Effect of 5' and 3' terminal sequences, overall length, and coding capacity on the accumulation of defective RNAs associated with broad bean mottle bromovirus in planta

A Survey of Virus Recombination Uncovers Canonical Features of Artificial Chimeras Generated During Deep Sequencing Library Preparation

Chimeric reads can be generated by in vitro recombination during the preparation of high-throughput sequencing libraries. Our attempt to detect biological recombination between the genomes of dengue virus (DENV; +ssRNA genome) and its mosquito host using the Illumina Nextera sequencing library preparation kit revealed that most, if not all, detected host-virus chimeras were artificial. Indeed, these chimeras were not more frequent than with control RNA from another species (a pillbug), which was never in contact with DENV RNA prior to the library preparation. The proportion of chimera types merely reflected those of the three species among sequencing reads. Chimeras were frequently characterized by the presence of 1-20 bp microhomology between recombining fragments. Within-species chimeras mostly involved fragments in opposite orientations and located less than 100 bp from each other in the parental genome. We found similar features in published datasets using two other viruses: Ebola virus (EBOV; -ssRNA genome) and a herpesvirus (dsDNA genome), both produced with the Illumina Nextera protocol. These canonical features suggest that artificial chimeras are generated by intra-molecular template switching of the DNA polymerase during the PCR step of the Nextera protocol. Finally, a published Illumina dataset using the Flock House virus (FHV; +ssRNA genome) generated with a protocol preventing artificial recombination revealed the presence of 1-10 bp microhomology motifs in FHV-FHV chimeras, but very few recombining fragments were in opposite orientations. Our analysis uncovered sequence features characterizing recombination breakpoints in short-read sequencing datasets, which can be helpful to evaluate the presence and extent of artificial recombination.

Use of a defective RNA of broad bean mottle bromovirus for stable gene expression in legumes

A viral vector that expressed foreign genes was engineered using a cDNA clone of broad bean mottle bromovirus (BBMV) defective interfering (DI) RNA. The expression vector required an active ORF to ensure efficient accumulation and replication in the host plants. After mechanical inoculation with BBMV RNAs, expression of the green fluorescent protein (GFP) reporter was driven by DI RNA constructs during consecutive passages through broad bean plants. Our data prove that BBMV DI RNAs, whose yield is similar to the virus genomic components, are useful as gene vectors after mechanical inoculation on legume plants.

A bipartite Tobacco mosaic virus-defective RNA (dRNA) system to study the role of the N-terminal methyl transferase domain in cell-to-cell movement of dRNAs

Plant viruses, in particular Tobacco mosaic virus (TMV), are model systems to study RNA and protein trafficking in plants. Although TMV cell-to-cell transport controlled by the 30-kDa movement protein (MP) has been intensively studied, it was only recently demonstrated that the 126/183-kDa replicase proteins are also involved in cell-to-cell movement. Elucidating the role(s) of 126/183-kDa proteins in movement is complicated because these proteins have multiple functions associated with replication and gene expression. To overcome these difficulties we developed a TMV helper virus-defective RNA (dRNA) system to study the role of replicase protein sequences in dRNA cell-to-cell movement. Artificially constructed dRNAs lacking sequences encoding the helicase and polymerase domains of the replicase proteins and portions of the MP were viable in protoplasts and plants in the presence of helper virus. Expression of at least approximately 50% of the methyl transferase (MT) domain was required for efficient dRNA movement in Nicotiana benthamiana. dRNAs that encoded the N-terminal 64 replicase amino acids or lacked a translatable MT domain failed to move or moved poorly. TMV dRNAs expressing 258 amino acids of the replicase protein moved into all specialized non-vascular tissues, whereas dRNAs expressing replicase sequences beyond amino acid 258 were restricted to the epidermis and palisade mesophyll tissues. Furthermore, second-site mutations within the dRNA-encoded truncated replicase protein altered efficiency in dRNA cell-to-cell movement.

Positional effect of deletions on viability, especially on encapsidation, of Brome mosaic virus D-RNA in barley protoplasts

Brome mosaic virus (BMV), a tripartite RNA plant virus, accumulates RNA3-derived defective RNAs (D-RNAs) in which 477-500 nucleotides (nt) are deleted in the central region of the 3a protein open reading frame (ORF), after prolonged infection in barley. In the present study, six artificial D-RNAs (AD-RNAs), having deletions of the same size as the naturally occurring D-RNA but at different positions in the 3a ORF, were constructed and tested for their amplification and encapsidation in barley protoplasts by coinoculation with BMV RNA1 and 2, or RNA1, 2, and 3. Northern blot analysis of RNA accumulation in total and virion fractions showed that deletions of 492 nt in the 3'-proximal and the 5'-proximal regions of the 3a ORF decreased encapsidation efficiency of the AD-RNAs compared with that of RNA3, whereas deletions in the central region enhanced encapsidation efficiency. The present results also show that deletion positions affect competition with RNA3 in the amplification and encapsidation of AD-RNAs.

