Ultrastructural nonisotopic mapping of nucleolar transcription sites in onion protoplasts

Understanding spatiotemporal coupling of gene expression using single molecule RNA imaging technologies

Across all kingdoms of life, gene regulatory mechanisms underlie cellular adaptation to ever-changing environments. Regulation of gene expression adjusts protein synthesis and, in turn, cellular growth. Messenger RNAs are key molecules in the process of gene expression. Our ability to quantitatively measure mRNA expression in single cells has improved tremendously over the past decades. This revealed an unexpected coordination between the steps that control the life of an mRNA, from transcription to degradation. Here, we provide an overview of the state-of-the-art imaging approaches for measurement and quantitative understanding of gene expression, starting from the early visualizations of single genes by electron microscopy to current fluorescence-based approaches in single cells, including live-cell RNA-imaging approaches to FISH-based spatial transcriptomics across model organisms. We also highlight how these methods have shaped our current understanding of the spatiotemporal coupling between transcriptional and post-transcriptional events in prokaryotes. We conclude by discussing future challenges of this multidisciplinary field.Abbreviations: mRNA: messenger RNA; rRNA: ribosomal rDNA; tRNA: transfer RNA; sRNA: small RNA; FISH: fluorescence in situ hybridization; RNP: ribonucleoprotein; smFISH: single RNA molecule FISH; smiFISH: single molecule inexpensive FISH; HCR-FISH: Hybridization Chain-Reaction-FISH; RCA: Rolling Circle Amplification; seqFISH: Sequential FISH; MERFISH: Multiplexed error robust FISH; UTR: Untranslated region; RBP: RNA binding protein; FP: fluorescent protein; eGFP: enhanced GFP, MCP: MS2 coat protein; PCP: PP7 coat protein; MB: Molecular beacons; sgRNA: single guide RNA.

Fluctuations of pol I and fibrillarin contents of the nucleoli

Nucleoli are formed on the basis of ribosomal DNA (rDNA) clusters called Nucleolus Organizer Regions (NORs). Each NOR contains multiple genes coding for RNAs of the ribosomal particles. The prominent components of the nucleolar ultrastructure, fibrillar centers (FC) and dense fibrillar components (DFC), together compose FC/DFC units. These units are centers of rDNA transcription by RNA polymerase I (pol I), as well as the early processing events, in which an essential role belongs to fibrillarin. Each FC/DFC unit probably corresponds to a single transcriptionally active gene. In this work, we transfected human-derived cells with GFP-RPA43 (subunit of pol I) and RFP-fibrillarin. Following changes of the fluorescent signals in individual FC/DFC units, we found two kinds of kinetics: 1) the rapid fluctuations with periods of 2-3 min, when the pol I and fibrillarin signals oscillated in anti-phase manner, and the intensities of pol I in the neighboring FC/DFC units did not correlate. 2) fluctuations with periods of 10 to 60 min, in which pol I and fibrillarin signals measured in the same unit did not correlate, but pol I signals in the units belonging to different nucleoli were synchronized. Our data indicate that a complex pulsing activity of transcription as well as early processing is common for ribosomal genes.

Reproduction of the FC/DFC units in nucleoli

The essential structural components of the nucleoli, Fibrillar Centers (FC) and Dense Fibrillar Components (DFC), together compose FC/DFC units, loci of rDNA transcription and early RNA processing. In the present study we followed cell cycle related changes of these units in 2 human sarcoma derived cell lines with stable expression of RFP-PCNA (the sliding clamp protein) and GFP-RPA43 (a subunit of RNA polymerase I, pol I) or GFP-fibrillarin. Correlative light and electron microscopy analysis showed that the pol I and fibrillarin positive nucleolar beads correspond to individual FC/DFC units. In vivo observations showed that at early S phase, when transcriptionally active ribosomal genes were replicated, the number of the units in each cell increased by 60-80%. During that period the units transiently lost pol I, but not fibrillarin. Then, until the end of interphase, number of the units did not change, and their duplication was completed only after the cell division, by mid G1 phase. This peculiar mode of reproduction suggests that a considerable subset of ribosomal genes remain transcriptionally silent from mid S phase to mitosis, but become again active in the postmitotic daughter cells.

