Force Generation Simplified

The force-generation process in active muscle is strain sensitive and endothermic: a temperature-perturbation study

In experiments on active muscle, we examined the tension decline and its temperature sensitivity at the onset of ramp shortening and at a range of velocities. A segment (∼1.5 mm long) of a skinned muscle fibre isolated from rabbit psoas muscle was held isometrically (sarcomere length ∼2.5 µm) at 8-9°C, maximally Ca²⁺-activated and a ramp shortening applied. The tension decline with a ramp shortening showed an early decrease of slope (the P₁ transition) followed by a slower decrease in slope (the P₂ transition) to the steady (isotonic) force. The tension level at the initial P₁ transition and the time to that transition decreased as the velocity was increased; the length change to this transition increased with shortening velocity to a steady value of ∼8 nm half-sarcomere^-1 A small, rapid, temperature jump (T-jump) (3-4°C, <0.2 ms) applied coincident with the onset of ramp shortening showed force enhancement by T-jump and changed the tension decline markedly. Analyses showed that the rate of T-jump-induced force rise increased linearly with increase of shortening velocity. These results provide crucial evidence that the strain-sensitive cross-bridge force generation, or a step closely coupled to it, is endothermic.

The endothermic ATP hydrolysis and crossbridge attachment steps drive the increase of force with temperature in isometric and shortening muscle

The isometric tetanic tension of skeletal muscle increases with temperature because attached crossbridge states bearing a relatively low force convert to those bearing a higher force. It was previously proposed that the tension-generating step(s) in the crossbridge cycle was highly endothermic and was therefore itself directly targeted by changes in temperature. However, this did not explain why a rapid rise in temperature (a temperature jump) caused a much slower rate of rise of tension than a rapid length step. This led to suggestions that the step targeted by a temperature rise is not the tension-generating step but is an extra step in the attached pathway of the crossbridge cycle, perhaps located on a parallel pathway. This enigma has been a major obstacle to a full understanding of the operation of the crossbridge cycle. We have now used a previously developed mechano-kinetic model of the crossbridge cycle in frog muscle to simulate the temperature dependence of isometric tension and shortening velocity. We allowed all five steps in the cycle to be temperature-sensitive. Models with different starting combinations of enthalpy changes and activation enthalpies for the five steps were refined by downhill simplex runs and scored by their ability to fit experimental data on the temperature dependence of isometric tension and the relationship between force and shortening velocity in frog muscle. We conclude that the first tension-generating step may be weakly endothermic and that the rise of tension with temperature is largely driven by the preceding two strongly endothermic steps of ATP hydrolysis and attachment of M.ADP.Pi to actin. The refined model gave a reasonable fit to the available experimental data and after a temperature jump the overall rate of tension rise was much slower than after a length step as observed experimentally. The findings aid our understanding of the crossbridge cycle by showing that it may not be necessary to include an additional temperature-sensitive step.

Mechanism of force enhancement during and after lengthening of active muscle: a temperature dependence study

The aim of the present study was to examine the temperature dependence of active force in lengthening and shortening muscle. Experiments were done, in vitro, on bundles of intact fibres (fibre length L(0) ~2 mm; sarcomere length ~2.5 μm) isolated from a rat fast muscle (flexor hallucis brevis) and a ramp length change of 5-7% L(0) was applied on the plateau of an isometric tetanic contraction. Ramp lengthening increased and ramp shortening decreased the muscle tension to new approximately steady levels in a velocity-dependent way. The isometric tension and the lower steady tension reached at a given shortening velocity, increased with warming from 10 to 35 °C and the relation between tension and reciprocal absolute temperature was sigmoidal. However, the tension-temperature curve of shortening muscle was sharper and shifted to higher temperature with increased velocity. In contrast, the enhanced steady tension during lengthening at a given velocity was largely temperature-insensitive within the same temperature range; we hypothesize that the tension-temperature curve may be shifted to lower temperatures in lengthening muscle. Consequently, when normalised to the isometric tension at each temperature, the tension during lengthening at a given velocity decreased exponentially with increase of temperature. The residual force enhancement that remains after ramp lengthening showed a similar behaviour and was markedly reduced in warming from 10 to 35 °C. The findings are consistent with the thesis that active force generation in muscle is endothermic and strain-sensitive; during shortening with a faster crossbridge cycle it becomes more pronounced, but during lengthening it becomes depressed as the cycle slows in a velocity-dependent way. The residual force enhancement may be caused by the same process in addition to non-crossbridge mechanism(s).

