Relaxation of ring strains

Formation of the elusive tetrahedral P3N molecule

The tetrahedral 1,2,3-triphospha-4-azatricyclo [1.1.0.0^2,4] butane (P₃N) molecule-an isovalent species of phosphorus (P₄)-was prepared in low-temperature (5 K) phosphine-nitrogen ices and was identified in the gas phase through isomer-selective, tunable, soft photoionization reflectron time-of-flight mass spectrometry. Theoretical calculations reveal that the substitution of a single phosphorus atom by nitrogen in the P₄ molecule results in enhanced spherical aromaticity while simultaneously increasing the strain energy from 74 to 195 kJ mol^-1. In P₃N, the P─P bond is shortened compared to those in P₄ by 3.6 pm, while the P─N─P bond angle of 73.0° is larger by 13.0° compared to the P─P─P bond angle of 60.0° in P₄. The identification of tetrahedral P₃N enhances our fundamental understanding of the chemical bonding, electronic structure, and stability of binary, interpnictide tetrahedral molecules and reveals a universal route to prepare ring strained cage molecules in extreme environments.

Accurate Ring Strain Energies of Unsaturated Three-Membered Heterocycles with One Group 13-16 Element

High-quality ring strain energy (RSE) data for 1H-unsaturated (CH)₂X parent rings, where X is a group 13–16 element, are reported in addition to the 2H-isomers of the pnictogenirene rings. RSE data are obtained from appropriate homosdesmotic reactions and calculated at the DLPNO-CCSD(T)/def2-TZVPP//B3LYP-D3/def2-TZVP(ecp) level. 1H-Tallirene and 1H-plumbirene have unique donor–acceptor structures between an acetylene π(CC) orbital and an empty p orbital of a metallylene subunit (a Dewar–Chatt–Duncanson description) and therefore cannot be described as proper rings but as pseudocyclic structures. Also, 1H-indirene and 1H-oxirene lack ring critical points and constitute borderline cases of pseudorings. 1H-Unsaturated rings exhibit enhanced RSE compared to their saturated homologues. The mechanism of ring strain relaxation by increasing the s character in the lone pair (LP) of group 15–16 elements is remarkable and increases on descending the groups. Furthermore, RSE is affected by the aromatic character of group 13 rings and certain aromatic or antiaromatic character in group 14 or 15–16 rings, respectively, which tend to vanish on descending the group as shown by NICS(1) values. 2H-Unsaturated rings were found only for group 15 elements (although only 2H-azirine shows a proper cyclic structure) and displayed lower RSE (higher stability) than the corresponding 1H-isomers.

Accurate ring strain energies (RSE) are calculated for three-membered 1H-unsaturated rings containing a 13−16 group element and group 15 2H-isomers. The presence or absence of lone pairs at the heteroatom and the existence of intrinsic or residual (anti)aromaticity were shown to affect the RSE.

Alleviating Strain in Organic Molecules by Incorporation of Phosphorus: Synthesis of Triphosphatetrahedrane

Phosphatetrahedranes (^tBuCP)₂ and (^tBuC)₃P were recently reported and represent the first tetrahedranes containing a mixed carbon/phosphorus core. Herein, we report that tetrahydrofuran (THF) solutions of the parent triphosphatetrahedrane HCP₃ may be generated in 31% yield (NMR internal standard yield) by combining [Na(THF)₃][P₃Nb(ODipp)₃] (Dipp = 2,6-diisopropylphenyl), INb(ODipp)₃(THF), and bromodichloromethane in thawing THF. While HCP₃ was found to be stable in dilute THF solutions for extended periods of time, the concentration of the solution at -40 °C led to the formation of a black precipitate, which has been tentatively assigned as a polymerized form of HCP₃. HCP₃ reacts readily with (dppe)Fe(Cp*)Cl (dppe = 1,2-bis(diphenylphosphino)ethane, Cp*= η⁵-C₅Me₅) in the presence of Na[BPh₄] to form a purple cationic iron complex of triphosphatetrahedrane (50% yield), which was structurally characterized in a single-crystal X-ray diffraction experiment. Additionally, we present a series of homodesmotic equations analyzed via quantum chemical calculations that suggest triphosphatetrahedrane is the least strained of the mixed C/P phosphatetrahedranes.

Accurate Ring Strain Energy Calculations on Saturated Three-Membered Heterocycles with One Group 13-16 Element

Accurate ring strain energy (RSE) data for parent (CH₂)₂X rings are reported, where X are group 13-16 elements (El) in their lowest oxidation state, from the second to the sixth row, with their covalence completed by bonds to H. They are obtained from appropriate homodesmotic and hyper-homodesmotic reactions at different levels up to the CCSD(T) level, thus providing a benchmark of high-quality reference RSE values, as well as acceptably accurate faster lower-level options. Derivatives of indium, thallium, and lead cannot be properly described by a three-member ring connectivity, because they display a unique donor-acceptor structure from an ethylene π(C═C) orbital to an empty p orbital of a metallylene subunit. The RSE of groups 13 and 14 heterocycles increases on descending in the group (except for Ga and Ge), while it decreases for groups 15 and 16. The latter is presumably due to a strain-releasing mechanism favored by the increase of p-character at the sp³-type atomic orbital used by El in the endocyclic El-C bonds, %p(El)_El-C, originated by the tendency of the El lone pairs in groups 15-16 to increase their s-character. This strain-releasing mechanism does not exist in heavier tetrels, which keep almost unchanged the p-character in the endocyclic bonds at El, whereas for triels the p-character is still lower owing to their sp²-like hybridization. Remarkable linear correlations were found between the RSE and either the above-mentioned %p(El)_El-C, the distal C-C bond distance or the relaxed force constants for the endocyclic bond angles.

Electron-Deficiency Aromaticity in Silicon Nanoclusters

Aromaticity in silicon-containing molecules has been a controversy for more than a century. Combining molecular dynamics simulations with ab initio calculations, we show here that it is possible to obtain aromatic-like behavior with pure hydrogenated silicon clusters without the need for multiple bonds. To this end, we exploit the natural tendency of silicon toward overcoordination to construct electron-deficient molecules with ring structures. Even without the incorporation of any protective bulky substituents the resulting structures are more stable than any other known hydrogenated silicon nanoparticles of this size and exhibit aromatic-like properties due to strong electron delocalization.