Stunning: damaging or protective to the myocardium?

On some pathogenetic and adaptation mechanisms of acute coronary disease

Acute coronary failure was modeled in rabbits by ligation of the descending left coronary artery at the interface of its middle and lower thirds. The function and morphology of left-ventricular and right-ventricular myocardium were studied on days 1, 3, and 5 of the pathological process. It was found that left-ventricular contractility decreased, while right-ventricular contractility increased. Deep morphological changes were observed in both ventricles: pronounced extracellular edema, increased content of collagen, decreased percentage of myofibrils. Hence, acute coronary failure involves both compartments of the heart, but the adaptive mechanisms more actively develop in the right ventricle.

Hibernation, Stunning, and Preconditioning: Historical Perspective, Current Concepts, Clinical Applications, and Future Implications

Despite considerable advances, coronary artery disease is the leading cause of morbidity and mortality in the Western world. The development of effective therapeutic strategies for protecting the myocardium from ischemia would have major impact on patients with coronary artery disease. It is now accepted that patients with coronary artery disease can experience prolonged regional ischemic dysfunction that does not necessarily arise from irreversible tissue damage, and to some extent, can be reversed by restoration of blood flow. The initial stages of dysfunction are probably caused by chronic stunning that can be reversed after revascularization, resulting in rapid and complete functional recovery. On the other hand, the more advanced stages of dysfunction likely correspond to chronic hibernation. After revascularization, functional recovery will probably be quite delayed and mostly incomplete. Over the past decade, the possibility that an innate mechanism of myocardial protection might be inducible in the human heart has generated considerable excitement. In the last two decades, there was phenomenal growth in the understanding of the mechanism known as ischemic preconditioning that is responsible for the innate myocardial protection. Continued research and progress in this area may soon lead to the availability of preconditioning-mimetic treatments. The current concepts, mechanisms, and potential clinical applications of myocardial hibernation, stunning, and ischemic preconditioning are reviewed.

Radionuclide viability testing: should it affect treatment strategy in patients with cardiomyopathy and significant coronary artery disease?

BACKGROUND

Ischemic heart failure is a significant source of morbidity and mortality, yet it has an unclear treatment strategy. The assessment of viable myocardium by nuclear imaging studies has shown promise in predicting improvements in ejection fraction and symptoms. However, the relationship of viability to long-term mortality has not been fully established.

METHODS

A number of studies have addressed long-term mortality with nuclear viability imaging in patients with impaired left ventricular function and significant coronary artery disease. These studies were analyzed to determine differences in design, results, trends, and limitations. They were then evaluated by use of qualitative criteria established for prognostic studies.

RESULTS

Fourteen studies met our criteria. Although the conclusions differed, it appears that patients with viability who undergo revascularization have the highest survival rate, whereas patients with viability who are treated medically have a much lower survival rate. Patients without viability have an intermediate survival rate, regardless of treatment. Several limitations were identified, including a lack of randomization, small sample size, inadequate follow-up, and extensive study protocol and design differences.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of viability testing in patients with heart failure and significant coronary artery disease has shown promise in predicting the long-term mortality rate with treatment allocation. However, there is a need for further study involving larger cohorts with a randomized design, longer periods of follow-up, improved study designs, and identification of referral bias and viability prevalence.

