The Convertible Nucleoside Approach: Structural Engineering of Nucleic Acids by Disulfide Cross-Linking. In: Eckstein F, Lilley DMJ, editors. Nucleic Acids and Molecular Biology. Berlin: Springer Berlin Heidelberg; 1994. pp. 14-40. [DOI: 10.1007/978-3-642-78666-2_2]

Convertible and Constrained Nucleotides: The 2'-Deoxyribose 5'-C-Functionalization Approach, a French Touch

Many strategies have been developed to modulate the biological or biotechnical properties of oligonucleotides by introducing new chemical functionalities or by enhancing their affinity and specificity while restricting their conformational space. Among them, we review our approach consisting of modifications of the 5'-C-position of the nucleoside sugar. This allows the introduction of an additional chemical handle at any position on the nucleotide chain without disturbing the Watson-Crick base-pairing. We show that 5'-C bromo or propargyl convertible nucleotides (CvN) are accessible in pure diastereoisomeric form, either for nucleophilic displacement or for CuAAC conjugation. Alternatively, the 5'-carbon can be connected in a stereo-controlled manner to the phosphate moiety of the nucleotide chain to generate conformationally constrained nucleotides (CNA). These allow the precise control of the sugar/phosphate backbone torsional angles. The consequent modulation of the nucleic acid shape induces outstanding stabilization properties of duplex or hairpin structures in accordance with the preorganization concept. Some biological applications of these distorted oligonucleotides are also described. Effectively, the convertible and the constrained approaches have been merged to create constrained and convertible nucleotides (C2NA) providing unique tools to functionalize and stabilize nucleic acids.

Reversibly constraining spliceosome-substrate complexes by engineering disulfide crosslinks

The spliceosome is a highly dynamic mega-Dalton enzyme, formed in part by assembly of U snRNPs onto its pre-mRNA substrate transcripts. Early steps in spliceosome assembly are challenging to study biochemically and structurally due to compositional and conformational dynamics. We detail an approach to covalently and reversibly constrain or trap non-covalent pre-mRNA/protein spliceosome complexes. This approach involves engineering a single disulfide bond between a thiol-bearing cysteine sidechain and a proximal backbone phosphate of the pre-mRNA, site-specifically modified with an N-thioalkyl moiety. When distance and angle between reactants is optimal, the sidechain will react with the single N-thioalkyl to form a crosslink upon oxidation. We provide protocols detailing how this has been applied successfully to trap an 11-subunit RNA-protein assembly, the human U1 snRNP, in complex with a pre-mRNA.

Forward translocation is the natural pathway of RNA release at an intrinsic terminator

Intrinsic terminators of bacterial RNA polymerase are small (< approximately 30 bp) sequences containing a dyad symmetry that encodes a hairpin in the RNA, followed immediately by a uridine-rich stretch of 5-9 nucleotides just before the site of RNA release. Formation of the RNA hairpin destabilizes the elongation complex, leading to transcript release. We test a model in which hair-pin formation drives RNA polymerase and the melted DNA bubble downstream without transcript elongation, thus releasing the transcript from its enclosure within the enzyme as an RNA/DNA hybrid. We show that blocking downstream translocation of RNAP and preventing downstream DNA unwinding both inhibit transcript release. We argue that translocation of RNA polymerase is essential and that translocation of the bubble stimulates, but is not required, for RNA release; we conclude that forward translocation is the natural pathway of RNA release at an intrinsic terminator.

Covalent trapping of protein-DNA complexes

High-resolution structural studies of protein-DNA complexes have proven to be an invaluable means of understanding the diverse functions of proteins that manage the genome. Most of the structures determined to date represent proteins bound noncovalently to various DNA sequences or structures. Although noncovalent complexation is often adequate to study the structures of proteins that have robust, specific interactions with DNA, it is poorly suited to the study of transient intermediates in enzyme-catalyzed DNA processing reactions or of complexes that exist in multiple equilibrating forms. In recent years, strategies developed for the covalent trapping of protein-DNA complexes have begun to show promise as a window into an otherwise inaccessible world of structure.

