Degradation of RNA in Escherichia coli. A hypothesis

Regulation of mRNA decay in E. coli

Detailed studies of the Gram-negative model bacterium, Escherichia coli, have demonstrated that post-transcriptional events exert important and possibly greater control over gene regulation than transcription initiation or effective translation. Thus, over the past 30 years, considerable effort has been invested in understanding the pathways of mRNA turnover in E. coli. Although it is assumed that most of the ribonucleases and accessory proteins involved in mRNA decay have been identified, our understanding of the regulation of mRNA decay is still incomplete. Furthermore, the vast majority of the studies on mRNA decay have been conducted on exponentially growing cells. Thus, the mechanism of mRNA decay as currently outlined may not accurately reflect what happens when cells find themselves under a variety of stress conditions, such as, nutrient starvation, changes in pH and temperature, as well as a host of others. While the cellular machinery for degradation is relatively constant over a wide range of conditions, intracellular levels of specific ribonucleases can vary depending on the growth conditions. Substrate competition will also modulate ribonucleolytic activity. Post-transcriptional modifications of transcripts by polyadenylating enzymes may favor a specific ribonuclease activity. Interactions with small regulatory RNAs and RNA binding proteins add additional complexities to mRNA functionality and stability. Since many of the ribonucleases are found at the inner membrane, the physical location of a transcript may help determine its half-life. Here we discuss the properties and role of the enzymes involved in mRNA decay as well as the multiple factors that may affect mRNA decay under various in vivo conditions.

Translation Initiation Control of RNase E-Mediated Decay of Polycistronic gal mRNA

In bacteria, mRNA decay is a major mechanism for regulating gene expression. In Escherichia coli, mRNA decay initiates with endonucleolytic cleavage by RNase E. Translating ribosomes impede RNase E cleavage, thus providing stability to mRNA. In transcripts containing multiple cistrons, the translation of each cistron initiates separately. The effect of internal translation initiations on the decay of polycistronic transcripts remains unknown, which we have investigated here using the four-cistron galETKM transcript. We find that RNase E cleaves a few nucleotides (14-36) upstream of the translation initiation site of each cistron, generating decay intermediates galTKM, galKM, and galM mRNA with fewer but full cistrons. Blocking translation initiation reduced stability, particularly of the mutated cistrons and when they were the 5'-most cistrons. This indicates that, together with translation failure, the location of the cistron is important for its elimination. The instability of the 5'-most cistron did not propagate to the downstream cistrons, possibly due to translation initiation there. Cistron elimination from the 5' end was not always sequential, indicating that RNase E can also directly access a ribosome-free internal cistron. The finding in gal operon of mRNA decay by cistron elimination appears common in E. coli and Salmonella.

Noncanonical features and modifications on the 5'-end of bacterial sRNAs and mRNAs

Although many eukaryotic transcripts contain cap structures, it has been long thought that bacterial RNAs do not carry any special modifications on their 5'-ends. In bacteria, primary transcripts are produced by transcription initiated with a nucleoside triphosphate and are therefore triphosphorylated on 5'-ends. Some transcripts are then processed by nucleases that yield monophosphorylated RNAs for specific cellular activities. Many primary transcripts are also converted to monophosphorylated species by removal of the terminal pyrophosphate for 5'-end-dependent degradation. Recent studies surprisingly revealed an expanded repertoire of chemical groups on 5'-ends of bacterial RNAs. In addition to mono- and triphosphorylated moieties, some mRNAs and sRNAs contain cap-like structures and diphosphates on their 5'-ends. Although incorporation and removal of these groups have become better understood in recent years, the physiological significance of these modifications remain obscure. This review highlights recent studies aimed at identification and elucidation of novel modifications on the 5'-ends of bacterial RNAs and discusses possible physiological applications of the modified RNAs. This article is categorized under: RNA Turnover and Surveillance > Regulation of RNA Stability RNA Structure and Dynamics > RNA Structure, Dynamics, and Chemistry RNA Processing > Capping and 5' End Modifications.

RNase E and the High-Fidelity Orchestration of RNA Metabolism

The bacterial endoribonuclease RNase E occupies a pivotal position in the control of gene expression, as its actions either commit transcripts to an irreversible fate of rapid destruction or unveil their hidden functions through specific processing. Moreover, the enzyme contributes to quality control of rRNAs. The activity of RNase E can be directed and modulated by signals provided through regulatory RNAs that guide the enzyme to specific transcripts that are to be silenced. Early in its evolutionary history, RNase E acquired a natively unfolded appendage that recruits accessory proteins and RNA. These accessory factors facilitate the activity of RNase E and include helicases that remodel RNA and RNA-protein complexes, and polynucleotide phosphorylase, a relative of the archaeal and eukaryotic exosomes. RNase E also associates with enzymes from central metabolism, such as enolase and aconitase. RNase E-based complexes are diverse in composition, but generally bear mechanistic parallels with eukaryotic machinery involved in RNA-induced gene regulation and transcript quality control. That these similar processes arose independently underscores the universality of RNA-based regulation in life. Here we provide a synopsis and perspective of the contributions made by RNase E to sustain robust gene regulation with speed and accuracy.

In vivo 3'-to-5' exoribonuclease targetomes of Streptococcus pyogenes

To cope with harsh environments and cause infection, bacteria need to constantly adjust gene expression. Ribonucleases (RNases) control the abundance of regulatory and protein-coding RNA through degradation and maturation. The current characterization of 3′-to-5′ exoribonucleases (exoRNases), processing RNAs from their 3′ end, is solely based on the description of a limited number of targets processed by these RNases. Here, we characterized bacterial 3′-to-5′ exoRNase targetomes. We show that YhaM, polynucleotide phosphorylase (PNPase), and RNase R have exoribonucleolytic activities in the human pathogen Streptococcus pyogenes. We demonstrate that PNPase is the main 3′-to-5′ exoRNase participating in RNA decay, we show that RNase R has a limited processing activity, and we describe an intriguing RNA processing behavior for YhaM.