Nucleolar DNA: the host and the guests

Nucleoli are formed on the basis of ribosomal genes coding for RNAs of ribosomal particles, but also include a great variety of other DNA regions. In this article, we discuss the characteristics of ribosomal DNA: the structure of the rDNA locus, complex organization and functions of the intergenic spacer, multiplicity of gene copies in one cell, selective silencing of genes and whole gene clusters, relation to components of nucleolar ultrastructure, specific problems associated with replication. We also review current data on the role of non-ribosomal DNA in the organization and function of nucleoli. Finally, we discuss probable causes preventing efficient visualization of DNA in nucleoli.

Separation of replication and transcription domains in nucleoli

In mammalian cells, active ribosomal genes produce the 18S, 5.8S and 28S RNAs of ribosomal particles. Transcription levels of these genes are very high throughout interphase, and the cell needs a special strategy to avoid collision of the DNA polymerase and RNA polymerase machineries. To investigate this problem, we measured the correlation of various replication and transcription signals in the nucleoli of HeLa, HT-1080 and NIH 3T3 cells using a specially devised software for analysis of confocal images. Additionally, to follow the relationship between nucleolar replication and transcription in living cells, we produced a stable cell line expressing GFP-RPA43 (subunit of RNA polymerase I, pol I) and RFP-PCNA (the sliding clamp protein) based on human fibrosarcoma HT-1080 cells. We found that replication and transcription signals are more efficiently separated in nucleoli than in the nucleoplasm. In the course of S phase, separation of PCNA and pol I signals gradually increased. During the same period, separation of pol I and incorporated Cy5-dUTP signals decreased. Analysis of single molecule localization microscopy (SMLM) images indicated that transcriptionally active FC/DFC units (i.e. fibrillar centers with adjacent dense fibrillar components) did not incorporate DNA nucleotides. Taken together, our data show that replication of the ribosomal genes is spatially separated from their transcription, and FC/DFC units may provide a structural basis for that separation.

Organization of the nucleoli of soybean root meristematic cells at different states of their activity

Internal organization of a nucleolus changes along with rRNA transcriptional activity. These changes mainly concern qualitative and quantitative alternations of three main nucleolar components: fibrillar centres (FC), dense fibrillar component (DFC) and granular component (GC). In the present work quantitative measurements of the number and sizes of FCs and DFCs in nucleoli of root meristematic cells of soybean seedlings grown at (1) chilling conditions that reduce transcriptional activity of soybean nucleoli (temp. of 10 degrees C) and at (2) conditions that increase this activity (recovery at optimal temp. of 25 degrees C after previous chilling), even more than (3) the control, have been carried out. Morphometric measurements showed that the highest number of FCs and DFCs was in the most active nucleoli, while the smallest number - in those with the lowest activity. The average size of an individual FC was similar in all nucleoli regardless of their transcriptional activity, that of the individual DFC varied, being bigger in the nucleoli of the chilled plants and smallest in those of the recovered plants. The numbers of FCs and DFCs seem to be indicators of transcriptional activity of plant nucleoli - the higher number of FCs and DFCs the more active nucleoli.

A protocol for studying the kinetics of RNA within cultured cells: application to ribosomal RNA

This protocol describes a nonisotopic method for high-resolution investigation of the kinetics of RNA within the cell. This involves the incorporation of bromouridine-5'-triphosphate into RNA of living cells by lipofection followed by immunocytological detection of BrRNAs. The use of the same antibody identified either with fluorescence or with gold particles revealed the three-dimensional organization of sites containing labeled RNAs or their precise localization by using confocal and ultrastructural microscopy, respectively. Comparison of three-dimensional reconstruction obtained from the series of optical sections and ultrathin sections was extremely fruitful to describe topological and spatial dynamics of RNAs from their synthesis site inside the nucleus to the cytoplasm. Combined with immunolocalization of proteins involved in different nuclear activities and with highly resolved three-dimensional visualizations of the labelings, this method should also provide a significant contribution to our understanding of the functional, volumic organization of the cell nucleus. The entire protocol can be completed in approximately 10 d.

