LFER and CoMFA studies on optical resolution of alpha-alkyl alpha-aryloxy acetic acid methyl esters on DACH-DNB chiral stationary phase

Mining Chromatographic Enantioseparation Data Using Matched Molecular Pair Analysis

We apply matched molecular pair (MMP) analysis to data from ChirBase, which contains literature reports of chromatographic enantioseparations. For the 19 chiral stationary phases we examined, we were able to identify 289 sets of pairs where there is a statistically significant and consistent difference in enantioseparation due to a small chemical change. In many cases these changes highlight enantioselectivity differences between pairs or small families of closely related molecules that have for many years been used to probe the mechanisms of chromatographic chiral recognition; for example, the comparison of N-H vs. N-Me analytes to determine the criticality of an N-H hydrogen bond in chiral molecular recognition. In other cases, statistically significant MMPs surfaced by the analysis are less familiar or somewhat puzzling, sparking a need to generate and test hypotheses to more fully understand. Consequently, mining of appropriate datasets using MMP analysis provides an important new approach for studying and understanding the process of chromatographic enantioseparation.

Chiral recognition by enantioselective liquid chromatography: mechanisms and modern chiral stationary phases

An overview of the state-of-the-art in LC enantiomer separation is presented. This tutorial review is mainly focused on mechanisms of chiral recognition and enantiomer distinction of popular chiral selectors and corresponding chiral stationary phases including discussions of thermodynamics, additivity principle of binding increments, site-selective thermodynamics, extrathermodynamic approaches, methods employed for the investigation of dominating intermolecular interactions and complex structures such as spectroscopic methods (IR, NMR), X-ray diffraction and computational methods. Modern chiral stationary phases are discussed with particular focus on those that are commercially available and broadly used. It is attempted to provide the reader with vivid images of molecular recognition mechanisms of selected chiral selector-selectand pairs on basis of solid-state X-ray crystal structures and simulated computer models, respectively. Such snapshot images illustrated in this communication unfortunately cannot account for the molecular dynamics of the real world, but are supposed to be helpful for the understanding. The exploding number of papers about applications of various chiral stationary phases in numerous fields of enantiomer separations is not covered systematically.

Quinine carbamate chiral stationary phases: Systematic optimization of steric selector-selectand binding increments and enantioselectivity by quantitative structure-enantioselectivity relationship studies

A series of quinine carbamate-based chiral stationary phases (CSPs) differing solely in the carbamate residue have been devised and a congeneric set of N-3,5-dinitrobenzoyl (DNB) amino acids (AAs) was separated into enantiomers on these CSPs by HPLC using a buffered hydro-organic mobile phase. Some details on retention and chiral recognition mechanisms have been investigated by application of quantitative structure-property relationship (QSPR) studies using the linear free energy relationship methodology, i.e., the extrathermodynamic approach. Retention factors of the high affinity enantiomer (log k2) and enantioselectivities (log alpha) were correlated with Taft's steric parameter as structural descriptor for the variability in the carbamate and AA residues, and statistically significant QSPR models could be obtained. They confirmed that the variance in the dependent variable (log k2, log alpha) is mainly associated with the steric bulkiness of the selectors' carbamate and of the AA residues. The retention factor of the second eluted enantiomers and the enantioselectivity first increased with steric bulkiness of the carbamate and AA residues, which may be explained by stronger dispersive interactions. After reaching an optimum, the dependent variable, however, declined with further increase of the steric bulkiness of the substituents, probably because of steric hindrance. The variability of the retention factors of the first eluted enantiomer could not be explained by steric descriptors. Instead, it has become obvious that the retention arises mainly from interactions of the DNB-AA and the quinine carbamate backbone, as it turned out to be more or less constant and solely to a minute amount modulated by the carbamate residue and the AA side chain. The QSPR models were fully in agreement with an earlier postulated chromatographically and spectroscopically derived hypothetical selector-selectand binding model.

Linear free energy relationship as a tool for characterization of three teicoplanin-based chiral stationary phases under various mobile phase compositions

Teicoplanin, teicoplanin aglycon, and methylated teicoplanin aglycon chiral stationary phases (CSPs) have been compared on the basis of the regression coefficients calculated from the linear free energy relationship (LFER) equation. The parameters have been obtained from the measurements of a set of 34 structurally diverse solutes. Influence of mobile phase composition - variation of methanol (MeOH) content - on the participation of different interactions types in the retention mechanism has been evaluated. Retention of the various interaction forces in analytes differs with both the CSP and the mobile phase composition. Hydrophobic interactions play a major role in mobile phases for high buffer contents. The more hydrophobic the CSP, the more important are they in the retention mechanism. With increase of MeOH contents in the mobile phase the major role in the interaction mechanism is shifted to more polar forces in which basicity and dipolarity/polarizability dominate. Although the LFER model does not address chiral aspects, we have attempted to explore the importance of the individual interactions in chiral discrimination of amino acids and their N-tert-butyloxycarbonyl derivatives.

Modeling the chromatographic enantioseparation of aryl- and hetarylcarbinols on ULMO, a brush-type chiral stationary phase, by 3D-QSAR techniques

The enantiomers of a series of chiral aryl- and hetaryl-carbinols were separated on a chiral stationary phase (ULMO) based on (S,S)-3,5-dinitrobenzoylated 1,2-diphenylethane-1,2-diamine. In all cases, the homochiral analogs of (S)-1-phenylethanol (mostly also S-enantiomers) were retained more. Log alpha values were modeled with the aid of the 3D-QSAR techniques CoMFA (comparative molecular field analysis) and CoMSIA (comparative molecular similarity indices analysis) as well as a descriptor based on normal mode eigenvalues (EVA). Partial least-squares analysis with two (CoMSIA) or three (CoMFA, EVA) latent variables on a set of 22 training analytes gives cross-validated correlation coefficients q(2) = 0.85-0.91 and conventional correlation coefficients r(2) = 0.94-0.99. The quantitative structure-enantioselective retention relationships derived thereby were used to predict the separation factors of the test set, containing also hetaryl-carbinols, e.g., furan and thiophene analogs, with good accuracy.