Crossbridge mechanism(s) examined by temperature perturbation studies on muscle

An overall view of the contractile process that has emerged from -temperature-studies on active muscle is outlined. In isometric muscle, a small rapid temperature-jump (T-jump) enhances an early, pre-phosphate release, step in the acto-myosin (crossbridge) ATPase cycle and induces a characteristic rise in force indicating that crossbridge force generation is endothermic (force rises when heat is absorbed). Sigmoidal temperature dependence of steady force is largely due to the endothermic nature of force generation. During shortening, when muscle force is decreased, the T-jump force generation is enhanced; conversely, when a muscle is lengthening and its force increased, the T-jump force generation is inhibited. Taking T-jump force generation as a signature of the crossbridge - ATPase cycle, the results suggest that during lengthening the ATPase cycle is truncated before endothermic force generation, whereas during shortening this step and the ATPase cycle, are accelerated; this readily provides a molecular basis for the Fenn effect.

Force and power generating mechanism(s) in active muscle as revealed from temperature perturbation studies

The basic characteristics of the process of force and power generation in active muscle that have emerged from temperature studies are examined. This is done by reviewing complementary findings from temperature-dependence studies and rapid temperature-jump (T-jump) experiments and from intact and skinned fast mammalian muscle fibres. In isometric muscle, a small T-jump leads to a characteristic rise in force showing that crossbridge force generation is endothermic (heat absorbed) and associated with increased entropy (disorder). The sensitivity of the T-jump force generation to added inorganic phosphate (Pi) indicates that a T-jump enhances an early step in the actomyosin (crossbridge) ATPase cycle before Pi-release. During muscle lengthening when steady force is increased, the T-jump force generation is inhibited. Conversely, during shortening when steady force is decreased, the T-jump force generation is enhanced in a velocity-dependent manner, showing that T-jump force generation is strain sensitive. Within the temperature range of ∼5–35◦C, the temperature dependence of steady active force is sigmoidal both in isometric and in shortening muscle. However, in shortening muscle, the endothermic character of force generation becomes more pronounced with increased velocity and this can, at least partly, account for the marked increase with warming of the mechanical power output of active muscle.

Temperature jump induced force generation in rabbit muscle fibres gets faster with shortening and shows a biphasic dependence on velocity

We examined the tension responses to ramp shortening and rapid temperature jump (<0.2 ms, 3-4 degrees C T-jump) in maximally Ca(2+)-activated rabbit psoas muscle fibres at 8-9 degrees C (the fibre length (L(0)) was approximately 1.5 mm and sarcomere length 2.5 microm). The aim was to investigate the strain sensitivity of crossbridge force generation in muscle. The T-jump induced tension rise was examined during steady shortening over a wide range of velocities (V) approaching the V(max) (V range approximately 0.01 to approximately 1.5 L(0) s(1)). In the isometric state, a T-jump induced a biphasic tension rise consisting of a fast (approximately 50 s(1), phase 2b) and a slow (approximately 10 s(1), phase 3) component, but if treated as monophasic the rate was approximately 20 s(1). During steady shortening the T-jump tension rise was monophasic; the rate of tension rise increased linearly with shortening velocity, and near V(max) it was approximately 200 s(1), approximately 10x faster than in the isometric state. Relative to the tension reached after the T-jump, the amplitude increased with shortening velocity, and near V(max) it was 4x larger than in the isometric state. Thus, the temperature sensitivity of muscle force is markedly increased with velocity during steady shortening, as found in steady state experiments. The rate of tension decline during ramp shortening also increased markedly with increase of velocity. The absolute amplitude of T-jump tension rise was larger than that in the isometric state at the low velocities (<0.5 L(0) s(1)) but decreased to below that of the isometric state at the higher velocities. Such a biphasic velocity dependence of the absolute amplitude of T-jump tension rise implies interplay between, at least, two processes that have opposing effects on the tension output as the shortening velocity is increased, probably enhancement of crossbridge force generation and faster (post-stroke) crossbridge detachment by negative strain. Overall, our results show that T-jump force generation is strain sensitive and becomes considerably faster when exposed to negative strain. Thus the crossbridge force generation step in muscle is both temperature sensitive (endothermic) and strain sensitive.

Mechanistic role of movement and strain sensitivity in muscle contraction

Tension generation can be studied by applying step perturbations to contracting muscle fibers and subdividing the mechanical response into exponential phases. The de novo tension-generating isomerization is associated with one of these phases. Earlier work has shown that a temperature jump perturbs the equilibrium constant directly to increase tension. Here, we show that a length jump functions quite differently. A step release (relative movement of thick and thin filaments) appears to release a steric constraint on an ensemble of noncompetent postphosphate release actomyosin cross-bridges, enabling them to generate tension, a concentration jump in effect. Structural studies [Taylor KA, et al. (1999) Tomographic 3D reconstruction of quick-frozen, Ca(2+)-activated contracting insect flight muscle. Cell 99:421-431] that map to these kinetics indicate that both catalytic and lever arm domains of noncompetent myosin heads change angle on actin, whereas lever arm movement alone mediates the power stroke. Together, these kinetic and structural observations show a 13-nm overall interaction distance of myosin with actin, including a final 4- to 6-nm power stroke when the catalytic domain is fixed on actin. Raising fiber temperature with both perturbation techniques accelerates the forward, but slows the reverse rate constant of tension generation, kinetics akin to the unfolding/folding of small proteins. Decreasing strain, however, causes both forward and reverse rate constants to increase. Despite these changes in rate, the equilibrium constant is strain-insensitive. Activation enthalpy and entropy data show this invariance to be the result of enthalpy-entropy compensation. Reaction amplitudes confirm a strain-invariant equilibrium constant and thus a strain-insensitive ratio of pretension- to tension-generating states as work is done.

