Neuropathological findings in muscle-eye-brain disease (MEB-D). Neuropathological delineation of MEB-D from congenital muscular dystrophy of the Fukuyama type

PERIPHERAL AVASCULAR RETINA WITH DISK ANOMALY AND HIGH MYOPIA: A Novel Association in a Hereditary Isolated Ocular Disorder

PURPOSE

To describe a family pedigree with a previously undescribed association of autosomal dominantly inherited ocular abnormalities.

METHODS

Case series study performed on 15 family members. Examination included history taking, visual acuity, intraocular pressure, slit-lamp, gonioscopy, indirect ophthalmoscopy (10 members), fluorescein angiography (5 members), general examination and renal ultrasound (4 members), and hemoglobin electrophoresis for the proband and another member.

RESULTS

Family pedigree revealed autosomal-dominant inheritance. Visual acuity ranged from 6/36 to no light perception. Examination revealed rubeosis in 7 eyes and atrophia bulbi in 11 eyes. Indirect ophthalmoscopy for 11 eyes revealed evidence of an ocular triad of peripheral avascular retina, disk anomaly (cavitary optic disk anomaly or disk dysplasia), and tessellated fundus of high myopia. The authors also observed new vessels elsewhere with or without extensive subretinal exudations in 6 eyes. All patients with any residual vision (up to perception of light) had nystagmus. Four affected members underwent general examination, renal ultrasound, and serum creatinine level (to exclude papillorenal syndrome), and all were normal. Hemoglobin electrophoresis (to exclude sickle cell retinopathy) revealed within normal values.

CONCLUSION

To the authors' knowledge, the aforementioned ocular triad has not been previously described, in association, with an autosomal-dominant pattern of inheritance.

Polymicrogyria: pathology, fetal origins and mechanisms

Polymicrogyria (PMG) is a complex cortical malformation which has so far defied any mechanistic or genetic explanation. Adopting a broad definition of an abnormally folded or festooned cerebral cortical neuronal ribbon, this review addresses the literature on PMG and the mechanisms of its development, as derived from the neuropathological study of many cases of human PMG, a large proportion in fetal life. This reveals the several processes which appear to be involved in the early stages of formation of polymicrogyric cortex. The most consistent feature of developing PMG is disruption of the brain surface with pial defects, over-migration of cells, thickening and reduplication of the pial collagen layers and increased leptomeningeal vascularity. Evidence from animal models is consistent with our observations and supports the notion that disturbance in the formation of the leptomeninges or loss of their normal signalling functions are potent contributors to cortical malformation. Other mechanisms which may lead to PMG include premature folding of the neuronal band, abnormal fusion of adjacent gyri and laminar necrosis of the developing cortex. The observation of PMG in association with other and better understood forms of brain malformation, such as cobblestone cortex, suggests mechanistic pathways for some forms of PMG. The role of altered physical properties of the thickened leptomeninges in exerting mechanical constraints on the developing cortex is also considered.

Cobblestone lissencephaly: neuropathological subtypes and correlations with genes of dystroglycanopathies

Cobblestone lissencephaly represents a peculiar brain malformation with characteristic radiological anomalies, defined as cortical dysplasia combined with dysmyelination, dysplastic cerebellum with cysts and brainstem hypoplasia. Cortical dysplasia results from neuroglial overmigration into the arachnoid space, forming an extracortical layer, responsible for agyria and/or 'cobblestone' brain surface and ventricular enlargement. The underlying mechanism is a disruption of the glia limitans, the outermost layer of the brain. Cobblestone lissencephaly is pathognomonic of a continuum of autosomal recessive diseases with cerebral, ocular and muscular deficits, Walker-Warburg syndrome, muscle-eye-brain and Fukuyama muscular dystrophy. Mutations in POMT1, POMT2, POMGNT1, LARGE, FKTN and FKRP genes attributed these diseases to α-dystroglycanopathies. However, studies have not been able to identify causal mutations in the majority of patients and to establish a clear phenotype/genotype correlation. Therefore, we decided to perform a detailed neuropathological survey and molecular screenings in 65 foetal cases selected on the basis of histopathological criteria. After sequencing the six genes of α-dystroglycanopathies, a causal mutation was observed in 66% of cases. On the basis of a ratio of severity, three subtypes clearly emerged. The most severe, which we called cobblestone lissencephaly A, was linked to mutations in POMT1 (34%), POMT2 (8%) and FKRP (1.5%). The least severe, cobblestone lissencephaly C, was linked to POMGNT1 mutations (18%). An intermediary type, cobblestone lissencephaly B, was linked to LARGE mutations (4.5%) identified for the first time in foetuses. We conclude that cobblestone lissencephaly encompasses three distinct subtypes of cortical malformations with different degrees of neuroglial ectopia into the arachnoid space and cortical plate disorganization regardless of gestational age. In the cerebellum, histopathological changes support the novel hypothesis that abnormal lamination arises from a deficiency in granule cells. Our studies demonstrate the positive impact of histoneuropathology on the identification of α-dystroglycanopathies found in 66% of cases, while with neuroimaging criteria and biological values, mutations are found in 32-50% of patients. Interestingly, our morphological classification was central in the orientation of genetic screening of POMT1, POMT2, POMGNT1, LARGE and FKRP. Despite intensive research, one-third of our cases remained unexplained; suggesting that other genes and/or pathways may be involved. This material offers a rich resource for studies on the affected neurodevelopmental processes of cobblestone lissencephaly and on the identification of other responsible gene(s)/pathway(s).