Immunodetection of nucleolar proteins and ultrastructure of nucleoli of soybean root meristematic cells treated with chilling stress and after recovery

The nucleolar proteins, fibrillarin and nucleophosmin, have been identified immunofluorescently in the root meristematic cells of soybean seedlings under varying experimental conditions: at 25 degrees C (control), chilling at 10 degrees C for 3 h and 4 days and recovery from the chilling stress at 25 degrees C. In each experimental variant, the immunofluorescence signals were present solely at the nucleolar territories. Fluorescent staining for both proteins was mainly in the shape of circular domains that are assumed to correspond to the dense fibrillar component of the nucleoli. The fewest fluorescent domains were observed in the nucleoli of chilled plants, and the highest number was observed in the plants recovered after chilling. This difference in the number of circular domains in the nucleoli of each variant may indicate various levels of these proteins in each variant. Both the number of circular domains and the level of these nucleolar proteins changed with changes in the transcriptional activity of the nucleoli, with the more metabolically active cell having higher numbers of active areas in the nucleolus and higher levels of nucleolar proteins, and conversely. Electron microscopic studies revealed differences in the ultrastructure of the nucleoli in all experimental variants and confirmed that the number of fibrillar centres surrounded by dense fibrillar component was the lowest in the nucleoli of chilled plants, and the highest in the nucleoli of recovered seedlings.

In situ comparative studies on subnucleolar distribution and configuration of plant rDNA

The distribution and configurations of nucleolar DNA in Pisum sativum L., Allium sativum L., Triticum aestivum L. were analyzed by specific cytochemical staining using NAMA-Ur. It has been observed that in the nucleoli of different plant species, the DNA occupied different positions in different areas, which may imply a different status and strategy of rDNA transcription. Our results showed irregular clumps of rDNA surrounding FCs in semi-circular formations in P. sativum and T. aestivum, indicating a regular pattern of rDNA distribution and supporting the helix model of rDNA configuration. The rDNA was condensed in some regions and uncondensed in others. Nucleolus-associated chromatin extended from outside the nucleolus to the periphery of the FCs via nucleolar channels, which suggests a possible origin for nucleolar DNA.

New Insights into Nucleolar Architecture and Activity

The nucleolus is the most obvious and clearly differentiated nuclear subcompartment. It is where ribosome biogenesis takes place and has been the subject of research over many decades. In recent years progress in our understanding of ribosome biogenesis has been rapid and is accelerating. This review discusses current understanding of how the biochemical processes of ribosome biosynthesis relate to an observable nucleolar structure. Emerging evidence is also described that points to other, unconventional roles for the nucleolus, particularly in the biogenesis of other RNA-containing cellular machinery, and in stress sensing and the control of cellular activity. Striking recent observations show that the nucleolus and its components are highly dynamic, and that the steady state structure observed by microscopical methods must be interpreted as the product of these dynamic processes. We still do not have detailed enough information to understand fully the organization and regulation of the various processes taking place in the nucleolus. However, the present power of light and electron microscopy (EM) techniques means that a description of nucleolar processes at the molecular level is now achievable, and the time is ripe for such an effort.

Spatio-temporal dynamics at rDNA foci: Global switching between DNA replication and transcription

We have investigated the in situ organization of ribosomal gene (rDNA) transcription and replication in HeLa cells. Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) revealed numerous rDNA foci in the nucleolus. Each rDNA focus corresponds to a higher order chromatin domain containing multiple ribosomal genes. Multi-channel labeling experiments indicated that, in the majority of cells, all the rDNA foci were active in transcription as demonstrated by co-localization with signals to transcription and fibrillarin, a protein involved in ribosomal RNA processing. In some cells, however, a small portion of the rDNA foci did not overlap with signals to transcription and fibrillarin. Labeling for DNA replication revealed that those rDNA foci inactive in transcription were restricted to the S-phase of the cell cycle and were replicated predominantly from mid to late S-phase. Electron microscopic analysis localized the nucleolar transcription, replication, and fibrillarin signals to the dense fibrillar components of the nucleolus and at the borders of the fibrillar centers. We propose that the rDNA foci are the functional units for coordinating replication and transcription of the rRNA genes in space and time. This involves a global switching mechanism, active from mid to late S-phase, for turning off transcription and turning on replication at individual rDNA foci. Once all the rRNA genes at individual foci are replicated, these higher order chromatin domains are reprogrammed for transcription.

Building an efficient factory: where is pre-rRNA synthesized in the nucleolus?