Metabolic derangement in ischemic heart disease and its therapeutic control

The term myocardial ischemia describes a condition that exists when fractional uptake of oxygen in the heart is not sufficient to maintain the rate of cellular oxidation. This leads to extremely complex situations that have been extensively studied in recent years. Experimental research has been directed toward establishing the precise sequence of biochemical events leading to myocyte necrosis, as such knowledge could lead to rational treatments designed to delay myocardial cell death. At the present time, there is no simple answer to the question of what determines cell death and the failure to recover cell function after reperfusion. Problems arise because: (1) ischemic damage is not homogeneous and many factors may combine to cause cell death; (2) severity of biochemical changes and development of necrosis are usually linked (both the processes being dependent on the duration of ischemia) and it is impossible to establish a causal relation; and (3) the inevitability of necrosis can only be assessed by reperfusion of the ischemic myocardium. Restoration of flow, however, might result in numerous other negative consequences, thus directly influencing the degree of recovery. From the clinical point of view, we have recently learned that there are several potential manifestations and outcomes associated with myocardial ischemia and reperfusion. Without a doubt, ventricular dysfunction (either systolic or diastolic) of the ischemic zone is the most reliable clinical sign of ischemia, since electrocardiographic changes and symptoms are often absent. The ischemia-induced ventricular dysfunction, at least initially, is reversible, as early reperfusion of the myocardium results in restoration of normal metabolism and contraction. In the ischemic zone, recovery of contraction may occur instantaneously or, more frequently, with a considerable delay, thus yielding the condition recently recognized as the "stunned" myocardium. On the other hand, when ischemia is severe and prolonged, cell death may occur. Reperfusion at this stage is associated with the release of intracellular enzymes, damage of cell membranes, influx of calcium, persistent reduction of contractility, and eventual necrosis of at least a portion of the tissue. This entity has been called "reperfusion damage" by those who believe that much of the injury is the consequence of events occurring at the moment of reperfusion rather than a result of changes occurring during the period of ischemia. The existence of reperfusion damage, however, has been questioned, and it has been argued that, with the exception of induction of arrhythmias, it is difficult to be certain that reperfusion causes further injury. The existence of such an entity has clinical relevance, as it would imply the possibility of improving recovery with specific interventions applied at the time of reperfusion. In 1985, Rahimtoola described another possible outcome of myocardial ischemia. He demonstrated that late reperfusion (after months or even years) of an ischemic area showing ventricular wall-motion abnormalities might restore normal metabolism and function. He was the first to introduce the term "hibernating myocardium," referring to ischemic myocardium wherein the myocytes remain viable but in which contraction is chronically depressed. In this article we review our data on metabolic changes occurring during ischemia followed by reperfusion, obtained either in the isolated and perfused rabbit hearts or in ischemic heart disease patients undergoing intracoronary thrombolysis or aortocoronary bypass grafting.

Different outcomes of the reperfused myocardium: insights into the comments of stunning and hibernation

There are several potential outcomes of myocardial ischaemia. When ischaemia is severe and prolonged, irreversible damage occurs and there is no recovery of contractile function. Interventions aimed at reducing mechanical activity and oxygen demand either before ischaemia or during reperfusion have been shown to delay the onset of ischaemic damage and to improve recovery during reperfusion. When myocardial ischaemia is less severe but still prolonged, myocytes may remain viable but exhibit depressed contractile function. Under these conditions, reperfusion restores complete contractile performance. This type of ischaemia leading to a reversible, chronic left ventricular dysfunction has been termed 'hibernating myocardium'. It is important clinically recognize hibernation as reperfusion of hibernating myocardium by angioplasty or heart surgery restores contraction and this correlates with long term survival. A third possible outcome after a short period of myocardial ischaemia is a transient post-ischaemic ventricular dysfunction, a situation termed 'stunned myocardium'.

Left ventricular dysfunction due to the new ischemic outcomes: stunning and hibernation