mRNA decay plays an essential role in the control of gene expression in bacteria. Exoribonucleases (exoRNases), which trim transcripts starting from the 5′ or 3′ end, are particularly important to fully degrade unwanted transcripts and renew the pool of nucleotides available in the cell. While recent techniques have allowed genome-wide identification of ribonuclease (RNase) targets in bacteria in vivo, none of the 3′-to-5′ exoRNase targetomes (i.e., global processing sites) have been studied so far. Here, we report the targetomes of YhaM, polynucleotide phosphorylase (PNPase), and RNase R of the human pathogen Streptococcus pyogenes. We determined that YhaM is an unspecific enzyme that trims a few nucleotides and targets the majority of transcript ends, generated either by transcription termination or by endonucleolytic activity. The molecular determinants for YhaM-limited processivity are yet to be deciphered. We showed that PNPase clears the cell from mRNA decay fragments produced by endoribonucleases (endoRNases) and is the major 3′-to-5′ exoRNase for RNA turnover in S. pyogenes. In particular, PNPase is responsible for the degradation of regulatory elements from 5′ untranslated regions. However, we observed little RNase R activity in standard culture conditions. Overall, our study sheds light on the very distinct features of S. pyogenes 3′-to-5′ exoRNases.

Enzymes Involved in Posttranscriptional RNA Metabolism in Gram-Negative Bacteria

Gene expression in Gram-negative bacteria is regulated at many levels, including transcription initiation, RNA processing, RNA/RNA interactions, mRNA decay, and translational controls involving enzymes that alter translational efficiency. In this review, we discuss the various enzymes that control transcription, translation, and RNA stability through RNA processing and degradation. RNA processing is essential to generate functional RNAs, while degradation helps control the steady-state level of each individual transcript. For example, all the pre-tRNAs are transcribed with extra nucleotides at both their 5' and 3' termini, which are subsequently processed to produce mature tRNAs that can be aminoacylated. Similarly, rRNAs that are transcribed as part of a 30S polycistronic transcript are matured to individual 16S, 23S, and 5S rRNAs. Decay of mRNAs plays a key role in gene regulation through controlling the steady-state level of each transcript, which is essential for maintaining appropriate protein levels. In addition, degradation of both translated and nontranslated RNAs recycles nucleotides to facilitate new RNA synthesis. To carry out all these reactions, Gram-negative bacteria employ a large number of endonucleases, exonucleases, RNA helicases, and poly(A) polymerase, as well as proteins that regulate the catalytic activity of particular RNases. Under certain stress conditions, an additional group of specialized endonucleases facilitate the cell's ability to adapt and survive. Many of the enzymes, such as RNase E, RNase III, polynucleotide phosphorylase, RNase R, and poly(A) polymerase I, participate in multiple RNA processing and decay pathways.

Regulation of mRNA Decay in Bacteria

Gram-negative and gram-positive bacteria use a variety of enzymatic pathways to degrade mRNAs. Although several recent reviews have outlined these pathways, much less attention has been paid to the regulation of mRNA decay. The functional half-life of a particular mRNA, which affects how much protein is synthesized from it, is determined by a combination of multiple factors. These include, but are not necessarily limited to, (a) stability elements at either the 5' or the 3' terminus, (b) posttranscriptional modifications, (c) ribosome density on individual mRNAs, (d) small regulatory RNA (sRNA) interactions with mRNAs, (e) regulatory proteins that alter ribonuclease binding affinities, (f) the presence or absence of endonucleolytic cleavage sites, (g) control of intracellular ribonuclease levels, and (h) physical location within the cell. Changes in physiological conditions associated with environmental alterations can significantly alter the impact of these factors in the decay of a particular mRNA.

Genetic and genomic analysis of RNases in model cyanobacteria

Cyanobacteria are diverse photosynthetic microbes with the ability to convert CO2 into useful products. However, metabolic engineering of cyanobacteria remains challenging because of the limited resources for modifying the expression of endogenous and exogenous biochemical pathways. Fine-tuned control of protein production will be critical to optimize the biological conversion of CO2 into desirable molecules. Messenger RNAs (mRNAs) are labile intermediates that play critical roles in determining the translation rate and steady-state protein concentrations in the cell. The majority of studies on mRNA turnover have focused on the model heterotrophic bacteria Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis. These studies have elucidated many RNA modifying and processing enzymes and have highlighted the differences between these Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacteria, respectively. In contrast, much less is known about mRNA turnover in cyanobacteria. We generated a compendium of the major ribonucleases (RNases) and provide an in-depth analysis of RNase III-like enzymes in commonly studied and diverse cyanobacteria. Furthermore, using targeted gene deletion, we genetically dissected the RNases in Synechococcus sp. PCC 7002, one of the fastest growing and industrially attractive cyanobacterial strains. We found that all three cyanobacterial homologs of RNase III and a member of the RNase II/R family are not essential under standard laboratory conditions, while homologs of RNase E/G, RNase J1/J2, PNPase, and a different member of the RNase II/R family appear to be essential for growth. This work will enhance our understanding of native control of gene expression and will facilitate the development of an RNA-based toolkit for metabolic engineering in cyanobacteria.

Messenger RNA degradation in bacterial cells

mRNA degradation is an important mechanism for controlling gene expression in bacterial cells. This process involves the orderly action of a battery of cellular endonucleases and exonucleases, some universal and others present only in certain species. These ribonucleases function with the assistance of ancillary enzymes that covalently modify the 5' or 3' end of RNA or unwind base-paired regions. Triggered by initiating events at either the 5' terminus or an internal site, mRNA decay occurs at diverse rates that are transcript specific and governed by RNA sequence and structure, translating ribosomes, and bound sRNAs or proteins. In response to environmental cues, bacteria are able to orchestrate widespread changes in mRNA lifetimes by modulating the concentration or specific activity of cellular ribonucleases or by unmasking the mRNA-degrading activity of cellular toxins.

All things must pass: contrasts and commonalities in eukaryotic and bacterial mRNA decay

Despite its universal importance for controlling gene expression, mRNA degradation was initially thought to occur by disparate mechanisms in eukaryotes and bacteria. This conclusion was based on differences in the structures used by these organisms to protect mRNA termini and in the RNases and modifying enzymes originally implicated in mRNA decay. Subsequent discoveries have identified several striking parallels between the cellular factors and molecular events that govern mRNA degradation in these two kingdoms of life. Nevertheless, some key distinctions remain, the most fundamental of which may be related to the different mechanisms by which eukaryotes and bacteria control translation initiation.

