Selection for NaCl tolerance in cell cultures of Medicago sativa and recovery of plants from a NaCl-tolerant cell line

Population differentiation for germination and early seedling root growth traits under saline conditions in the annual legume Medicago truncatula (Fabaceae)

PREMISE OF THE STUDY

Seedling establishment and survival are highly sensitive to soil salinity and plants that evolved in saline environments are likely to express traits that increase fitness in those environments. Such traits are of ecological interest and they may have practical value for improving salt tolerance in cultivated species. We examined responses to soil salinity and tested potential mechanisms of salt tolerance in Medicago truncatula, using genotypes that originated from natural populations occurring on saline and nonsaline soils.

METHODS

Germination and seedling responses were quantified and compared between saline and nonsaline origin genotypes. Germination treatments included a range of sodium chloride (NaCl) concentrations in both offspring and parental environments. Seedling treatments included NaCl, abscisic acid (ABA), and potassium chloride (KCl).

KEY RESULTS

Saline origin genotypes displayed greater salinity tolerance for germination and seedling traits relative to nonsaline origin genotypes. We observed population specific differences for the effects of salinity on time to germination and for the impact of parental environment on germination rates. ABA and NaCl treatments had similar negative effects on root growth, although relative sensitivities differed, with saline population less sensitive to NaCl and more sensitive to ABA compared to their nonsaline counterparts.

CONCLUSIONS

We report population differentiation for germination and seedling growth traits under saline conditions among populations derived from saline and nonsaline environments. These observations are consistent with a syndrome of adaptations for salinity tolerance during early plant development, including traits that are common among saline environments and those that are idiosyncratic to local populations.

Characterization and regeneration of salt- and water-stress mutants from protoplast culture of Nicotiana plumbaginifolia (Viviani)

Protoplast-derived colonies of haploid N. plumbaginifolia leaves were used to select for resistance to NaCl, KCl and polyethylene glycol 6000 (PEG). Salt-and PEG-tolerant cell lines were isolated on the basis of growth in a culture medium containing inhibitory concentrations of either NaCl or KCl (200 mM) or PEG (25%). The frequency of resistant lines ranged from 10(-5) to 10(-6). One resistant line from each treatment was regenerated into plants. All resistant lines produced 10-25 times more proline than the wild type when grown on a non-selective medium. Similar values were also observed in the leaves of resistant progeny plants. In each mutant line, salt or PEG resistance was transmitted as a single dominant nuclear gene as shown by segregation ratios in progenies of crosses between resistant and wild-type plants. The latter observation demonstrates clearly the existence of a genetic basis for increased salt tolerance.

Characterization of alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) plants regenerated from selected NaCl tolerant cell lines

Selection of stable, NaCl tolerant alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) cell lines was accomplished by a step-up selection procedure, whereby cell lines originally selected for tolerance at 0.5% NaCl were subsequently selected at 1.0% NaCl. Sodium chloride tolerant cell lines retained tolerance following four subcultures (16 weeks) on control media (0% NaCl). Plants were regenerated from selected NaCl tolerant cell lines of three initial genotypes, one diploid (2n=2x=16) and two tetraploids (2n=4x=32). In addition, plants were regenerated from control cell lines maintained on 0% NaCl media for the same duration. Plants regenerated from NaCl tolerant cell lines were characterized by extensive somaclonal variation compared to plants regenerated from control lines. Morphologically, all plants regenerated from NaCl tolerant cell lines are abnormal and many (44.7%) were extreme dwarfs (maximum height of 5 cm). The grossly aberrant phenotypes prevented an in-depth characterization of many of the plants regenerated from NaCl tolerant cell lines. Most plants regenerated from NaCl tolerant cell lines had unbalanced polyploid chromosome sets with the most extreme cytogenetic variant having 106 chromosomes. In contrast, 98.5% of the plants regenerated from control cell lines were euploid (85% were tetraploid, 15% were octoploid). Isozyme phenotypes of the plants from NaCl tolerant cell lines were also extensively altered, compared to plants from control cell lines. In vitro NaCl tolerance was maintained following plant regeneration for nine of the 12 regenerants tested. Importantly, whole plant NaCl tolerance was expressed in two of the seven regenerated plants tested at the whole plant level; however, only one of these plants has flowered and is both male and female sterile; the other plant has never flowered. Although NaCl tolerant alfalfa cell lines are efficiently selected, the extensive somaclonal variation that accompanied the selection was a deterrent to successful recovery of heritable NaCl tolerance.

