Protein-splicing reaction via a thiazolidine intermediate: crystal structure of the VMA1-derived endonuclease bearing the N and C-terminal propeptides

Hedgehog proteins create a dynamic cholesterol interface

During formation of the Hedgehog (Hh) signaling proteins, cooperative activities of the Hedgehog INTein (Hint) fold and Sterol Recognition Region (SRR) couple autoproteolysis to cholesterol ligation. The cholesteroylated Hh morphogens play essential roles in embryogenesis, tissue regeneration, and tumorigenesis. Despite the centrality of cholesterol in Hh function, the full structure of the Hint-SRR ("Hog") domain that attaches cholesterol to the last residue of the active Hh morphogen remains enigmatic. In this work, we combine molecular dynamics simulations, photoaffinity crosslinking, and mutagenesis assays to model cholesterolysis intermediates in the human Sonic Hedgehog (hSHH) protein. Our results provide evidence for a hydrophobic Hint-SRR interface that forms a dynamic, non-covalent cholesterol-Hog complex. Using these models, we suggest a unified mechanism by which Hh proteins can recruit, sequester, and orient cholesterol, and offer a molecular basis for the effects of disease-causing hSHH mutations.

Structural, Dynamic, and Functional Characterization of a DnaX Mini-intein Derived from Spirulina platensis Provides Important Insights into Intein-Mediated Catalysis of Protein Splicing

Protein splicing is a self-catalyzed post-translational modification in which the intein enzyme excises itself from a precursor protein and ligates the flanking sequences to produce a mature protein. We report the solution structure of a 136-residue DnaX mini-intein enzyme derived from the cyanobacterium Spirulina platensis. This sequence adopts a well-defined globular structure and forms a horseshoe-shaped fold commonly found in the HINT (hedgehog intein) topology. Backbone dynamics and hydrogen exchange experiments revealed conserved motions on various time scales, which is proposed to be a characteristic of the intein fold. Interestingly, several dynamic motions were found in symmetrically equivalent positions within the protein structure, which might be a consequence of the symmetrical intein fold. In cell splicing activity showed that Spl DnaX mini-intein is a highly active enzyme. The precursor protein was not detected at any timepoint of the assay. Apart from the splicing reaction, catalytic cleavage at the N- and C-termini of the precursor protein was also observed. To determine the roles of the catalytic residues in splicing and cleavage reactions, all combinations of alanine mutations of these residues were generated and functionally characterized. This in-depth analysis revealed cooperativity between these catalytic residues, which suppresses the N- and C-terminal cleavage reactions and enhances the yield of the spliced product. Overall, this study provides a thorough structural, dynamic, and functional characterization of a new intein sequence and adds to the collection of these unique enzymes that have found tremendous applications in biochemistry and biotechnology.

The Convergence of the Hedgehog/Intein Fold in Different Protein Splicing Mechanisms

Protein splicing catalyzed by inteins utilizes many different combinations of amino-acid types at active sites. Inteins have been classified into three classes based on their characteristic sequences. We investigated the structural basis of the protein splicing mechanism of class 3 inteins by determining crystal structures of variants of a class 3 intein from Mycobacterium chimaera and molecular dynamics simulations, which suggested that the class 3 intein utilizes a different splicing mechanism from that of class 1 and 2 inteins. The class 3 intein uses a bond cleavage strategy reminiscent of proteases but share the same Hedgehog/INTein (HINT) fold of other intein classes. Engineering of class 3 inteins from a class 1 intein indicated that a class 3 intein would unlikely evolve directly from a class 1 or 2 intein. The HINT fold appears as structural and functional solution for trans-peptidyl and trans-esterification reactions commonly exploited by diverse mechanisms using different combinations of amino-acid types for the active-site residues.

The crystal structure of the naturally split gp41-1 intein guides the engineering of orthogonal split inteins from cis-splicing inteins

Protein trans-splicing catalyzed by split inteins has increasingly become useful as a protein engineering tool. We solved the 1.0 Å-resolution crystal structure of a fused variant from the naturally split gp41-1 intein, previously identified from environmental metagenomic sequence data. The structure of the 125-residue gp41-1 intein revealed a compact pseudo-C2-symmetry commonly found in the Hedgehog/Intein superfamily with extensive charge-charge interactions between the split N- and C-terminal intein fragments that are common among naturally occurring split inteins. We successfully created orthogonal split inteins by engineering a similar charge network into the same region of a cis-splicing intein. This strategy could be applicable for creating novel natural-like split inteins from other, more prevalent cis-splicing inteins. DATABASE: Structural data are available in the RCSB Protein Data Bank under the accession number 6QAZ.

Twenty-five years of nomenclature and classification of proteolytic enzymes

Proteolytic enzymes and their homologues have been classified into clans by comparing the tertiary structures of the peptidase domains, into families by comparing the protein sequences of the peptidase domains, and into protein-species by comparing various attributes including domain architecture, substrate preference, inhibitor interactions, subcellular location, and phylogeny. The results are compared with the earlier classification (Rawlings and Barrett, 1993 [1]). The numbers of sequences, protein-species, families, clans and even catalytic type have substantially increased during the intervening 26 years. The alternative classifications by catalytic type and/or activity are shown not to reflect evolutionary relationships.

Crystal structures of CDC21-1 inteins from hyperthermophilic archaea reveal the selection mechanism for the highly conserved homing endonuclease insertion site

Self-splicing inteins are mobile genetic elements invading host genes via nested homing endonuclease (HEN) domains. All HEN domains residing within inteins are inserted at a highly conserved insertion site. A purifying selection mechanism directing the location of the HEN insertion site has not yet been identified. In this work, we solved the three-dimensional crystal structures of two inteins inserted in the cell division control protein 21 of the hyperthermophilic archaea Pyrococcus abyssi and Pyrococcus horikoshii. A comparison between the structures provides the structural basis for the thermo-stabilization mechanism of inteins that have lost the HEN domain during evolution. The presence of an entire extein domain in the intein structure from Pyrococcus horikoshii suggests the selection mechanism for the highly conserved HEN insertion point.

