Insights into Escherichia coli RNA polymerase structure from a combination of x-ray and electron crystallography

Concerted Protein and Nucleic Acid Conformational Changes Observed Prior to Nucleotide Incorporation in a Bacterial RNA Polymerase: Raman Crystallographic Evidence

Transcription elongation requires the continuous incorporation of ribonucleotide triphosphates into a growing transcript. RNA polymerases (RNAPs) are able to processively synthesize a growing RNA chain via translocation of the RNAP enzyme along its nucleic acid template strand after each nucleotide addition cycle. In this work, a time-resolved Raman spectroscopic analysis of nucleotide addition in single crystals of the Thermus thermophilus elongation complex (TthEC) is reported. When [(13)C,(15)N]GTP (*GTP) is soaked into crystals of the TthEC, large reversible changes in the Raman spectrum that are assigned to protein and nucleic acid conformational events during a single-nucleotide incorporation are observed. The *GTP population in the TthEC crystal reaches a stable population at 37 min, while substantial and reversible protein conformational changes (mainly ascribed to changes in α-helical Raman features) maximize at approximately 50 min. At the same time, changes in nucleic acid bases and phosphodiester backbone Raman marker bands occur. Catalysis begins at approximately 65-70 min, soon after the maximal protein and DNA changes, and is monitored via the decline in a triphosphate vibrational Raman mode from *GTP. The Raman data indicate that approximately 40% of the total triphosphate population, present as *GTP, reacts in the crystal. This may suggest that a second population of noncovalently bound *GTP resides in a site distinct from the catalytic site. The data reported here are an extension of our recent work on the elongation complex (EC) of a bacterial RNAP, Thermus thermophilus (Tth), where Raman spectroscopy and polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis were employed to monitor incorporation and misincorporation in single TthEC crystals [Antonopoulos, I. H., et al. (2015) Biochemistry 54, 652-665]. Therefore, the initial study establishes the groundwork for this study. In contrast to our previous study, in which incorporation takes place very rapidly inside the crystals, the data on this single crystal exhibit a slower time regime, which allows the dissection of the structural dynamics associated with GMP incorporation within the TthEC crystal.

A unified model of transcription elongation: what have we learned from single-molecule experiments?

The transcription of the genetic information encoded in DNA into RNA is performed by RNA polymerase (RNAP), a complex molecular motor, highly conserved across species. Despite remarkable progress in single-molecule techniques revealing important mechanistic details of transcription elongation (TE) with up to base-pair resolution, some of the results and interpretations of these studies are difficult to reconcile, and have not yet led to a minimal unified picture of transcription. We propose a simple model that accounts quantitatively for many of the experimental observations. This model belongs to the class of isothermal ratchet models of TE involving the thermally driven stochastic backward and forward motion (backtracking and forward tracking) of RNAP along DNA between single-nucleotide incorporation events. We uncover two essential features for the success of the model. The first is an intermediate state separating the productive elongation pathway from nonelongating backtracked states. The rates of entering and exiting this intermediate state modulate pausing by RNAP. The second crucial ingredient of the model is the cotranscriptional folding of the RNA transcript, sterically inhibiting the extent of backtracking. This model resolves several apparent differences between single-molecule studies and provides a framework for future work on TE.

Subunit compositions of the RNA-silencing enzymes Pol IV and Pol V reveal their origins as specialized forms of RNA polymerase II

In addition to RNA polymerases I, II, and III, the essential RNA polymerases present in all eukaryotes, plants have two additional nuclear RNA polymerases, abbreviated as Pol IV and Pol V, that play nonredundant roles in siRNA-directed DNA methylation and gene silencing. We show that Arabidopsis Pol IV and Pol V are composed of subunits that are paralogous or identical to the 12 subunits of Pol II. Four subunits of Pol IV are distinct from their Pol II paralogs, six subunits of Pol V are distinct from their Pol II paralogs, and four subunits differ between Pol IV and Pol V. Importantly, the subunit differences occur in key positions relative to the template entry and RNA exit paths. Our findings support the hypothesis that Pol IV and Pol V are Pol II-like enzymes that evolved specialized roles in the production of noncoding transcripts for RNA silencing and genome defense.

