Simple, reliable detection of T cell clones by PCR-LIS-SSCP analysis of TCRgamma rearrangement

Assay design affects the interpretation of T-cell receptor gamma gene rearrangements: comparison of the performance of a one-tube assay with the BIOMED-2-based TCRG gene clonality assay

Interpretation of capillary electrophoresis results derived from multiplexed fluorochrome-labeled primer sets can be complicated by small peaks, which may be incorrectly interpreted as clonal T-cell receptor-γ gene rearrangements. In this report, different assay designs were used to illustrate how design may adversely affect specificity. Ten clinical cases, with subclonal peaks containing one of the two infrequently used joining genes, were identified with a tri-color, one-tube assay. The DNA was amplified with the same NED fluorochrome on all three joining primers, first combined (one-color assay) and then amplified separately using a single NED-labeled joining primer. The single primer assay design shows how insignificant peaks could easily be wrongly interpreted as clonal T-cell receptor-γ gene rearrangements. Next, the performance of the one-tube assay was compared with the two-tube BIOMED-2-based TCRG Gene Clonality Assay in a series of 44 cases. Whereas sensitivity was similar between the two methods (92.9% vs. 96.4%; P = 0.55), specificity was significantly less in the BIOMED-2 assay (87.5% vs. 56.3%; P = 0.049) when a 2× ratio was used to define clonality. Specificity was improved to 81.3% by the use of a 5× peak height ratio (P = 0.626). These findings illustrate how extra caution is needed in interpreting a design with multiple, separate distributions, which is more difficult to interpret than a single distribution assay.

Effect of age on the repertoire of cytotoxic memory (CD8+CD45RO+) T cells in peripheral blood: the use of rearranged T cell receptor gamma genes as clonal markers

We have established a method to estimate the number of clones in peripheral blood, using rearranged T cell receptor gamma genes as clonal markers, selecting cells at random, and establishing the sizes of the clones to which they belong. Clone sizes were quantified by a clone-specific PCR test based on the VNJ junctional sequence, which typically detects 1-2 copies of its target gene. All clones chosen for study were subsequently quantified in blood, and sizes ranged from 3 x 10(-6) (1 cell in 330,000 CD8+CD45RO+ cells) to 3.5 x 10(-2) permitting numbers of clones to be estimated from the harmonic mean of clone size. Two independent estimates from a healthy young adult (20-30 years old) gave repertoires of 94,000 and 110,000 clones. Two other healthy young adults gave repertoires of 40,000 and 55,000 clones. Repertoires in four healthy active older (>75 years old) adults were more variable but generally lower, being 3600, 5500, 14,000 and 97,000 clones, despite enlarged clones making up >1% of the compartment in the last individual. Overall, young adults had smaller clones (p=0.026, non-directional Mann-Whitney U-test). If the human body contains 5 l of blood, clones have 2 x 10(3)-1.0 x 10(7) cells in blood. These results confirm a diverse repertoire of rearranged T cell receptor gamma genes. The number of clones thus defined are broadly consistent with other estimates of repertoire, despite differences in marker genes used and subsets of cells studied.

A T-cell receptor gamma polymerase chain reaction assay using capillary electrophoresis for the diagnosis of cutaneous T-cell lymphomas

Detection of clonal T-cell receptor gamma rearrangements by polymerase chain reaction (TCRgamma PCR) followed by high-resolution electrophoresis has now become a valuable tool in the diagnosis of cutaneous T-cell lymphoma (CTCL). The identification of clonal TCRgamma PCR products by fluorescent fragment analysis (FFA) on a capillary DNA sequencer is described here and compared with an established hetero-duplex temperature gradient gel electrophoresis (HD-TGGE). Of 55 CTCL derived lesional skin samples, clonality was obtained in 46 samples by FFA (83.6%) and in 45 samples by HD-TGGE (81.8%). Of 35 control skin specimens from various nonmalignant dermatoses, two samples (pityriasis lichenoides chronica) showed clonality by both methods, one sample (chronic dermatitis) only by FFA. The sensitivity of FFA was established using three clonal T-cell lines and peripheral blood mononuclear cells. The detection limit for clonal material was approximately 1% to 2.5% in mixtures of DNA and 1% to 3% in cell dilutions. For cell dilution series, we confirmed a linear correlation between the clonal/polyclonal peak-size ratios and the portion of clonal cells up to about 10%. Thus, the initial ratio between mono-and polyclonal template is correctly displayed by FFA within that concentration range. In conclusion, FFA on capillary DNA sequencer is a well-suited separation technique in TCRgamma PCR-based clonality analysis also exhibiting quantitative properties.

