factor Cyt-18. To understand the mechanism of action of RNA chaperones, we probed the impact of StpA on the structure of the td intron in vivo. Our data suggest that StpA loosens tertiary interactions. The most prominent structural change was the opening of the base triples, which are involved in the correct orientation of the two major intron core domains. In line with the destabilizing activity of StpA, splicing of mutant introns with a reduced structural stability is sensitive to StpA. In contrast, Cyt-18 strengthens tertiary contacts, thereby rescuing splicing of structurally compromised td mutants in vivo. Our data provide direct evidence for protein-induced conformational changes within catalytic RNA in vivo. Whereas StpA resolves tertiary contacts enabling the RNA to refold, Cyt-18 contributes to the overall compactness of the td intron in vivo.

RNA folding in vivo

RNA folding in vivo is influenced by the cellular environment, the vectorial nature of transcription and translation, trans-acting factors and ion homeostasis. Specific RNA-binding proteins promote RNA folding by stabilizing the native structure or by guiding folding. In contrast, RNA chaperones, which are believed to interact nonspecifically with RNA, were proposed to resolve misfolded RNA structures and to promote intermolecular RNA-RNA annealing. Small trans-acting noncoding RNAs are thought to modulate mRNA structures, thereby regulating gene expression. So far, there is some evidence that in vitro and invivo RNA folding pathways share basic features. However, it is unclear whether the rules deduced from in vitro folding experiments generally apply to invivo conditions.

tRNA-like recognition of group I introns by a tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase

The Neurospora crassa mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (CYT-18 protein) functions in splicing group I introns by promoting the formation of the catalytically active RNA structure. Previous work suggested that CYT-18 recognizes a conserved tRNA-like structure of the group I intron catalytic core. Here, directed hydroxyl-radical cleavage assays show that the nucleotide-binding fold and C-terminal domains of CYT-18 interact with the expected group I intron cognates of the aminoacyl-acceptor stem and D-anticodon arms, respectively. Further, three-dimensional graphic modeling, supported by biochemical data, shows that conserved regions of group I introns can be superimposed over interacting regions of the tRNA in a Thermus thermophilus TyrRS/tRNA(Tyr) cocrystal structure. Our results support the hypothesis that CYT-18 and other aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases interact with group I introns by recognizing conserved tRNA-like structural features of the intron RNAs.

The renaissance of aminoacyl-tRNA synthesis

The role of tRNA as the adaptor in protein synthesis has held an enduring fascination for molecular biologists. Over four decades of study, taking in numerous milestones in molecular biology, led to what was widely held to be a fairly complete picture of how tRNAs and amino acids are paired prior to protein synthesis. However, recent developments in genomics and structural biology have revealed an unexpected array of new enzymes, pathways and mechanisms involved in aminoacyl-tRNA synthesis. As a more complete picture of aminoacyl-tRNA synthesis now begins to emerge, the high degree of evolutionary diversity in this universal and essential process is becoming clearer.

A comprehensive characterization of a group IB intron and its encoded maturase reveals that protein-assisted splicing requires an almost intact intron RNA

The group I intron (AnCOB) of the mitochondrial apocytochrome b gene from Aspergillus nidulans encodes a bi-functional maturase protein that is also a DNA endonuclease. Although the AnCOB intron self-splices, the encoded maturase protein greatly facilitates splicing, in part, by stabilizing RNA tertiary structure. To determine their role in self-splicing and in protein-assisted splicing, several peripheral RNA sub-domains in the 313 nucleotide intron were deleted (P2, P9, P9.1) or truncated (P5ab, P6a). The sequence in two helices (P2 and P9) was also inverted. Except for P9, the deleted regions are not highly conserved among group I introns and are often dispensable for catalytic activity. Nevertheless, despite the very tight binding of AnCOB RNA to the maturase and the high activity of the bimolecular complex (the rate of 5' splice-site cleavage was >20 min(-1) with guanosine as the cofactor), the intron was surprisingly sensitive to these modifications. Several mutations inactivated splicing completely and virtually all impaired splicing to varying degrees. Mutants containing comparatively small deletions in various regions of the intron significantly decreased binding affinity (generally >10(4)-fold), indicating that none of the domains that remained constitutes the primary recognition site of the maturase. The data argue that tight binding requires tertiary interactions that can be maintained by only a relatively intact intron RNA, and that the binding mechanism of the maturase differs from those of two other well-characterized group I intron splicing factors, CYT-18 and Cpb2. A model is proposed in which the protein promotes widespread cooperative folding of an RNA lacking extensive initial tertiary structure.