Structure of an engineered intein reveals thiazoline ring and provides mechanistic insight

We have engineered an intein which spontaneously and reversibly forms a thiazoline ring at the native N-terminal Lys-Cys splice junction. We identified conditions to stablize the thiazoline ring and provided the first crystallographic evidence, at 1.54 Å resolution, for its existence at an intein active site. The finding bolsters evidence for a tetrahedral oxythiazolidine splicing intermediate. In addition, the pivotal mutation maps to a highly conserved B-block threonine, which is now seen to play a causative role not only in ground-state destabilization of the scissile N-terminal peptide bond, but also in steering the tetrahedral intermediate toward thioester formation, giving new insight into the splicing mechanism. We demonstrated the stability of the thiazoline ring at neutral pH as well as sensitivity to hydrolytic ring opening under acidic conditions. A pH cycling strategy to control N-terminal cleavage is proposed, which may be of interest for biotechnological applications requiring a splicing activity switch, such as for protein recovery in bioprocessing.

Structural Insights into Subunits Assembly and the Oxyester Splicing Mechanism of Neq pol Split Intein

Split inteins are expressed as two separated subunits (N-intein and C-intein) fused to the corresponding exteins. The specific association of both intein subunits precedes protein splicing, which results in excision of the intein subunits and in ligation, by a peptide bond, of the concomitant exteins. Catalytically active intein precursors are typically too reactive for crystallization or even isolation. Neq pol is the trans-intein of the B-type DNA polymerase I split gene from hyperthermophile Nanoarchaeum equitans. We have determined the crystal structures of both the isolated NeqN and the complex of NeqN and NeqC subunits carrying the wild-type sequences, including the essential catalytic residues Ser1 and Thr+1, in addition to seven and three residues of the N- and C-exteins, respectively. These structures provide detailed information on the unique oxyester chemistry of the splicing mechanism of Neq pol and of the extensive rearrangements that occur in NeqN during the association step.

Structural Basis for the Persistence of Homing Endonucleases in Transcription Factor IIB Inteins

Inteins are mobile genetic elements that are spliced out of proteins after translation. Some inteins contain a homing endonuclease (HEN) responsible for their propagation. Hedgehog/INTein (HINT) domains catalyzing protein splicing and their nested HEN domains are thought to be functionally independent because of the existence of functional mini-inteins without HEN domains. Despite the lack of obvious mutualism between HEN and HINT domains, HEN domains are persistently found at one specific site in inteins, indicating their potential functional role in protein splicing. Here we report crystal structures of inactive and active mini-inteins derived from inteins residing in the transcription factor IIB of Methanococcus jannaschii and Methanocaldococcus vulcanius, revealing a novel modified HINT fold that might provide new insights into the mutualism between the HEN and HINT domains. We propose an evolutionary model of inteins and a functional role of HEN domains in inteins.

Coordination of the third step of protein splicing in two cyanobacterial inteins

The third step of protein splicing is cyclization of Asn coupled to peptide bond cleavage. In two related cyanobacterial inteins, this step is facilitated by Asn or Gln. For a Synechococcus sp. PCC7002 intein, the isolated third step of protein splicing is more efficient with its native Asn than with substitution to Gln. For a Trichodesmium erythraeum intein, its native Gln facilitates the third step as efficiently as with Asn. Despite these differences, the yield of splicing is not affected, suggesting that the third step is influenced by mechanism-linked conformational changes. A conserved catalytic His and the penultimate residue also play roles in promoting side-chain cyclization.

An Unprecedented Combination of Serine and Cysteine Nucleophiles in a Split Intein with an Atypical Split Site

Protein splicing mediated by inteins is a self-processive reaction leading to the excision of the internal intein domain from a precursor protein and the concomitant ligation of the flanking sequences, the extein-N and extein-C parts, thereby reconstituting the host protein. Most inteins employ a splicing pathway in which the upstream scissile peptide bond is consecutively rearranged into two thioester or oxoester intermediates before intein excision and rearrangement into the new peptide bond occurs. The catalytically critical amino acids involved at the two splice junctions are cysteine, serine, or threonine. Notably, the only potential combination not observed so far in any of the known or engineered inteins corresponds to the transesterification from an oxoester to a thioester, which suggested that this formal uphill reaction with regard to the thermodynamic stability might be incompatible with intein-mediated catalysis. We show that corresponding mutations also led to inactive gp41-1 and AceL-TerL inteins. We report the novel GOS-TerL split intein identified from metagenomic databases as the first intein harboring the combination of Ser1 and Cys+1 residues. Mutational analysis showed that its efficient splicing reaction indeed follows the shift from oxoester to thioester and thus represents a rare diversion from the canonical pathway. Furthermore, the GOS-TerL intein has an atypical split site close to the N terminus. The Int(N) fragment could be shortened from 37 to 28 amino acids and exchanged with the 25-amino acid Int(N) fragment from the AceL-TerL intein, indicating a high degree of promiscuity of the Int(C) fragment of the GOS-TerL intein.

Protein splicing: how inteins escape from precursor proteins

Inteins are nature's escape artists; they facilitate their excision from flanking polypeptides (exteins) concomitant with extein ligation to produce a mature host protein. Splicing requires sequential nucleophilic displacement reactions catalyzed by strategies similar to proteases and asparagine lyases. Inteins require precise reaction coordination rather than rapid turnover or tight substrate binding because they are single turnover enzymes with covalently linked substrates. This has allowed inteins to explore alternative mechanisms with different steps or to use different methods for activation and coordination of the steps. Pressing issues include understanding the underlying details of catalysis and how the splicing steps are controlled.

Internal disulfide bond acts as a switch for intein activity

Inteins are intervening polypeptides that catalyze their own removal from flanking exteins, concomitant to the ligation of the exteins. The intein that interrupts the DP2 (large) subunit of DNA polymerase II from Methanoculleus marisnigri (Mma) can promote protein splicing. However, protein splicing can be prevented or reduced by overexpression under nonreducing conditions because of the formation of a disulfide bond between two internal intein Cys residues. This redox sensitivity leads to differential activity in different strains of E. coli as well as in different cell compartments. The redox-dependent control of in vivo protein splicing in an intein derived from an anaerobe that can occupy multiple environments hints at a possible physiological role for protein splicing.

