Use of the oxygen cost of breathing as an index of weaning ability from mechanical ventilation

Monitoring CO2 in shock states

The primary end point when treating acute shock is to restore blood circulation, mainly by reaching macrocirculatory parameters. However, even if global haemodynamic goals can be achieved, microcirculatory perfusion may remain impaired, leading to cellular hypoxia and organ damage. Interestingly, few methods are currently available to measure the adequacy of organ blood flow and tissue oxygenation. The rise in tissue partial pressure of carbon dioxide (CO2) has been observed when tissue perfusion is decreased. In this regard, tissue partial pressure of CO2 has been proposed as an early and reliable marker of tissue hypoxia even if the mechanisms of tissue partial pressure in CO2 rise during hypoperfusion remain unclear. Several technologies allow the estimation of CO2 content from different body sites: vascular, tissular (in hollow organs, mucosal or cutaneous), and airway. These tools remain poorly evaluated, and some are used but are not widely used in clinical practice. The present review clarifies the physiology of increasing tissue CO2 during hypoperfusion and underlines the specificities of the different technologies that allow bedside estimation of tissue CO2 content.

Do simple ventilation and gas exchange measurements predict early successful weaning from respiratory support in unselected general intensive care patients?

BACKGROUND

The value of respiratory variables as weaning predictors in the intensive care unit (ICU) is controversial. We evaluated the ability of tidal volume (Vt(exp)), respiratory rate (f), minute volume (MV(exp)), rapid shallow breathing index (f/Vt), inspired-expired oxygen concentration difference [(I-E)O(2)], and end-tidal carbon dioxide concentration (Pe'(co(2))) at the end of a weaning trial to predict early weaning outcomes.

METHODS

Seventy-three patients who required >24 h of mechanical ventilation were studied. A controlled pressure support weaning trial was undertaken until 5 cm H(2)O continuous positive airway pressure or predefined criteria were reached. The ability of data from the last 5 min of the trial to predict whether a predefined endpoint indicating discontinuation of ventilator support within the next 24 h was evaluated.

RESULTS

Pre-test probability for achieving the outcome was 44% in the cohort (n=32). Non-achievers were older, had higher APACHE II and organ failure scores before the trial, and higher baseline arterial H(+) concentrations. The Vt, MV, f, and f/Vt had no predictive power using a range of cut-off values or from receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis. The [I-E]O(2) and Pe'(co(2)) had weak discriminatory power [area under the ROC curve: [I-E]O(2) 0.64 (P=0.03); Pe'(co(2)) 0.63 (P=0.05)]. Using best cut-off values for [I-E]O(2) of 5.6% and Pe'(co(2)) of 5.1 kPa, positive and negative likelihood ratios were 2 and 0.5, respectively, which only changed the pre- to post-test probability by about 20%.

CONCLUSIONS

In unselected ICU patients, respiratory variables predict early weaning from mechanical ventilation poorly.

Oxygen cost of breathing in newborn infants with long-term ventilatory support

Oxygen consumption (VO2) was measured during controlled and spontaneous ventilation with continuous positive airway pressure in newborn infants in whom chronic lung disease later developed. The oxygen cost of breathing (the difference in VO2 between spontaneous and controlled ventilation) was significantly higher in infants with chronic lung disease than in control infants (20.1% +/- 7.5% and 4.8% +/- 4.9% of VO2 during spontaneous ventilation (p < 0.05), respectively).

Effect of weaning on oxygen consumption and cardiovascular function. A comparison of continuous flow and demand valve systems

This study compared the continuous positive airways pressure mode of the demand valve system of the Engstrom Erica ventilator with a custom-made continuous flow continuous positive airways pressure system in terms of the oxygen cost of breathing during weaning from mechanical ventilation. Ten consecutive patients in our intensive care unit, with thermodilution pulmonary artery flotation catheters in situ, were studied. Measurements were carried out under steady-state conditions, initially when breathing spontaneously with continuous positive airways pressure via the Erica and then when transition to the continuous flow system was achieved. There were no significant differences between the two methods of providing continuous positive airways pressure in terms of the measured and derived physiological variables studied, with the exception of oxygen consumption. Oxygen consumption with the continuous flow system was significantly less than with the Erica (142.8 (SEM 31.4) ml.min-1.m-2 compared with 165.8 (SEM 30.5) ml.min-1.m-2, p < 0.05). This difference reflects the reduced oxygen cost of breathing when the custom-made continuous flow system was used during weaning.

Bedside measurement of work of breathing

This paper describes the technique of measuring work of breathing, presented at the 13th International Symposium on Computers in Clinical Medicine and Anaesthesiology, Rotterdam, June 1992. Measuring work of breathing has clinical uses in the Intensive Care Unit. Oxygen consumption does not truly reflect work of breathing. Mechanical work of breathing can be measured by recording continuous pressure and flow and integrating the resultant power. This method is facilitated at the bedside with the use of a PC computer and a spreadsheet program. It is further simplified by software to measure the area under the inspiratory pressure: volume loop.