A Putative Defective Interfering RNA from Bean pod mottle virus

A putative defective interfering (DI) RNA from the Bean pod mottle virus (BPMV) was discovered by screening of random cDNA clones in a soybean cDNA library. This was unexpected because the library was constructed from mRNA of visually healthy soybean pods. The insert in the cDNA clone, VS-16, is not present in the soybean genome but showed strong mRNA expression in pod tissue of soybean and in bean leaf beetles collected in the field. Analysis of the VS-16 sequence reveals that it has significant homology to the 3.66-kb BPMV RNA-2. A 2-kb region has been deleted in VS-16, and other regions of the viral RNA genome have been rearranged to yield a putative defective interfering RNA (DI RNA) of 1.35 kb. The three regions of VS-16 are 95.8, 77.8, and 85.6% identical at the nucleotide level to the corresponding regions of BPMV RNA-2. This is the first report of a DI RNA from the comovirus group of plant viruses. It may be helpful in antivirus efforts for soybean, especially since there are increasing numbers of reports of BPMV in soybeans in the midwestern United States.

Efficient homologous RNA recombination and requirement for an open reading frame during replication of equine arteritis virus defective interfering RNAs

Equine arteritis virus (EAV), the prototype arterivirus, is an enveloped plus-strand RNA virus with a genome of approximately 13 kb. Based on similarities in genome organization and protein expression, the arteriviruses have recently been grouped together with the coronaviruses and toroviruses in the newly established order Nidovirales. Previously, we reported the construction of pEDI, a full-length cDNA copy of EAV DI-b, a natural defective interfering (DI) RNA of 5.6 kb (R. Molenkamp et al., J. Virol. 74:3156-3165, 2000). EDI RNA consists of three noncontiguous parts of the EAV genome fused in frame with respect to the replicase gene. As a result, EDI RNA contains a truncated replicase open reading frame (EDI-ORF) and encodes a truncated replicase polyprotein. Since some coronavirus DI RNAs require the presence of an ORF for their efficient propagation, we have analyzed the importance of the EDI-ORF in EDI RNA replication. The EDI-ORF was disrupted at different positions by the introduction of frameshift mutations. These were found either to block DI RNA replication completely or to be removed within one virus passage, probably due to homologous recombination with the helper virus genome. Using recombination assays based on EDI RNA and full-length EAV genomes containing specific mutations, the rates of homologous RNA recombination in the 3'- and 5'-proximal regions of the EAV genome were studied. Remarkably, the recombination frequency in the 5'-proximal region was found to be approximately 100-fold lower than that in the 3'-proximal part of the genome.

The fitness of citrus tristeza virus defective RNAs is affected by the lengths of their 5'- and 3'-termini and by the coding capacity

Populations of the Closterovirus Citrus tristeza virus (CTV) generally contain defective RNAs (dRNAs) that vary in size, abundance, and sequence. The variation in abundance of the different dRNAs in a population suggests selection for those of higher fitness. To examine factors affecting fitness of dRNAs, we investigated a series of in vitro constructed dRNAs for their ability to be amplified in protoplasts by an efficiently replicated CTV deletion mutant. The minimal sequences required for accumulation of the dRNAs were within the genomic 5' proximal approximately 1 kb and the 3' 270 nucleotides. However, other factors were involved, because a dRNA with only the minimal sequences failed to be replicated. Rescue of a nonviable dRNA by insertion of nonviral sequences between the termini suggested that "spacing" between terminal cis-acting signals influenced fitness. A continuous open reading frame (ORF) through most of the sequences derived from the 5' of the genome was a requirement for dRNA amplification. In general, insertions, deletions, or nucleotide substitutions were tolerated in the dRNAs as long as an ORF was retained, whereas dRNAs with mutations that prematurely terminated the ORF were not viable. To discriminate between a requirement for an essential protein and ribosomal travel, perhaps to present replication signals to the replicase complex, mutations were made to modify the potential protein but still maintain an ORF. Deletions, insertions of nonviral sequences, or switching of reading frames that altered the amino acid sequence of the protein, except the N-terminal 161 amino acids, did not destroy the fitness of the dRNAs. Yet termination of the ORF in the middle of nonviral sequences did destroy the ability of the dRNAs to be amplified. These results suggest that even though a continuous ORF was needed for fitness, its protein product did not affect the amplification of the dRNAs.

