Stereotactic biopsy and treatment of brain stem lesions: combined study of 33 cases (Bologna-Marseille)

Pediatric Brainstem Tumor Biopsy: Surgical Planning and Execution for Maximal Safety and Tissue Yield

Brainstem tumors account for 10-20% of pediatric brain tumors with a peak age of diagnosis between 7 and 9 years old and are often fatal. Historically, diagnosis of brainstem tumors has been largely based on imaging; however, recent studies have demonstrated the incongruities between preoperative MRI diagnosis and postoperative pathological findings highlighting the importance of brainstem biopsy for diagnostic accuracy. Stereotactic brainstem biopsy for pediatric brainstem tumors has been proven to be safe with a high diagnostic yield (96.1-97.4%) and relatively low morbidity and mortality. Successful pediatric brainstem tumor biopsy demands intricate knowledge of brainstem anatomy, cranial nerves and vasculature, and common pediatric brainstem tumors by the performing surgeon. Additionally, understanding of the surgical indications and techniques (e.g., frame-based versus frameless, robotic assistance, surgical approach, and targets selection) helps to ensure maximal safety and tissue yield. Pediatric brainstem biopsy permits histological conformation of brainstem lesions leading to accurate diagnosis and the potential for personalized treatment and future therapeutic research.

[Primary tumors of the brain stem. State of the problem]

Primary brainstem gliomas are still poorly studied in neurooncology. This concept includes tumors with different histological and genetic features, as well as variable clinical course and outcomes. Nevertheless, treatment implies radiotherapy without a clear idea of morphological substrate of disease in 80% of cases. Small number of studies and insufficient data on histological and genetic nature of brainstem tumors complicate clear diagnostic and treatment algorithms. This review provides current information regarding primary glial brainstem tumors. Appropriate problems and objectives are highlighted. The purpose of the review is to provide a comprehensive and updated understanding of the current state of brainstem glial tumors and to identify areas requiring further study for improvement of diagnosis and treatment of these diseases. Brainstem tumors are an understudied problem with small amount of data that complicates optimal treatment strategies. Further researches and histological verification are required to develop new methods of therapy, especially for diffuse forms of neoplasms.

Stereotactic biopsy of brainstem lesions: 21 years experiences of a single center

Stereotactic biopsies are procedures performed to obtain tumor tissue for diagnostic examinations. Cerebral lesions of unknown entities can safely be accessed and tissue can be examined, resulting in correct diagnosis and according treatment. Stereotactic procedures of lesions in highly eloquent regions such as the brainstem have been performed for more than two decades in our department. In this retrospective study we focus on results, approaches, modalities of anesthesia, and complications. We performed a retrospective analysis of our prospective database, including 26 patients who underwent stereotactic biopsy of the brainstem between April 1994 and June 2015. All of the patients underwent preoperative MRI. Riechert-Mundinger-frame was used before 2000, thereafter the Leksell stereotactic frame was used. After 2000 entry and target points were calculated by using BrainLab stereotactic system. We evaluated histopathological results as well as further treatment; additionally we compared complications of local versus general anesthesia and complications of a frontal versus a trans-cerebellar approach. Median age of all patients was 33 years, and median number of tissue samples taken was 12. In all patients a final histopathological diagnosis could be established. 5 patients underwent the procedure under local anesthesia, 21 patients in general anesthesia. In 19 patients a frontal approach was performed, while in 7 patients a trans-cerebellar approach was used. Complications occurred in five patients. Thereby no significant difference was found with regard to approach (frontal versus trans-cerebellar) or anesthesia (local versus general). Stereotactic biopsies even of lesions in the brainstem are a save way to obtain tumor tissue for final diagnosis, resulting in adequate treatment. Approach can be trans-cerebellar or frontal and procedure can be performed either under local or general anesthesia without significant differences concerning complication rate.

Long-term survival of an infant with diffuse brainstem lesion diagnosed by prenatal MRI: a case report and review of the literature

BACKGROUND

We describe a unique case of expansive diffuse brainstem lesion diagnosed prenatally by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with long-term survival. Findings of fetal and postpartum MRI were highly consistent with the characteristics of diffuse brainstem glioma.

METHODS

Diagnosis was based on the features of MRI, and histopathology was not confirmed by biopsy. Although the prognosis of diffuse brainstem tumor is usually poor, this child was asymptomatic at birth and the neurological condition is still normal at 4 years of age without any treatment.

RESULTS

During routine imaging follow-up, diameters of the expansion have remained stable, while the size of the lesion compared to the posterior fossa size has diminished. In addition to brainstem tumor, a skin lesion of the back was observed and MRI of the thoracic spine showed a large asymptomatic extradural cystic lesion suggesting an arachnoid cyst. The pontine tumor of this infant, in agreement with a few previously reported cases, suggests a subgroup of beneficial outcome of expansive diffuse brainstem lesions, particularly in the neonatal period.

DISCUSSION

In this article, we discuss the prognosis and characteristics of pediatric brainstem tumors and differential diagnosis of neonatal brainstem lesions.

The efficacy of a biopsy of intrinsic brainstem lesions for decision making of the treatments

OBJECT

The diagnosis of diffuse intrinsic pontine gliomas (DIPGs) has been generally made mainly by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and clinical course. However, the accuracy of MRI-based diagnosis has not been fully confirmed yet. Our aim was to review efficacy of biopsy for decision making of the treatments.

METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed pediatric patients undergoing biopsy for intrinsic brainstem lesions which were considered atypical for DIPGs by MRI findings. The lesion was evaluated atypical when it extended beyond the pons or it had a well-margined localized enhancing portion.