Chemical linkage at allosteric activation of E. coli cAMP receptor protein

Cyclic AMP Receptor protein (CRP) regulates transcription initiation in E. coli. The ligand and DNA binding data yields the following results: (1) There are two different types of cAMP binding sites; weak and strong. (2) CRP-DNA-cAMP is the active form of all CRP conformers and this complex prefers to form from CRP-DNA rather than CRP-cAMP form. (3) Binding of additional cAMP(s) to CRP-DNA-cAMP complex greatly reduces DNA binding affinity. (4) Variants showed that ribose moiety of cAMP is important to transmit the signal to the DNA binding domain to activate specific DNA binding. (5) Deconvolution of DNA binding data leads us to propose a model for cAMP's role in transcription initiation process.

A complexomic study of Escherichia coli using two-dimensional blue native/SDS polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis

Study of the complexome - all the protein complexes of the cell - is essential for a better understanding and more global vision of cell function. Using two-dimensional blue native/SDS-PAGE (2-D BN/SDS-PAGE) technology, the cytosolic and membrane protein complexes of Escherichia coli were separated. Then, the different partners of each protein complex were identified by LC-MS/MS. In this report, 306 protein complexes were separated and identified. Among these protein complexes, 50 heteromultimeric and 256 homomultimeric protein complexes were found. Among the 50 heteromultimeric protein complexes, 18 previously described protein complexes validate the technology. In this study, 109 new protein complexes were found, providing insight into the function of previously uncharacterized bacterial proteins.

Collision events between RNA polymerases in convergent transcription studied by atomic force microscopy

Atomic force microscopy (AFM) has been used to image, at single molecule resolution, transcription events by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase (RNAP) on a linear DNA template with two convergently aligned lambda(pr) promoters. For the first time experimentally, the outcome of collision events during convergent transcription by two identical RNAP has been studied. Measurement of the positions of the RNAP on the DNA, allows distinction of open promoter complexes (OPCs) and elongating complexes (EC) and collided complexes (CC). This discontinuous time-course enables subsequent analysis of collision events where both RNAP remain bound on the DNA. After collision, the elongating RNAP has caused the other (usually stalled) RNAP to back-track along the template. The final positions of the two RNAP indicate that these are collisions between an EC and a stalled EC (SEC) or OPC (previously referred to as sitting-ducks). Interestingly, the distances between the two RNAP show that they are not always at closest approach after 'collision' has caused their arrest.

Thermodynamic and kinetic modeling of transcriptional pausing

We present a statistical mechanics approach for the prediction of backtracked pauses in bacterial transcription elongation derived from structural models of the transcription elongation complex (EC). Our algorithm is based on the thermodynamic stability of the EC along the DNA template calculated from the sequence-dependent free energy of DNA-DNA, DNA-RNA, and RNA-RNA base pairing associated with (i) the translocational and size fluctuations of the transcription bubble; (ii) changes in the associated DNA-RNA hybrid; and (iii) changes in the cotranscriptional RNA secondary structure upstream of the RNA exit channel. The calculations involve no adjustable parameters except for a cutoff used to discriminate paused from nonpaused complexes. When applied to 100 experimental pauses in transcription elongation by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase on 10 DNA templates, the approach produces statistically significant results. We also present a kinetic model for the rate of recovery of backtracked paused complexes. A crucial ingredient of our model is the incorporation of kinetic barriers to backtracking resulting from steric clashes of EC with the cotranscriptionally generated RNA secondary structure, an aspect not included explicitly in previous attempts at modeling the transcription elongation process.