Thermodynamics of DNA containing very stable chemically modified base pairs

DNA chemical modifications caused by the binding of some antitumor drugs give rise to a very strong local stabilization of the double helix. These sites melt at a temperature that is well above the melting temperatures of ordinary AT and GC base pairs. In this work we have examined the melting behavior of DNA containing very stable sites. Analytical expressions were derived and used to evaluate the thermodynamic properties of homopolymer DNA with several different distributions of stable sites. The results were extended to DNA with a heterogeneous sequence of AT and GC base pairs. The results were compared to the melting properties of DNA with ordinary covalent interstrand cross-links. It was found that, as with an ordinary interstrand cross-link, a single strongly stabilized site makes a DNA's melting temperature (T(m)) independent of strand concentration. However in contrast to a DNA with an interstrand cross-link, a strongly stabilized site makes the DNA's T(m) independent of DNA length and equal to T(infinity), the melting temperature of an infinite length DNA with the same GC-content and without a stabilized site. Moreover, at a temperature where more than 80% of base pairs are melted, the number of ordinary (non-modified) helical base pairs (n) is independent of both the DNA length and the location of the stabilized sites. For this condition, n(T) = (2 omega-a)S/(1-S) and S = exp[DeltaS(T(infinity)-T)/(RT)] where omega is the number of strongly stabilized sites in the DNA chain, a is the number of DNA ends that contain a stabilized site, and DeltaS, T, and R are the base pair entropy change, the temperature, and the universal gas constant per mole. The above expression is valid for a temperature interval that corresponds to n<0.2N for omega=1, and n<0.1N for omega>1, where N is the number of ordinary base pairs in the DNA chain.

Melting of cross-linked DNA v. cross-linking effect caused by local stabilization of the double helix

DNA interstrand cross-links are usually formed due to bidentate covalent or coordination binding of a cross-linking agent to nucleotides of different strands. However interstrand linkages can be also caused by any type of chemical modification that gives rise to a strong local stabilization of the double helix. These stabilized sites conserve their helical structure and prevent local and total strand separation at temperatures above the melting of ordinary AT and GC base pairs. This local stabilization makes DNA melting fully reversible and independent of strand concentration like ordinary covalent interstrand cross-links. The stabilization can be caused by all the types of chemical modifications (interstrand cross-links, intrastrand cross-links or monofunctional adducts) if they give rise to a strong enough local stabilization of the double helix. Our calculation demonstrates that an increase in stability by 25 to 30 kcal in the free energy of a single base pair of the double helix is sufficient for this "cross-linking effect" (i.e. conserving the helicity of this base pair and preventing strand separation after melting of ordinary base pairs). For the situation where there is more then one stabilized site in a DNA duplex (e.g., 1 stabilized site per 1000 bp), a lower stabilization per site is sufficient for the "cross-linking effect" (18 - 20 kcal). A substantial increase in DNA stability was found in various experimental studies for some metal-based anti-tumor compounds. These compounds may give rise to the effect described above. If ligand induced stabilization is distributed among several neighboring base pairs, a much lower minimum increase per stabilized base pair is sufficient to produce the cross-linking effect (1 bp- 24.4 kcal; 5 bp- 5.3 kcal; 10 bp- 2.9 kcal, 25 bp- 1.4 kcal; 50 bp- 1.0 kcal). The relatively weak non-covalent binding of histones or protamines that cover long regions of DNA (20- 40 bp) can also cause this effect if the salt concentration of the solution is sufficiently low to cause strong local stabilization of the double helix. Stretches of GC pairs more than 25 bp in length inserted into poly(AT) DNA also exhibit properties of stabilizing interstrand cross-links.

Evidence for helical unwinding of an RNA substrate by the RNA enzyme RNase P: use of an interstrand disulfide crosslink in substrate

To gain an understanding of structural changes induced in substrates by Escherichia coli ribonuclease P (RNase P), we have incorporated an interstrand disulfide crosslink proximal to the cleavage site in a model substrate. RNase P is able to process the reduced, non-crosslinked form of this substrate as well as a substrate in which the free thiol molecules have been alkylated with iodoacetamide. However, the oxidized, crosslinked form is cleaved at a significantly lower rate. Therefore, helical unwinding of the analog of the aminoacyl stem of the substrate near its site of cleavage may be necessary for efficient processing by E. coli RNase P.

Interstrand disulfide cross-linking of internal sugar residues in duplex RNA

Disulfide cross-linking is being used increasingly more to study the structure and dynamics of nucleic acids. We have previously developed a procedure for the formation of disulfide cross-links through the sugar-phosphate backbone of nucleic acids. Here we report the preparation and characterization of an RNA duplex containing a disulfide interstrand cross-link. A self-complementary oligoribonucleotide duplex containing an interstrand cross-link was prepared from the corresponding 2'-amino modified oligomer. Selective modification of the 2'-amino group with an aliphatic isocyanate, containing a protected disulfide, gave the corresponding 2'-urea derivative in excellent yield. An RNA duplex containing an intrahelical, interstrand disulfide cross-link was subsequently prepared by a thiol disulfide exchange reaction in nearly quantitative yield as judged by denaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (DPAGE). The cross-linked RNA was further characterized by enzymatic digestion and the Structure of the cross-link lesion was verified by comparison to an authentic sample, prepared by chemical synthesis. The effect of the chemical modifications on duplex stability was determined by UV thermal denaturation experiments. The intrahelical cross-link stabilized the duplex considerably: the disulfide cross-linked oligomer had a melting temperature that was ca. 40 degrees C higher than that of the noncross-linked oligomer.