Interaction of the Neurospora crassa mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (CYT-18 protein) with the group I intron P4-P6 domain. Thermodynamic analysis and the role of metal ions

The Neurospora crassa mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (CYT-18 protein) functions in splicing group I introns by promoting the formation of the catalytically active structure of the intron's catalytic core. Previous studies suggested a model in which the protein binds first to the intron's P4-P6 domain, and then makes additional contacts with the P3-P9 domain to stabilize the two domains in the correct relative orientation to form the intron's active site. Here, we analyzed the interaction of CYT-18 with a small RNA (P4-P6 RNA) corresponding to the isolated P4-P6 domain of the N. crassa mitochondrial large subunit ribosomal RNA intron. RNA footprinting and modification-interference experiments showed that CYT-18 binds to this small RNA around the junction of the P4-P6 stacked helices on the side opposite the active-site cleft, as it does to the P4-P6 domain in the intact intron. The binding is inhibited by chemical modifications that disrupt base-pairing in P4, P6, and P6a, indicating that a partially folded structure of the P4-P6 domain is required. The temperature-dependence of binding indicates that the interaction is driven by a favorable enthalpy change, but is accompanied by an unfavorable entropy change. The latter may reflect entropically unfavorable conformational changes or decreased conformational flexibility in the complex. CYT-18 binding is inhibited at > or =125 mM KCl, indicating a strong dependence on phosphodiester-backbone interactions. On the other hand, Mg(2+) is absolutely required for CYT-18 binding, with titration experiments showing approximately 1.5 magnesium ions bound per complex. Metal ion-cleavage experiments identified a divalent cation-binding site near the boundary of P6 and J6/6a, and chemical modification showed that Mg(2+) binding induces RNA conformational changes in this region, as well as elsewhere, particularly in J4/5. Together, these findings suggest a model in which the binding of Mg(2+) near J6/6a and possibly at one additional location in the P4-P6 RNA induces formation of a specific phosphodiester-backbone geometry that is required for CYT-18 binding. The binding of CYT-18 may then establish the correct structure at the junction of the P4/P6 stacked helices for assembly of the P3-P9 domain. The interaction of CYT-18 with the P4-P6 domain appears similar to the TyrRS interaction with the D-/anticodon arm stacked helices of tRNA(Tyr).

Function of the Neurospora crassa mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase in RNA splicing. Role of the idiosyncratic N-terminal extension and different modes of interaction with different group I introns

The Neurospora crassa mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (CYT-18 protein) promotes the splicing of group I introns by helping the intron RNA fold into the catalytically active structure. The regions required for splicing include an idiosyncratic N-terminal extension, the nucleotide-binding fold domain, and the C-terminal RNA-binding domain. Here, we show that the idiosyncratic N-terminal region is in fact comprised of two functionally distinct parts: an upstream region consisting predominantly of a predicted amphipathic alpha-helix (H0), which is absent from bacterial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetases (TyrRSs), and a downstream region, which contains predicted alpha-helices H1 and H2, corresponding to features in the X-ray crystal structure of the Bacillus stearothermophilus TyrRS. Bacterial genetic assays with libraries of CYT-18 mutants having random mutations in the N-terminal region identified functionally important amino acid residues and supported the predicted structures of the H0 and H1 alpha-helices. The function of N and C-terminal domains of CYT-18 was investigated by detailed biochemical analysis of deletion mutants. The results confirmed that the N-terminal extension is required only for splicing activity, but surprisingly, at least in the case of the N. crassa mitochondrial (mt) large ribosomal subunit (LSU) intron, it appears to act primarily by stabilizing the structure of another region that interacts directly with the intron RNA. The H1/H2 region is required for splicing activity and TyrRS activity with the N. crassa mt tRNA(Tyr), but not for TyrRS activity with Escherichia coli tRNA(Tyr), implying a somewhat different mode of recognition of the two tyrosyl-tRNAs. Finally, a CYT-18 mutant lacking the N-terminal H0 region is totally defective in binding or splicing the N. crassa ND1 intron, but retains substantial residual activity with the mt LSU intron, and conversely, a CYT-18 mutant lacking the C-terminal RNA-binding domain is totally defective in binding or splicing the mt LSU intron, but retains substantial residual activity with the ND1 intron. These findings lead to the surprising conclusion that CYT-18 promotes splicing via different sets of interactions with different group I introns. We suggest that these different modes of promoting splicing evolved from an initial interaction based on the recognition of conserved tRNA-like structural features of the group I intron catalytic core.