Genetic interrelationships and genome organization of double-stranded RNA elements of Fusarium poae

The similar sized double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) elements present in vegetatively compatible strains of Fusarium poae were always genetically related, while vegetatively incompatible strains of the fungus contained either homologous or non-homologous dsRNAs of the same size. Electron microscopic observations revealed the co-existence of encapsidated and naked dsRNA elements in the same host. A mycovirus, named FUPO-1 was purified from strain A-11 and was found to contain two kinds of dsRNA segments, dsRNA 1 and dsRNA 2. The dsRNA genome of these segments was converted to cDNA clones by reverse transcription and the clones were subjected to sequence analysis. The single long open reading frame deduced from the sequence of dsRNA 1 showed similarities to the putative coat protein genes known from other mycoviruses, while conserved motifs of an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase were identified in the predicted amino acid sequence of dsRNA 2. The genome organization and certain sequence motifs of FUPO-1 show similarities to that of the Atkinsonella hypoxylon 2H virus and the FusoV mycovirus, members of the Partitiviridae family.

A defective RNA associated with bamboo mosaic virus and the possible common mechanisms for RNA recombination in potexviruses

A naturally occurring 1.1 kb RNA was isolated from purified virions of bamboo mosaic potexvirus isolate S (BaMV-S). This RNA is a defective RNA (D RNA) derived from a single internal deletion of the BaMV genome. A cDNA clone representing the complete nucleotide sequence of the BaMV-S D RNA was generated and its nucleotide sequence was determined. The BaMV D cDNA is 1015 nts in length [excluding the poly(A) tail] and consists of two regions corresponding to 867 nts of the 5' terminus and 148 nts of the 3' terminus of the BaMV genomic RNA. BaMV D cDNA contains a single open reading frame (ORF) encoding a putative 29.7 kDa protein comprised of a fusion of the first 258 amino acids of BaMV ORF 1 and the last 2 amino acids of coat protein. The coding capacity of D RNA was verified by in vitro translation of native BaMV-S D RNA and of 1.1 kb RNA transcribed in vitro from the full-length D cDNA. BaMV D RNA can be reproducibly generated by serial passages of BaMV-S in Nicotiana benthamiana and is the first D RNA in the potexvirus group shown to be generated de novo. Alignments of sequences surrounding the 5' and 3' junction borders of reported potexvirus D RNAs reveal a 65.2-84.6% sequence identity, suggesting that common mechanisms for viral RNA recombination are involved in the generation of potexvirus D RNAs.

Deletion of internal sequences results in tobacco mosaic virus defective RNAs that accumulate to high levels without interfering with replication of the helper virus

Deletion of certain internal sequences of the tobacco mosaic tobamovirus (TMV) genome was required to create replication-defective RNAs (dRNA) that were replicated in trans by TMV. All dRNAs that accumulated to detectable levels were missing nucleotides 3420-4902, which appeared to constitute a core region that inhibited replication in trans. Deletion of additional sequences resulted in dRNAs that varied tremendously in ability to be replicated from none to levels exceeding that of the helper viral RNA. Accumulation of dRNA negative- and positive-stranded RNAs of each dRNA paralleled those of the helper virus. Negative-stranded RNA accumulation of both helper and dRNA ceased at the same early time in the infection while synthesis of both positive-stranded RNAs continued, suggesting that both dRNAs and helper virus RNAs were synthesized from the same pool of replicase complexes. Positive- to negative-stranded RNA ratios for the dRNAs were similar to, or slightly greater than the wild-type helper virus. Full-length dRNAs were not supported in trans by a replication-competent helper virus. Even though some of the artificially constructed dRNAs accumulated to levels exceeding the level of the helper virus, none appreciably affected the replication of the helper virus, suggesting that the dRNAs are produced from "excess" replicase capacity.

Molecular characterization of tomato spotted Wilt virus defective interfering RNAs and detection of truncated L proteins

Junction sites of 25 different defective interfering (DI) RNAs of tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) were characterized. The DI RNAs varied in size from 2.0 to 5.2 kilobases (kb) and contained a single internal deletion. The absence of DI RNAs smaller than 2 kb suggested a size constraint for the survival of TSWV DI RNAs. This hypothesis was reinforced by the finding of a dimeric DI RNA formed by two 1.6-long monomers linked head to tail. Three types of junction sites were found, one type originating from a simple deletion; the second type contained a few extra nucleotides of unknown origin; and the third type contained a stretch of three to five nucleotides, originally occurring at both sides of the deletion and of which one was deleted. In 19 of the 25 DI RNAs studied, the original reading frame was maintained, suggesting a selective preference of DI RNAs with translational potency. Truncated proteins encoded by these DI RNAs were indeed detected in the nucleocapsid preparations. Folding studies of the complete L RNA revealed that the calculated minimal energy of folding was at 16 degreesC lower than at 23 degrees, indicating a higher stability of this molecule at low temperatures. The results suggest an involvement of locally folded secondary structures in the process of deletion, rather than the requirement of certain sequences around the deletion point. The DI RNA generation in TSWV is essentially, as discussed, similar to the process of RNA recombination described in many viruses.