Recent progress in intein research: from mechanism to directed evolution and applications

Inteins catalyze a post-translational modification known as protein splicing, where the intein removes itself from a precursor protein and concomitantly ligates the flanking protein sequences with a peptide bond. Over the past two decades, inteins have risen from a peculiarity to a rich source of applications in biotechnology, biomedicine, and protein chemistry. In this review, we focus on developments of intein-related research spanning the last 5 years, including the three different splicing mechanisms and their molecular underpinnings, the directed evolution of inteins towards improved splicing in exogenous protein contexts, as well as novel applications of inteins for cell biology and protein engineering, which were made possible by a clearer understanding of the protein splicing mechanism.

NMR and crystal structures of the Pyrococcus horikoshii RadA intein guide a strategy for engineering a highly efficient and promiscuous intein

In protein splicing, an intervening protein sequence (intein) in the host protein excises itself out and ligates two split host protein sequences (exteins) to produce a mature host protein. Inteins require the involvement for the splicing of the first residue of the extein that follows the intein (which is Cys, Ser, or Thr). Other extein residues near the splicing junctions could modulate splicing efficiency even when they are not directly involved in catalysis. Mutual interdependence between this molecular parasite (intein) and its host protein (exteins) is not beneficial for intein spread but could be advantageous for intein survival during evolution. Elucidating extein-intein dependency has increasingly become important since inteins are recognized as useful biotechnological tools for protein ligation. We determined the structures of one of inteins with high splicing efficiency, the RadA intein from Pyrococcus horikoshii (PhoRadA). The solution NMR structure and the crystal structures elucidated the structural basis for its high efficiency and directed our efforts of engineering that led to rational design of a functional minimized RadA intein. The crystal structure of the minimized RadA intein also revealed the precise interactions between N-extein and the intein. We systematically analyzed the effects at the -1 position of N-extein and were able to significantly improve the splicing efficiency of a less robust splicing variant by eliminating the unfavorable extein-intein interactions observed in the structure. This work provides an example of how unveiling structure-function relationships of inteins offer a promising way of improving their properties as better tools for protein engineering.

The Thermococcus kodakaraensis Tko CDC21-1 intein activates its N-terminal splice junction in the absence of a conserved histidine by a compensatory mechanism

Inteins and other self-catalytic enzymes, such as glycosylasparaginases and hedgehog precursors, initiate autocleavage by converting a peptide bond to a (thio)ester bond when Ser, Thr, or Cys undergoes an N-[S/O] acyl migration assisted by residues within the precursor. Previous studies have shown that a His at position 10 in intein Block B is essential for this initial acyl migration and N-terminal splice junction cleavage. This His is present in all inteins identified to date except the Thermococcus kodakaraensis Tko CDC21-1 intein orthologs and the inactive Arthrobacter species FB24 Arth_1007 intein. This study demonstrates that the Tko CDC21-1 intein is fully active and has replaced the lost catalytic function normally provided by the Block B His using a compensatory mechanism involving a conserved ortholog-specific basic residue (Lys(58)) present outside the standard intein conserved motifs. We propose that Lys(58) catalyzes the initial N-S acyl migration by stabilizing the thiazolidine-tetrahedral intermediate, allowing it to be resolved by water-mediated hydrolysis rather than by protonating the leaving group as His is theorized to do in many other inteins. Autoprocessing enzymes may have more flexibility in evolving catalytic variations because high reaction rates are not required when performing single-turnover reactions on "substrates" that are covalently attached to the enzyme. Consequently, inteins have more flexibility to sample catalytic mechanisms, providing insight into various strategies that enzymes use to accomplish catalysis.

Intramolecular disulfide bond between catalytic cysteines in an intein precursor

Protein splicing is a self-catalyzed and spontaneous post-translational process in which inteins excise themselves out of precursor proteins while the exteins are ligated together. We report the first discovery of an intramolecular disulfide bond between the two active-site cysteines, Cys1 and Cys+1, in an intein precursor composed of the hyperthermophilic Pyrococcus abyssi PolII intein and extein. The existence of this intramolecular disulfide bond is demonstrated by the effect of reducing agents on the precursor, mutagenesis, and liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) with tandem MS (MS/MS) of the tryptic peptide containing the intramolecular disulfide bond. The disulfide bond inhibits protein splicing, and splicing can be induced by reducing agents such as tris(2-carboxyethyl)phosphine (TCEP). The stability of the intramolecular disulfide bond is enhanced by electrostatic interactions between the N- and C-exteins but is reduced by elevated temperature. The presence of this intramolecular disulfide bond may contribute to the redox control of splicing activity in hypoxia and at low temperature and point to the intriguing possibility that inteins may act as switches to control extein function.

Probing intein-catalyzed thioester formation by unnatural amino acid substitutions in the active site

Inteins are single-turnover catalysts that splice themselves out of a precursor polypeptide chain. For most inteins, the first step of protein splicing is the formation of a thioester through an N-S acyl shift at the upstream splice junction. However, the mechanism by which this reaction is achieved and the impact of mutations in and close to the active site remain unclear on the atomic level. To investigate these questions, we have further explored a split variant of the Ssp DnaB intein by introducing substitutions with unnatural amino acids within the short synthetic N-terminal fragment. A previously reported collapse of the oxythiazolidine anion intermediate into a thiazoline ring was found to be specificially dependent on the methyl side chain of the flanking Ala(-1). The stereoisomer d-Ala and the constitutional isomers β-Ala and sarcosine did not lead to this side reaction but rather supported splicing. Substitution of the catalytic Cys1 with homocysteine strongly inhibited protein splicing; however, thioester formation was not impaired. These results argue against the requirement of a base to deprotonate the catalytic thiol group prior to the N-S acyl shift, because it should be misaligned for optimal proton abstraction. A previously described mutant intein evolved for more general splicing in different sequence contexts could even rather efficiently splice with this homocysteine. Our findings show the large impact of some subtle structural changes on the protein splicing pathway, but also the remarkable tolerance toward other changes. Such insights will also be important for the biotechnological exploitation of inteins.