Compressed representations of macromolecular structures and properties

We introduce a new and unified, compressed volumetric representation for macromolecular structures at varying feature resolutions, as well as for many computed associated properties. Important caveats of this compressed representation are fast random data access and decompression operations. Many computational tasks for manipulating large structures, including those requiring interactivity such as real-time visualization, are greatly enhanced by utilizing this compact representation. The compression scheme is obtained by using a custom designed hierarchical wavelet basis construction. Due to the continuity offered by these wavelets, we retain very good accuracy of molecular surfaces, at very high compression ratios, for macromolecular structures at multiple resolutions.

A multiwell assay to isolate compounds inhibiting the assembly of the prokaryotic RNA polymerase

We have developed a multiwell assay for the detection of modulators of prokaryotic transcription based on the quantification of protein-protein interaction. This assay consists of three steps: (a) the immobilization of the Escherichia coli protein sigma70 in the well, (b) the incubation of the immobilized protein with core RNA polymerase and a potential inhibitor, and (c) washing and quantification of the binding of core to sigma70 with a monoclonal antibody conjugated to horseradish peroxidase. We show that this assay is sensitive, reproducible, and robust, and is able to discriminate between control competitors with different affinities. We demonstrate the usefulness of the assay to screen for microbial RNA polymerase inhibitors as potential new drugs for the treatment of emerging antibiotic-resistant bacteria.

Distance-restrained docking of rifampicin and rifamycin SV to RNA polymerase using systematic FRET measurements: developing benchmarks of model quality and reliability

We are developing distance-restrained docking strategies for modeling macromolecular complexes that combine available high-resolution structures of the components and intercomponent distance restraints derived from systematic fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) measurements. In this article, we consider the problem of docking small-molecule ligands within macromolecular complexes. Using simulated FRET data, we have generated a series of benchmarks that permit estimation of model accuracy based on the quantity and quality of FRET-derived distance restraints, including the number, random error, systematic error, distance distribution, and radial distribution of FRET-derived distance restraints. We find that expected model accuracy is 10 A or better for models based on: i), > or =20 restraints with up to 15% random error and no systematic error, or ii), > or =20 restraints with up to 15% random error, up to 10% systematic error, and a symmetric radial distribution of restraints. Model accuracies can be improved to 5 A or better by increasing the number of restraints to > or =40 and/or by optimizing the distance distribution of restraints. Using experimental FRET data, we have defined the positions of the binding sites within bacterial RNA polymerase of the small-molecule inhibitors rifampicin (Rif) and rifamycin SV (Rif SV). The inferred binding sites for Rif and Rif SV were located with accuracies of, respectively, 7 and 10 A relative to the crystallographically defined binding site for Rif. These accuracies agree with expectations from the benchmark simulations and suffice to indicate that the binding sites for Rif and Rif SV are located within the RNA polymerase active-center cleft, overlapping the binding site for the RNA-DNA hybrid.

Conformational flexibility in sigma70 region 2 during transcription initiation

Prokaryotic RNA polymerase holoenzyme is composed of core subunits (alpha(2)betabeta'omega) plus a sigma factor that confers promoter specificity allowing for regulation of gene expression. Holoenzyme is known to undergo several conformational changes during the multiple steps of transcription initiation. However, the effects of these changes on the functions of specific regions have not been well characterized. In this work, we addressed the role of possible conformational change in region 2 of Escherichia coli sigma(70) by engineering disulfide bonds that "lock" region 2.1 with region 2.2 and region 2.2 with region 2.3. When these mutant holoenzymes were characterized for gross defects in multiple-round transcription, we found that insertion of either disulfide bond did not result in a fundamental block, indicating that the disulfide-containing holoenzymes are active. However, both disulfide-containing holoenzymes exhibited defects in formation and stability of the open complex. Our results suggest that conformational flexibility within sigma(70) region 2 facilitates open complex formation and transcription initiation.