Endonucleolytic initiation of mRNA decay in Escherichia coli

Instability is a fundamental property of mRNA that is necessary for the regulation of gene expression. In E. coli, the turnover of mRNA involves multiple, redundant pathways involving 3'-exoribonucleases, endoribonucleases, and a variety of other enzymes that modify RNA covalently or affect its conformation. Endoribonucleases are thought to initiate or accelerate the process of mRNA degradation. A major endoribonuclease in this process is RNase E, which is a key component of the degradative machinery amongst the Proteobacteria. RNase E is the central element in a multienzyme complex known as the RNA degradosome. Structural and functional data are converging on models for the mechanism of activation and regulation of RNase E and its paralog, RNase G. Here, we discuss current models for mRNA degradation in E. coli and we present current thinking on the structure and function of RNase E based on recent crystal structures of its catalytic core.

Fate of the sblA transcript in Streptomyces lividans and Escherichia coli

In Streptomyces lividans, the tight temporal regulation of the transient expression of the sblA gene was shown to involve an operator-like sequence located on the sblA transcript. This operator-like structure constitutes a stem-loop structure containing a Shine/Dalgarno-like sequence. Its destruction, by site directed mutagenesis, led to an enhancement of sblA expression. This structure thus plays a negative role in the regulation of sblA expression and might be involved in the regulation of the specific degradation of the sblA transcript. In this issue, the fates of the sblA transcript, in S. lividans and in Escherichia coli, were compared. Analysis of the decay of the sblA transcript revealed that, in both species, the sblA transcript was cleaved just behind the stem-loop structure by an RNAse E-like activity. In E. coli, three discrete products resulting from the cleavage of the full-length transcript by the RNAase E at another site, located 282 nucleotides downstream of the stem-loop structure, were detected whereas only one processed product, corresponding to the 5' end of the gene, was detected in S. lividans. These differences in the mode of degradation of the sblA transcript in S. lividans and E. coli are discussed.

Initiation of RNA decay in Escherichia coli by 5' pyrophosphate removal

The common belief that endonucleolytic cleavage is the initial, rate-determining step of mRNA decay in Escherichia coli fails to explain the influence of 5' termini on the half-lives of primary transcripts. We have re-examined the initial events of RNA degradation in that organism by devising an assay to probe the 5' phosphorylation state of RNA and by employing a self-cleaving hammerhead ribozyme to investigate the degradative consequences of an unphosphorylated 5' end. These studies have identified a previously unrecognized prior step in decay that triggers subsequent internal cleavage by the endonuclease RNase E and thereby governs RNA longevity: the rate-determining conversion of a triphosphorylated to a monophosphorylated 5' terminus. Our findings redefine the role of RNase E in RNA degradation and explain how unpaired 5'-terminal nucleotides can facilitate access to internal cleavage sites within primary transcripts. Moreover, these results reveal a striking parallel between the mechanisms of mRNA decay in prokaryotic and eukaryotic organisms.

Messenger RNA Decay

This chapter discusses several topics relating to the mechanisms of mRNA decay. These topics include the following: important physical properties of mRNA molecules that can alter their stability; methods for determining mRNA half-lives; the genetics and biochemistry of proteins and enzymes involved in mRNA decay; posttranscriptional modification of mRNAs; the cellular location of the mRNA decay apparatus; regulation of mRNA decay; the relationships among mRNA decay, tRNA maturation, and ribosomal RNA processing; and biochemical models for mRNA decay. Escherichia coli has multiple pathways for ensuring the effective decay of mRNAs and mRNA decay is closely linked to the cell's overall RNA metabolism. Finally, the chapter highlights important unanswered questions regarding both the mechanism and importance of mRNA decay.

Outer membrane c-type cytochromes required for Fe(III) and Mn(IV) oxide reduction in Geobacter sulfurreducens

The potential role of outer membrane proteins in electron transfer to insoluble Fe(III) oxides by Geobacter sulfurreducens was investigated because this organism is closely related to the Fe(III) oxide-reducing organisms that are predominant in many Fe(III)-reducing environments. Two of the most abundant proteins that were easily sheared from the outer surfaces of intact cells were c-type cytochromes. One, designated OmcS, has a molecular mass of ca. 50 kDa and is predicted to be an outer membrane hexaheme c-type cytochrome. Transcripts for omcS could be detected during growth on Fe(III) oxide, but not on soluble Fe(III) citrate. The omcS mRNA consisted primarily of a monocistronic transcript, and to a lesser extent, a longer transcript that also contained the downstream gene omcT, which is predicted to encode a second hexaheme outer membrane cytochrome with 62.6% amino acid sequence identity to OmcS. The other abundant c-type cytochrome sheared from the outer surface of G. sulfurreducens, designated OmcE, has a molecular mass of ca. 30 kDa and is predicted to be an outer membrane tetraheme c-type cytochrome. When either omcS or omcE was deleted, G. sulfurreducens could no longer reduce Fe(III) oxide but could still reduce soluble electron acceptors, including Fe(III) citrate. The mutants could reduce Fe(III) in Fe(III) oxide medium only if the Fe(III) chelator, nitrilotriacetic acid, or the electron shuttle, anthraquinone 2,6-disulfonate, was added. Expressing omcS or omcE in trans restored the capacity for Fe(III) oxide reduction. OmcT was not detected among the sheared proteins, and genetic studies indicated that G. sulfurreducens could not reduce Fe(III) oxide when omcT was expressed but OmcS was absent. In contrast, Fe(III) oxide was reduced when omcS was expressed in the absence of OmcT. These results suggest that OmcS and OmcE are involved in electron transfer to Fe(III) oxides in G. sulfurreducens. They also emphasize the importance of evaluating mechanisms for Fe(III) reduction with environmentally relevant Fe(III) oxide, rather than the more commonly utilized Fe(III) citrate, because additional electron transfer components are required for Fe(III) oxide reduction that are not required for Fe(III) citrate reduction.

