The Life and Times of Lac Permease: Crystals Ain’t Everything, but They Certainly Do Help

The proton electrochemical gradient induces a kinetic asymmetry in the symport cycle of LacY

Protonation and deprotonation of Glu325 with a pK_a of 10.5 is required for symport. Moreover, the H⁺ electrochemical gradient (∆μ∼H+) accelerates deprotonation on the intracellular side with a 50- to 100-fold decrease in the K_m. To probe the pK on the cytoplasmic side of the membrane, rates of lactose/H⁺ efflux were determined from pH 5.0 to 9.0 without or with a membrane potential (ΔΨ, interior positive) in right-side-out membrane vesicles. WT lactose efflux has an apparent pK of ∼7.2 that is unaffected by ΔΨ, mutant E325A is defective, and pH or ΔΨ (interior positive) has no effect. The effect of ΔΨ (interior positive) on the K_m for efflux with WT LacY is insignificant relative to the marked effect on influx.

LacY catalyzes accumulation of galactosides against a concentration gradient by coupling galactoside and H⁺ transport (i.e., symport). While alternating access of sugar- and H⁺-binding sites to either side of the membrane is driven by binding and dissociation of sugar, the electrochemical H⁺ gradient (∆μ∼H+) functions kinetically by decreasing the K_m for influx 50- to 100-fold with no change in K_d. The affinity of protonated LacY for sugar has an apparent pK (pK^app) of ∼10.5, due specifically to the pK_a of Glu325, a residue that plays an irreplaceable role in coupling. In this study, rates of lactose/H⁺ efflux were measured from pH 5.0 to 9.0 in the absence or presence of a membrane potential (ΔΨ, interior positive), and the effect of the imposed ΔΨ on the kinetics of efflux was also studied in right-side-out membrane vesicles. The findings reveal that ∆μ∼H+ induces an asymmetry in the transport cycle based on the following observations: 1) the efflux rate of WT LacY exhibits a pK^app of ∼7.2 that is unaffected by the imposed ΔΨ; 2) ΔΨ increases the rate of efflux at all tested pH values, but enhancement is almost 2 orders of magnitude less than observed for influx; 3) mutant Glu325 ˗ Ala does little or no efflux in the absence or presence of ΔΨ, and ambient pH has no effect; and 4) the effect of ΔΨ (interior positive) on the K_m for efflux is almost insignificant relative to the 50- to 100-fold decrease in the K_m for influx driven by ΔΨ (interior negative).

Direct protein-lipid interactions shape the conformational landscape of secondary transporters

Secondary transporters undergo structural rearrangements to catalyze substrate translocation across the cell membrane – yet how such conformational changes happen within a lipid environment remains poorly understood. Here, we combine hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX-MS) with molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to understand how lipids regulate the conformational dynamics of secondary transporters at the molecular level. Using the homologous transporters XylE, LacY and GlpT from Escherichia coli as model systems, we discover that conserved networks of charged residues act as molecular switches that drive the conformational transition between different states. We reveal that these molecular switches are regulated by interactions with surrounding phospholipids and show that phosphatidylethanolamine interferes with the formation of the conserved networks and favors an inward-facing state. Overall, this work provides insights into the importance of lipids in shaping the conformational landscape of an important class of transporters.

Secondary transporters catalyse substrate translocation across the cell membrane but the role of lipids during the transport cycle remains unclear. Here authors used hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry and molecular dynamics simulations to understand how lipids regulate the conformational dynamics of secondary transporters.

pKa of Glu325 in LacY

Lactose permease (LacY), a paradigm for the largest family of membrane transport proteins, catalyzes the coupled translocation of a galactoside and a H⁺ across the cytoplasmic membrane of Escherichia coli (galactoside/H⁺ symport). One of the most important aspects of the mechanism is the relationship between protonation and binding of the cargo galactopyranoside. In this regard, it has been shown that protonation is required for binding. Furthermore when galactoside affinity is measured as a function of pH, an apparent pK (pK^app) of ∼10.5 is obtained. Strikingly, when Glu325, a residue long known to be involved in coupling between H⁺ and sugar translocation, is replaced with a neutral side chain, the pH effect is abolished, and high-affinity binding is observed until LacY is destabilized at alkaline pH. In this paper, infrared spectroscopy is used to identify Glu325 in situ. Moreover, it is demonstrated that this residue exhibits a pK_a of 10.5 ± 0.1 that is insensitive to the presence of galactopyranoside. Thus, it is apparent that protonation of Glu325 specifically is required for effective sugar binding to LacY.