Molecular divergence of alfalfa somaclones

Plantlets were regenerated from alfalfa callus following passage through a tissue culture medium which contained gibberellic acid. A proportion of these plantlets showed obvious morphological variations. Leaflet, stem and petiole tissue of these plants were extracted to yield a soluble protein homogenate which was characterized by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Over 18 individual protein bands were resolved and visualized by staining with coomassie blue G250. Electrophoretic gels from regenerated plantlets and from the parent plant were scanned spectrophotometrically and analyzed. The relative quantity of each of the proteins resolved from plants was correlated with proteins of other plants via the Pearson's product-moment correlation. Cluster analysis was then performed using these correlation coefficients to judge relatedness among somaclones and the parent plant. Two of 22 somaclones (9.1%) differed significantly from the parent and from the other somaclones judged by quantitative protein pattern variations. Three distinctive lineages through tissue culture produced plantlets. Using a discriminant analysis strategy somaclones could be grouped according to lineage with 80.8% accuracy based upon distinctions between protein electrophoretic patterns. Two of the somaclone lineage groupings showed no overlap with the parental grouping which indicated significant molecular divergence of these plantlets as judged by quantitative protein differences.

Tissue culture evaluation of NaCl tolerance in Medicago species: Cellular versus whole plant response

Tissue culture responses to three levels of NaCl (0, 85mM and 170 mM) were evaluated in several Medicago species including: M. dzhawakhetica, M. marina, M. rhodopea, M. rupestris, M. sativa (alfalfa) and M. suffruticosa. The whole plant responses of the same genotypes were evaluated in half-strength Hoagland's solution containing 0, 51.5, and 103 mM NaCl. One or more genotypes of M. dzhawakhetica, M. rhodopea, M. rupestris, and M. sativa exhibited in vitro NaCl tolerance at 85 mM. In addition, one genotype each of M. dzhawakhetica, M. rhodopea, and M. sativa was tolerant of 170 mM NaCl. However, all of the genotypes that demonstrated NaCl tolerance in vitro were NaCl sensitive at the whole plant level. Conversely, M. marina the only species exhibiting whole plant NaCl tolerance, had the most NaCl sensitive genotypes at the in vitro level. Although an in vitro NaCl tolerance mechanism which confers whole plant NaCl tolerance was not observed, a potential NaCl tolerance germplasm source, M. marina, was identified.

Variation from plant tissue cultures: Biotechnological application to improving salinity tolerance

Breeding for salt tolerance in crop plants is envisaged as one way to combat a worldwide problem of increasing soil salinity in agricultural land. Tissue culture techniques may prove valuable as a means of achieving this goal. In this review, reports of the selection and characterization of plant cell cultures tolerant to excess salt are assessed, in the context of variability from tissue culture and the significance of cellular physiological adaptation to salinity. The examples of plant regeneration from salt grown cell cultures are also outlined, with emphasis on correlation to the effect of salt on cell cultures, genetic variability for salt tolerance in vitro, and the value of regenerates in the development of salt tolerant plants.

Retention of shoot regeneration capacity of tobacco callus by Na2SO 4

Callus of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L. cv. Wisconsin 38) was grown in the light on shoot-forming medium in the presence of Na2SO4 for over a year. An increase in Na2SO4 concentration resulted in decreasing callus growth, decreasing percentage of calli producing shoots and number of shoots per callus, and increasing callus percent dry weight. Regeneration of shoots from callus grown in the absence of Na2SO4 began to decline after 14 months in culture, and shoot regeneration capacity was completely lost after 18 months. In contrast, 18-month old callus continuously grown in the presence of Na2SO4 retained the ability to form shoots. The highest percent of callus pieces that formed shoots and the maximum number of shoots per callus occurred at 70 mM (1%) Na2SO4. All plants arising from the 18-month old callus were polyploid. Both 9- and 18-month old callus exhibited more negative water and osmotic potentials in the presence of increasing Na2SO4 concentration.

Isolation of sodium chloride-tolerant callus line of Cicer arietinum L. cv. BG-203

A NaCl-tolerant callus line of Cicer arietinum has been isolated, as a spontaneous variant, on agar-solidified MS-medium supplemented with 100 mM NaCl. The growth of this line, in the presence of 100 mM NaCl, was comparable to that of the NaCl-sensitive callus line growing in the absence of NaCl. Regarding relative tolerance of the two callus lines towards NaCl (0 to 200 mM), the tolerant line performed poorly in the absence of NaCl and exhibited optimal growth at 50 mM NaCl. The tolerance persisted even after three passages of 4-wk each, tested so far, away from the selective agent.