Conformational flexibility of bacterial RNA polymerase

The structure of Escherichia coli core RNA polymerase (RNAP) was determined by cryo-electron microscopy and image processing of helical crystals to a nominal resolution of 15 A. Because of the high sequence conservation between the core RNAP subunits, we were able to interpret the E. coli structure in relation to the high-resolution x-ray structure of Thermus aquaticus core RNAP. A very large conformational change of the T. aquaticus RNAP x-ray structure, corresponding to opening of the main DNA/RNA channel by nearly 25 A, was required to fit the E. coli map. This finding reveals, at least partially, the range of conformational flexibility of the RNAP, which is likely to have functional implications for the initiation of transcription, where the DNA template must be loaded into the channel.

Conformation of fork junction DNA in a complex with Escherichia coli RNA polymerase

Escherichia coli RNA polymerase is able to bind fork junction DNA containing a conserved -10 promoter element in a sequence-specific manner, and it is believed that polymerase-fork junction DNA interaction mimics those between the enzyme and the promoter DNA in the open complex. In this report we determined the conformation of polymerase-bound fork junction DNA in solution. A series of distances between sites in the fork junction DNA in complex with polymerase were determined using luminescence and fluorescence resonance energy transfer. A series of fork junction DNAs were prepared containing the luminescent or fluorescent donor probe at the upstream or at the downstream end of the fork DNA and acceptor probes at nine positions within the fork junction DNA. The measured distances were compared with analogous distances in a model reference DNA duplex, and the observed distance differences were used to build a model of the fork junction DNA in a complex with the polymerase. The obtained model revealed an insignificant perturbation of the duplex part of the fork DNA in a complex with the polymerase whereas a sharp kink of DNA was observed at the ds/ss DNA boundary of the fork junction DNA.

Structure analysis of soluble proteins using electron crystallography

Electron crystallography as a structural determination technique has grown dramatically in use over recent years. Improvements in microscopes, equipment, practical techniques, computation facilities and image processing methods are reflected in the increasing number of near-atomic resolution structures that have been published. In this review we shall summarize the techniques involved in structure determination of soluble proteins using electron crystallography. Many soluble protein structures have been investigated in this manner over the past two decades. Here we present several examples where a variety of approaches have been used to gradually increase the information obtained.

Bacterial RNA polymerase

The recently determined crystal structure of a bacterial core RNA polymerase (RNAP) provides the first glimpse of this family of evolutionarily conserved cellular RNAPs. Using the structure as a framework, a consistent picture of protein-nucleic acid interactions in transcription complexes has been accumulated from cross-linking experiments. The molecule can be viewed as a molecular machine, with distinct structural features hypothesized to perform specific functions. Comparison with the alpha-carbon backbone of a eukaryotic RNAP reveals close structural similarity.

Functional interaction between Ssu72 and the Rpb2 subunit of RNA polymerase II in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

SSU72 is an essential gene encoding a phylogenetically conserved protein of unknown function that interacts with the general transcription factor TFIIB. A recessive ssu72-1 allele was identified as a synthetic enhancer of a TFIIB (sua7-1) defect, resulting in a heat-sensitive (Ts(-)) phenotype and a dramatic downstream shift in transcription start site selection. Here we describe a new allele, ssu72-2, that confers a Ts(-) phenotype in a SUA7 wild-type background. In an effort to further define Ssu72, we isolated suppressors of the ssu72-2 mutation. One suppressor is allelic to RPB2, the gene encoding the second-largest subunit of RNA polymerase II (RNAP II). Sequence analysis of the rpb2-100 suppressor defined a cysteine replacement of the phylogenetically invariant arginine residue at position 512 (R512C), located within homology block D of Rpb2. The ssu72-2 and rpb2-100 mutations adversely affected noninduced gene expression, with no apparent effects on activated transcription in vivo. Although isolated as a suppressor of the ssu72-2 Ts(-) defect, rpb2-100 enhanced the transcriptional defects associated with ssu72-2. The Ssu72 protein interacts directly with purified RNAP II in a coimmunoprecipitation assay, suggesting that the genetic interactions between ssu72-2 and rpb2-100 are a consequence of physical interactions. These results define Ssu72 as a highly conserved factor that physically and functionally interacts with the RNAP II core machinery during transcription initiation.