Neuronal migration disorders

Neuronal migration disorders are a category of developmental brain disorders leading to cortical dysplasia. This group of disorders is characterized by defective movement of neurons from the place of origin along the lining of the lateral ventricle, to the eventual place of residence in the correct laminar position within the cerebral cortex. As a result of defective migration, affected individuals typically display mental retardation and epilepsy. Although patients with the more severe forms of these disorders often present during infancy, patients may present at any age from newborn to adulthood. The migration defect may be generalized or focal, and may be disturbed at any of several stages, leading to several distinct radiographical and clinical presentations. The human phenotypes suggests that there are at least four distinct and clinically-important steps in cortical neuronal migration, and the identification of the responsible genes suggests that multiple cellular processes are critical for correct neuronal positioning.

Pathologic basis of the symptomatic epilepsies in childhood

The epilepsies in childhood are classified as primary (or idiopathic) and secondary (or symptomatic). The primary epilepsies account for two thirds of all childhood epilepsies and are presumed to be genetically determined. In the remaining one third of cases, a neuropathologic lesion can be identified. This paper summarizes the etiologies of the symptomatic epilepsies. They are classified according to the pathologic processes; malformative, metabolic, neoplastic and phakomatoses, hypoxic-ischemic, infectious, and of unknown pathologic process.

Congenital muscular dystrophy and severe central nervous system atrophy in two siblings

Severe degenerative features of the nervous system of a hitherto unknown kind, associated with a neuromuscular disorder with histopathological features of congenital muscular dystrophy, are reported in two female siblings. The clinical profile was characterized by generalized hypotonia followed by spastic tetraplegia, contractures, polyneuropathy, lack of cognitive development and progressive microcephaly. There as no involvement of the eyes. Neuropathological examination of the brain of one sibling, who died at the age of 30 months, revealed subtotal loss of neurons in the cerebral and cerebellar cortex and in the ventral pons, and secondary loss of myelin in the cerebral and cerebellar subcortical white matter. Sural nerve biopsy in the other sibling, who had a similar neurological affection, showed a lack of large myelinated fibers.

White matter abnormalities in congenital muscular dystrophy

Central nervous system (CNS) characteristics were examined in seventeen patients with autosomal recessive classic or "pure" congenital muscular dystrophy (CMD). In three patients, neuroradiological examination (CT/MRI) indicated hypodense white matter areas. Two out of these three patients had epilepsy (seizures and epileptic discharges on their EEG). Only two of the remaining patients had epileptic EEG discharges, but without clinical seizures. By comparing our results to data in the literature, we could conclude that the classic or "pure" form of CMD can be subdivided into two subtypes, i.e. those with and those without white matter hypodensities. A mild form of epilepsy or an epileptic predisposition on EEG can be part of the subtype with white matter hypodensities.

Developmental aspects of type II lissencephaly. Comparative study of dysplastic lesions in fetal and post-natal brains

We report neuropathological studies of five cases of type II lissencephaly from three fetuses and two infants. This comparative study allowed us to determine the developmental course of the cerebral lesions. Two distinct developmental events seem to generate this type of brain malformation: firstly, an early disturbance in cortex formation, which results both from a disorder of radial migration and a pial barrier disruption; secondly, a late perturbation of cerebral surface organization, resulting in fusion of the cerebral surface. All these features can be related to a primitive meningeal pathology, and more generally, to a neurocristopathy. Accordingly to our observations, this brain malformation appears during both migrational and post-migrational stages and may be considered more like a polymicrogyria than a lissencephaly.