Unaltered stability of newly synthesized RNA in strains of Escherichia coli missing a ribonuclease specific for double-stranded RNA

Pairs of very closely related Escherichia coli strains were prepared, one having the wild-type allele for ribonuclease III, an enzyme which specifically degrades double-stranded RNA, and the other having a mutant RNase III allele. Growth and phage plating efficiency were compared in these strains. The RNase III+ strains grow better than the RNase III- strains and plate T7 and lambda phage better, but T4 plates with the same efficiency on both strains. On the other hand, the half lives of newly synthesized RNA as well as of functional beta-galactosidase mRNA are similar in both kind of strains. These two parameters, however, are significantly longer in both strains as compared to the original strain from which they were derived. Also, no difference in the differential induction of beta-galactosidase was observed between such strains. Thus, we have to conclude that either ribonuclease III does not play a significant role in the functioning and stability of newly synthesized mRNA, or that enough enzymatic activity was left, residual RNase III or some other enzyme to deal with double-stranded regions in the message.

A novel endoribonuclease, RNase LS, in Escherichia coli

The dmd gene of bacteriophage T4 is required for the stability of late-gene mRNAs. When this gene is mutated, late genes are globally silenced because of rapid degradation of their mRNAs. Our previous work suggested that a novel Escherichia coli endonuclease, RNase LS, is responsible for the rapid degradation of mRNAs. In this study, we demonstrated that rnlA (formerly yfjN) is essential for RNase LS activity both in vivo and in vitro. In addition, we investigated a role of RNase LS in the RNA metabolism of E. coli cells under vegetative growth conditions. A mutation in rnlA reduced the decay rate of many E. coli mRNAs, although there are differences in the mutational effects on the stabilization of different mRNAs. In addition, we found that a 307-nucleotide fragment with an internal sequence of 23S rRNA accumulated to a high level in rnlA mutant cells. These results strongly suggest that RNase LS plays a role in the RNA metabolism of E. coli as well as phage T4.

Genomic analysis in Escherichia coli demonstrates differential roles for polynucleotide phosphorylase and RNase II in mRNA abundance and decay

Previous work has shown that simultaneous inactivation of polynucleotide phosphorylase (PNPase) and RNase II (both 3' 5' exonucleases) in Escherichia coli leads to the loss of cell viability and the accumulation of partially degraded mRNA species. In order to help to distinguish how these two enzymes globally affect the abundance and decay of mRNAs, we have carried out a genome-wide analysis of the steady-state levels of E. coli transcripts using deletion mutations in either rnb or pnp. The data show that, in exponentially growing cells, inactivation of PNPase leads to an increase in the steady-state level of more expressed mRNAs (17.3%) than inactivation of RNase II (7.3%). In contrast, the steady-state levels of a large number of E. coli mRNAs (31%) are decreased in the absence of RNase II, including almost all the ribosomal protein genes, suggesting that a major function of this enzyme is to protect specific mRNAs from the activity of other ribonucleases. Array data were confirmed by Northern analysis of 12 individual mRNAs. A comparison between the steady-state levels and the half-lives of individual mRNAs indicates that there may be a direct interaction between transcription and mRNA decay for some of the transcripts. In addition, results are presented to show significant phenotypic differences between the pnp-7 point mutant and the pnp delta 683 deletion allele.

Preferential cleavage of degradative intermediates of rpsT mRNA by the Escherichia coli RNA degradosome

RNase E, the principal RNase capable of initiating mRNA decay, preferentially attacks 5'-monophosphorylated over 5'-triphosphorylated substrates. Site-specific cleavage in vitro of the rpsT mRNA by RNase H directed by chimeric 2'-O-methyl oligonucleotides was employed to create truncated RNAs which are identical to authentic degradative intermediates. The rates of cleavage of two such intermediates by RNase E in the RNA degradosome are significantly faster (2.5- to 8-fold) than that of intact RNA. This verifies the preference of RNase E for degradative intermediates and can explain the frequent "all-or-none" behavior of mRNAs during the decay process.

Polynucleotide phosphorylase, RNase II and RNase E play different roles in the in vivo modulation of polyadenylation in Escherichia coli

Poly(A) tails in Escherichia coli are hypothesized to provide unstructured single-stranded substrates that facilitate the degradation of mRNAs by ribonucleases. Here, we have investigated the role that such nucleases play in modulating polyadenylation in vivo by measuring total poly(A) levels, polyadenylation of specific transcripts, growth rates and cell viabilities in strains containing various amounts of poly(A) polymerase I (PAP I), polynucleotide phosphorylase (PNPase), RNase II and RNase E. The results demonstrate that both PNPase and RNase II are directly involved in regulating total in vivo poly(A) levels. RNase II is primarily responsible for degrading poly(A) tails associated with 23S rRNA, whereas PNPase is more effective in modulating the polyadenylation of the lpp and 16S rRNA transcripts. In contrast, RNase E appears to affect poly(A) levels indirectly through the generation of new 3' termini that serve as substrates for PAP I. In addition, whereas excess PNPase suppresses polyadenylation by more than 70%, the toxicity associated with increased poly(A) levels is not reduced. Conversely, toxicity is significantly reduced in the presence of excess RNase II. Overproduction of RNase E leads to increased polyadenylation and no reduction in toxicity.

Messenger RNA stability and its role in control of gene expression in bacteria and phages

The stability of mRNA in prokaryotes depends on multiple factors and it has not yet been possible to describe the process of mRNA degradation in terms of a unique pathway. However, important advances have been made in the past 10 years with the characterization of the cis-acting RNA elements and the trans-acting cellular proteins that control mRNA decay. The trans-acting proteins are mainly four nucleases, two endo- (RNase E and RNase III) and two exonucleases (PNPase and RNase II), and poly(A) polymerase. RNase E and PNPase are found in a multienzyme complex called the degradosome. In addition to the host nucleases, phage T4 encodes a specific endonuclease called RegB. The cis-acting elements that protect mRNA from degradation are stable stem-loops at the 5' end of the transcript and terminators or REP sequences at their 3' end. The rate-limiting step in mRNA decay is usually an initial endonucleolytic cleavage that often occurs at the 5' extremity. This initial step is followed by directional 3' to 5' degradation by the two exonucleases. Several examples, reviewed here, indicate that mRNA degradation is an important step at which gene expression can be controlled. This regulation can be either global, as in the case of growth rate-dependent control, or specific, in response to changes in the environmental conditions.

