IS-elements in microorganisms

DNA cloning: a personal view after 40 years

In November 1973, my colleagues A. C. Y. Chang, H. W. Boyer, R. B. Helling, and I reported in PNAS that individual genes can be cloned and isolated by enzymatically cleaving DNA molecules into fragments, linking the fragments to an autonomously replicating plasmid, and introducing the resulting recombinant DNA molecules into bacteria. A few months later, Chang and I reported that genes from unrelated bacterial species can be combined and propagated using the same approach and that interspecies recombinant DNA molecules can produce a biologically functional protein in a foreign host. Soon afterward, Boyer's laboratory and mine published our collaborative discovery that even genes from animal cells can be cloned in bacteria. These three PNAS papers quickly led to the use of DNA cloning methods in multiple areas of the biological and chemical sciences. They also resulted in a highly public controversy about the potential hazards of laboratory manipulation of genetic material, a decision by Stanford University and the University of California to seek patents on the technology that Boyer and I had invented, and the application of DNA cloning methods for commercial purposes. In the 40 years that have passed since publication of our findings, use of DNA cloning has produced insights about the workings of genes and cells in health and disease and has altered the nature of the biotechnology and biopharmaceutical industries. Here, I provide a personal perspective of the events that led to, and followed, our report of DNA cloning.

The gene yjcG, cotranscribed with the gene acs, encodes an acetate permease in Escherichia coli

We isolated an Escherichia coli mutant strain that suppresses the glycolate-negative phenotype of a strain deficient in both GlcA and LldP transporters of this compound. This suppressing phenotype was assigned to yjcG, a gene whose function was previously unknown, which was found to encode a membrane protein able to transport glycolate. On the basis of sequence similarity, the yjcG gene product was classified as a member of the sodium:solute symporter family. Northern experiments revealed that yjcG is cotranscribed with its neighbor, acs, encoding acetyl coenzyme A synthetase, which is involved in the scavenging acetate. The fortuitous presence of an IS2 element in acs, which impaired yjcG expression by polarity in our parental strain, allowed us to conclude that the alternative glycolate carrier became active after precise excision of IS2 in the suppressed strain. The finding that yjcG encodes a putative membrane carrier for glycolate and the cotranscription of yjcG with acs suggested that the primary function of the yjcG gene product (proposed gene name, actP) could be acetate transport and allowed us to define an operon involved in acetate metabolism. The time course of [1,2-(14)C]acetate uptake and the results of a concentration kinetics analysis performed with cells expressing ActP or cells deficient in ActP supported the the hypothesis that this carrier is an acetate transporter and suggested that there may be another transport system for this monocarboxylate.

Isolation of a transposable element from Neurospora crassa

A Neurospora crassa strain from Adiopodoumé, Ivory Coast, contains multiple copies of a transposable element, Tad. The element was detected as a 7-kilobase insertion in two independently isolated spontaneous forward mutants of the am (glutamate dehydrogenase) gene. Laboratory strains do not contain Tad. All progeny from crosses of the Adiopodoumé strain to laboratory strains contain multiple copies. When the element was inserted in am, target sequences of 14 and 17 base pairs were duplicated in the two cases analyzed. One mutation, caused by the insertion of Tad at the beginning of the am coding sequence, is genetically stable. The other mutation, caused by insertion upstream of the transcriptional start site, has a reversion frequency of 2.5 x 10(-3). Precise excisions of Tad have not been found.

Ty insertions at two loci account for most of the spontaneous antimycin A resistance mutations during growth at 15 degrees C of Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains lacking ADH1

The mutation rate to antimycin A resistance was determined for strains of Sacchromyces cerevisiae lacking a functional copy of the structural gene for alcohol dehydrogenase I (ADH1). One type of mutation that can cause antimycin A resistance in these strains is insertion of the transposable element Ty 5' to ADH2, the structural gene for the glucose-repressed isozyme of alcohol dehydrogenase, resulting in expression of this gene during growth on glucose. Here we show that after growth at 15 or 20 degrees C on glucose, 30% of the antimycin A resistance mutations are Ty insertions at ADH2 and another 65% of the mutations are Ty insertions at ADH4, a new locus identified and cloned as described in this paper. At 30 degrees C only 6% of the mutations are Ty insertions at either of these two loci. In addition, we show that the transposition rate is lower in mating-incompetent (a/alpha) cells than in either haploid or diploid mating-competent cells. Our results suggest that under certain conditions Ty transposition may be a major cause of spontaneous mutations in S. cerevisiae.