Branched intermediate formation is the slowest step in the protein splicing reaction of the Ala1 KlbA intein from Methanococcus jannaschii

We report the first detailed investigation of the kinetics of protein splicing by the Methanococcus jannaschii KlbA (Mja KlbA) intein. This intein has an N-terminal Ala in place of the nucleophilic Cys or Ser residue that normally initiates splicing but nevertheless splices efficiently in vivo [Southworth, M. W., Benner, J., and Perler, F. B. (2000) EMBO J.19, 5019-5026]. To date, the spontaneous nature of the cis splicing reaction has hindered its examination in vitro. For this reason, we constructed an Mja KlbA intein-mini-extein precursor using intein-mediated protein ligation and engineered a disulfide redox switch that permits initiation of the splicing reaction by the addition of a reducing agent such as dithiothreitol (DTT). A fluorescent tag at the C-terminus of the C-extein permits monitoring of the progress of the reaction. Kinetic analysis of the splicing reaction of the wild-type precursor (with no substitutions in known nucleophiles or assisting groups) at various DTT concentrations shows that formation of the branched intermediate from the precursor is reversible (forward rate constant of 1.5 × 10(-3) s(-1) and reverse rate constant of 1.7 × 10(-5) s(-1) at 42 °C), whereas the productive decay of this intermediate to form the ligated exteins is faster and occurs with a rate constant of 2.2 × 10(-3) s(-1). This finding conflicts with reports about standard inteins, for which Asn cyclization has been assigned as the rate-determining step of the splicing reaction. Despite being the slowest step of the reaction, branched intermediate formation in the Mja KlbA intein is efficient in comparison with those of other intein systems. Interestingly, it also appears that this intermediate is protected against thiolysis by DTT, in contrast to other inteins. Evidence is presented in support of a tight coupling between the N-terminal and C-terminal cleavage steps, despite the fact that the C-terminal single-cleavage reaction occurs in variant Mja KlbA inteins in the absence of N-terminal cleavage. We posit that the splicing events in the Mja KlbA system are tightly coordinated by a network of intra- and interdomain noncovalent interactions, rendering its function particularly sensitive to minor disruptions in the intein or extein environments.

Structural and mutational studies of a hyperthermophilic intein from DNA polymerase II of Pyrococcus abyssi

Protein splicing is a precise self-catalyzed process in which an intein excises itself from a precursor with the concomitant ligation of the flanking polypeptides (exteins). Protein splicing proceeds through a four-step reaction but the catalytic mechanism is not fully understood at the atomic level. We report the solution NMR structures of the hyperthermophilic Pyrococcus abyssi PolII intein, which has a noncanonical C-terminal glutamine instead of an asparagine. The NMR structures were determined to a backbone root mean square deviation of 0.46 Å and a heavy atom root mean square deviation of 0.93 Å. The Pab PolII intein has a common HINT (hedgehog intein) fold but contains an extra β-hairpin that is unique in the structures of thermophilic inteins. The NMR structures also show that the Pab PolII intein has a long and disordered loop in place of an endonuclease domain. The N-terminal Cys-1 amide is hydrogen bonded to the Thr-90 hydroxyl in the conserved block-B TXXH motif and the Cys-1 thiol forms a hydrogen bond with the block F Ser-166. Mutating Thr-90 to Ala dramatically slows N-terminal cleavage, supporting its pivotal role in promoting the N-S acyl shift. Mutagenesis also showed that Thr-90 and His-93 are synergistic in catalyzing the N-S acyl shift. The block F Ser-166 plays an important role in coordinating the steps of protein splicing. NMR spin relaxation indicates that the Pab PolII intein is significantly more rigid than mesophilic inteins, which may contribute to the higher optimal temperature for protein splicing.

Intein lacking conserved C-terminal motif G retains controllable N-cleavage activity

A split-intein consists of two complementary fragments (N-intein and C-intein) that can associate to carry out protein trans-splicing. The Ssp GyrB S11 split-intein is an engineered unconventional split-intein consisting of a 150-amino-acid N-intein and an extremely small six-amino-acid C-intein, which comprises the conserved intein motif G. Here, we show that fusion proteins containing the 150-amino-acid N-intein could be triggered to undergo controllable N-cleavage in vitro when the six-amino-acid C-intein or a derivative thereof was added as a synthetic peptide in trans. More importantly, we discovered, unexpectedly, that the 150-amino-acid N-intein could be induced by strong nucleophiles to undergo N-cleavage in vitro, and in Escherichia coli cells, in the absence of the motif G-containing six-amino-acid C-intein. This finding indicated that the first step of the protein splicing mechanism (acyl shift) could occur in the absence of the entire motif G. Extensive kinetic analyses revealed that both the motif G residues and the Ser+1 residue positively influenced N-cleavage rate constants and yields. The 150-amino-acid N-intein could also tolerate various unrelated sequences appended to its C-terminus without disruption of the N-cleavage function, suggesting that the catalytic pocket of the intein has considerable structural flexibility. Our findings reveal interesting insights into intein structure-function relationships, and demonstrate a new and potentially more useful method of controllable, intein-mediated N-cleavage for protein engineering applications.

Spontaneous C-cleavage of a mini-intein without its conserved N-terminal motif A

Previously, the C-terminal fragment of a split intein was known to undergo controllable C-cleavage at its C-terminus only when the N-terminal fragment of the intein was added. Here we constructed a similar split intein from the Ssp DnaX intein, but we unexpectedly observed that its C-terminal 136-aa fragment could undergo spontaneous C-cleavage without the N-terminal fragment that was up to 15 aa long and contained the conserved intein motif A. This C-cleavage activity was significantly decreased by a mutation of the conserved Thr residue in the conserved intein motif B. These findings suggest a robust intein structure in the absence of motif A and a larger role of motif B in the third step of the protein splicing mechanism.

pK(a) coupling at the intein active site: implications for the coordination mechanism of protein splicing with a conserved aspartate

Protein splicing is a robust multistep posttranslational process catalyzed by inteins. In the Mtu RecA intein, a conserved block-F aspartate (D422) coordinates different steps in protein splicing, but the precise mechanism is unclear. Solution NMR shows that D422 has a strikingly high pK(a) of 6.1, two units above the normal pK(a) of aspartate. The elevated pK(a) of D422 is coupled to the depressed pK(a) of another active-site residue, the block-A cysteine (C1). A C1A mutation lowers the D422 pK(a) to normal, while a D422G mutation increases the C1 pK(a) from 7.5 to 8.5. The pK(a) coupling and NMR structure determination demonstrate that protonated D422 serves as a hydrogen bond donor to stabilize the C1 thiolate and promote the N-S acyl shift, the first step of protein splicing. Additionally, in vivo splicing assays with mutations of D422 to Glu, Cys, and Ser show that the deprotonated aspartate is essential for splicing, most likely by deprotonating and activating the downstream nucleophile in transesterification, the second step of protein splicing. We propose that the sequential protonation and deprotonation of the D422 side chain is the coordination mechanism for the first two steps of protein splicing.