Interaction between RNA polymerase and RapA, a bacterial homolog of the SWI/SNF protein family

Recently, we identified a novel Escherichia coli RNA polymerase (RNAP)-associated protein, an ATPase, called RapA (Sukhodolets, M. V. , and Jin, D. J. (1998) J. Biol. Chem. 273, 7018-7023). RapA is a bacterial homolog of SWI2/SNF2. We showed that RapA forms a stable complex with RNAP holoenzyme and that binding to RNAP holoenzyme stimulates the ATPase activity of RapA. We have further analyzed the interactions between purified RapA and the two forms of RNAP: core RNAP and RNAP holoenzyme. We found that RapA interacts with either form of RNAP. However, RapA exhibits higher affinity for core RNAP than for RNAP holoenzyme. Chemical cross-linking of the RNAP-RapA complex indicated that the RapA-binding sites are located at the interface between the alpha and beta' subunits of RNAP. Contrary to previously reported results (Muzzin, O., Campbell, E., A., Xia, L., Severinova, E., Darst, S. A., and Severinov, K. (1998) J. Biol. Chem. 273, 15157-15161), our in vivo analysis of a rapA null mutant suggested that RapA is not likely to be directly involved in DNA repair.

Structure determination of tubular crystals of membrane proteins. I. Indexing of diffraction patterns

Indexing of diffraction patterns is the starting point of every crystallographic analysis. The diffraction patterns from helical particles consist of a series of layer-planes, the indexing of which involves the assignment of the start numbers of the helices that contribute to the layer-planes. The indexing could be challenging if the diameter of the helical particle is large and if the conventional indexing methods based on selection rule is used. Presented here is a tutorial on how to index them using (h, k; n) indexing method, which is particularly useful for tubular crystals of membrane proteins.

Structural organization of the RNA polymerase-promoter open complex

We have used systematic site-specific protein-DNA photocrosslinking to define interactions between bacterial RNA polymerase (RNAP) and promoter DNA in the catalytically competent RNAP-promoter open complex (RPo). We have mapped more than 100 distinct crosslinks between individual segments of RNAP subunits and individual phosphates of promoter DNA. The results provide a comprehensive description of protein-DNA interactions in RPo, permit construction of a detailed model for the structure of RPo, and permit analysis of effects of a transcriptional activator on the structure of RPo.

Direct localization of a beta-subunit domain on the three-dimensional structure of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase

To identify the location of a domain of the beta-subunit of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase (RNAP) on the three-dimensional structure, we developed a method to tag a nonessential surface of the multisubunit enzyme with a protein density easily detectable by electron microscopy and image processing. Four repeats of the IgG-binding domain of Staphylococcus aureus protein A were inserted at position 998 of the E. coli RNAP beta-subunit. The mutant RNAP supported E. coli growth and showed no apparent functional defects in vitro. The structure of the mutant RNAP was determined by cryoelectron microscopy and image processing of frozen-hydrated helical crystals. Comparison of the mutant RNAP structure with the previously determined wild-type RNAP structure by Fourier difference analysis at 20-A resolution directly revealed the location of the inserted protein domain, thereby locating the region around position 998 of the beta-subunit within the RNAP three-dimensional structure and refining a model for the subunit locations within the enzyme.