Thiol-containing RNA for the study of structure and function of ribozymes

RNA performs multiple functions in cellular environments, such as transferring genetic information, catalyzing chemical reactions, and providing an integral component of ribonucleoprotein complexes involved in mRNA processing and translation. Many of these functions are poorly understood, mainly due to the lack of structural information. Because limited information has been obtained by physical and biophysical techniques, chemical and biochemical methods have been extensively used for studying RNA structure. This article outlines one such method which relies on site-specific incorporation of thiols into RNA. A brief overview of the methods for incorporation of thiols into RNA is followed by a detailed description of a procedure which utilizes postsynthetic modification of 2'-amino-containing RNA for incorporation of thiols. The use of thiol-containing RNA to form disulfide cross-links for the study of the structure and dynamics of ribozymes is subsequently described.

Modified oligonucleotides: synthesis and strategy for users

Synthetic oligonucleotide analogs have greatly aided our understanding of several biochemical processes. Efficient solid-phase and enzyme-assisted synthetic methods and the availability of modified base analogs have added to the utility of such oligonucleotides. In this review, we discuss the applications of synthetic oligonucleotides that contain backbone, base, and sugar modifications to investigate the mechanism and stereochemical aspects of biochemical reactions. We also discuss interference mapping of nucleic acid-protein interactions; spectroscopic analysis of biochemical reactions and nucleic acid structures; and nucleic acid cross-linking studies. The automation of oligonucleotide synthesis, the development of versatile phosphoramidite reagents, and efficient scale-up have expanded the application of modified oligonucleotides to diverse areas of fundamental and applied biological research. Numerous reports have covered oligonucleotides for which modifications have been made of the phosphodiester backbone, of the purine and pyrimidine heterocyclic bases, and of the sugar moiety; these modifications serve as structural and mechanistic probes. In this chapter, we review the range, scope, and practical utility of such chemically modified oligonucleotides. Because of space limitations, we discuss only those oligonucleotides that contain phosphate and phosphate analogs as internucleotidic linkages.

Melting of cross-linked DNA. III. Calculation of differential melting curves

In our previous papers I and II (D. Y. Lando et al, J. Biomol. Struct. Dynam. (1997) v. 15, N1, p. 129-140, p. 141-150), two methods were developed for calculation of melting curves of cross-linked DNA. One of them is based on Poland's and another on the Fixman-Freire approach. In the present communication, III, a new theoretical method is developed for computation of differential melting curves of DNAs cross-linked by anticancer drugs and their inactive analogs. As Poland's approach, the method allows study of the influence of the loop entropy factor, delta(n), on melting behavior (n is the length of a loop in base pairs). However the method is much faster and requires computer time that inherent for the most rapid Fixman-Freire calculation approach. In contrast to the computation procedures described before in communications I and II, the method is suitable for computation of differential melting curves in the case of long DNA chains, arbitrary loop entropy factors of melted regions and arbitrary degree of cross-linking including very low values that occur in vivo after administration of antitumor drugs. The method is also appropriate for DNAs without cross-links. The results of calculation demonstrate that even very low degree of cross-linking alters the DNA differential melting curve. Cross-linking also markedly strengthens the influence of particular function delta(n) upon melting behavior.

Melting of cross-linked DNA: II. Influence of interstrand linking on DNA stability

In the previous paper (D.Y. Lando, J. Biomol. Struct. Dynam, 15, 129-140 (1997)) the melting of cross-linked DNA with N base pairs and omega interstrand cross-links has been considered theoretically. In the present study on the basis of these results, two simple schemes are developed for the computation of melting curves of cross-linked DNA. The investigation of influence of interstrand linking on DNA stability has been carried out by computer simulation. It is shown that the relative concentration of cross-links, CCT = omega/N, their distribution along a DNA molecule, and particular values of the entropy factors of small loops formed by cross-links in melted regions strongly affect the DNA melting temperature, Tm. On the contrary, for DNA without cross-links, a ten-fold increase or decrease in the entropy factors of small loops does not cause the Tm variation. The comparison of the results of calculation with experimental data suggests that the majority of types of cross-link neither maintain ordered parallel orientation of bases in melted regions nor increase considerably the thermostability of cross-linked base pairs. Four different ways of influence of interstrand cross-linking on the DNA double helix stability are considered. It is shown that cross-linking significantly enhances the influence of single strand stiffness in melted regions on DNA melting behavior.