Several potential manifestations and outcomes are associated with myocardial ischemia and reperfusion. When ischemia is severe and prolonged, irreversible damage occurs and there is no recovery of contractile function. When ischemia is less severe or shorter in duration, recovery of contraction may occur instantaneously or more commonly, after considerable delay, which is the condition recognized as "stunned myocardium." Stunning is defined as a transient left ventricular dysfunction that persists after reperfusion despite the absence of irreversible damage and restoration of normal or near-normal coronary flow. Oxidative stress and alteration of calcium homeostasis during reperfusion are the probable causes of stunning. Clinically, stunning may occur after acute infarction, successful thrombolysis, unstable angina, angioplasty, resolution of coronary spasm, open-heart surgery, or transplantation. It can be treated with interventions aimed at prevention or reversal. When ischemia is prolonged but less severe, myocytes may remain viable but exhibit depressed contraction. Under these conditions, reperfusion restores normal contractile performance. This type of ischemia, leading to a reversible, chronic left ventricular dysfunction, has been termed "hibernating myocardium." The intrinsic mechanisms of this condition are unknown. Clinically, it is very important to diagnose hibernation because reperfusion of the hibernating myocardium by angioplasty or heart surgery restores contraction, and this correlates with long-term survival. A number of methods are available to access the hibernating myocardium. These include cardiac imaging techniques that evaluate myocardial viability, such as positron emission tomography and thallium myocardial imaging, or methods that evaluate contractile reserve, such as low-dose dobutamine echocardiography. Interestingly, reperfusion of patients with end-stage ischemic cardiomyopathy and hibernating myocardium can be considered an alternative to transplantation.

From coronary artery disease to heart failure: role of the hibernating myocardium

Hibernating myocardium is defined as persistently impaired myocardial and left ventricular (LV) function at rest resulting from reduced myocardial blood flow. It may occur in unstable angina and chronic stable angina, acute myocardial infarction, and LV dysfunction and congestive heart failure. Recovery of the hibernating myocardium has clearly been shown to occur with the establishment of successful revascularization either by coronary bypass surgery or by percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty. It may be possible to show recovery of the viable myocardium by reducing myocardial oxygen demand and/or by increasing coronary blood flow with pharmaceutical agents.

Effect of adenosine deaminase inhibition with pentostatin on myocardial stunning in dogs

Pentostatin (2-deoxycoformycin) is a potent inhibitor of adenosine deaminase and has been demonstrated to augment endogenous adenosine levels during regional and global myocardial ischemia. Based on the rationale that increasing endogenous adenosine during ischemia may be cardioprotective, the objective of this study was to determine if adenosine deaminase inhibition with pentostatin could improve postischemic contractile dysfunction (stunning) in open-chest anesthetized dogs. All animals underwent 15 min of coronary occlusion followed by 3 h of reperfusion preceded by an intravenous bolus of either 0.2 mg/kg of pentostatin (n = 8) or saline (n = 7). Sonomicrometers were placed in the ischemic area and were used to measure systolic wall thickening before, during, and after occlusion of the left anterior descending artery. Myocardial blood flow was measured with tracer labeled microspheres at baseline, 10 min of occlusion and at 1 h of reperfusion. Both groups were equally dyskinetic during occlusion (-21 +/- 5% of baseline thickening in the controls and -28 +/- 8% in the pentostatin group). The pentostatin group, however, demonstrated better contractile function at all time points during reperfusion, which was significantly different from the control group at 3 h of reperfusion. The improvement in regional function in the pentostatin group was not due to significant disparities in hemodynamic variables, size of the region at risk, or in collateral blood flow. These results indicate that pentostatin can ameliorate the severity of myocardial stunning, an effect we propose is due to increasing endogenous levels of adenosine during the ischemic interval. Although significant improvement was detected with pentostatin, the improvement was modest compared to controls, suggesting that the utility of inhibiting adenosine deaminase to modify regional mechanical stunning is limited.

Left ventricular dysfunction due to stunning and hibernation in patients

Left ventricular dysfunction is in most cases the consequence of myocardial ischemia. It may occur transiently during an attack of angina and usually it is reversible. It may persist over hours or even days in patients after an episode of ischemia followed by reperfusion, leading to the so-called condition of stunning. In patients with persistent limitation of coronary flow, left ventricular dysfunction may be present over months and years, or indefinitely in subjects with fibrosis, scar formation, and remodeling after myocardial infarction. However, chronic left ventricular dysfunction does not mean permanent or irreversible cell damage. Hypoperfused myocytes can remain viable but akinetic. This type of dysfunction has been called hibernating myocardium. The dysfunction due to hibernation can be partially or completely restored to normal by reperfusion. It is, therefore, important to clinically recognize a hibernating myocardium. In the present article we evaluate stunning and hibernation with respect to clinical decision making and, when possible, we refer to our ongoing clinical experience.