DNA element of Corynebacterium diphtheriae with properties of an insertion sequence and usefulness for epidemiological studies

The segment of DNA which is inserted within the tox gene of bacteriophage gamma and is responsible for its Tox- phenotype was found to be present and repeated approximately 30 times in the chromosome of Corynebacterium diphtheriae Belfanti 1030. Other C. diphtheriae strains contained a variable number of copies (1 to 25) of the same element. Sequence analysis showed that this repeated and interspersed DNA element was flanked by 9-base-pair direct repeats and that the 5' and 3' ends of the insertion contained sequences forming an imperfect inverted repeat. Therefore, the DNA segment here described has most of the typical structural features of a bacterial insertion sequence element. We show that different C. diphtheriae isolates derived from the same outbreak of diphtheria have an identical genomic distribution of this DNA element and that such DNA can be useful for epidemiological studies.

DNA inversion mediated by the r-determinant of plasmid NR1: evidence for the intramolecular replicative transposition of a 23 kb IS1-flanked transposon?

The r-determinant (r-det) of the R plasmid NR1-Basel is a 23 kb, IS1-flanked transposon, called Tn2671, which has been shown to transpose to the genome of bacteriophage P7. Among the derivatives of phage P7::r-det we found one which carried two copies of the r-det as inverted repeats and which also contained the P7 genome segment between them in inverted orientation. Its generation is best explained by assuming that the entire 23 kb Tn2671 transposon has undergone intramolecular replicative transposition.

Ty insertions at two loci account for most of the spontaneous antimycin A resistance mutations during growth at 15 degrees C of Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains lacking ADH1

The mutation rate to antimycin A resistance was determined for strains of Sacchromyces cerevisiae lacking a functional copy of the structural gene for alcohol dehydrogenase I (ADH1). One type of mutation that can cause antimycin A resistance in these strains is insertion of the transposable element Ty 5' to ADH2, the structural gene for the glucose-repressed isozyme of alcohol dehydrogenase, resulting in expression of this gene during growth on glucose. Here we show that after growth at 15 or 20 degrees C on glucose, 30% of the antimycin A resistance mutations are Ty insertions at ADH2 and another 65% of the mutations are Ty insertions at ADH4, a new locus identified and cloned as described in this paper. At 30 degrees C only 6% of the mutations are Ty insertions at either of these two loci. In addition, we show that the transposition rate is lower in mating-incompetent (a/alpha) cells than in either haploid or diploid mating-competent cells. Our results suggest that under certain conditions Ty transposition may be a major cause of spontaneous mutations in S. cerevisiae.

Positive selection procedure for entrapment of insertion sequence elements in gram-negative bacteria

We constructed the broad-host-range plasmid pUCD800 containing the sacB gene of Bacillus subtilis for use in the positive selection and isolation of insertion sequence (IS) elements in gram-negative bacteria. Cells containing pUCD800 do not grow on medium containing 5% sucrose unless the sacB gene is inactivated. By using pUCD800, we isolated a 1.4-kilobase putative IS element from Agrobacterium tumefaciens NT1RE by selection for growth on sucrose medium. This putative IS element appears to be unique to Agrobacterium strains.

Molecular basis of mutations at the waxy locus of maize: correlation with the fine structure genetic map

More than 40 mutant alleles of the waxy (Wx) locus of maize are available for molecular analysis. Previous studies have examined the nature of phenotypically unstable Wx mutant alleles caused by insertion of the maize transposable activator (Ac) and dissociation (Ds) elements. In this study we have used Southern blot analysis to characterize the locus in 22 strains harboring wx alleles with stable mutant phenotypes. Of these mutations, 17 are of spontaneous origin, 4 were induced by gamma rays, and 1 was induced by ethyl methanesulfonate. Of these 22 alleles, we find that 13 have either insertions or deletions within the Wx transcription unit. The insertions range in size from 150 base pairs to 6.1 kilobases. For 4 of the 6 deletions identified, the two breakpoints are within the Wx gene. For 9 other alleles we can detect no obvious lesions within or around the transcription unit. Evidence is presented that the insertions and deletions result in the mutant phenotype and are not polymorphisms. This conclusion is based on two findings: (i) a survey of inbred lines revealed only a single instance of polymorphism within the transcription unit, whereas all of the lesions described alter the transcription unit; and (ii) there is an excellent correlation between the position of these lesions on the physical map and their relative position on a fine structure genetic map of the locus.