RESULTS

Seven patients underwent biopsy. Preoperative MRI revealed a lesion extending beyond the pons in five patients and a focal enhancing lesion in four. Two patients had both of these. Open biopsy was performed via midline suboccipital approach in six patients and retrosigmoid approach in one. No intraoperative complications were observed. Histopathological examination revealed diffuse brainstem glioma in five patients, primitive neuroectodermal tumor (PNET) in one, and pilocytic astrocytoma in one. In the case with PNET, chemotherapy and radiotherapy were effective and the patient had been stable for 12 months without recurrence. The patient with pilocytic astrocytoma did not undergo radiotherapy and has been stable without regrowth of the tumor for 9 months.

CONCLUSIONS

Open biopsy of intrinsic brainstem lesions is considered to be safe and effective for selecting an appropriate course of therapy. Patients with intrinsic pontine lesions which extend beyond the pons or with localized enhancing portion seem to be benefited from the biopsy.

Transcerebellar stereotactic biopsy for brainstem lesions in children

Brain stem lesions are pathologically heterogeneous. Pre-operative radiological diagnoses prove to be wrong in 10 to 20% of cases. It is therefore imperative to have a tissue diagnosis for appropriate therapeutic measures. We report a series of 24 patients (14 males, ten females, age range: 6-17 years) CT guided stereotactic biopsy for brain stem lesions approached via the suboccipital transcerebellar route in semi sitting position with principle used to violate only one pial plane with the biopsy probe not entering the ventral surface of the cerebellum. The inclusion and exclusion criteria with detailed material and method are discussed. Histological diagnosis was established in 23 patients (96%) with no procedure-related mortality. Our results indicate that stereotaxic approach to brain-stem lesions provides a high yield of positive histological diagnoses with a low incidence of morbidity. Awake CT-guided stereotactic biopsy via the suboccipital transcerebellar route in a semi-sitting position is a safe, reliable, and effective method for brainstem lesions that can obtain adequate tissue for histological diagnosis, thus providing each patient with the best available treatment.

Stereotactic biopsy of brain stem masses: decision analysis and literature review

BACKGROUND

Adult brain stem tumors are rare, and diverse pathology can be found in this location. Stereotactic biopsy of lesions in the brain stem has been performed since the 1960s with high diagnostic and low complication rates. Advances in imaging technology have raised questions regarding the utility of biopsy. We perform decision analysis to aid clinicians in their approach to management of adult brain stem lesions.

METHODS

A structured literature search revealed 20 publications with 457 patients who had undergone brain stem lesion biopsy. These publications were reviewed to determine diagnostic rates and the incidence of complications. Standard decision analytic techniques were applied to the case of a virtual adult patient with a lesion in the brain stem.

RESULTS

A 1-way sensitivity analysis revealed the likelihood that the preoperative diagnosis was correct and the rate at which incorrect treatment was based on faulty empirical diagnosis as the 2 factors with the greatest effects on patient outcome. The diagnostic rate and complication rate of biopsy, within the ranges reported in the literature, had lesser effects. A threshold analysis was constructed to compare outcomes from stereotactic biopsy vs empiric therapy for a brain stem lesion. The probability that the preoperative diagnosis is correct is plotted vs the probability that empirical treatment based on an incorrect diagnosis will have adverse effect.

CONCLUSIONS

Management of lesions in the adult brain stem requires careful consideration of multiple preoperative factors including clinical and radiographic diagnostic certainty, consequences of empiric therapy, and the surgeon's complication rate.

Stereotactic biopsies of focal brainstem lesions

BACKGROUND

Stereotactic biopsies of the brainstem (SBB) are a selected group of stereotactic operations owing to the lower incidence of brainstem lesions requiring biopsy, the greater complexity, and the higher risks of these procedures. Usually, the lower the lesion in the brainstem, the greater the risks involved. The approach of the different target locations by distinct routes, transcerebral and transcerebellar, is still a matter of debate. Moreover, pure medullary lesions are seldom biopsied, whereas diffuse brainstem lesions, typical of children's brainstem gliomas and rather frequent in most published series, depend less and less on the histopathological confirmation for treatment. In this study, the authors present their own experience on SBB aiming to discuss mainly their indications, approach routes choice, and procedure techniques.

METHODS

The authors reviewed a series of 30 SBB (27 adults and 3 children) out of 450 stereotactic biopsies of the central nervous system performed for the last 10 years. All cases but one presented as focal brainstem masses, 19 mainly in the pons and 10 in the midbrain. Eleven lesions (10 in the midbrain and one midbrain-pontine) were approached by a transfrontal route. All the others were approached by a suboccipital transcerebellar route.

RESULTS

Twenty-six (87%) out of the 28 cases (93%) where a positive histopathological result was obtained had a specific diagnosis: 18 tumors (14 astrocytomas, 2 primary brain lymphomas, 1 oligodendroglioma, and 1 ganglioglioma), 2 toxoplasmosis, 2 sarcoidosis, 1 aspergillus abscess, 1 vasculitis, 1 acute inflammatory demyelinating disease, and 1 progressive multifocal leucoencephalopathy. Four nontumoral lesions arose in patients with AIDS. Morbidity was restricted to 2 cases consisting of transient cranial nerve deficits.

CONCLUSIONS

Stereotactic biopsies are specially useful for the diagnosis of focal brainstem lesions. Midbrain and midline lesions should be approached through the cerebrum, whereas most of the pontine lesions through the cerebellum. Overall, this procedure should be performed with "functional-like" precision and require some technical refinements to reach maximal accuracy with minimal morbidity.