The subnucleolar structure that is involved in rDNA transcription has been controversial. A report by Koberna et al. (2002)(this issue, page 743) adds significant weight toward the idea that dense fibrillar components (DFCs)**Abbreviations used in this paper: DFC, dense fibrillar component; FC, fibrillar center; GC, granular component; Pol I, polymerase I. and fibrillar center (FC)/DFC borders are the sites of pre-rRNA synthesis.

Single ribosomal transcription units are linear, compacted Christmas trees in plant nucleoli

The rDNA transcription units are enormous macromolecular structures located in the nucleolus and containing 50-100 RNA polymerases together with the nascent pre-rRNA attached to the rDNA. It has not previously been possible to visualize nucleolar transcription units directly in intact nucleoli, although highly spread preparations in the electron microscope have been imaged as "Christmas trees" 2-3 microm long. Here we determine the relative conformation of individual transcription units in Pisum sativum plant nucleoli using a novel labelling technique. Nascent transcripts were detected by a highly sensitive silver-enhanced 1 nm gold procedure, followed by 3D electron microscopy of entire nucleoli. Individual transcription units are seen as conical, elongated clusters approximately 300 nm in length and 130 nm in width at the thickest end. We further show that there were approximately 300 active ribosomal genes in the nucleoli examined. The underlying chromatin structure of the transcribing rDNA was directly visualized by applying a novel limited extraction procedure to fixed specimens in order to wash out the proteins and RNA, thus specifically revealing DNA strands after uranyl acetate staining. Using this technique, followed by post-embedding in situ hybridization, we observed that the nucleolar rDNA fibres are not extended but show a coiled, thread-like appearance. Our results show for the first time that native rDNA transcription units are linear, compacted Christmas trees.

Structures of nucleolus and transcription sites of rRNA genes in rat liver cells

We observed the ultrastructure of nucleolus in rat liver cells by conventional electron microscopy, and employed cytochemistry NAMA-Ur DNA specific stain method to analyze the distribution and position of nucleolar DNAin situ. The results showed that nucleolar DNA of rat liver cells comes from nucleolus-associated chromatin, and continuously extends in the dense fibrillar component (DFC) of nucleolus, localizes at the periphery of fibrillar center (FC) and in DFC. Furthermore, by employing anti-DNA/RNA hybrid antibodies, we directly and selectively labeled transcription sites of rRNA genes and testified that localization of transcription sites not only to DFC but also to the periphery of FC.

Simultaneous localization of transcription and early processing markers allows dissection of functional domains in the plant cell nucleolus

Nucleolar transcription in isolated onion cell nuclei was visualized, after Br-UTP incorporation, under the conventional fluorescence microscope, the confocal microscope, and the transmission electron microscope. The confocal microscopy study of transcription was combined with immunodetection of fibrillarin, a component of the RNP complex involved in the early processing of pre-rRNA. Superposition of transcription and fibrillarin images from the same optical section showed some small "black holes" in the nucleolus, around which a lateral and radial differentiation of labeling was observed: laterally, zones corresponding to transcription labeling alternated with zones of fibrillarin labeling; radially, areas of transcription gradually became areas of colocalization of transcription and fibrillarin, and, further outward, of fibrillarin alone, which occupied the major part of the labeled nucleolar area. Three-dimensional reconstruction of the nucleolar transcription labeling, from confocal optical sections, showed clusters of foci arranged around an area of low or no labeling. Thin labeled extensions, connecting single foci, were observed. Visualization of transcription at the ultrastructural level identified the black holes as fibrillar centers, in view of their size and the absence of labeling in them. In fact, most of the labeling was observed in discrete areas of the dense fibrillar component, near fibrillar centers, including the transition area between these two components. This observation was supported by a quantitative study. Otherwise, the outline of fibrillar centers did not appear entirely surrounded by particles, and a minor proportion of particles was detected dispersed throughout the dense fibrillar component. As a complementary study, the transcription factor upstream binding factor (UBF) and the protein NopA64, a plant nucleolin homologue, were immunolocalized. Small foci of UBF localization alone and other foci in which the two protein markers overlapped were observed. The outer areas of the nucleolus showed the exclusive presence of NopA64. Under the electron microscope, UBF labeling, quantitatively assessed, appeared as clusters of particles, most of them surrounding fibrillar centers. A graphic model is presented to give a molecular interpretation of these data.

