Methods for evaluation of antiviral efficacy against influenza virus infections in animal models

Discovery and development of safe-in-man broad-spectrum antiviral agents

•

We reviewed the discovery and development process of broad-spectrum antiviral agents.

•

We summarized the information on 120 safe-in-man agents in a freely accessible database.

•

Further studies will increase the number of broad-spectrum antivirals, expand the spectrum of their indications, and identify drug combinations for treatment of emerging and re-emerging viral infections.

Viral diseases are one of the leading causes of morbidity and mortality in the world. Virus-specific vaccines and antiviral drugs are the most powerful tools to combat viral diseases. However, broad-spectrum antiviral agents (BSAAs, i.e. compounds targeting viruses belonging to two or more viral families) could provide additional protection of the general population from emerging and re-emerging viral diseases, reinforcing the arsenal of available antiviral options. Here, we review discovery and development of BSAAs and summarize the information on 120 safe-in-man agents in a freely accessible database (https://drugvirus.info/). Future and ongoing pre-clinical and clinical studies will increase the number of BSAAs, expand the spectrum of their indications, and identify drug combinations for treatment of emerging and re-emerging viral infections as well as co-infections.

Development of a respiratory disease model for enterovirus D68 in 4-week-old mice for evaluation of antiviral therapies

Enterovirus D68 (EV-D68) is a non-polio enterovirus that affects the respiratory system and can cause serious complications, especially in children and older people with weakened immune systems. As an emerging virus, there are no current antiviral therapies or vaccines available. Our goal was to develop a mouse model of human EV-D68 infection that mimicked the disease observed in humans and could be used for evaluation of experimental therapeutics. This is the first report of a respiratory disease model for EV-D68 infection in mice. We adapted the virus by 30 serial passages in AG129 mice, which are deficient in IFN- α/β and -γ receptors. Despite a lack of weight loss or mortality in mice, lung function measured by plethysmography, showed an increase in enhanced pause (Penh) on days 6 and 7 post-infection. In addition, as virus adapted to mice, virus titer in the lungs increased 50-fold, and the pro-inflammatory cytokines MCP-1 and RANTES increased 15-fold and 2-fold in the lung, respectively. In addition, a time course of mouse-adapted EV-D68 infection was determined in lung, blood, liver, kidney, spleen, leg muscle, spinal cord and brain. Virus in the lung replicated rapidly after intranasal inoculation of adapted virus, 10⁶ CCID₅₀/mL by 4 h and 10^8.3 CCID₅₀/mL by 24 h. Virus then spread to the blood and other tissues, including spinal cord and brain. This mouse model for EV-D68 infection includes enhanced pause (Penh) as an indicator of morbidity, and viremia, virus titers and proinflammatory cytokines in the lung, and lung histopathology as indicators of disease. Our mouse-adapted virus has a similar antiviral profile to the original isolate as well as another respiratory picornavirus, rhinovirus-14. This model will be valuable in evaluating experimental therapies in the future.

Structure-Property Relationship Studies of Influenza A Virus AM2-S31N Proton Channel Blockers

Majority of current circulating influenza A viruses carry the S31N mutation in their M2 genes, rendering AM2-S31N as a high profile antiviral drug target. With our continuous interest in developing AM2-S31N channel blockers as novel antivirals targeting both oseltamivir-sensitive and -resistant influenza A viruses, we report herein the structure-property relationship studies of AM2-S31N inhibitors. The goal was to identify lead compounds with improved microsomal stability and membrane permeability. Two lead compounds, 10d and 10e, were found to have high mouse and human liver microsomal stability (T _1/2 > 145 min) and membrane permeability (>200 nm/s). Both compounds also inhibit both currently circulating oseltamivir-sensitive and -resistant human influenza A viruses (H1N1 and H3N2) with EC₅₀ values ranging from 0.4 to 2.8 μM and a selectivity index of >100. We also showed for the first time that AM2-S31N channel blockers such as 10e inhibited influenza virus replication at both low and high multiply of infection (10²-10⁶ pfu/mL) and the inhibition was not cell-type dependent. Overall, these studies have identified two promising lead candidates for further development as antiviral drugs against drug-resistant influenza A viruses.

Assessment of Influenza Virus Hemagglutinin Stalk-Specific Antibody Responses

Animal models are essential to examine the pathogenesis and transmission of influenza viruses and for preclinical evaluation of influenza virus vaccines. Among the animal models used in influenza virus research, the domestic ferret (Mustela putorius furo) is the gold standard. As seen in humans, infection with influenza virus or immunization with an influenza virus vaccine induces humoral and cellular immunity in ferrets that provides protection against infection by an antigenically similar influenza virus. Antibodies against the globular head domain of the influenza hemagglutinin can provide sterilizing immunity against virus infection by blocking receptor binding. However, antibodies that bind the stalk region of the hemagglutinin also confer protection by several mechanisms including antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity or phagocytosis. Recently, the antigenically and structurally conserved hemagglutinin stalk has become an attractive target for the development of universal influenza virus vaccines that hold the promise to provide protection against influenza epidemics and pandemics. Herein, in vivo and in vitro assays, including optimization of assay conditions to examine hemagglutinin stalk-specific antibody responses in small animal models, are described.