Protein trans-splicing as a protein ligation tool to study protein structure and function

Protein trans-splicing (PTS) exerted by split inteins is a protein ligation reaction which enables overcoming the barriers of conventional heterologous protein production. We provide an overview of the current state-of-the-art in split intein engineering, as well as the achievements of PTS technology in the realm of protein structure-function analyses, including incorporation of natural and artificial protein modifications, controllable protein reconstitution, segmental isotope labeling and protein cyclization. We further discuss factors crucial for the successful implementation of PTS in these protein engineering approaches, and speculate on necessary future endeavours to make PTS a universally applicable protein ligation tool.

Electronic structure of neighboring extein residue modulates intein C-terminal cleavage activity

Protein splicing is an autocatalytic reaction where an intervening element (intein) is excised and the remaining two flanking sequences (exteins) are joined. The reaction requires specific conserved residues, and activity may be affected by both the intein and the extein sequence. Predicting how sequence will affect activity is a challenging task. Based on first-principles density functional theory and multiscale quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics, we report C-terminal cleavage reaction rates for five mutations at the first residue of the C-extein (+1), and describe molecular properties that may be used as predictors for future mutations. Independently, we report on experimental characterization of the same set of mutations at the +1 residue resulting in a wide range of C-terminal cleavage activities. With some exceptions, there is general agreement between computational rates and experimental cleavage, giving molecular insight into previous claims that the +1 extein residue affects intein catalysis. These data suggest utilization of attenuating +1 mutants for intein-mediated protein manipulations because they facilitate precursor accumulation in vivo for standard purification schemes. A more detailed analysis of the "+1 effect" will also help to predict sequence-defined effects on insertion points of the intein into proteins of interest.

Cloning, expression, purification, crystallization and preliminary X-ray diffraction data of the Pyrococcus horikoshii RadA intein

The RadA intein from the hyperthermophilic archaebacterium Pyrococcus horikoshii was cloned, expressed and purified for subsequent structure determination. The protein crystallized rapidly in several conditions. The best crystals, which diffracted to 1.75 Å resolution, were harvested from drops consisting of 0.1 M HEPES pH 7.5, 3.0 M NaCl and were cryoprotected with Paratone-N before flash-cooling. The collected data were processed in the orthorhombic space group P2(1)2(1)2(1), with unit-cell parameters a = 58.1, b = 67.4, c = 82.9 Å. Molecular replacement with Rosetta using energy- and density-guided structure optimization provided the initial solution, which is currently under refinement.

Expanding the definition of class 3 inteins and their proposed phage origin

Inteins are the protein equivalent of introns. Their protein splicing activity is essential for the host protein's maturation and function. Inteins are grouped into three classes based on sequence signature and splicing mechanism. The sequence signature of the recently characterized class 3 inteins is a noncontiguous Trp-Cys-Thr (WCT) motif and the absence of the standard class 1 Cys¹ or Ser¹ N-terminal nucleophile. The intein N-terminal Cys¹ or Ser¹ residue is essential for splicing in class 1 inteins. The mycobacteriophage Catera Gp206, Nocardioides sp. strain JS614 TOPRIM, and Thermobifida fusca YX Tfu2914 inteins have a mixture of class 1 and class 3 motifs. They carry the class 3 Trp-Cys-Thr motif and have the standard class 1 N-terminal Ser¹ or Cys¹. This study determined which class the mycobacteriophage Catera Gp206 and Nocardioides sp. JS614 TOPRIM inteins belong to based on catalytic mechanism. The mycobacteriophage Catera Gp206 intein (starting with Ser¹) is a class 3 intein, and its Ser¹ residue is not required for splicing. Based on phylogenetic analysis, we propose that class 3 inteins arose from a single mutated intein that was spread by phage into predominantly helicase genes in various phages and their hosts.

The Deinococcus radiodurans Snf2 intein caught in the act: detection of the Class 3 intein signature Block F branched intermediate

Inteins are the protein equivalent of introns. They are remarkable and robust single turnover enzymes that splice out of precursor proteins during post-translational maturation of the host protein (extein). The Deinococcus radiodurans Snf2 intein is the second member of the recently discovered Class 3 subfamily of inteins to be characterized. Class 3 inteins have a unique sequence signature: (a) they start with residues other than the standard Class 1 Cys, Ser or Thr, (b) have a noncontiguous, centrally located Trp/Cys/Thr triplet, and (c) all but one have Ser or Thr at the start of the C-extein instead of the more common Cys. We previously proposed that Class 3 inteins splice by a variation in the standard intein-mediated protein splicing mechanism that includes a novel initiating step leading to the formation of a previously unrecognized branched intermediate. In this mechanism defined with the Class 3 prototypic Mycobacteriophage Bethlehem DnaB intein, the triplet Cys attacks the peptide bond at the N-terminal splice junction to form the class specific branched intermediate after which the N-extein is transferred to the side chain of the Ser, Thr, or Cys at the C-terminal splice junction to form the standard intein branched intermediate. Analysis of the Deinococcus radiodurans Snf2 intein confirms this splicing mechanism. Moreover, the Class 3 specific Block F branched intermediate was isolated, providing the first direct proof of its existence.

Mechanism of protein splicing of the Pyrococcus abyssi lon protease intein

Protein splicing is a post-translational process by which an intervening polypeptide, the intein, excises itself from the flanking polypeptides, the exteins, coupled to ligation of the exteins. The lon protease of Pyrococcus abyssi (Pab) is interrupted by an intein. When over-expressed as a fusion protein in Escherichia coli, the Pab lon protease intein can promote efficient protein splicing. Mutations that block individual steps of splicing generally do not lead to unproductive side reactions, suggesting that the intein tightly coordinates the splicing process. The intein can splice, although it has Lys in place of the highly conserved penultimate His, and mutants of the intein in the C-terminal region lead to the accumulation of stable branched-ester intermediate.

