Evidence for the existence of low-energy laser bioeffects on the nervous system

Novel Method of Non-contact Remote Measurement of Neuronal Electrical Activity

Measuring the electrical potential of a neuron cell currently requires direct contact with the cell surface. This method requires invasive probing and is limited by the deflection of electricity from baseline. From a clinical perspective, the electrical potential of the brain's surface can only be measured to a depth of one centimeter using an electroencephalogram (EEG), however, it cannot measure much deeper structures. In this trial, we attempt a novel method to remotely record the electromagnetic field (EMF) of action potential provoked from hippocampal neurons without contact.

A bipolar stimulating electrode was placed in contact with the CA1 region of viable hippocampal slice from donor mice. The specimen was bathed in artifical cerebrospinal fluid (aCSF) to simulate in vivo conditions. This setup was then placed into a magnetic shielded tube. Very low-frequency EMF sensors were used to obtain recordings. The impedance of the aCSF and hippocampal slice were measured after each stimulation individually and in combination.

An electromagnetic signal was detected in three out of four scenarios: (a) aCSF alone with electrical stimulus without a hippocampal slice, (b) Hippocampal slice in aCSF without electrical stimulus and, (c) Hippocampal slice in aCSF with an electric stimulus applied. Therefore, our trial suggests that EMFs from neuronal tissue can be recorded through non-invasive non-contact sensors.

Effect of low-power pulsed laser on peripheral nerve regeneration in rats

The purpose of this study was to determine whether low-power pulsed laser irradiation could affect the regeneration of a 10-mm gap of rat sciatic nerve created between the proximal and distal nerve stumps, which were sutured into silicone rubber tubes. After 8 weeks of recovery, pulsed laser-irradiated groups at frequencies of 5 kHz and 20 kHz both had significantly lower success percentages of regeneration (50% and 44%, respectively) compared to sham-irradiated controls (100%). In addition, qualitative and quantitative histology of the regenerated nerves revealed a less mature ultrastructural organization with a smaller cross-sectional area and a lower number of myelinated axons in both pulsed laser-irradiated groups than in controls. These results suggest that pulsed laser irradiation could elicit suppressing effects on regenerating nerves.

Lightdosimetric quantitative analysis of the human petrous bone: experimental study for laser irradiation of the cochlea

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Application of laser irradiation targeting the inner ear has to be investigated for therapeutic effectiveness in cochlear injury and dysfunction. In vitro data demonstrate low-level laser-induced photochemical and photobiologic cell response, depending on cell type and irradiation parameters such as light dose. The aim of the presented study was to determine the light dose received by the cochlear hair cells by using different irradiation modalities for the human petrous bone.

STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS

Lightdosimetric assessment was performed in human cadaver temporal bones (n = 13) after removing the cochlear membranous labyrinth. The external auditory meatus, the tympanic membrane (quadrants), and the mastoid bone were illuminated by a helium-neon laser (lambda = 593 nm) and diode lasers of different wavelengths (lambda = 635, 690, 780, and 830 nm). The spatial distribution of transmitted light in the cochlear windings was measured by means of a retrocochlearly positioned endoscopic CCD camera for image processing and was assigned to acoustic frequencies according to the tonotopic organization of the cochlea. For an estimation of the corresponding space irradiance in an intact cochlea, correction factors have been calculated by a Monte Carlo procedure on the basis of experimentally determined optical properties of skull bone.

RESULTS

The transmission of light across the tympanic cavity and the promontory depends strongly on wave-length of the laser and the position of the radiator. Transtympanal irradiation results in spatial intensity variations of a factor 4 to 10 within the cochlear windings. The space irradiance in an intact cochlea is 10 to 20 times the measured irradiance. For an irradiation of the mastoid, the light transmission within the cochlea is 10(3) to 10(5) times smaller compared with an irradiation of the tympanic membrane and is extremely variable for different specimens.

CONCLUSION

The strong dependence of the cochlear light distribution on various irradiation parameters demonstrates the impact of preclinical lightdosimetric investigations for effective individual laser irradiation of the human cochlea. Because of the observed spatial intensity variations, the optimal external light dose has to be chosen with regard to the tonotopy of the human cochlea. The obtained results are enabling us to apply defined laser light doses to different cochlear winding areas. Mastoidal irradiation leads to therapeutically insufficient light doses within reasonable treatment times, whereas transmeatal irradiation is recommendable. Further studies are mandatory for development of clinical devices for transmeatal irradiation of the cochlea.

In vitro frog sciatic nerve as a peripheral nerve model for studies of the mechanism of action of low energy lasers: Part one

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

There have been numerous reports of modulation of peripheral nerve action potential characteristics through application of low energy laser irradiation (LELI), although no mechanism has yet been advanced to explain these observations. In order to investigate the mechanism of LELI effects in peripheral nerve tissue, a well-characterized, reliable, and robust peripheral nerve preparation is required. The objective of this study was to evaluate the in vitro frog sciatic nerve as a candidate model for future LELI mechanism studies.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Following 60-minute baseline recordings of compound action potential (CAP) amplitude, latency, depolarization rate, and repolarization rate, helium-neon (HeNe) laser irradiation (632 nm, 15 min, 1-7 J, 44-320 J/cm2) was delivered to one of two sites on the nerve. Laser-induced changes in CAP parameters were analyzed during irradiation and for 60 minutes post-irradiation using a repeated measures linear regression model.

RESULTS

In the treatment group that received 7 J of HeNe energy over the recording electrode, CAP latency increased relative to nonirradiated controls during the postirradiation period. No other treatment group demonstrated laser-induced changes in CAP characteristics at any time during the experiment.

CONCLUSION

HeNe irradiation demonstrated limited ability to alter the CAP under these conditions. As such, the in vitro frog sciatic nerve is an inappropriate model for mechanism of action studies.

Importance of using rigorous statistical methods to analyze low energy laser experimental data: Part two

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Numerous authors have reported successful alteration of peripheral nerve action potential characteristics through application of low energy laser irradiation (LELI). The statistical analysis that accompanies many of these reports frequently does not account for the special nature of the data generated in typical LELI experiments. The objective of this study was to evaluate the application of repeated measures linear regression techniques to the analysis of this type of data. Issues of analyzing raw versus normalized data, proper accounting for correlation between measurements, and discrete time point hypothesis testing were addressed.

STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS

The data analyzed in this work were generated from an experiment in which in vitro frog sciatic nerves were irradiated with a helium-neon laser using a variety of treatment protocols. Compound action potential (CAP) amplitude, latency, depolarization rate, and repolarization rate were recorded at 1-minute intervals for 135 minutes for each nerve. Laser-induced changes in CAP parameters were analyzed using various repeated measures linear regression models.

RESULTS

The findings of statistical significance were highly dependent on the rigor of the regression model applied. Application of the same regression model to raw and normalized data produced different findings of significance. Determination of significant contrasts was highly dependent on how well the regression model accounted for the correlation between repeated measurements made on the same nerve. In general, models that failed to account adequately for this correlation produced more findings of significant contrasts than increasingly rigorous models. Finally, discrete time point hypothesis testing on normalized data can suggest improper statistical conclusions if the proper correlation structure is not applied to the data set.

CONCLUSION

Linear regression analysis offers advantages over discrete time point hypothesis testing in the analysis of highly correlated serial data of this type. Trends in the behavior of the measured parameters are evident, rigorous accounting for correlation between measurements is facilitated, and hypothesis testing is highly flexible.