Serum amyloid A (SAA) is an early biomarker of influenza virus disease in BALB/c, C57BL/2, Swiss-Webster, and DBA.2 mice

Assessment of influenza virus disease progression and efficacy of antiviral therapy in the widely used mouse models relies mostly on body weight loss and lung virus titers as markers of disease. However, both parameters have their shortcomings. Therefore, the aim of our study was to find non-invasive markers in the murine model of severe influenza that could detect disease early and predict disease outcome. BALB/c mice were lethally infected with influenza A(H1N1)pdm09 virus and serum samples were collected at various time points. Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays were performed to quantify amounts of serum amyloid A (SAA), C-reactive protein, complement 3, transferrin, corticosterone, prostaglandin E2, H2O2, and alpha-2,6-sialyltransferase. We found that SAA was the most promising candidate with levels acutely and temporarily elevated by several hundred-fold 3 days post virus inoculation. Upon treatment with oseltamivir phosphate, levels of SAA were significantly decreased. High levels of SAA were associated with poor disease prognosis, whereas body weight loss was not as a reliable predictor of disease outcome. SAA levels were also transiently increased in BALB/c mice infected with influenza A(H3N2) and influenza B virus, as well as in C57BL/2, Swiss-Webster, and DBA.2 mice infected with influenza A(H1N1)pdm09 virus. High levels of SAA often, but not always, were associated with disease outcome in these other influenza virus mouse models. Therefore, SAA represents a valid biomarker for influenza disease detection in all tested mouse strains but its prognostic value is limited to BALB/c mice infected with influenza A(H1N1)pdm09 virus.

The Iminosugar UV-4 is a Broad Inhibitor of Influenza A and B Viruses ex Vivo and in Mice

Iminosugars that are competitive inhibitors of endoplasmic reticulum (ER) α-glucosidases have been demonstrated to have antiviral activity against a diverse set of viruses. A novel iminosugar, UV-4B, has recently been shown to provide protection against lethal infections with dengue and influenza A (H1N1) viruses in mice. In the current study, the breadth of activity of UV-4B against influenza was examined ex vivo and in vivo. Efficacy of UV-4B against influenza A and B viruses was shown in primary human bronchial epithelial cells, a principal target tissue for influenza. Efficacy of UV-4B against influenza A (H1N1 and H3N2 subtypes) and influenza B was demonstrated using multiple lethal mouse models with readouts including mortality and weight loss. Clinical trials are ongoing to demonstrate safety of UV-4B and future studies to evaluate antiviral activity against influenza in humans are planned.

Can animal data translate to innovations necessary for a new era of patient-centred and individualised healthcare? Bias in preclinical animal research

Background

The public and healthcare workers have a high expectation of animal research which they perceive as necessary to predict the safety and efficacy of drugs before testing in clinical trials. However, the expectation is not always realised and there is evidence that the research often fails to stand up to scientific scrutiny and its 'predictive value' is either weak or absent.

Discussion

Problems with the use of animals as models of humans arise from a variety of biases and systemic failures including: 1) bias and poor practice in research methodology and data analysis; 2) lack of transparency in scientific assessment and regulation of the research; 3) long-term denial of weaknesses in cross-species translation; 4) profit-driven motives overriding patient interests; 5) lack of accountability of expenditure on animal research; 6) reductionist-materialism in science which tends to dictate scientific inquiry and control the direction of funding in biomedical research.

Summary

Bias in animal research needs to be addressed before medical research and healthcare decision-making can be more evidence-based. Research funding may be misdirected on studying 'disease mechanisms' in animals that cannot be replicated outside tightly controlled laboratory conditions, and without sufficient critical evaluation animal research may divert attention away from avenues of research that hold promise for human health. The potential for harm to patients and trial volunteers from reliance on biased animal data¹ requires measures to improve its conduct, regulation and analysis. This article draws attention to a few of the many forms of bias in animal research that have come to light in the last decade and offers a strategy incorporating ten recommendations stated at the end of each section on bias. The proposals need development through open debate and subsequent rigorous implementation so that reviewers may determine the value of animal research to human health. The 10Rs + are protected by a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License and therefore may be 'shared, remixed or built on, even commercially, so long as attributed by giving appropriate credit with a link to the license, and indicate if changes were made.’

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12910-015-0043-7) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Animal models for influenza virus pathogenesis, transmission, and immunology

In humans, infection with an influenza A or B virus manifests typically as an acute and self-limited upper respiratory tract illness characterized by fever, cough, sore throat, and malaise. However, influenza can present along a broad spectrum of disease, ranging from sub-clinical or even asymptomatic infection to a severe primary viral pneumonia requiring advanced medical supportive care. Disease severity depends upon the virulence of the influenza virus strain and the immune competence and previous influenza exposures of the patient. Animal models are used in influenza research not only to elucidate the viral and host factors that affect influenza disease outcomes in and spread among susceptible hosts, but also to evaluate interventions designed to prevent or reduce influenza morbidity and mortality in man. This review will focus on the three animal models currently used most frequently in influenza virus research - mice, ferrets, and guinea pigs - and discuss the advantages and disadvantages of each.