Branched intermediate formation stimulates peptide bond cleavage in protein splicing

Protein splicing is a posttranslational modification in which an intein domain excises itself out of a host protein. Here, we investigate how the steps in the splicing process are coordinated so as to maximize the production of the final splice products and minimize the generation of undesired cleavage products. Our approach has been to prepare a branched intermediate (and analogs thereof) of the Mxe GyrA intein using protein semi-synthesis. Kinetic analysis of these molecules indicates that the high fidelity of this protein splicing reaction results from the penultimate step in the process (intein-succinimide formation) being rate-limiting. NMR experiments indicate that formation of the branched intermediate affects the local structure around the amide bond cleaved during succinimide formation. We propose that this structural change reflects a re-organization of the catalytic apparatus to accelerate succinimide formation at the C-terminal splice junction.

Splicing of the mycobacteriophage Bethlehem DnaB intein: identification of a new mechanistic class of inteins that contain an obligate block F nucleophile

Inteins are single turnover enzymes that splice out of protein precursors during maturation of the host protein (extein). The Cys or Ser at the N terminus of most inteins initiates a four-step protein splicing reaction by forming a (thio)ester bond at the N-terminal splice junction. Several recently identified inteins cannot perform this acyl rearrangement because they do not begin with Cys, Thr, or Ser. This study analyzes one of these, the mycobacteriophage Bethlehem DnaB intein, which we describe here as the prototype for a new class of inteins based on sequence comparisons, reactivity, and mechanism. These Class 3 inteins are characterized by a non-nucleophilic N-terminal residue that co-varies with a non-contiguous Trp, Cys, Thr triplet (WCT) and a Thr or Ser as the first C-extein residue. Several mechanistic differences were observed when compared with standard inteins or previously studied atypical KlbA Ala¹ inteins: (a) cleavage at the N-terminal splice junction in the absence of all standard N- and C-terminal splice junction nucleophiles, (b) activation of the N-terminal splice junction by a variant Block B motif that includes the WCT triplet Trp, (c) decay of the branched intermediate by thiols or Cys despite an ester linkage at the C-extein branch point, and (d) an absolute requirement for the WCT triplet Block F Cys. Based on biochemical data and confirmed by molecular modeling, we propose roles for these newly identified conserved residues, a novel protein splicing mechanism that includes a second branched intermediate, and an intein classification with three mechanistic categories.

Highly conserved histidine plays a dual catalytic role in protein splicing: a pKa shift mechanism

Protein splicing is a precise autocatalytic process in which an intein excises itself from a precursor with the concomitant ligation of the flanking sequences. Protein splicing occurs through acid-base catalysis in which the ionization states of active site residues are crucial to the reaction mechanism. In inteins, several conserved histidines have been shown to play important roles in protein splicing, including the most conserved "B-block" histidine. In this study, we have combined NMR pK(a) determination with quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) modeling to study engineered inteins from Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtu) RecA intein. We demonstrate a dramatic pK(a) shift for the invariant B-block histidine, the most conserved residue among inteins. The B-block histidine has a pK(a) of 7.3 +/- 0.6 in a precursor and a pK(a) of <3.5 in a spliced intein. The pK(a) values and QM/MM data suggest that the B-block histidine has a dual role in the acid-base catalysis of protein splicing. This histidine likely acts as a general base to initiate splicing with an acyl shift and then as a general acid to cause the breakdown of the scissile bond at the N-terminal splicing junction. The proposed pK(a) shift mechanism accounts for the biochemical data supporting the essential role for the B-block histidine and for the near absolute sequence conservation of this residue.

Reflections on protein splicing: structures, functions and mechanisms

Twenty years ago, evidence that one gene produces two enzymes via protein splicing emerged from structural and expression studies of the VMA1 gene in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. VMA1 consists of a single open reading frame and contains two independent genetic information for Vma1p (a catalytic 70-kDa subunit of the vacuolar H(+)-ATPase) and VDE (a 50-kDa DNA endonuclease) as an in-frame spliced insert in the gene. Protein splicing is a posttranslational cellular process, in which an intervening polypeptide termed as the VMA1 intein is self-catalytically excised out from a nascent 120-kDa VMA1 precursor and two flanking polypeptides of the N- and C-exteins are ligated to produce the mature Vma1p. Subsequent studies have demonstrated that protein splicing is not unique to the VMA1 precursor and there are many operons in nature, which implement genetic information editing at protein level. To elucidate its structure-directed chemical mechanisms, a series of biochemical and crystal structural studies has been carried out with the use of various VMA1 recombinants. This article summarizes a VDE-mediated self-catalytic mechanism for protein splicing that is triggered and terminated solely via thiazolidine intermediates with tetrahedral configurations formed within the splicing sites where proton ingress and egress are driven by balanced protonation and deprotonation.

Interaction studies and alanine scanning analysis of a semi-synthetic split intein reveal thiazoline ring formation from an intermediate of the protein splicing reaction

We recently reported an artificially split intein based on the Ssp DnaB mini-intein that consists of a synthetic N-terminal intein fragment (Int(N)) and a recombinant C-terminal part (Int(C)), which are 11 and 143 amino acids in length, respectively. This intein holds great promise for the preparation of semi-synthetic proteins by protein trans-splicing. In this work we synthesized a set of Int(N) peptide variants to investigate their structure-function relationship with regard to fragment association and promotion of protein trans-splicing. A further truncation of the Int(N) sequence below 11 amino acids resulted in loss of activity, whereas C-terminal extensions were tolerated. Alanine scanning analysis identified three essential hydrophobic residues, whereas substitutions at other positions were tolerated. We developed assays to monitor association of Int(N) with an Int(C) mutant blocked in protein splicing by native PAGE and fluorescence anisotropy. The kinetic parameters of intein complex formation were K(d) = 1.1 mum, k(on) = 16.8 m(-1) s(-1), and k(off) = 1.8 x 10(-5) s(-1) for the native Int(N11) sequence. Intriguingly, a G(-1)A substitution, previously known to significantly impair protein splicing, was revealed to result in thiazoline ring formation involving the catalytic Cys-1, likely by aberrant dehydration of a oxythiazolidine intermediate. This finding provides experimental evidence for the postulated intermediate during the initial N/S acyl shift and underlines the delicate spatial and temporal alignment required in the intein active site to prevent side reactions of the protein-splicing pathway.