Degradation of mRNA in Escherichia coli: an old problem with some new twists

Metabolic instability is a hallmark property of mRNAs in most if not all organisms and plays an essential role in facilitating rapid responses to regulatory cues. This article provides a critical examination of recent progress in the enzymology of mRNA decay in Escherichia coli, focusing on six major enzymes: RNase III, RNase E, polynucleotide phosphorylase, RNase II, poly(A) polymerase(s), and RNA helicase(s). The first major advance in our thinking about mechanisms of RNA decay has been catalyzed by the possibility that mRNA decay is orchestrated by a multicomponent mRNA-protein complex (the "degradosome"). The ramifications of this discovery are discussed and developed into mRNA decay models that integrate the properties of the ribonucleases and their associated proteins, the role of RNA structure in determining the susceptibility of an RNA to decay, and some of the known kinetic features of mRNA decay. These models propose that mRNA decay is a vectorial process initiated primarily at or near the 5' terminus of susceptible mRNAs and propagated by successive endonucleolytic cleavages catalyzed by RNase E in the degradosome. It seems likely that the degradosome can be tethered to its substrate, either physically or kinetically through a preference for monphosphorylated RNAs, accounting for the usual "all or none" nature of mRNA decay. A second recent advance in our thinking about mRNA decay is the rediscovery of polyadenylated mRNA in bacteria. Models are provided to account for the role of polyadenylation in facilitating the 3' exonucleolytic degradation of structured RNAs. Finally, we have reviewed the documented properties of several well-studied paradigms for mRNA decay in E. coli. We interpret the published data in light of our models and the properties of the degradosome. It seems likely that the study of mRNA decay is about to enter a phase in which research will focus on the structural basis for recognition of cleavage sites, on catalytic mechanisms, and on regulation of mRNA decay.

Ribonuclease E is a 5'-end-dependent endonuclease

The selective degradation of messenger RNAs enables cells to regulate the levels of particular mRNAs in response to changes in the environment. Ribonuclease (RNase) E, a single-strand-specific endonuclease that is found in a multi-enzyme complex known as the 'degradosome', initiates the degradation of many mRNAs in Escherichia coli. Its relative lack of sequence specificity and the presence of many potential cleavage sites in mRNA substrates cannot explain why mRNA decay frequently proceeds in a net 5'-to-3' direction. I have prepared covalently closed circular derivatives of natural substrates, the rpsT mRNA encoding ribosomal protein S20 and the 9S precursor to 5S ribosomal RNA, and find that these derivatives are considerably more resistant to cleavage in vitro by RNase E than are linear molecules. Moreover, antisense oligo-deoxynucleotides complementary to the 5' end of linear substrates significantly reduce the latter's susceptibility to attack by RNase E. Finally, natural substrates with terminal 5'-triphosphate groups are poorly cleaved by RNase E in vitro, whereas 5' monophosphorylated substrates are strongly preferred. These results show that RNase E has inherent vectorial properties, with its activity depending on the 5' end of its substrates; this can account for the direction of mRNA decay in E. coli, the phenomenon of 'all or none' mRNA decay, and the stabilization provided by 5' stem-loop structures.

Escherichia coli mrsC is an allele of hflB, encoding a membrane-associated ATPase and protease that is required for mRNA decay

The mrsC gene of Escherichia coli is required for mRNA turnover and cell growth, and strains containing the temperature-sensitive mrsC505 allele have longer half-lives than wild-type controls for total pulse-labeled and individual mRNAs (L. L. Granger et al., J. Bacteriol. 180:1920-1928, 1998). The cloned mrsC gene contains a long open reading frame beginning at an initiator UUG codon, confirmed by N-terminal amino acid sequencing, encoding a 70,996-Da protein with a consensus ATP-binding domain. mrsC is identical to the independently identified ftsH gene except for three additional amino acids at the N terminus (T. Tomoyasu et al., J. Bacteriol. 175:1344-1351, 1993). The purified protein had a Km of 28 microM for ATP and a Vmax of 21.2 nmol/microg/min. An amino-terminal glutathione S-transferase-MrsC fusion protein retained ATPase activity but was not biologically active. A glutamic acid replacement of the highly conserved lysine within the ATP-binding motif (mrsC201) abolished the complementation of the mrsC505 mutation, confirming that the ATPase activity is required for MrsC function in vivo. In addition, the mrsC505 allele conferred a temperature-sensitive HflB phenotype, while the hflB29 mutation promoted mRNA stability at both 30 and 44 degrees C, suggesting that the inviability associated with the mrsC505 allele is not related to the defect in mRNA decay. The data presented provide the first direct evidence for the involvement of a membrane-bound protein in mRNA decay in E. coli.

The kdp system of Clostridium acetobutylicum: cloning, sequencing, and transcriptional regulation in response to potassium concentration

The complete sequence of the kdp gene region of Clostridium acetobutylicum has been determined. This part of the chromosome comprises two small open reading frames (orfZ and orfY), putatively encoding hydrophobic peptides, and the genes kdpA, kdpB, kdpC, and kdpX, followed by an operon encoding a pair of sensor-effector regulatory proteins (KdpD and KdpE). Except for orfZ, orfY, and kdpX, all genes showed significant homology to the kdp genes of Escherichia coli, encoding a high-affinity potassium transport ATPase and its regulators. The complete genome sequence of Synechocystis sp. strain PCC 6803 and a recently published part of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis genome indicate the existence of a kdp system in these organisms as well, but all three systems comprise neither a second orf upstream of kdpA nor an additional kdpX gene. Expression of the clostridial kdp genes, including the unique kdpX gene, was found to be inducible by low potassium concentrations. A transcription start point could be mapped upstream of orfZ. A promoter upstream of kdpD was active only under noninducing conditions. Lowering the potassium content of the medium led to formation of a common transcript (orfZYkdpABCXDE), with a putative internal RNase E recognition site, which could be responsible for the instability of the common transcript. Except for the two small peptides, all gene products could be detected in in vitro transcription-translation experiments.

