The Telencephalon of Cartilaginous Fishes. In: Jones EG, Peters A, editors. Comparative Structure and Evolution of Cerebral Cortex, Part I. Boston: Springer US; 1990. pp. 3-30. [DOI: 10.1007/978-1-4757-9622-3_1]

Structural and functional evolution of the basal ganglia in vertebrates

While a basal ganglia with striatal and pallidal subdivisions is 1 clearly present in many extant anamniote species, this basal ganglia is cell sparse and receives only a relatively modest tegmental dopaminergic input and little if any cortical input. The major basal ganglia influence on motor functions in anamniotes appears to be exerted via output circuits to the tectum. In contrast, in modern mammals, birds, and reptiles (i.e., modern amniotes), the striatal and pallidal parts of the basal ganglia are very neuron-rich, both consist of the same basic populations of neurons in all amniotes, and the striatum receives abundant tegmental dopaminergic and cortical input. The functional circuitry of the basal ganglia also seems very similar in all amniotes, since the major basal ganglia influences on motor functions appear to be exerted via output circuits to both cerebral cortex and tectum in sauropsids (i.e., birds and reptiles) and mammals. The basal ganglia, output circuits to the cortex, however, appear to be considerably more developed in mammals than in birds and reptiles. The basal ganglia, thus, appears to have undergone a major elaboration during the evolutionary transition from amphibians to reptiles. This elaboration may have enabled amniotes to learn and/or execute a more sophisticated repertoire of behaviors and movements, and this ability may have been an important element of the successful adaptation of amniotes to a fully terrestrial habitat. The mammalian lineage appears, however, to have diverged somewhat from the sauropsid lineage with respect to the emergence of the cerebral cortex as the major target of the basal ganglia circuitry devoted to executing the basal ganglia-mediated control of movement.

The emergence and evolution of mammalian neocortex

Cortical variation in mammals and other terrestrial vertebrates, re-examined by current comparative methodology (out-group analysis), indicates that separate lateral (olfactory), dorsal and medial (hippocampal) pallial or cortical formations arose with the origin of vertebrates. Although the exact origin of mammalian isocortex (so-called neocortex) is still disputed, it appears that the earliest mammals already had a six-layered isocortex with ten to 20 functional subdivisions. Among placental mammals, at least, isocortex has expanded numerous times, producing additional cortical subdivisions. Because these expansions were independent transformations of a simpler cortex, they produced subdivisions that are not homologous.

Secondary olfactory projections and pallial topography in the Pacific hagfish, Eptatretus stouti

The extent of the secondary olfactory projections shows great variation among different groups of craniates. Gnathostomes typically display restricted secondary olfactory projections, whereas lampreys have more extensive projections. Any attempt to determine the phylogenetic polarity of these characters, that is, to decide which is primitive and which is derived, requires an investigation of the secondary olfactory system in the sister group of lampreys and gnathostomes, the hagfishes. Therefore the secondary olfactory projections of the Pacific hagfish, Eptatretus stouti, were traced with the use of horseradish peroxidase and the lipophilic fluorescent tracing compound DiI. The projections are bilateral and massive to all pallial areas and the septum, moderate to the striatum, and relatively weak to the preoptic and infundibular regions of the hypothalamus, reaching caudally to the diencephalic-mesencephalic boundary. Afferents to the olfactory bulb arise from the pallium, the preoptic area, and the ventral thalamus. We compare the secondary olfactory projections in hagfishes with those in lampreys and in gnathostomes, and we conclude that the presence of extensive secondary olfactory projections is a primitive character of craniate brains.