Activation of expression of a cloned archaebacterial gene in Escherichia coli by IS2, IS5, or deletions

A DNA fragment from the methanogenic archaebacterium Methanococcus voltae, when cloned into the PstI site of the plasmid vector pBR322, complements the Escherichia coli argG mutation strongly or weakly depending on its orientation. Faster-growing variants derived from a strain containing the poorly expressed fragment were found to harbor plasmids which had undergone genetic rearrangements. Some of the plasmids were shown to have acquired an insertion element (IS2 or IS5), derived from the E. coli chromosome, close to the region essential for complementing activity. Other plasmids exhibited no homology with E. coli chromosomal DNA. These were found to represent multimeric forms of the parental plasmid in which 2-3 kb of DNA between the tet promoter and the argG-complementing region had been deleted. Growth rates of the variant strains in the absence of arginine varied significantly, suggesting differences in efficiency of activation of the cloned DNA.

Inverted repeats in the DNA of Streptomyces plasmids pMG110 and pMG120

Two cryptic plasmids pMG110 (10.5 kb) and pMG120 (14.5 kb) isolated from Streptomyces luteolutescens were cleaved by restriction endonucleases Bg/II, KpnI, and SalGI. A physical map was constructed for pMG110. After denaturation and intrastrand reannealing, two types of snap-back structures were identified by electron microscopy, differing in the size of the loop (type 1, 1 kb; type 2, 1.6 kb), whereas the stem of both structures was about 190 bp long. Stem-loop structures of similar size were also observed in pMG120. In rare cases, both types of elements were present on the same DNA molecule. The analysis of Bg/II- and KpnI-generated fragments allowed the localization of the elements at two alternative positions on the physical map of pMG110.

Spontaneous deletions and flanking regions of the chromosomally inherited hemolysin determinant of an Escherichia coli O6 strain

The hemolytic Escherichia coli strain 536 (O6) propagates spontaneous hemolysin-negative mutants at relatively high rates (10(-3) to 10(-4)). One type of mutant (type I) lacks both secreted (external) and periplasmic (internal) hemolysin activity (Hlyex-/Hlyin-) and in addition shows no mannose-resistant hemagglutination (Mrh-), whereas the other type (type II) is Hlyex-/Hlyin+ and Mrh+. The genetic determinants for hemolysin production (hly) and for mannose-resistant hemagglutination (mrh) of this strain are located on the chromosome. Hybridization experiments with DNA probes specific for various parts of the hly determinant reveal that mutants of type I have lost the total hly determinant, whereas those of type II lack only part of the hlyB that is essential for transport of hemolysin across the outer membrane. Using a probe that contains the end sequence of the plasmid pHly152-encoded hly determinant (adjacent to hlyB), we determined that a related sequence flanks also the hlyB-distal end of the chromosomal hly determinant of E. coli 536. In addition several other similar or even identical sequences are found in the vicinity of the hlyC- and the hlyB-distal ends of both the chromosomal and the plasmid hly determinants.