Analysis of the in vivo decay of the Escherichia coli dicistronic pyrF-orfF transcript: evidence for multiple degradation pathways

Messenger RNA decay in Escherichia coli is slowed in pnp-7 (PNPase) rnb-500 (RNase II) rne-1(RNase E) multiple mutants. We have used Northern blots, S1 nuclease protection and primer extension analysis to map 18 endonucleolytic cleavage sites within the pyrF-orfF dicistronic transcript. Although examination of a total of 27 cleavage sites including those determined for the monocistronic trxA transcript revealed a complex pattern, the central four nucleotides within a cluster of 12 residues encompassing the cleavage sites showed a definite A/U preference. Also of interest was the processing of the dicistronic transcript to remove the downstream orfF sequence as a stable but untranslated RNA fragment. The data provide further support for the hypothesis that multiple decay pathways are involved in the decay of a single transcript. In particular, the pyrF-orfF transcript apparently can be degraded either in the 5' to 3' or the 3' to 5' direction. Our results are discussed in light of current models of mRNA decay involving polyadenylation and multiprotein decay complexes.

DNA sequencing and expression of the gene rnb encoding Escherichia coli ribonuclease II

The Escherichia coli ribonuclease II (RNase II) is an exonuclease involved in mRNA degradation that hydrolyses single-stranded polyribonucleotides processively in the 3' to 5' direction. Sequencing of a 2.2 kb MseI-RsaI fragment containing the rnb gene revealed an open reading frame of 1794 nucleotides that encodes a protein of 598 amino acid residues, whose calculated molecular mass is 67,583 Da. This value is in good agreement with that obtained by sodium dodecyl sulphate/polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of polypeptides synthesized by expression with the T7 RNA polymerase/promoter system. This system was also used to confirm the correct orientation of rnb. Translation initiation was confirmed by rnb-lacZ fusions. The mRNA start site was determined by S1 nuclease mapping. Two E. coli mutants harbouring different rnb alleles deficient in RNase II activity were complemented with the expressed fragment carrying the rnb gene.

Purification and properties of a decapping enzyme from rat liver cytosol

A decapping enzyme has been purified about 2400-fold from rat liver cytosol. The decapping enzyme was shown to be fairly homogeneous by sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The enzyme had an apparent molecular weight of 110,000 and consisted of two equal subunits. The enzyme hydrolyzed m7Guo5'PPP5'Ado to m7GMP and ADP. Analysis of the products produced from radioactively capped oligonucleotides and intact mRNA having 3H-cap suggests that the enzyme can hydrolyze capped mono- to pentanucleotides (m7Guo5'PPP5'N (where N = 1-5 nucleotides)) but not intact mRNA. The existence of methyl group at the N7 position of guanosine moiety of cap structure was necessary for the action of the decapping enzyme. This was confirmed by the comparison of the rates of hydrolysis of m7Guo5'PPP5'Ado by the enzyme in the presence of various nucleotides. The activity of enzyme was slightly stimulated by Na+, K+, NH4+, Ca2+ and polyamines. Mg2+ and Mn2+ were without effect on the enzyme activity.

Specific endonucleolytic cleavage of the mRNA for ribosomal protein S20 of Escherichia coli requires the product of the ams gene in vivo and in vitro

Endonucleolytic cleavage is believed to initiate the degradation of most bacterial mRNAs, but with several exceptions, the enzymes responsible have yet to be identified. Crude (S-30) or partially fractionated extracts of Escherichia coli strains with reduced exonuclease activities catalyze the cleavage of a 372-residue RNA substrate containing the sequences coding for ribosomal protein S20 to yield a number of discrete products. The major product of 147 residues is obtained in 60 to 70% yield, is coterminal with the 3' end of the substrate, and is identical to an mRNA fragment previously characterized in vivo (G. A. Mackie, J. Bacteriol. 171:4112-4120, 1989). A number of other products of 150 to 340 residues are also formed, and the cleavage sites, typically N decreases AU sequences, have been identified in the S20 mRNA substrate by Northern (RNA) blotting and primer extension. All cleavages required a native rather than a denatured RNA substrate. The rate of cutting of the S20 mRNA substrate at the site yielding the prominent 147-residue product appears to be independent of cleavages at other sites. In addition, the activity of the putative endonuclease(s) depends strongly, both in vivo and in vitro, on the product of the ams gene, which is known to influence mRNA lifetimes in vivo. Taken together, the data show that the fractionated extract described here reproduces steps in the degradation of some mRNAs which occur in living cells.

Multiple determinants of functional mRNA stability: sequence alterations at either end of the lacZ gene affect the rate of mRNA inactivation

The Escherichia coli lacZ gene was used as a model system to identify specific sequence elements affecting mRNA stability. Various insertions and substitutions at the ribosome-binding site increased or decreased the rate of mRNA inactivation by up to fourfold. Deletion of a dyad symmetry, which may give rise to a very stable secondary structure in the mRNA immediately downstream of the gene, decreased the functional stability of the lacZ message. The magnitude of the latter effect was strongly dependent on the sequences at the ribosome-binding site, ranging from practically no effect for the most labile transcripts to a threefold decrease in stability for the most stable one. The results suggest that the wild-type lacZ message is inactivated predominantly by attacks near the ribosome-binding site, presumably in part because the putative secondary structure downstream of the gene protects against 3'-exonucleolytic attack. Taken together, the data for all of the modified variants of lacZ were shown to be quantitatively compatible with a general model of mRNA inactivation involving multiple independent target sites.