Ultrastructural methods for nucleic acid detection by immunocytology

In the present review are summarized recent developments in immunocytochemical detection of nucleic acids in biological materials at the ultrastructural level. Not only the approaches using antibodies to natural nucleic acids are described but also the techniques involving the use of antibodies raised against various nucleotide analogs incorporated beforehand into nucleic acids. Special emphasis is placed on each method's potential and limitations. These methods, combined or not with molecular biotechnology, are powerful tools for studying the structure and function of nucleic acids. They can be used to investigate the distribution and topological organization of DNA and RNA molecules or of specialized within these molecules in the cells.

Ultrastructural distribution of DNA within plant meristematic cell nucleoli during activation and the subsequent inactivation by a cold stress

We have investigated the precise location of DNA within the meristematic cell nucleolus of Zea mays root cells and Pisum sativum cotyledonary buds, in the course of their activation and induced inactivation following a subsequent treatment at low temperature. For this purpose, we combined the acetylation method, providing an excellent distinction between the various nucleolar components, with the in situ terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-immunogold technique, a highly sensitive method for detecting DNA at the ultrastructural level. In addition to the presence of DNA in the condensed chromatin associated with the nucleolus, we demonstrated that a significant label was detected in the nucleolus of quiescent cells in both plant models. Evident labels were also found in the dense fibrillar component of actived nucleoli. Whereas in inactivated nucleoli no significant label was observed within the dense fibrillar component, an intense label was seen over the large heterogeneous fibrillar centres only during inactivation. The granular component was never significantly labelled. These results appear to indicate that the DNA present in the dense fibrillar component of activated nucleoli withdraws from this structure during its inactivation and becomes incorporated in the large fibrillar centres. These observations suggest that in plant cells inactivation of rRNA genes is clearly accompanied by changes in the conformation of ribosomal chromatin.

Histones and DNA ultrastructural distribution in plant cell nucleus: a combination of immunogold and cytochemical methods

In this work we report for the first time the ultrastructural distribution of histones and DNA in the nuclear compartments in two different plant cell types: Allium cepa L. root meristems and Capsicum annuum L. microspores and pollen grains, by using antibodies against histones H2B and H4 and anti-DNA. Immunolocalizations were combined with ultrastructural cytochemistry for nucleic acids (methylation-acetylation method), DNA (NAMA-Ur) and RNPs (EDTA), to relate the subcellular location of histones and DNA with the chemical subcompartmentalization of the cell nucleus. This is particularly interesting concerning the presence of histones or not on fibers of the interchromatin region and on the fibrillar components of the nucleolus, nuclear subcompartments where transcription has been shown to take place at some regions. Our methodological approach permitted to define precisely the structures where histones were detected in relation to the ultrastructural localization of chromatin in various structural condensation levels. Concerning the localization of DNA and histones on the different components of the nucleolus, the combination of immunogold labeling with the methylation-acetylation cytochemical method, developed in our laboratory, was very useful, thus permitting a clear recognition of the nucleolar components and a correct assignment of labeling, which is not always evident on uranyl-lead-stained Lowicryl sections. Double immunogold assays were also done for a simultaneous visualization of histones and DNA. Our results show a coincident distribution of histones and DNA on the same nuclear compartments revealing the presence of both antigens on condensed chromatin, fibers of the interchromatin region, principally located at the periphery of the condensed chromatin, and in the fibrillar components of the nucleolus.

Preferential silver reaction of nucleolar regions adjacent to fibrillar centers in ring shaped nucleoli of leukemic lymphocytes

Silver stained proteins (SSPs) characteristic for interphasic nucleolus organizer regions (NORs) associated with fibrillar centers (FCs) and adjacent nucleolar regions of ring shaped nucleoli in leukemic lymphocytes exhibit a different sensitivity to the mild acid extraction including that with HCl. Such extractions permit a preferential visualization of fibrillar centers adjacent regions (FCARs) which are believed to represent sites of the ribosomal RNA (rRNA) transcription. The resistance of SSPs in FCARs to the extraction with HCl seems to be due to their binding to other components present in these regions. The extractibility of SSPs with HCl was influenced by the fixatives used. The largest resistance of SSPs to the extraction with HCl was noted after fixation with glutaraldehyde. In contrast, the largest extractibility of these proteins was observed after fixation with unbuffered formaldehyde.