Echocardiography during infusion of dobutamine for identification of reversibly dysfunction in patients with chronic coronary artery disease

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to test whether the contractile response of akinetic myocardium to low dose dobutamine is useful for detecting myocardial viability in patients with coronary artery disease and persistent left ventricular dysfunction.

BACKGROUND

In some patients with chronic coronary artery disease, persistent abnormalities of left ventricular wall motion can be reversed by successful coronary artery bypass surgery. Thus, identification of potentially reversible dysfunction has important therapeutic and prognostic implications. Echocardiography during infusion of low dose dobutamine can detect viable myocardium in patients after thrombolytic therapy. However, there is no detailed information on the use of this method in patients with chronic left ventricular dysfunction without reperfusion.

METHODS

We studied 33 selected patients with angiographically proved coronary artery disease and persistent left ventricular dysfunction. The effect of dobutamine infusion (5 micrograms/kg body weight per min, followed by 10 micrograms/kg per min) on left ventricular wall motion was evaluated by transthoracic echocardiography before coronary artery bypass grafting and compared with that obtained immediately after the operation (evaluated by intraoperative epicardial echocardiography) and both 2 weeks and 3 months later. Left ventricular wall motion was analyzed qualitatively by dividing the left ventricle into 16 segments, and a score was assigned to each region.

RESULTS

Before coronary artery bypass surgery, 314 segments were akinetic. Of these, 183 became normokinetic immediately after revascularization, and 15 became hypokinetic. Dobutamine infusion was able to predict improvement in 178 of the 205 segments that recovered function after revascularization (sensitivity 86.8%) and to identify 89 of the 109 segments that did not recover postoperatively (specificity 81.6%). Mean (+/- SD) segment scores were 2.24 +/- 0.35 at baseline, 1.49 +/- 0.34 (p < 0.001) after dobutamine infusion, 1.51 +/- 0.38 (p < 0.001) immediately after and 1.51 +/- 0.38 (p < 0.001) 2 weeks after coronary artery bypass and 1.55 +/- 0.37 (p < 0.001) at 3-month follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

Echocardiography during infusion of low dose dobutamine is a safe and accurate method for identifying reversible dysfunctioning myocardium and predicts early reversibility of wall motion after surgical revascularization in selected patients with coronary artery disease with chronic left ventricular dysfunction.

Hibernating myocardium in patients with coronary artery disease: identification and clinical importance

The term hibernating myocardium describes a particular outcome of myocardial ischemia in which myocytes show a chronically depressed contractile ability but remain viable. Revascularization of hibernating tissue causes a recovery of mechanical function that correlates with long-term survival. Therefore it is important clinically to distinguish hibernating from infarcted myocardium, since asynergies due to hibernation will improve on reperfusion, whilst those due to infarct will not. One suggested technique to identify hibernating myocardium is to stimulate the myocytes acutely, but briefly, by administration of inotropic agents while monitoring contractile function by echocardiography. We report our experience on the use of low dosages of dobutamine. Myocardial viability was validated by measuring the recovery in contraction of the akinetic areas after coronary artery bypass surgery by means of intraoperative epicardial echocardiography. The test has a sensitivity of 93% and a specificity of 78%. It is useful for identification of viable myocardium and also for quantification of intraoperative risk in individual patients. Limitations of this test are related to the presence of downregulation of beta receptors and to the impossibility of differentiating hibernating from stunned myocardium. Another useful technique of identifying hibernating myocardium is the use of radionuclear markers for viability. In our experience the two most important tests are (1) rest-redistribution imaging of thallium 201 (which has a high sensitivity of 93% but a low specificity of 44%) and (2) 99mTc-Sestamibi imaging, which provides information on both perfusion and function with a single injection. This latter technique allows differentiation between stunning and hibernating on the basis of coronary flow which is preserved in stunning and reduced in hibernation.