Genetic variability in Halobacterium halobium

Halobacterium halobium exhibits an extraordinary degree of spontaneous variability. Mutants which are defective in the formation of gas vacuoles (vac) arise at a frequency of 10(-2). Other easily detectable phenotypes, like the synthesis of bacterioruberin (Rub) or the synthesis of retinal (Ret) and bacterio-opsin (Ops), the two components which form the purple membrane (Pum) of H. halobium, are lost at a frequency of about 10(-4). With the same frequency a mutant type appears which exhibits an extremely high variability in these phenotypes. With the exception of the ret mutants, all spontaneously arising mutants show alterations, i.e., insertions, rearrangements, or deletions, in the plasmid pHH1. It appears that the introduction of one insertion into pHH1 triggers further insertions, which makes the identification of relationships between phenotypic and genotypic alterations rather difficult. From the analysis of a large number of spontaneous vac mutants and their vac+ revertants it can be concluded that the formation of the gas vacuoles is determined or controlled by plasmid genes. No such conclusion is yet possible for the rub mutants, although all mutants of this type so far analyzed exhibit a defined insertion. pum mutants which have lost the capability of forming bacterio-opsin carry insertions in the plasmid which are distributed over a rather large region of the plasmid. No strains of H. halobium could be obtained which had lost plasmid pHH1 completely.

A cDNA clone from Zea mays endosperm sucrose synthetase mRNA

A cDNA clone for maize endosperm sucrose synthetase of 62o nucleotide pairs length was obtained by cloning double stranded DNA obtained from the total maize endosperm poly(A) RNA in pBR322, and identifying the appropriate clone by hybrid-promoter translation. In Southern blotting to genomic BamHI-digested DNA, a single band only of approximately 20 Kb lights up, indicating that the sucrose synthetase gene is unique, or that closely linked copies are located on this DNA fragment.

The structure of unstable constitutive revertants of mutant galOP-308::IS2-I

The isolation and characterization of three unstable and constitutive revertants of mutant galOP-308 of E. coli is described. In this mutant an IS2 element is integrated between the promoter and the first structural gene of the galactose operon, and exerts a strong polar effect on the expression of the three galactose genes. In the three revertants under investigation it was observed that relief of polarity and constitutive expression of the gal-operon were accompanied by the deletion of 90% of the IS2 sequence and of various lengths of the adjacent sequences including the gal-promoter. We conclude from this result that the transcription termination signals causing strong polarity were located on the deleted part of IS2, and that in our revertants the galactose genes are now under the control of a new promoter which is apparently unstable.

Control of gene expression by a mobile recombinational switch

Transposable recombinational switches may play important roles in the evolution of bacterial populations by increasing flexibility in the control of expression of particular genes and thereby maintaining heterogeneity in clones of cells growing in a uniform environment. Experiments reported here show that Tn5-112, a deletion derivative of kanamycin-resistance transposon Tn5, can function as such a mobile recombinational switch. The internal deletion in Tn5-112 removes transcription termination signals and permits transcription initiated within the element to continue into nearby bacterial genes. Consequently, in one orientation Tn5-112 stimulates distal gene expression, whereas in the other orientation the normal polarity imposed by wild-type Tn5 intervenes and distal gene expression is not stimulated. Because Tn5-112 contains terminal inverted repeats, intramolecular recombination can invert the Tn5-112 element and alter gene expression. Tn5-112 is transposition deficient. Its mobility derives from the recessive nature of the transposition deficiency and, in this study, from the possibility of homologous recombination which permits its placement in either orientation at any site occupied by nother Tn5 element.

The nucleotide sequence of an untranslated but conserved domain at the 3' end of the avian sarcoma virus genome

The genomes of numerous avian retroviruses contain at their 3' termini a conserved domain denoted "c". The precise boundaries and function of "c" have been enigmas. In an effort to resolve these issues, we determined the sequence of over 900 nucleotides at the 3' end of the genome of the Schmidt-Ruppin subgroup A strain of avian sarcoma virus (ASV). We obtained the sequence from a suitable fragment of ASV DNA that had cloned into the single-stranded DNA phage M13mp2. Computer-assisted analysis of the sequence revealed the following structural features: i) the length of "c" - 473 nucleotides; ii) the 3' terminal domain of src, ending in an amber codon at the 5'boundary of "c"; iii) terminator codons that preclude continuous translation from "c"; iv) suitably located sequences that may serve as signals for the initiation of viral RNA synthesis and for the processing and/or polyadenylation of viral mRNA; v) a repeated sequence that flanks src and that could facilitate deletion of this gene; vi) repeated sequences within "c"; and vii) unexplained homologies between sequences in "c" and sequences in several other nucleic acids, including the 5' terminal domain of the ASV genome, tRNATrp and its inversion, the complement of tRNATrp and its inversion, and the 18S RNA of eukaryotic ribosomes. We conclude that "c" probably does not encode a protein, but its sequence may nevertheless serve several essential functions in viral replication.