Semireannealing, single-stranded conformational polymorphism: a novel and effective tool for the diagnosis of T-cell clonality

Single-stranded conformational polymorphism (SSCP) is often used for the diagnosis of T-cell clonality in lymphoproliferative disorders. We introduce a semireannealing SSCP (SR-SSCP) protocol that is rapid, reproducible, and effective. By denaturing and reannealing the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) product before high-resolution polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, it is possible to generate a diagnostic fingerprint for each case with clonal T-cell receptor-gamma (TCR-gamma) gene rearrangement detected after PCR with TCR-gamma specific consensus primers. Discrete and distinct denatured single-stranded DNA band profiles characterize the rearranged TCR-gamma clones. In the same gel, the clone size may be estimated in the reannealed double-stranded PCR DNA and can be assessed down to the 2% clonal T-cell population level. Eighty-four cases, including 37 T-cell neoplasms, 29 B-cell neoplasms, and 18 reactive lymph node samples were analyzed by SR-SSCP. Clonal TCR-gamma rearrangement was diagnosed in 32 out of 37 T-cell neoplasms but in none of the B-cell tumors or reactive lymph node samples corresponding to sensitivity and specificity of 86.5% and 100%, respectively. We compare the results of SR-SSCP to those obtained by capillary electrophoresis and direct sequence analysis with 100% correlation. This novel method is applicable to any system for identification and quantitation of microheterogeneity in PCR products.

Induction of polyclonal prostate cancer-specific CTL using dendritic cells transfected with amplified tumor RNA

Polyvalent cancer vaccines targeting the entire antigenic spectrum on tumor cells may represent a superior therapeutic strategy for cancer patients than vaccines solely directed against single Ags. In this study, we show that autologous dendritic cells (DC) transfected with RNA amplified from microdissected tumor cells are capable of stimulating CTL against a broad set of unidentified and critical prostate-specific Ags. Although the polyclonal CTL responses generated with amplified tumor RNA-transfected DC encompassed as a subcomponent a response against prostate-specific Ag (PSA) as well as against telomerase reverse transcriptase, the tumor-specific CTL were consistently more effective than PSA or telomerase reverse transcriptase CTL to lyse tumor targets, suggesting the superiority of the polyclonal response. Although tumor RNA-transfected DC stimulated CTL, which recognized not only tumor but also self-Ags expressed by benign prostate tissue, these cross-reactive CTL were exclusively specific for the PSA, indicating an immunodominant role of PSA in the prostate cancer-specific immune response. Our data suggest that tumor RNA-transfected DC may represent a broadly applicable, potentially clinically effective vaccine strategy for prostate cancer patients, which is not limited by tumor tissue availability for Ag preparation and may minimize the risk of clonal tumor escape.

Detection of clonal T cell populations by high resolution PCR using fluorescently labelled nucleotides; evaluation using conventional LIS-SSCP

AIMS

To detect clonal T cell populations by high resolution polymerase chain reaction (PCR) using fluorescently labelled nucleotides and analysis on an ABI 377 DNA sequencer, and to evaluate this method using low ionic strength single strand conformation polymorphism (LIS-SSCP) analysis.

METHODS

DNA samples from 11 patients diagnosed with a T cell disease and 15 with no known T cell disorder were amplified using four multiplex T cell receptor gamma (TCR gamma) PCR reactions containing fluorescently labelled nucleotides. PCR products were analysed using both LIS-SSCP electrophoresis and an ABI 377 DNA sequencer using Genescan software. A Jurkat T cell leukaemia cell line was used to determine the sensitivity of the two methods.