Formation of helical protein assemblies of IgG and transducin on varied lipid tubules

Helical protein arrays on lipid tubules are valuable assemblies for studying protein structure and protein-lipid interactions through electron microscopy and crystallography. We describe conditions for forming such arrays from two proteins, IgG and transducin, the photoreceptor G protein, using a variety of lipid surfaces. Anti-dinitrophenyl (DNP) IgG arrays formed on DNP-phosphatidylethanolamine (DNP-PE) mixed with either galactosyl-ceramide lipids or phosphatidylcholine (PC) display different pH sensitivities and dimensions, yet have similar helical symmetries. DNP-PE/PC mixtures formed small crystals and large well-ordered flattened tubules. The peripheral membrane protein transducin (G(t)) formed helical arrays either on a mixture of cationic and neutral lipids or on residual photoreceptor lipids. Despite differences in lipid composition, the G(t) arrays have similar structures and show similar sensitivity to activation and variations in ionic environment. G(t) activation causes the helical assemblies to collapse to small vesicles, a process resembling the vesiculation of activated dynamin-lipid tubules. In a preliminary three-dimensional reconstruction, the hapten-bound IgG appears to make two contacts to the central lipid tubule, presumably via the F(ab) domains. The ability to generate a three-dimensional reconstruction without tilts illustrates one advantage of helical structures for two-dimensional crystallography, especially for visualizing protein-lipid interactions.

Transcription activation by catabolite activator protein (CAP)

Transcription activation by Escherichia coli catabolite activator protein (CAP) at each of two classes of simple CAP-dependent promoters is understood in structural and mechanistic detail. At class I CAP-dependent promoters, CAP activates transcription from a DNA site located upstream of the DNA site for RNA polymerase holoenzyme (RNAP); at these promoters, transcription activation involves protein-protein interactions between CAP and the RNAP alpha subunit C-terminal domain that facilitate binding of RNAP to promoter DNA to form the RNAP-promoter closed complex. At class II CAP-dependent promoters, CAP activates transcription from a DNA site that overlaps the DNA site for RNAP; at these promoters, transcription activation involves both: (i) protein-protein interactions between CAP and RNAP alpha subunit C-terminal domain that facilitate binding of RNAP to promoter DNA to form the RNAP-promoter closed complex; and (ii) protein-protein interactions between CAP and RNAP alpha subunit N-terminal domain that facilitates isomerization of the RNAP-promoter closed complex to the RNAP-promoter open complex. Straightforward combination of the mechanisms for transcription activation at class I and class II CAP-dependent promoters permits synergistic transcription activation by multiple molecules of CAP, or by CAP and other activators. Interference with determinants of CAP or RNAP involved in transcription activation at class I and class II CAP-dependent promoters permits "anti-activation" by negative regulators. Basic features of transcription activation at class I and class II CAP-dependent promoters appear to be generalizable to other activators.

Crystal structure of Thermus aquaticus core RNA polymerase at 3.3 A resolution

The X-ray crystal structure of Thermus aquaticus core RNA polymerase reveals a "crab claw"-shaped molecule with a 27 A wide internal channel. Located on the back wall of the channel is a Mg2+ ion required for catalytic activity, which is chelated by an absolutely conserved motif from all bacterial and eukaryotic cellular RNA polymerases. The structure places key functional sites, defined by mutational and cross-linking analysis, on the inner walls of the channel in close proximity to the active center Mg2+. Further out from the catalytic center, structural features are found that may be involved in maintaining the melted transcription bubble, clamping onto the RNA product and/or DNA template to assure processivity, and delivering nucleotide substrates to the active center.

Interaction with free beta' subunit unmasks DNA-binding domain of RNA polymerase sigma subunit

The promoter recognition site on the sigma70 initiation factor is shielded from interaction with DNA unless sigma70 is bound to the core component of RNA polymerase (RNAP). It is shown that interaction of sigma70 with the isolated beta' subunit of Escherichia coli RNAP is sufficient to induce unshielding of the DNA binding site. Using UV-induced DNA-protein cross-linking we demonstrate that free beta' stimulates specific cross-links between region 2 of the sigma70 polypeptide and a fragment of the non-template promoter strand containing the TATAAT sequence. Thus the sigmabeta' subassembly of RNAP can assume a functionally competent conformation independently of the bulk of the RNAP core.