Polarity of Tn5 insertion mutations in Escherichia coli

We assessed the effect of insertions of the kanamycin resistance transposon Tn5 in the lac operon of Escherichia coli on the expression of distal genes lacY and lacA (melibiose fermentation at 41 degrees C and thiogalactoside transacetylase synthesis, respectively). Every insertion mutation tested (41 in lacZ and 23 in lacY) was strongly polar. However, approximately one-third of the insertion mutants expressed distal genes at low levels due to a promoter associated with Tn5. To localize this promoter, we (i) reversed the orientation of Tn5 at several sites and (ii) replaced wild-type Tn5 with several substitution derivatives which lack Tn5's central region. Neither alteration changed the expression of distal genes. Thus, in contrast to transposons IS2 and TnA. Tn5's ability to turn on distal gene expression is not due to a promoter in its central region and therefore is not dependent on the overall orientation of Tn5 in the operon. Our results suggest that the promoter is within 186 base pairs of the ends of Tn5. It is possible that the promoter is detected in only a fraction of insertions because it overlaps Tn5-target sequence boundary.

Adjacent insertion sequences IS2 and IS5 in bacteriophage Mu mutants and an IS5 in a lambda darg bacteriophage

Using electron microscopic heteroduplex analysis, we have demonstrated that an insertion found in a Mu prophage and in some infectious. Mu deletion-substitution mutants derived from it consists of bacterial insertion sequence IS2 linked directly to IS5. Other infectious Mu mutants derived from the same lysogen have only IS5 or a portion of IS2. In addition, we have found that an independent insertion in a transducing phage, lambda 13 dargB2, is IS5. The ends of IS5 are short, inverted duplications of each other. These observations support the notion that the DNA insertion previously designated IS5 on the basis of a single example in lambda KH100 is a bona fide bacterial insertion sequence.

Excision of a DNA sequence determining kanamycin resistance from a ColE1-Km recombinant plasmid

A 4.8 X 10(6) dalton ECoRI-generated fragment of the R-factor R6-5 carrying the gene for kanamycin resistance (Km) was joined in vitro to ECoRI-treated ColE1 plasmid DNA. Transformation of E. coli with the ColE1-Km recombinant plasmid yielded clones, which were immune to colicin E1, resistant to kanamycin and failed to produce colicin E1. During multiplication of this recombinant plasmid in the presence of chloramphenicol, cells expressed an increased resistance to kanamycin. Transformation studies with the recombinant DNA molecule showed very frequent loss of Km resistance in those cells harbouring a preexisting F'gal plasmid. Since colicin immunity is not affected and the col- phenotype is still present, one has to test for a remaining DNA sequence further existing in ColE1 DNA by cleaving the plasmid DNA with the ECoRI restriction endonuclease. The full length of ColE1 DNA (6.2 kb) was restored, which confirmed that no deletion of ColE1 DNA sequences had occured. The remaining DNA sequence was identified as a 2.0 or 2.2 kb segment. On the basis of the length of the excised fragment it is proposed that the insertion sequence ISI and a part of the inverted repeat sequence with corrdinates 21.0 to 22.0 of the R6-5 DNA are recognised by a nucleolytic function.

Isolation and characterization of phi80dgal transducing phages that carry gal operator-promoter insertion mutations

phi80dgal transducing bacteriophages have been isolated by the F-fusion technique of Press et al. (1971) and gal-operator-promoter insertion mutations have been introduced by homogenate formation. Five different phi80dgal isolates have been studied in more detail. One of the phi80 phages transduces the gal operon and gene aroG as well as at least part of the trp-operon; the gal operon of another phi80dgal transducing phage is inverted with respect to the phi80dgal sequences. Heteroduplex DNA mapping indicates that one of the phi80dgal isolates in addition to the gal operon and a portion of the adjacent chromosomal region carries an IS2-element which is derived from the F'gal episome. The isolated phi80dgal phages may be utilized for preparing pure gal mRNA and insertion-RNA as well as pure gal operon DNA.