NMR structure of a KlbA intein precursor from Methanococcus jannaschii

Certain proteins of unicellular organisms are translated as precursor polypeptides containing inteins (intervening proteins), which are domains capable of performing protein splicing. These domains, in conjunction with a single residue following the intein, catalyze their own excision from the surrounding protein (extein) in a multistep reaction involving the cleavage of two intein-extein peptide bonds and the formation of a new peptide bond that ligates the two exteins to yield the mature protein. We report here the solution NMR structure of a 186-residue precursor of the KlbA intein from Methanococcus jannaschii, comprising the intein together with N- and C-extein segments of 7 and 11 residues, respectively. The intein is shown to adopt a single, well-defined globular domain, representing a HINT (Hedgehog/Intein)-type topology. Fourteen beta-strands are arranged in a complex fold that includes four beta-hairpins and an antiparallel beta-ribbon, and there is one alpha-helix, which is packed against the beta-ribbon, and one turn of 3(10)-helix in the loop between the beta-strands 8 and 9. The two extein segments show increased disorder, and form only minimal nonbonding contacts with the intein domain. Structure-based mutation experiments resulted in a proposal for functional roles of individual residues in the intein catalytic mechanism.

Preceding hydrophobic and beta-branched amino acids attenuate splicing by the CnePRP8 intein

As the Cne PRP8 intein is active and exists in an essential gene of an important fungal pathogen, inhibitors of splicing and assays for intein activity are of interest. The self-splicing activity of Cne PRP8, the intein from the Prp8 gene of Cryptococcus neoformans, was assessed in different heterologous fusion proteins expressed in Escherichia coli. Placement of a putatively inactive variant of the intein adjacent to the alpha-complementation peptide abolished the peptide's ability to restore beta-galactosidase activity, while an active variant allowed complementation. This alpha-complementation peptide therefore provides a facile assay of splicing which can be used to test potential inhibitors. When placed between two heterologous protein domains, splicing was impaired by a beta-branched amino acid immediately preceding the intein, while splicing occurred only with a hydroxyl or thiol immediately following the intein. Both these assays sensitively report impairment of splicing and provide information on how context constrains the splicing ability of Cne PRP8.

Sequence requirements for splicing by the Cne PRP8 intein

The dependence of protein splicing on conserved residues of the Cne PRP8 intein was assessed by alanine scanning mutagenesis in a foreign protein context. Corroboration was obtained for the involvement of residues at the splice junctions and of the conserved threonine and histidine of motif B. Five additional residues were identified as absolutely required for splicing. Variant W151A displayed premature C-terminal cleavage, not seen with other Cne PRP8 mutants. We propose a model whereby W151 acts to prevent premature C-terminal cleavage, favoring complete splicing as opposed to two disjointed cleavage events.

Protein splicing in cis and in trans

Intein-mediated protein splicing is a self-catalytic process in which the intervening intein sequence is removed from a precursor protein and the flanking extein segments are ligated with a native peptide bond. Splice junction proximal residues and internal residues within the intein direct these reactions. The identity of these residues varies in each intein, as groups of related residues populate conserved motifs. Although the basics of the four-step protein splicing pathway are known, mechanistic details are still unknown. Structural and kinetic analyses are beginning to shed some light. Several structures were reported for precursor proteins with mutations in catalytic residues, which stabilize the precursors for crystallographic study. Progress is being made despite limitations inherent in using mutated precursors. However, no uniform mechanism has emerged. Kinetic parameters were determined using conditional trans-splicing (splicing of split precursor fragments after intein reassembly). Several groups concluded that the rate of the initial acyl rearrangement step is rapid and Asn cyclization (step 3) is slow, suggesting that this latter step is rate limiting. Understanding the protein splicing pathway has allowed scientists to harness inteins for numerous applications.

Mechanism for intein C-terminal cleavage: a proposal from quantum mechanical calculations

Inteins are autocatalytic protein cleavage and splicing elements. A cysteine to alanine mutation at the N-terminal of inteins inhibits splicing and isolates the C-terminal cleavage reaction. Experiments indicate an enhanced C-terminal cleavage reaction rate upon decreasing the solution pH for the cleavage mutant, which cannot be explained by the existing mechanistic framework. We use intein crystal structure data and the information about conserved amino acids to perform semiempirical PM3 calculations followed by high-level density functional theory calculations in both gas phase and implicit solvent environments. Based on these calculations, we propose a detailed "low pH" mechanism for intein C-terminal cleavage. Water plays an important role in the proposed reaction mechanism, acting as an acid as well as a base. The protonation of the scissile peptide bond nitrogen by a hydronium ion is an important first step in the reaction. That step is followed by the attack of the C-terminal asparagine side chain on its carbonyl carbon, causing succinimide formation and simultaneous peptide bond cleavage. The computed reaction energy barrier in the gas phase is approximately 33 kcal/mol and reduces to approximately 25 kcal/mol in solution, close to the 21 kcal/mol experimentally observed at pH 6.0. This mechanism is consistent with the observed increase in C-terminal cleavage activity at low pH for the cleavage mutant of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis RecA mini-intein.

Protein splicing: its discovery and structural insight into novel chemical mechanisms

Protein splicing is a posttranslational cellular process, in which an intervening protein sequence (intein) is self-catalytically excised out from a nascent protein precursor and the two flanking sequences (N- and C-exteins) are ligated to produce two mature enzymes. This unique reaction was first discovered from studies of the structure and expression of the VMA1 gene in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. VMA1 consists of a single open reading frame and yet comprises two independent genetic information for Vma1p (a catalytic 70-kDa subunit of the vacuolar H+-ATPase) and VDE (a 50-kDa DNA endonuclease) as an in-frame spliced insert in the gene. Subsequent studies have demonstrated that protein splicing is not unique for the VMA1 precursor and there are many operons in nature, which implement genetic information editing at protein level. To elucidate its precise reaction mechanisms from a viewpoint of structure-directed chemistry, a series of crystal structural studies has been carried out with the use of splicing-inactive and slowly spliceable precursors of VMA1 recombinants. One precursor structure revealed that the N-terminal junction of the introduced extein polypeptide forms an intermediate containing a five-membered thiazolidine ring. The other precursor structures showed spliced products with a linkage between the N- and C-extein segments. This article summarizes biochemical and structural studies on a self-catalytic mechanism for protein splicing that is triggered and terminated solely via thiazolidine intermediates with tetrahedral configurations formed within the splicing sites where proton ingress and egress are driven by balanced protonation and deprotonation.