RNase III cleavages in non-coding leaders of Escherichia coli transcripts control mRNA stability and genetic expression

The primary transcripts of the rpsO-pnp, rnc-era-recO and metY-nusA-infB operons of E coli are each processed by RNase III, upstream of the first translated gene, in hair-pin structures formed by the 5' non-coding leader. The mRNAs of the 3 operons, of which the 5' terminal motifs have been removed by RNase III, decay significantly more rapidly than the uncut transcripts which accumulate in the RNase III deficient strain. The rapid decay of a primary transcript of the metY-nusA-infB operon, initiated at a secondary promoter in the vicinity of the RNase III sites, suggests that the 5' features upstream of the RNase III cutting sites are responsible for the stability of the uncut RNAs. RNase III autocontrols its own expression by removing the 5' motif which stabilizes its mRNA. Similarly, the synthesis of polynucleotide phosphorylase and of protein Era are also controlled by RNase III cleavages which trigger the degradation of their messengers. The role of RNase III in the regulation of gene expression and the possible mechanisms of mRNA stabilization and of 5' to 3' decay initiated by RNase III processing are discussed.

The ompA 5' untranslated RNA segment functions in Escherichia coli as a growth-rate-regulated mRNA stabilizer whose activity is unrelated to translational efficiency

The 5' untranslated region (UTR) of the long-lived Escherichia coli ompA message can function in vivo as an mRNA stabilizer. Substitution of this ompA mRNA segment for the corresponding segment of the labile bla gene transcripts prolongs their lifetime by a factor of 6. We show here that the function of this ompA mRNA stabilizer requires the presence of a 115-nucleotide ompA RNA segment that lies upstream of the ribosome-binding site. Although deletion of this segment reduced the half-life of the ompA transcript by a factor of 5, its absence had almost no effect on the translational efficiency of ompA mRNA. Like the ompA transcript, but unlike bla mRNA, hybrid ompA-bla messages containing the complete ompA 5' UTR were significantly less stable under conditions of slow bacterial growth. We conclude that the stabilizing activity of the ompA 5' UTR is growth rate regulated and that the mechanism of mRNA stabilization by this RNA segment is not related to the spacing between translating ribosomes.

Stabilization of the 3' one-third of Escherichia coli ribosomal protein S20 mRNA in mutants lacking polynucleotide phosphorylase

Mutations which largely inactivate polynucleotide phosphorylase and which render RNase II thermolabile exert two effects on the metabolism of the two nested mRNAs which encode ribosomal protein S20. (i) The lifetime of both mRNA species is extended 2.5-fold at 38 degrees C in a strain harboring both mutations. (ii) A relatively stable truncated fragment of these mRNAs accumulates to significant levels in strains lacking polynucleotide phosphorylase. The truncated RNA (Po RNA) is 147 to 148 residues long and is coterminal with the 3' ends of intact S20 mRNAs. Its 5' end appears to be generated by endonucleolytic cleavage to the 5' side of a G residue in the sequence AACCGAUC. The data are consistent with the hypothesis that S20 mRNAs can be degraded by alternative pathways. The normal pathway depends on functional polynucleotide phosphorylase and is concerted, since S20 mRNAs disappear without accumulation of detectable intermediates in the decay process. The slower alternative pathway is followed when polynucleotide phosphorylase is inactivated by mutation. This pathway is distinguished by segmental rather than concerted degradation of S20 mRNAs and involves at least one endonucleolytic cleavage. The 5' two-thirds of S20 mRNAs decays significantly more quickly than the 3' third in this latter mode of mRNA turnover.

Mechanisms of mRNA decay in bacteria: a perspective

Messenger RNA decay plays an important role in prokaryotic gene expression. The disparate stabilities of bacterial messages in vivo are a consequence of their differential susceptibility to degradation by cellular endoribonucleases and 3' -exoribonucleases, which in turn results from differences in mRNA sequence and structure. RNase II and polynucleotide phosphorylase, the major bacterial exonucleases involved in mRNA turnover, rapidly degrade single-stranded RNA from the 3' end, but are impeded by 3' stem-loop structures. At present, the identify and substrate specificity of the endonucleases that control mRNA decay rates are relatively poorly defined. Ribosomes and antisense RNA also can influence the stability of transcripts with which they associate. Differences in mRNA stability can contribute to differential expression of genes within polycistronic operons and to modulation of gene expression in response to changes in bacterial growth conditions.

Stabilization of translationally active mRNA by prokaryotic REP sequences

The REP sequence is a highly conserved inverted repeat that is present in about 25% of all E. coli transcription units. We show that the REP sequence can stabilize upstream RNA, independently of any other sequences, by protection from 3'-5' exonuclease attack. The REP sequence is frequently responsible for the differential stability of different segments of mRNA within an operon. We demonstrate that REP-stabilized mRNA can be translated in vivo and that cloning the REP sequence downstream of a gene can increase protein synthesis. This provides direct evidence that alterations in mRNA stability can play a role in determining bacterial gene expression. The implications of these findings for the mechanisms of mRNA degradation and for the role of RNA stability in the regulation of gene expression are discussed.

The stability of E. coli gene transcripts is dependent on determinants localized to specific mRNA segments

To map the structural features responsible for the 5-fold difference in stability of the E. coli ompA and bla gene transcripts, we have constructed gene fusions that encode chimeric ompA/bla transcripts and a deletion that eliminates a large internal segment of bla mRNA. Shortening of bla transcripts by internal deletion or replacement of the 3' end with the corresponding segment of the ompA transcript had little effect on bla mRNA stability. However, fusion of a 5'-terminal 147 nucleotide segment of the ompA message 5' to full-length or truncated bla transcripts increased the half-life of the bla segments 3- to 5-fold. These and other findings indicate that E. coli transcripts contain discrete structural determinants of stability and instability that can influence the decay rate of linked mRNA segments derived from other genes.