Crystal structure of a LacY-nanobody complex in a periplasmic-open conformation

The lactose permease of Escherichia coli (LacY), a dynamic polytopic membrane protein, catalyzes galactoside-H⁺ symport and operates by an alternating access mechanism that exhibits multiple conformations, the distribution of which is altered by sugar binding. We have developed single-domain camelid nanobodies (Nbs) against a mutant in an outward (periplasmic)-open conformation to stabilize this state of the protein. Here we describe an X-ray crystal structure of a complex between a double-Trp mutant (Gly46→Trp/Gly262→Trp) and an Nb in which free access to the sugar-binding site from the periplasmic cavity is observed. The structure confirms biochemical data indicating that the Nb binds stoichiometrically with nanomolar affinity to the periplasmic face of LacY primarily to the C-terminal six-helix bundle. The structure is novel because the pathway to the sugar-binding site is constricted and the central cavity containing the galactoside-binding site is empty. Although Phe27 narrows the periplasmic cavity, sugar is freely accessible to the binding site. Remarkably, the side chains directly involved in binding galactosides remain in the same position in the absence or presence of bound sugar.

Structure of LacY with an α-substituted galactoside: Connecting the binding site to the protonation site

The X-ray crystal structure of a conformationally constrained mutant of the Escherichia coli lactose permease (the LacY double-Trp mutant Gly-46→Trp/Gly-262→Trp) with bound p-nitrophenyl-α-d-galactopyranoside (α-NPG), a high-affinity lactose analog, is described. With the exception of Glu-126 (helix IV), side chains Trp-151 (helix V), Glu-269 (helix VIII), Arg-144 (helix V), His-322 (helix X), and Asn-272 (helix VIII) interact directly with the galactopyranosyl ring of α-NPG to provide specificity, as indicated by biochemical studies and shown directly by X-ray crystallography. In contrast, Phe-20, Met-23, and Phe-27 (helix I) are within van der Waals distance of the benzyl moiety of the analog and thereby increase binding affinity nonspecifically. Thus, the specificity of LacY for sugar is determined solely by side-chain interactions with the galactopyranosyl ring, whereas affinity is increased by nonspecific hydrophobic interactions with the anomeric substituent.

Comparative Sequence-Function Analysis of the Major Facilitator Superfamily: The "Mix-and-Match" Method

The major facilitator superfamily (MFS) is a diverse group of secondary transporters with members found in all kingdoms of life. The paradigm for MFS is the lactose permease (LacY) of Escherichia coli, which has been the test bed for the development of many methods applied for the analysis of transport proteins. X-ray structures of an inward-facing conformation and the most recent structure of an almost occluded conformation confirm many conclusions from previous studies. One fundamentally important problem for understanding the mechanism of secondary active transport is the identification and physical localization of residues involved in substrate and H(+) binding. This information is exceptionally difficult to obtain with the MFS because of the broad sequence diversity among the members. The increasing number of solved MFS structures has led to the recognition of a common feature: inverted structure-repeat, formed by fused triple-helix domains with opposite orientation in the membrane. The presented method here exploits this feature to predict functionally homologous positions of known relevant positions in LacY. The triple-helix motifs are aligned in combinatorial fashion so as to detect substrate and H(+)-binding sites in symporters that transport substrates, ranging from simple ions like phosphate to more complex disaccharides.