RESULTS

Clonal TCR gamma populations were detected in all 11 samples from patients with a T cell disease and no clonal populations were detected in samples from patients without a T cell disorder, using both LIS-SSCP and DNA sequencer analysis. Although the sensitivity of the two methods was comparable, the data generated by the sequencer were easier to interpret than the LIS-SSCP gels, and allowed accurate size determination of every product, which was not possible using LIS-SSCP.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of fluorescent labelled nucleotides provides a more flexible and economical alternative to end labelled fluorescent primers for the detection of clonal TCR gamma gene rearrangements. This method allows clonal populations to be sized accurately and reproducibly, permitting the detection of identical clonal populations in different samples, and providing a method of monitoring disease progression and response to treatment.

Benign monoclonal expansion of CD8+ lymphocytes in HIV infection

BACKGROUND

A transient expansion of the CD8+ T cell pool normally occurs in the early phase of HIV infection. Persistent expansion of this pool is observed in two related settings: diffuse infiltrative lymphocytosis syndrome (DILS) and HIV associated CD8+ lymphocytosis syndrome.

AIM

To investigate a group of HIV infected patients with CD8+ lymphocytosis syndrome with particular emphasis on whether monoclonality was present.

METHODS

A group of 18 patients with HIV-1 infection and persistent circulating CD8+ lymphocytosis was compared with 21 HIV positive controls. Serum samples were tested for antinuclear antibodies, antibodies to extractable nuclear antigens, immunoglobulin levels, paraproteins, human T lymphotropic virus type 1 (HTLV-1), Epstein-Barr virus, and cytomegalovirus serology. Lymphocyte phenotyping and HLA-DR typing was performed, and T cell receptor (TCR) gene rearrangement studies used to identify monoclonal populations of T cells. CD4+ and CD8+ subsets of peripheral blood lymphocytes were purified to determine whether CD8+ populations inhibited HIV replication in autologous CD4+ cells.

RESULTS

A subgroup of patients with HIV-1 infection was found to have expanded populations of CD8+ T cell large granular lymphocytes persisting for 6 to 30 months. The consensus immunophenotype was CD4- CD8+ DRhigh CD11a+ CD11c+ CD16- CD28+/- CD56- CD57+, consistent with typical T cell large granular lymphocytes expressing cellular activation markers. Despite the finding of monoclonal TCR gene usage in five of 18 patients, there is evidence that the CD8+ expansions are reactive populations capable of mediating non-cytotoxic inhibition of HIV replication.

CONCLUSIONS

A subgroup of HIV positive patients has CD8+ lymphocytosis, but despite the frequent occurrence of monoclonal TCR gene usage there is evidence that this represents an immune response to viral infection rather than a malignant disorder.

Amplification of PCR products in excess of 600 base pairs using DNA extracted from decalcified, paraffin wax embedded bone marrow trephine biopsies

AIMS

To establish a robust method of extracting DNA from paraffin wax embedded bone marrow trephine (PBMT) biopsies for the amplification of relatively long polymerase chain reaction (PCR) products.

METHOD

Xylene and ethanol were used to remove paraffin wax from eight formalin fixed, EDTA decalcified PBMT biopsies and DNA extraction was performed using a Qiagen QIAamp tissue kit. The DNA samples were amplified using nine different PCR primers sets, including those used to detect chromosomal translocations (t(11;14) and t(14;18), and clonal B cell populations. A t(11;14) PCR product of approximately 600 base pairs (bp) was sequenced using dye terminator cycle sequencing.

RESULTS

All eight DNA samples extracted from PBMT biopsies were amplified successfully to generate DNA fragments up to 643 bp in length. Chromosomal translocations and immunoglobulin gene rearrangements were detected by PCR in some of the samples. Sequencing of the t(11;14) PCR product demonstrated the presence of chimaeric sequences, which included both bcl-1 and immunoglobulin heavy chain (IgH) gene sequences, consistent with the presence of this translocation.