Melting of cross-linked DNA: I. Model and theoretical methods

Covalent and strong coordination binding to DNA of a large number of antitumour drugs and other compounds leads to interstrand cross-link formation. To investigate cross-link influence on double helix stability, two methods are developed for the calculation of melting curves. The first method is based on Poland's approach. It requires computer time proportional to u.N, where u is the average distance (in base pairs) between neighboring cross-links and N is the number of base pairs in the DNA chain. The method is more suitable when u is not large, and small loops formed by interstrand cross-links in melted regions strongly affect DNA melting. The computer time for the second method, based on the Fixman-Freire approach, does not depend on the number of cross-links and is proportional to I.N (I is the number of exponential functions used for a decomposition of the loop entropy factor). It is more appropriate when N and u are large, and therefore particular values of the entropy factors of small loops do not influence DNA melting behavior.

How do DNA repair proteins locate damaged bases in the genome?

The genome is susceptible to the attack of reactive species that chemically modify the bases of DNA. If genetic information is to be transmitted faithfully to successive generations, it is essential that the genome be repaired. All organisms express proteins specifically dedicated to this task. But how do these proteins find the aberrant bases amongst the enormous number of normal ones?

Synthesis and biochemical evaluation of RNA containing an intrahelical disulfide crosslink

BACKGROUND

Several factors impede the elucidation of RNA structure and function by X-ray and NMR methods, including the complexity of folded RNA motifs, the tendency of RNA to aggregate, and its ability to fold into multiple isomeric structures. The ability to constrain the process of RNA folding to give a single, homogeneous product would assist these investigations. We therefore set out to develop a synthetic procedure for the site-specific insertion of a disulfide crosslink into oligoribonucleotides. We also examined the ability of a crosslinked species to serve as a substrate for ricin, an RNA glycosylase.

RESULTS

A convertible nucleoside derivative (C) suitable for the site-specific introduction of N4-alkylcytidine residues into RNA has been developed. The corresponding C phosphoramidite was employed in the synthesis of an 8-mer oligonucleotide, 5'-CGGA-GACG-3', which was then efficiently converted to an 8-mer containing two S-protected N4-(2-thioethyl)C residues. Upon deprotection and air oxidation, the 8-mer efficiently formed an intramolecular disulfide bond, yielding a GAGA tetraloop presented on a two-base-pair CpG disulfide crosslinked ministem. We show that this ministem-loop is an excellent substrate for ricin. Control 8-mers lacking the disulfide crosslink were substantially poorer substrates for ricin.

CONCLUSIONS

The nucleoside chemistry described here should be generally useful for the site-specific introduction of a range of non-native functional groups into RNA. We have used this chemistry to constrain an RNA ministem through introduction of an intrahelical disulfide crosslink. That this tetraloop substrate linked to a two base-pair ministem is efficiently processed by ricin is clear evidence that ricin makes all of its energetically favorable contacts to the extreme end of the stem-loop structure, and that the two base pairs of the stem abutting the loop remain intact during recognition and processing by ricin.

Modifying the helical structure of DNA by design: recruitment of an architecture-specific protein to an enforced DNA bend

BACKGROUND

Proteins can force DNA to adopt distorted helical structures that are rarely if ever observed in naked DNA. The ability to synthesize DNA that contains defined helical aberrations would offer a new avenue for exploring the structural and energetic plasticity of DNA. Here we report a strategy for the enforcement of non-canonical helical structures through disulfide cross-linking; this approach is exemplified by the design and synthesis of an oligonucleotide containing a pronounced bend.

RESULTS

A localized bend was site-specifically introduced into DNA by the formation of a disulfide cross-link between the 5' adenines of a 5'-AATT-3' region in complementary strands of DNA. The DNA bend was characterized by high-resolution NMR structure determination of a cross-linked dodecamer and electrophoretic mobility assays on phased multimers, which together indicate that the cross-linked tetranucleotide induces a helical bend of approximately 30 degrees and a modest degree of unwinding. The enforced bend was found to stimulate dramatically the binding of an architecture-specific protein, HMG-D, to the DNA. DNase I foot-printing analysis revealed that the protein is recruited to the section of DNA that is bent.

CONCLUSIONS

The present study reports a novel approach for the investigation of non-canonical DNA structures and their recognition by architecture-specific proteins. The mode of DNA bending induced by disulfide cross-linking resembles that observed in structures of protein-DNA complexes. The results reveal common elements in the DNA-binding mode employed by sequence-specific and architecture-specific HMG proteins.