A chemiosmotic mechanism of symport

Lactose permease (LacY), a paradigm for the largest family of membrane transport proteins, catalyzes the coupled translocation of a galactoside and an H(+) across the Escherichia coli membrane (galactoside/H(+) symport). Initial X-ray structures reveal N- and C-terminal domains, each with six largely irregular transmembrane helices surrounding an aqueous cavity open to the cytoplasm. Recently, a structure with a narrow periplasmic opening and an occluded galactoside was obtained, confirming many observations and indicating that sugar binding involves induced fit. LacY catalyzes symport by an alternating access mechanism. Experimental findings garnered over 45 y indicate the following: (i) The limiting step for lactose/H(+) symport in the absence of the H(+) electrochemical gradient (∆µ̃H+) is deprotonation, whereas in the presence of ∆µ̃H+, the limiting step is opening of apo LacY on the other side of the membrane; (ii) LacY must be protonated to bind galactoside (the pK for binding is ∼10.5); (iii) galactoside binding and dissociation, not ∆µ̃H+, are the driving forces for alternating access; (iv) galactoside binding involves induced fit, causing transition to an occluded intermediate that undergoes alternating access; (v) galactoside dissociates, releasing the energy of binding; and (vi) Arg302 comes into proximity with protonated Glu325, causing deprotonation. Accumulation of galactoside against a concentration gradient does not involve a change in Kd for sugar on either side of the membrane, but the pKa (the affinity for H(+)) decreases markedly. Thus, transport is driven chemiosmotically but, contrary to expectation, ∆µ̃H+ acts kinetically to control the rate of the process.

Outward-facing conformers of LacY stabilized by nanobodies

The lactose permease of Escherichia coli (LacY), a highly dynamic polytopic membrane protein, catalyzes stoichiometric galactoside/H(+) symport by an alternating access mechanism and exhibits multiple conformations, the distribution of which is altered by sugar binding. We have developed single-domain camelid nanobodies (Nbs) against a LacY mutant in an outward (periplasmic)-open conformation to stabilize this state of the WT protein. Twelve purified Nbs inhibit lactose transport in right-side-out membrane vesicles, indicating that the Nbs recognize epitopes on the periplasmic side of LacY. Stopped-flow kinetics of sugar binding by WT LacY in detergent micelles or reconstituted into proteoliposomes reveals dramatic increases in galactoside-binding rates induced by interaction with the Nbs. Thus, WT LacY in complex with the great majority of the Nbs exhibits varied increases in access of sugar to the binding site with an increase in association rate constants (kon) of up to ∼ 50-fold (reaching 10(7) M(-1) ⋅ s(-1)). In contrast, with the double-Trp mutant, which is already open on the periplasmic side, the Nbs have little effect. The findings are clearly consistent with stabilization of WT conformers with an open periplasmic cavity. Remarkably, some Nbs drastically decrease the rate of dissociation of bound sugar leading to increased affinity (greater than 200-fold for lactose).

Function, Structure, and Evolution of the Major Facilitator Superfamily: The LacY Manifesto

The major facilitator superfamily (MFS) is a diverse group of secondary transporters with members found in all kingdoms of life. A paradigm for MFS is the lactose permease (LacY) of Escherichia coli, which couples the stoichiometric translocation of a galactopyranoside and an H+ across the cytoplasmic membrane. LacY has been the test bed for the development of many methods applied for the analysis of transport proteins. X-ray structures of an inward-facing conformation and the most recent structure of an almost occluded conformation confirm many conclusions from previous studies. Although structure models are critical, they are insufficient to explain the catalysis of transport. The clues to understanding transport are based on the principles of enzyme kinetics. Secondary transport is a dynamic process—static snapshots of X-ray crystallography describe it only partially. However, without structural information, the underlying chemistry is virtually impossible to conclude. A large body of biochemical/biophysical data derived from systematic studies of site-directed mutants in LacY suggests residues critically involved in the catalysis, and a working model for the symport mechanism that involves alternating access of the binding site is presented. The general concepts derived from the bacterial LacY are examined for their relevance to other MFS transporters.