The relationship between translational initiation and messenger RNA inactivation in down-shifted Escherichia coli

The parameters of protein synthesis and functional inactivation of global messenger RNA (mRNA) were examined in a Tic+ strain of Escherichia coli during the 30-min period following a shift-down from glucose-minimal to succinate-minimal medium. The rate of mRNA inactivation and the relative translational initiation frequency were both most severely depressed immediately after the shift-down and increased slowly thereafter. If glucose was restored to the medium at any time after shift-down, mRNA inactivation immediately resumed its normal (preshift) rate and the protein-forming capacity was increased. These changes in mRNA inactivation rate do not reflect an altered mRNA composition in the down-shifted cells. The relative rate of mRNA inactivation was linearly proportional to the relative translational initiation frequency over a 10-fold range of initiation frequencies. Low initiation frequencies represent increased "dwell" of the ribosomes at the initiation site before the commencement of polypeptide chain initiation. We propose that initiating ribosomes protect mRNA from an inactivating endonucleolytic cleavage at or near the ribosome binding site.

Purification and mode of action of a microsomal endoribonuclease from rat liver

An endoribonuclease has been purified nearly to homogeneity from rat liver microsomes, and its mode of action and general properties were studied. The enzyme had an apparent molecular weight of 58 000, as estimated by both gel filtration and SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and produced oligonucleotides from poly(A), poly(U) and poly(C). No mononucleotide was obtained by the enzymatic hydrolysis of the above substrates. The enzyme made endonucleolytic cleavages which generated 5'-phosphate-terminated oligonucleotides. It was suggested that the existence of at least (Ado5'P)2 residues at both sides of the cleavage bond was necessary for the action of the endoribonuclease. Divalent cations (Mg2+ or Mn2+) were required for the enzymatic activity, while K+ inhibited the enzyme. Spermine stimulated the enzymatic activity in the presence of 1 mM Mg2+.

Purification and mode of action of a microsomal exoribonuclease from rat liver

An exoribonuclease has been purified nearly to homogeneity from rat liver microsomes and its mode of action and general properties were studied. The molecular weight values for the enzyme, as estimated by gel filtration and SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, were 88 000 and 92 000, respectively. The enzyme produced, via a processive mechanism Ado5'P as the only product from poly(A). The results of the hydrolysis of 4 S (Ado5'P)n and (Ado3'P)n by the exoribonuclease with or without alkaline phosphatase and the inhibition of the enzymatic activity by oligonucleotides having a 3'-phosphate group in the 3'-terminus suggested that the degradation proceeds in the 3' to 5' direction. These findings were confirmed by the analysis of hydrolyzed products of various oligoadenylates and Ado3'PUrdPGuo and by the comparison of the rates of hydrolysis of (Ado3'P)2Ado by the enzyme in the presence of varying amounts of (Ado3'P)3. Mg2+ was required for the enzymatic activity, and Mn2+ partially substituted for Mg2+. The activity of the enzyme was stimulated by K+ and spermine.

Differential expression of photosynthesis genes in R. capsulata results from segmental differences in stability within the polycistronic rxcA transcript

We report that the light-harvesting and reaction center genes in the rxcA locus of R. capsulata are contained within a single operon and that their differential expression results predominantly from marked segmental differences in stability within the polycistronic rxcA transcript. The 3' portion of this transcript is rapidly degraded to give rise to either of two slowly decaying mRNA remnants, both of which encode only the light-harvesting polypeptides. The greater stability of these remnants accounts for nearly all of the difference between the concentrations of the light-harvesting and reaction center proteins. The unstable 3' portion of the transcript is delimited by two alternative stem-and-loop structures, which apparently act as barriers to 3' exoribonucleases and thereby protect the upstream RNA segment. When a DNA fragment containing the rxcA locus was fused to a plasmid promoter and transcribed in E. coli, the long precursor transcript was processed to two short messages of greater stability, as in R. capsulata.

Amplification of ribonuclease II (rnb) activity in Escherichia coli K-12

A 7.1 kb HindIII-XhoI fragment of E. coli DNA which contains the structural gene for ribonuclease II (rnb) has been cloned in the recombinant plasmid pDK24. At least two constitutively expressed genes are encoded on the fragment as shown by maxicell analysis. On denaturing polyacrylamide gels RNase II appears as a single 72,000 dalton species. The approximate site of transcription initiation of the rnb gene has been mapped. Although derivatives of E. coli harboring pDK24 contained 10-fold more RNase II activity that wild type strains without the plasmid, the degradation rate of mRNA was similar in all strains tested. Strains deficient in both RNase II and polynucleotide phosphorylase appear inviable.

Endoplasmic reticulum nuclease. Purification and specificity

An endonuclease, which was originally identified for its RNA polymerase inhibitory activity, was isolated from rat liver endoplasmic reticulum. The enzyme yields on gel chromatography four active fractions of different molecular weights (Mr 5.3 X 10(4), 9 X 10(4), 1.55 X 10(5) and Sephacryl S-200 fraction at V0). Each fraction contains polypeptide chains which give a single band on sodium dodecylsulphate electrophoresis (Mr 5.4 X 10(4). This indicates that the enzyme is an oligomeric protein and each of its subunits exhibits the same or very similar molecular weights. Deoxyribonucleoside and ribonucleoside triphosphates can bind to the endoplasmic reticulum nuclease. Binding is enhanced in the presence of divalent cations particularly Mg2+. The enzyme exhibits mainly RNase activity but can also degrade denatured DNA and DNA . RNA hybrids which contain breaks in one of the two strands. Poly(A) and mainly poly(U) are most susceptible to its nucleolytic activity whereas poly(C) is completely resistant.

A microsomal endoribonuclease from rat liver

An endoribonuclease has been purified about 320-fold from the microsomes of rat liver. The enzyme had an apparent molecular weight of 54 000-58 000 and produced oligonucleotides, each consisting of 3-7 nucleotides from poly(A) and poly(U). No mononucleotide was obtained by the enzymatic hydrolysis of poly(A) and poly(U) under standard coditions. The relative rates of breakdown of synthetic polynucleotides by the enzyme under standard conditions were in the order poly(U) = poly(A) > poly(C). Divalent cations (Mg2+ or Mn2+) was required for the enzymatic activity, but monovalent cations (Na+, K+ or NH4+) inhibited the enzyme. The breakdown of poly(C) and poly(U) by the enzyme was inhibited by spermine, but that of poly(A) was not influenced by spermine. The enzyme was inhibited by p-chloromercuribenzoate and poly(G), but not by rat-liver ribonuclease-inhibitor and anti-RNase A serum.