Crystal Structures of an Intein from the Split dnaE Gene of Synechocystis sp. PCC6803 Reveal the Catalytic Model Without the Penultimate Histidine and the Mechanism of Zinc Ion Inhibition of Protein Splicing

The first naturally occurring split intein was found in the dnaE gene of Synechocystis sp. PCC6803 and belongs to a subclass of inteins without a penultimate histidine residue. We describe two high-resolution crystal structures, one derived from an excised Ssp DnaE intein and the second from a splicing-deficient precursor protein. The X-ray structures indicate that His147 in the conserved block F activates the side-chain N(delta) atom of the intein C-terminal Asn159, leading to a nucleophilic attack on the peptide bond carbonyl carbon atom at the C-terminal splice site. In this process, Arg73 appears to stabilize the transition state by interacting with the carbonyl oxygen atom of the scissile bond. Arg73 also seems to substitute for the conserved penultimate histidine residue in the formation of an oxyanion hole, as previously identified in other inteins. The finding that the precursor structure contains a zinc ion chelating the highly conserved Cys160 and Asp140 reveals the structural basis of Zn2+-mediated inhibition of protein splicing. Furthermore, it is of interest to observe that the carbonyl carbon atom of Asn159 and N(eta) of Arg73 are 2.6 angstroms apart in the free intein structure and 10.6 angstroms apart in the precursor structure. The orientation change of the aromatic ring of Tyr-1 following the initial acyl shift may be a key switching event contributing to the alignment of Arg73 and the C-terminal scissile bond, and may explain the sequential reaction property of the Ssp DnaE intein.

Protein splicing elements and plants: from transgene containment to protein purification

Protein splicing elements, termed inteins, have been discovered in all the domains of life. Basic research on inteins has led to a greater understanding of how they mediate the protein splicing process. Because inteins are natural protein engineering elements they have been harnessed for use in a number of applications, including protein purification, protein semisynthesis, and in vivo and in vitro protein modifications. This review focuses on the use of inteins in plants. A split-gene technique utilizes inteins to reconstitute the activity of a transgene product with the goal of limiting the spread of transgenes from a genetically modified plant to a weedy relative. Furthermore, merging the intein tag for protein purification with the large protein yields possible with plants has the potential to produce pharmaceutically important proteins. Finally, relevant techniques that may be used in plants in the future are discussed.

Mutational Analysis of Protein Splicing, Cleavage, and Self-Association Reactions Mediated by the Naturally SplitSspDnaE Intein

The ability to separately purify the naturally split Synechocystis sp. PCC6803 (Ssp) DnaE intein domains has allowed detailed examination of both universal and Ssp DnaE intein-specific steps in the protein splicing pathway. By engineering substitutions at both the +1 and penultimate intein positions, we have further characterized intein reaction kinetics in this system. Replacement of the crucial +1Cys with serine decreased N-terminal cleavage and trans-splicing rates; however, this substitution did not prevent splicing or the ability of ZnCl2 to inhibit it. Substitution of the penultimate intein residue (alanine) with a typically conserved histidine did not increase the rate or extent of trans-splicing or cleavage under typical assay conditions. Despite the observation that this histidine aids in asparagine cyclization for other inteins, it did not encourage C-terminal cleavage for the Ssp DnaE intein or uncouple it from N-terminal cleavage. Both the +1Ser and Ala to His mutants were insensitive to ZnCl2 during trans-cleavage experiments, uncoupling a previously linked inhibition in asparagine cyclization from an inhibition in trans-thioesterification detected for the wild-type intein.

Semisynthesis of a segmental isotopically labeled protein splicing precursor: NMR evidence for an unusual peptide bond at the N-extein-intein junction

Protein splicing is a posttranslational autocatalytic process in which an intervening sequence, termed an intein, is removed from a host protein, the extein. Although we have a reasonable picture of the basic chemical steps in protein splicing, our knowledge of how these are catalyzed and regulated is less well developed. In the current study, a combination of NMR spectroscopy and segmental isotopic labeling has been used to study the structure of an active protein splicing precursor, corresponding to an N-extein fusion of the Mxe GyrA intein. The (1)J(NC') coupling constant for the (-1) scissile peptide bond at the N-extein-intein junction was found to be approximately 12 Hz, which indicates that this amide is highly polarized, perhaps because of nonplanarity. Additional mutagenesis and NMR studies indicate that conserved box B histidine residue is essential for catalysis of the first step of splicing and for maintaining the (-1) scissile bond in its unusual conformation. Overall, these studies support the "ground-state destabilization" model as part of the mechanism of catalysis.

Structural constraints on protein self-processing in L-aspartate-alpha-decarboxylase

Aspartate decarboxylase, which is translated as a pro-protein, undergoes intramolecular self-cleavage at Gly24-Ser25. We have determined the crystal structures of an unprocessed native precursor, in addition to Ala24 insertion, Ala26 insertion and Gly24-->Ser, His11-->Ala, Ser25-->Ala, Ser25-->Cys and Ser25-->Thr mutants. Comparative analyses of the cleavage site reveal specific conformational constraints that govern self-processing and demonstrate that considerable rearrangement must occur. We suggest that Thr57 Ogamma and a water molecule form an 'oxyanion hole' that likely stabilizes the proposed oxyoxazolidine intermediate. Thr57 and this water molecule are probable catalytic residues able to support acid-base catalysis. The conformational freedom in the loop preceding the cleavage site appears to play a determining role in the reaction. The molecular mechanism of self-processing, presented here, emphasizes the importance of stabilization of the oxyoxazolidine intermediate. Comparison of the structural features shows significant similarity to those in other self-processing systems, and suggests that models of the cleavage site of such enzymes based on Ser-->Ala or Ser-->Thr mutants alone may lead to erroneous interpretations of the mechanism.