Use of indirect calorimetry in clinical nutrition

The tremendous variability in resting energy expenditure makes efforts to predict caloric requirements difficult. Indirect calorimetry has provided a valuable tool in assessing energy expenditure, evaluating the way in which the body uses nutrient fuel, and designing nutritional regimens that best fit the clinical condition of the patient. The many indirect calorimetric instruments available vary in their application to clinical nutrition. The best metabolic studies are achieved by controlling the testing environment, accounting for the many clinical factors that may affect measurements, and eliminating potential sources for error. Although indirect calorimetry would seem to reduce the likelihood of complications from overfeeding, its greatest effect may be in cost savings by avoiding unnecessary nutritional support and in providing a means for clinical research.

Plasma catecholamines and oxygen consumption during weaning from mechanical ventilation

Previous studies on oxygen consumption (VO2) during weaning from mechanical ventilation assumed that an increase in VO2 (delta VO2) reflected oxygen consumption by respiratory muscles (VO2RESP), and proposed delta VO2 as a weaning predictor. We measured VO2 CO2 production (VCO2) and plasma catecholamines in 20 short-term ventilated patients during weaning by SIMV and CPAP. delta VO2 as a percentage of VO2 during spontaneous ventilation (delta VO2%) ranged from 4.8% to 41.5%. VCO2 also increased and correlated with VO2. Plasma adrenaline and noradrenaline increased significantly to levels known to produce considerable increases in metabolic rate. Mean arterial pressure and heart rate concomitantly increased, but spontaneous minute ventilation decreased. Thus, since the increased plasma catecholamines are calorigenic, the assumption that delta VO2 represents VO2RESP is incorrect. Although mean delta VO2% of successfully weaned patients was significantly less than that of failure-to-wean patients, the wide scatter of individual values in the latter group excludes delta VO2% as an accurate weaning predictor.

Oxygen cost of breathing and diaphragmatic pressure-time index. Measurement in patients with COPD during weaning with pressure support ventilation

The oxygen cost of breathing and the time integral of the transdiaphragmatic pressure were measured at the onset of the weaning period in eight patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease requiring mechanical ventilation. Measurements were achieved during continuous positive airway pressure ventilation and during 15 cmH2O pressure support ventilation. For both periods, the O2COB was estimated as the difference between oxygen uptake of the period and that during controlled ventilation. During CPAP ventilation, the O2COB was 16.9 +/- 1.5 percent. During PSV, it was only 6.3 +/- 1.3 percent, and PTdi decreased by 73 percent compared to the CPAP period. Both effects illustrate the ability of PSV to facilitate spontaneous breathing during weaning from mechanical ventilation. However, we found these measurements to be of no help in predicting the duration of the weaning process.

Energy expenditure associated with CPAP and T-piece spontaneous ventilatory trials. Changes following prolonged mechanical ventilation

The use of portable metabolic carts to assess energy expenditure (EE) by measuring oxygen consumption (VO2) and carbon dioxide production (VCO2) has recently been applied to patients undergoing weaning from mechanical ventilation. The VO2 and EE can be used to estimate changes in the work of breathing (WOB) associated with different weaning strategies. The purpose of this study was to use VO2 and EE to assess changes in the WOB when assisted mechanical ventilation (AMV) was replaced with two spontaneous ventilatory trial (SVT) techniques: continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) and T-piece. Nine difficult-to-wean patients were studied during the initial weaning period following 26 +/- 18 days (mean +/- SD) of mechanical ventilatory support. The VO2 and EE during all AMV were 296 +/- 75 ml/min and 2069 +/- 519 kcal/day, respectively. Compared to the baseline AMV levels, during CPAP overall VO2 and EE increased 14 percent and 13 percent, respectively, and during T-piece overall VO2 and EE increased 20 percent and 19 percent, respectively. Respiration rate (f) increased and tidal volume (VT) decreased during both SVTs compared to AMV although no significant change in minute ventilation was seen. The WOB, as judged from changes in VO2, was only 5 percent higher during T-piece compared to CPAP; however, patients tolerated an average of only 141 +/- 45 min on T-piece vs 165 +/- 29 minutes on CPAP. We conclude that during the initial weaning stages in patients who have received prolonged mechanical ventilatory support, the WOB associated with SVTs is increased compared to AMV but that the WOB associated with T-piece is not significantly greater than that for CPAP.

Ventilation and ventilators--an update

In the five years which have passed since the previous review, the literature has been concerned more with the ways in which ventilators may be applied to patients and the effects of differing patterns of ventilation than with the design philosophy of the ventilators themselves. This account should be read in conjunction with that of 1982 [1].