Real-time conformational changes in LacY

Galactoside/H(+) symport across the cytoplasmic membrane of Escherichia coli is catalyzed by lactose permease (LacY), which uses an alternating access mechanism with opening and closing of deep cavities on the periplasmic and cytoplasmic sides. In this study, conformational changes in LacY initiated by galactoside binding were monitored in real time by Trp quenching/unquenching of bimane, a small fluorophore covalently attached to the protein. Rates of change in bimane fluorescence on either side of LacY were measured by stopped flow with LacY in detergent or in proteoliposomes and were compared with rates of galactoside binding. With LacY in proteoliposomes, the periplasmic cavity is tightly sealed and the substrate-binding rate is limited by the rate of opening of this cavity. Rates of opening, measured as unquenching of bimane fluorescence, are 20-30 s(-1), independent of sugar concentration and essentially the same in detergent or in proteoliposomes. On the cytoplasmic side of LacY in proteoliposomes, slow bimane quenching (i.e., closing of the cavity) is observed at a rate that is also independent of sugar concentration and similar to the rate of sugar binding from the periplasmic side. Therefore, opening of the periplasmic cavity not only limits access of sugar to the binding site of LacY but also controls the rate of closing of the cytoplasmic cavity.

Substrate-induced changes in the structural properties of LacY

The lactose permease (LacY) of Escherichia coli, a paradigm for the major facilitator superfamily, catalyzes the coupled stoichiometric translocation of a galactopyranoside and an H(+) across the cytoplasmic membrane. To catalyze transport, LacY undergoes large conformational changes that allow alternating access of sugar- and H(+)-binding sites to either side of the membrane. Despite strong evidence for an alternating access mechanism, it remains unclear how H(+)- and sugar-binding trigger the cascade of interactions leading to alternating conformational states. Here we used dynamic single-molecule force spectroscopy to investigate how substrate binding induces this phenomenon. Galactoside binding strongly modifies kinetic, energetic, and mechanical properties of the N-terminal 6-helix bundle of LacY, whereas the C-terminal 6-helix bundle remains largely unaffected. Within the N-terminal 6-helix bundle, the properties of helix V, which contains residues critical for sugar binding, change most radically. Particularly, secondary structures forming the N-terminal domain exhibit mechanically brittle properties in the unbound state, but highly flexible conformations in the substrate-bound state with significantly increased lifetimes and energetic stability. Thus, sugar binding tunes the properties of the N-terminal domain to initiate galactoside/H(+) symport. In contrast to wild-type LacY, the properties of the conformationally restricted mutant Cys154→Gly do not change upon sugar binding. It is also observed that the single mutation of Cys154→Gly alters intramolecular interactions so that individual transmembrane helices manifest different properties. The results support a working model of LacY in which substrate binding induces alternating conformational states and provides insight into their specific kinetic, energetic, and mechanical properties.

Structure of sugar-bound LacY

Here we describe the X-ray crystal structure of a double-Trp mutant (Gly46→Trp/Gly262→Trp) of the lactose permease of Escherichia coli (LacY) with a bound, high-affinity lactose analog. Although thought to be arrested in an open-outward conformation, the structure is almost occluded and is partially open to the periplasmic side; the cytoplasmic side is tightly sealed. Surprisingly, the opening on the periplasmic side is sufficiently narrow that sugar cannot get in or out of the binding site. Clearly defined density for a bound sugar is observed at the apex of the almost occluded cavity in the middle of the protein, and the side chains shown to ligate the galactopyranoside strongly confirm more than two decades of biochemical and spectroscopic findings. Comparison of the current structure with a previous structure of LacY with a covalently bound inactivator suggests that the galactopyranoside must be fully ligated to induce an occluded conformation. We conclude that protonated LacY binds D-galactopyranosides specifically, inducing an occluded state that can open to either side of the membrane.

Functional architecture of MFS D-glucose transporters

The Major Facilitator Superfamily (MFS) is a diverse group of secondary transporters with over 10,000 members, found in all kingdoms of life, including Homo sapiens. One objective of determining crystallographic models of the bacterial representatives is identification and physical localization of residues important for catalysis in transporters with medical relevance. The recently solved crystallographic models of the D-xylose permease XylE from Escherichia coli and GlcP from Staphylococcus epidermidus, homologs of the human D-glucose transporters, the GLUTs (SLC2), provide information about the structure of these transporters. The goal of this work is to examine general concepts derived from the bacterial XylE, GlcP, and other MFS transporters for their relevance to the GLUTs by comparing conservation of functionally critical residues. An energy landscape for symport and uniport is presented. Furthermore, the substrate selectivity of XylE is compared with GLUT1 and GLUT5, as well as a XylE mutant that transports D-glucose.