CONCLUSIONS

This method enables PCR analyses of PBMT biopsies that were not previously possible, offering the prospect of improved accuracy of diagnosis and the monitoring of patients with bone marrow disease.

CD4 + /CD7- T cell frequency and polymerase chain reaction-based clonality assay correlate with stage in cutaneous T cell lymphomas

In cutaneous T cell lymphomas, tumor cells can be found in skin and in other compartments. A precise definition of extracutaneous spread including blood involvement is necessary for staging and treatment design. We investigated peripheral blood in 51 patients with various types of cutaneous T cell lymphomas by the analysis of blood smears for Sézary cells, the CD4 + /CD7- T helper cell frequency in the peripheral blood by fluorescence activated cell sorter analysis and by polymerase chain reaction for the T cell receptor gamma-chain followed by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis. Eleven polymerase chain reaction products were sequenced. Thirty-five per cent of patients with stage Ia-IIb cutaneous T cell lymphomas presented a peripheral blood T cell clone. In patients with stage III-IVb cutaneous T cell lymphomas 75% were positive for clonality in the peripheral blood by polymerase chain reaction. Interestingly, three of 13 Sézary patients showed a TCR-gamma joining region pseudogene (JgammaP1/JgammaP2) usage. CD4 + /CD7- cell counts were significantly higher in patients with advanced cutaneous T cell lymphomas than in patients with early cutaneous T cell lymphomas. There was a correlation between increased percentage of circulating CD4 + /CD7- cells and detection of clonality by polymerase chain reaction (p = 0.001). There was no significant correlation between the polymerase chain reaction data and the percentage of Sézary cells on blood smears. A significant correlation between CD4 + /CD7- cells and Sézary cells was found, however. Stepwise logistic regression analysis showed that the CD4 + /CD7- cell count and clonal T cell detection in peripheral blood are independently correlated with stage. The combination of both parameters gives more information than each one separately. In conclusion, our data indicate that fluorescence activated cell sorter analysis of peripheral blood and polymerase chain reaction-based clonality assays can improve the accuracy of staging investigations in cutaneous T cell lymphomas patients.

Detection of clonal T-cell receptor gamma gene rearrangements in paraffin-embedded tissue by polymerase chain reaction and nonradioactive single-strand conformational polymorphism analysis

The diagnosis of T-cell lymphoproliferative disorders, which frequently involve the skin and other extranodal sites, is often problematic because of the difficulty in establishing clonality in paraffin-embedded tissue. To this end, we developed a simple, nonradioactive method to detect T-cell receptor gamma (TCR-gamma) gene rearrangements by polymerase chain reaction single-strand conformational polymorphism (PCR-SSCP) in paraffin-embedded tissue. Jurkat and HSB-2 cell lines and peripheral blood samples from normal individuals were used as monoclonal and polyclonal controls, respectively. DNA was extracted from 24 biopsies of T-cell lymphomas, 12 biopsies of reactive lymphoid infiltrates, and 2 biopsies of primary cutaneous large B-cell lymphomas. Vgamma1-8, Vgamma9, Vgamma10, Vgamma11, and Jgamma1/Jgamma2 consensus primers were used for TCR-gamma gene rearrangement amplification and PCR products were analyzed by nonradioactive SSCP. Monoclonal controls yielded a well-defined banded pattern, whereas all polyclonal T-cell controls showed a reproducible pattern of smears. We detected monoclonality in 20/21 (95%) T-cell lymphoma cases, whereas no dominant T-cell clones were found in any of the reactive lymphoid infiltrates or B-cell lymphomas. Sensitivity of 1-5% was demonstrated by serially diluting Jurkat cells in mononuclear blood cells from normal individuals. We conclude that nonradioactive PCR-SSCP for TCR-gamma gene rearrangement analysis is a useful adjunct to routine histological and immunophenotypic methods in the diagnosis of T-cell lymphoproliferative disorders in paraffin-embedded tissue.