An analysis of the temperature dependence of force, during steady shortening at different velocities, in (mammalian) fast muscle fibres

We examined, over a wide range of temperatures (10–35°C), the isometric tension and tension during ramp shortening at different velocities (0.2–4 L₀/s) in tetanized intact fibre bundles from a rat fast (flexor hallucis brevis) muscle; fibre length (L₀) was 2.2 mm and sarcomere length ~2.5 μm. During a ramp shortening, the tension change showed an initial inflection of small amplitude (P₁), followed by a larger exponential decline towards an approximate steady level; the tension continued to decline slowly afterwards and the approximate steady tension at a given velocity was estimated as the tension (P₂) at the point of intersection between two linear slopes, as previously described (Roots et al. 2007). At a given temperature, the tension P₂ declined to a lower level and at a faster rate (from an exponential curve fit) as the shortening velocity was increased; the temperature sensitivity of the rate of tension decline during ramp shortening at different velocities was low (Q₁₀ 0.9–1.5). The isometric tension and the P₂ tension at a given shortening velocity increased with warming so that the relation between tension and (reciprocal) temperature was sigmoidal in both. In isometric muscle, the temperature T_0.5 for half-maximal tension was ~10°C, activation enthalpy change (∆H) was ~100 kJ mol⁻¹ and entropy change (∆S) ~350 J mol⁻¹ K⁻¹. In shortening, these were increased with increase of velocity so that at a shortening velocity (~4 L₀/s) producing maximal power at 35°C, T_0.5 was ~28°C, ∆H was ~200 kJ mol⁻¹ and ∆S ~ 700 J mol⁻¹ K⁻¹; the same trends were seen in the tension data from isotonic release experiments on intact muscle and in ramp shortening experiments on maximally Ca-activated skinned fibres. In general, our findings show that the sigmoidal relation between force and temperature can be extended from isometric to shortening muscle; the implications of the findings are discussed in relation to the crossbridge cycle. The data indicate that the endothermic, entropy driven process that underlies crossbridge force generation in isometric muscle (Zhao and Kawai 1994; Davis, 1998) is even more pronounced in shortening muscle, i.e. when doing external work.

Mechanism of tension generation in muscle: an analysis of the forward and reverse rate constants

Tension generation in muscle occurs during the attached phase of the ATP-powered cyclic interaction of myosin heads with thin filaments. The transient nature of tension-generating intermediates and the complexity of the mechanochemical cross-bridge cycle have impeded a quantitative description of tension generation. Recent experiments performed under special conditions yielded a sigmoidal dependence of fiber tension on temperature--a unique case that simplifies the system to a two-state transition. We have applied this two-state analysis to kinetic data obtained from biexponential laser temperature-jump tension transients. Here we present the forward and reverse rate constants for de novo tension generation derived from analysis of the kinetics of the fast laser temperature-jump phase tau(2) (equivalent of the length-jump phase 2(slow)). The slow phase tau(3) is temperature-independent indicating coupling to rather than a direct role in, de novo tension generation. Increasing temperature accelerates the forward, and slows the reverse, rate constant for the creation of the tension-generating state. Arrhenius behavior of the forward and anti-Arrhenius behavior of the reverse rate constant is a kinetic signature of multistate multipathway protein-folding reactions. We conclude that locally unfolded tertiary and/or secondary structure of the actomyosin cross-bridge mediates the power stroke.

Endothermic force generation, temperature-jump experiments and effects of increased [MgADP] in rabbit psoas muscle fibres