Muscle and brain disease: an update

A number of syndromes included under this rubric are considered, and their main features discussed. The congenital muscular dystrophy of the Fukuyama type as it occurs in Japan and in the western world are almost certainly the same condition. The muscle disorder is associated with cerebral lesions which may be due to an arrest of neural migration or to demyelination. Muscle, eye and brain disease, or Santavuori's syndrome, shows ocular abnormalities, as well as those of the muscle and brain, as does the Walker-Warburg syndrome. In the latter disorder the cerebral lesions tend to be more severe, and it is more rapidly fatal. The manifestations of all these syndromes undoubtedly overlap, but there has been controversy on the question of their identity. Are they separate entities, or are they different expressions of a similar genetic disorder? The genes for all these conditions will have to be isolated to see if the different phenotypes are alleles of the same gene, or not. Some of the arguments, for and against, are presented.

Neuropathology of lissencephalies

The neuropathological findings at autopsy in four cases of type I and three of type II lissencephaly are presented. Type I lissencephaly is characterized by agyriapachygyria with a markedly thickened cerebral cortex with four coarse histological layers. The normally myelinated white matter, often with neuronal heterotopias, is very narrow, and the gray-to-white matter ratio is inverted (about 4:1); there are no white-gray interdigitations. Claustrum and capsula extrema are absent. Ventricular dilatation is present, especially of the occipital horns. In the hypoplastic brain stem large olivary heterotopias can often be observed. Severe cerebellar malformations, obstructive hydrocephalus, severe eye abnormalities, and congenital muscular dystrophy are not seen. Clinically, type I lissencephaly presents as "isolated lissencephaly sequence" or as "Miller-Dieker syndrome" with characteristic facial dysmorphism. The long survival of 20 years achieved by one of our patients is very uncommon. Type II lissencephaly is characterized by widespread agyria. Usually, obstructive hydrocephalus is present with a thin cerebral mantle showing a slightly thickened cortex and a narrow, hypomyelinated white matter often with neuronal heterotopias (gray-to-white matter ratio about 1:1). The border between gray and white matter is blurred. Claustrum and capsula extrema are absent. Histologically, the cortex appears disorganized without layering; widespread leptomeningeal gliomesenchymal proliferations and glioneuronal heterotopias are present.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Congenital muscular dystrophy. A study on the variability of morphological changes and dystrophin distribution in muscle biopsies

Histomorphological and histochemical variability was studied in muscle specimens from 30 patients with congenital muscular dystrophy (CMD). We found involvement of the central nervous system in 8 patients (Fukuyama CMD, F-CMD), involvement of the brain and the eyes in 5 patients (muscle, eye and brain disease, MEB-D) and hypodense white matter on the CT scans of 2 patients with (sub)normal intelligence (occidental-type cerebromuscular dystrophy, O-CMD). No morphological hallmarks were found to differentiate these subgroups. Only fat cell infiltration was found to be increased with increasing age in 'pure' CMD (pure-CMD). The morphological data did not appear to be correlated with the clinical severity or type of dystrophy (pure-CMD, F-CMD, MEB-D and O-CMD). Immunohistochemistry with dystrophin, vimentin and desmin antibodies in 14 patients (6 pure-CMD, 5 F-CMD, 2 MEB-D and 1 O-CMD) showed a normal expression pattern.

Ocular findings in cerebro-ocular-myopathy syndrome (COMS). A possible role of growth factors?

The clinical and histopathological findings are described in a case of cerebral and ocular abnormalities associated with (congenital) muscular dystrophy. Histopathological examination of the eyes revealed a fetal configuration of the anterior chamber angle, elongated ciliary processes, cataract, persistence of primary hyperplastic vitreous and total retinal detachment with retinal dysplasia. The similarity of ocular findings in Walker-Warburg syndrome, muscle-eye-brain disease and Fukuyama's congenital muscular dystrophy, and the role of growth factors as a possible unifying (foetal) cause are discussed. This case has been presented at the meeting of the EOPS Verhoeff Society, Nürnberg 1991.