High affinity central benzodiazepine receptor ligands. Part 2: quantitative structure-activity relationships and comparative molecular field analysis of pyrazolo[4,3-c]quinolin-3-ones

A large series of 2-aryl(heteroaryl)-2,5-dihydropyrazolo[4,3-c]quinolin-3(3H)-ones (PQ, 106 compounds), carrying appropriate substituents at the quinoline and N2-phenyl rings, were designed, prepared and tested as central benzodiazepine receptor ligands. Compounds with an affinity significantly higher than the parent compound CGS-8216 were obtained, the most active ligand showing a pIC50 = 10.35. Hansch and comparative molecular field analyses gave coherent results suggesting the main structural requirements of high receptor binding affinity. The possible formation of a three-centred hydrogen bond (HB) at the HB donor site H2, as a key interaction for high receptor binding affinity, was assessed by the calculation and comparison of the molecular electrostatic potentials of a series of selected ligands.

Comparative molecular field analysis of quinine derivatives used as chiral selectors in liquid chromatography: 3D QSAR for the purposes of molecular design of chiral stationary phases

A comparative molecular field analysis (CoMFA) was carried out on a set of aligned quinine-based stationary phase molecules used in enantioselective chromatography. The best QSAR derived has a cross-validated (predictive) r(2)(cv) = 0.671 and a normal r(2) = 0.998. For CoMFAs using both steric and electrostatic fields as descriptors, the steric field descriptors explained more than 91% of the variance while the electrostatic descriptors explained less than 9% of the variance. It is concluded that the long-range electrostatic potential surrounding the positively charged CSPs are not enantiodiscriminating, while the van der Waals and local electrostatic surface features of these CSPs are highly discriminating. Quantum mechanical calculations back up this claim by showing a relatively symmetric electrostatic iso-contour surface. From the QSAR derived here, a region around the carbamate moiety was located where placement of steric bulk is predicted to enhance chiral discrimination. A set of possible synthetic target molecules is presented.

Atomistic modeling of enantioselective binding

This Account focuses on computational studies related to chiral recognition. It begins with a description of potential energy surfaces and the computational tools used to explore such surfaces, describes approximations and assumptions made by researchers computing enantioselective binding, and then explains why differential free energies of binding can be computed so accurately. The review focuses on chiral recognition in chromatography, emphasizing binding and enantiodiscriminating forces responsible for chiral recognition. The Account also describes computational studies of chiral recognition in cyclodextrins, proteins, and synthetic receptors.

2-D and 3-D modeling of imidazoline receptor ligands: insights into pharmacophore

A 3-D quantitative structure-activity relationship (3-D QSAR) study was carried out using comparative molecular field analysis (CoMFA) on both imidazoline (I2R) and alpha 2 receptor binding affinities of a large series of 2-substituted imidazolines. Significant cross-validated correlations, having promising predictive ability, were obtained along with 3-D pharmacophore models that defined the spatial regions where steric and electrostatic interactions may modulate the in vitro binding affinities and indicated possible physicochemical and structural requirements for I2/alpha 2 receptor selectivity.

Structure-activity relationships of 2-aryl-2,5-dihydropyridazino [4,3-b]indol-3(3H)-ones at the benzodiazepine receptor

A large series of 2-aryl-2,5-dihydropyridazino[4,3-b]indol-3(3H)ones (PIs) carrying properly selected substituents at the indole and N2-phenyl rings was prepared and tested as central benzodiazepine receptor (BZR) ligands and potential (anti)convulsant agents. Stereoelectronic requirements for high receptor affinity were detected by means of 2-D and 3-D QSAR analyses. BZR affinities and pharmacological profiles of the compounds were examined in comparison with some other pyridazinoindolones recently described by us and with pyrazoloquinoline (PQ) analogues. An anticonvulsant activity greater than PQs was generally observed for PIs. Notably, in the test of audiogenically induced seizures, one compound showed a potency comparable to that of diazepam.

Substituent effects on the enantioselective retention of anti-HIV 5-aryl-delta 2-1,2,4-oxadiazolines on R,R-DACH-DNB chiral stationary phase

A series of racemic 3-phenyl-4-(1-adamantyl)-5-X-phenyl- delta 2-1,2,4-oxadiazo lines (PAdOx) were directly resolved by HPLC using a Pirkle-type stationary phase containing N,N'-(3,5-dinitrobenzoyl)-1(R),2(R)-diaminocyclohexane as chiral selector. The more retained enantiomers have S configuration, as demonstrated by X-ray crystallography and circular dichroism measurements. The influence of aromatic ring substituents on enantioselective retention was quantitatively assessed by traditional linear free energy-related (LFER) equations and comparative molecular field analysis (CoMFA). In good agreement with previous findings, the results from this study indicate that the increase in retention (k') is favoured mainly by the phi-basicity and the hydrophilicity of solute, whereas enantioselectivity (alpha) can be satisfactorily modeled by electronic and bulk parameters or CoMFA descriptors. The LFER equations and CoMFA models gave helpful insights into chiral recognition mechanisms.