We studied, by experiment and by kinetic modelling, the characteristics of the force increase on heating (endothermic force) in muscle. Experiments were done on maximally Ca2+-activated, permeabilized, single fibres (length approximately 2 mm; sarcomere length, 2.5 microm) from rabbit psoas muscle; [MgATP] was 4.6 mM, pH 7.1 and ionic strength was 200 mM. A small-amplitude (approximately 3 degrees C) rapid laser temperature-jump (0.2 ms T-jump) at 8-9 degrees C induced a tension rise to a new steady state and it consisted of two (fast and slow) exponential components. The T-jump-induced tension rise became slower as [MgADP] was increased, with half-maximal effect at 0.5 mM [MgADP]; the pre- and post-T-jump tension increased approximately 20% with 4 mM added [MgADP]. As determined by the tension change to small, rapid length steps (<1.4%L0 complete in <0.5 ms), the increase of force by [MgADP] was not associated with a concomitant increase of stiffness; the quick tension recovery after length steps (Huxley-Simmons phase 2) was slower with added MgADP. In steady-state experiments, the tension was larger at higher temperatures and the plot of tension versus reciprocal absolute temperature was sigmoidal, with a half-maximal tension at 10-12 degrees C; the relation with added 4 mM MgADP was shifted upwards on the tension axis and towards lower temperatures. The potentiation of tension with 4 mM added MgADP was 20-25% at low temperatures (approximately 5-10 degrees C), but approximately 10% at the physiological temperatures (approximately 30 degrees C). The shortening velocity was decreased with increased [MgADP] at low and high temperatures. The sigmoidal relation between tension and reciprocal temperature, and the basic effects of increased [MgADP] on endothermic force, can be qualitatively simulated using a five-step kinetic scheme for the crossbridge/A-MATPase cycle where the force generating conformational change occurs in a reversible step before the release of inorganic phosphate (P(i)), it is temperature sensitive (Q10 of approximately 4) and the release of MgADP occurs by a subsequent, slower, two-step mechanism. Modelling shows that the sigmoidal relation between force and reciprocal temperature arises from conversion of preforce-generating (A-M.ADP.P(i)) states to force-bearing (A-M.ADP) states as the temperature is raised. A tension response to a simulated T-jump consists of three (one fast and two slow) components, but, by combining the two slow components, they could be reduced to two; their relative amplitudes vary with temperature. The model can qualitatively simulate features of the tension responses induced by large-T-jumps from low starting temperatures, and those induced by small-T-jumps from different starting temperatures and, also, the interactive effects of P(i) and temperature on force in muscle fibres.

Kinetic effects of fiber type on the two subcomponents of the Huxley-Simmons phase 2 in muscle

The Huxley-Simmons phase 2 controls the kinetics of the first stages of tension recovery after a step-change in fiber length and is considered intimately associated with tension generation. It had been shown that phase 2 is comprised of two distinct unrelated phases. This is confirmed here by showing that the properties of phase 2(fast) are independent of fiber type, whereas those of phase 2(slow) are fiber type dependent. Phase 2(fast) has a rate of 1000-2000 s(-1) and is temperature insensitive (Q(10) approximately 1.16) in fast, medium, and slow speed fibers. Regardless of fiber type and temperature, the amplitude of phase 2(fast) is half (approximately 0.46) that of phase 1 (fiber instantaneous stiffness). Consequently, fiber compliance (cross-bridge and thick/thin filament) appears to be the common source of both phase 1 elasticity and phase 2(fast) viscoelasticity. In fast fibers, stiffness increases in direct proportion to tension from an extrapolated positive origin at zero tension. The simplest explanation is that tension generation can be approximated by two-state transition from attached preforce generating (moderate stiffness) to attached force generating (high stiffness) states. Phase 2(slow) is quite different, progressively slowing in concert with fiber type. An interesting interpretation of the amplitude and rate data is that reverse coupling of phase 2(slow) back to P(i) release and ATP hydrolysis appears absent in fast fibers, detectable in medium speed fibers, and marked in slow fibers contracting isometrically. Contracting slow and heart muscles stretched under load could employ this enhanced reversibility of the cross-bridge cycle as a mechanism to conserve energy.

Kinetic effects of myosin regulatory light chain phosphorylation on skeletal muscle contraction

Kinetic analysis of contracting fast and slow rabbit muscle fibers in the presence of the tension inhibitor 2,3-butanedione monoxime suggests that regulatory light chain (RLC) phosphorylation up-regulates the flux of weakly attached cross-bridges entering the contractile cycle by increasing the actin-catalyzed release of phosphate from myosin. This step appears to be separate from earlier Ca(2+) regulated steps. Small step-stretches of single skinned fibers were used to study the effect of phosphorylation on fiber mechanics. Subdivision of the resultant tension transients into the Huxley-Simmons phases 1, 2(fast), 2(slow), 3, and 4 reveals that phosphorylation reduces the normalized amplitude of the delayed rise in tension (stretch activation response) by decreasing the amplitudes of phase 3 and, to a lesser extent, phase 2(slow). In slow fibers, the RLC P1 isoform phosphorylates at least 4-fold faster than the P2 isoform, complicating the role of RLC phosphorylation in heart and slow muscle. We discuss the functional relevance of the regulation of stretch activation by RLC phosphorylation for cardiac and other oscillating muscles and speculate how the interaction of the two heads of myosin could account for the inverse effect of Ca(2+) levels on isometric tension and rate of force redevelopment (k(TR)).